Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Friday, March 31, 2017 12:29:59 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Legal prosecution and departmental proceeding may run together but penalty shall be stayed until court case ends

By
15th-Oct-2016       Readers ( 224 )   0 Comments
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all (0) »

Appellate Division (Civil) :
Surendra Kumar Sinha CJ
Nazmun Ara Sultana J
Syed Mahmud Hossain J
Hasan Foez Siddique J
Judgment
July 27th, 2015
Asaduzzaman (Md)………….Petitioner
vs
Government of Bangladesh represented by the Secretary, Internal Resources Division Ministry of Finance and another….. Respondents
Government Servants' (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985
Rule 25
If there be any prosecution or legal proceeding against a government servant pending in any court on the same issue, there shall be no bar in the disposal of the departmental proceedings against him, but if the authority decides to impose any penalty on such government servant in the departmental proceedings, imposition of such penalty shall be stayed until disposal of that prosecution or legal proceeding. . ..... (9)
AJ Mohammad Ali Senior Advocate· instructed by Sufia Khatun, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioner (In both the Petitions).
None Represented -For  the Respondents (In both the Petitions).
Judgment
Nazmun Ara Sultana J : This Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 2-8-2010 passed by the Administrative Appellate Tribunal, Dhaka in Appeal No. 79 of 2007 dismissing the appeal and thereby affirming the judgment and order dated 20-2-2007 passed by the administrative Tribunal No. 1, Dhaka in AT Case No.77 of 2003 dismissing the case.
2. The present leave-petitioner filed the above mentioned AT Case No.77 of 2003 challenging the order of his dismissal from service. The material case of the leave-petitioner is that he joined as Pesker of the Customs, Excise and VAT Appellate Tribunal on 18-9-1996 and since then he had been serving as such with outmost satisfaction of the authority concerned. That on 24-6-2001 the opposite party No. 2. placed him under suspension and thereafter on' 22-7-2001 he framed charge against the petitioner under the provisions of Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985 on the allegations of misconduct and corruption. The petitioner submitted his reply on 5-8-2001 denying all "the allegations brought against him. Ultimately. the petitioner was dismissed from service in that departmental proceeding by the order dated 31-12-2002. The petitioner preferred departmental appeal against that dismissal order but the authority concerned did not give any decision in that appeal within 2 (two) months and, as such, the petitioner was compelled to file this case.
3. The opposite parties contested the case by filing written statement contending, interalia, that the petitioner was found guilty of charge of corruption in the departmental proceeding and, as such, he was dismissed from service in accordance with rules.
4. The learned member of the Administrative Tribunal No.1, Dhaka, upon hearing both the parties and examining the records, dismissed the petitioner's case by the judgment and order dated 20-2-2007.
5. Being aggrieved by the said judgment and order the petitioner preferred the above mentioned Appeal No.79 of 2007 before the Administrative Appellate Tribunal. Upon hearing the learned Counsel of both the parties and examining the materials on record the Administrative Appellate Tribunal found that the petitioner was dismissed from service on the charge of corruption quite in accordance with rules and therefore, upheld the judgment and order of the Administrative Tribunal by the impugned judgment and order.
6. Mr AJ Mohammad Ali, the learned Senior Advocate appearing for the leave-petitioner has assailed the concurrent findings and decision of the Administrative Tribunal and the Administrative Appellate Tribunal making submissions to the effect only that on the self same allegations. a criminal case also was initiated against this petitioner and in that criminal case the petitioner has been acquitted and in the circumstances the conviction of the petitioner in the departmental proceeding on the same allegation has been illegal.
7. This contention of the learned Advocate is not correct. The departmental proceeding was initiated against the petitioner on some specific allegations as per provisions of the Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985 and on enquiry held in that departmental proceeding those allegations were found proved and, as such, the petitioner was dismissed from service on those allegations in compliance with all the mandatory requirements of the Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985. There is no provision in these Rules or in any' other Laws and Rules to the effect that if a government servant is acquitted in the criminal case on the self same allegations, he cannot be punished in the departmental proceeding initiated on the same allegation.
8. Mr AJ Mohammad Ali, the learned Advocate for the leave-petitioner has argued that as per provision of Public Servants (Dismissal on Conviction) Ordinance, 1985 a government servant convicted in any criminal case for any offence punishable with imprisonment for 6 (six) months or more is liable to be dismissed from service and if this conviction is set aside on appeal the said government servant is entitled to be reinstated in his service. The learned Advocate has contended that since in the present case the leave-petitioner has been acquitted from the criminal case initiated on the self same allegations, he is now entitled to be reinstated in his service. But we are unable to accept this contention of the learned Advocate. In this case the leave-petitioner has not been dismissed from service as per provision of Public Servants (Dismissal on Conviction) Ordinance, 1985, rather he has been dismissed from service on being found guilty of the charge of corruption in the departmental proceeding initiated in accordance with the provisions of the Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985. For conviction a government servant on the ground of conviction in any criminal case as per provision of Public Servants (Dismissal on Conviction) Ordinance, 1985 no departmental proceeding requires to be initiated at all.
9. In the Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985 there is a provision, namely, rule 25, which provides that if there be
any prosecution or legal proceeding against a government servant pending in any court on the same issue, there shall be no bar on the disposal of the departmental proceedings against him, but if the authority decides to impose any penalty on such government servant in the departmental proceedings, imposition of such penalty shall be stayed until disposal of that prosecution or .legal proceeding. This rule 25 does not say at all that-if any government servant is convicted in any criminal case he cannot be imposed any. penalty in the departmental proceeding on the same allegation.
However, we find no merit in this civil petition for leave to appeal and hence it is dismissed.

0 Comments. Share your thoughts also.
Write a comment
Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Europe faces uncertainty as Theresa May triggers Brexit


BRITAIN triggered Brexit process to leave the European Union (EU) as Prime Minister Theresa May on Wednesday sent the letter to EU leadership in Brussels to start negotiation leaving the country sharply divided and the future of EU largely uncertain. Most Britons fear that the split will isolate them from ...

Sports »

The winners of the ARK Group 35th National Weightlifting (Men`s) Championship with the officials of different federations pose for a photo session at the gymnasium of National Sports Council on Thursday.


Cricket »

Shahid Afridi (left) and Younis Khan unveiled the ICC Champions Trophy in Karachi on Thursday.


City »

Canadian Parliament Member Nathaniel Eroskin called on BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia at the latter's Gulshan office in the city on Thursday.


Entertainment »

Chumki under Mir Sabbir`s direction


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Mir Sabbir and Chumki is real life’s husband-wife. They worked together as a pair on the screen in several number of works. But Chumki cannot give time to acting due to maintaining her family and two sons. So she is not regular in acting. She did not ...

International »

Japan ruling party urges strike ability amid N Korea threat


AP, Tokyo :Japan's ruling party urged the government Thursday to consider arming the country with more advanced and offensive capability, such as striking enemy targets with cruise missiles, further loosening the self-defense-only military posture Japan has had since the end of World War II.The Liberal Democratic Party's council on defense ...

Weekend Plus »

Tips for your healthy skin


Weekend Plus Desk :Don’t have time for intensive skin care? You can still pamper yourself by acing the basics. Good skin care and healthy lifestyle choices can help delay the natural aging process and prevent various skin problems. Get started with these five no-nonsense tips.Protect from the sunOne of the ...

Weekend Plus »

Beat the heat with these 3 refreshing drinks


Weekend Plus Desk :As the temperature rises, hot tea and coffee are more an option. While Lassi and Buttermilk are a perfect option for your everyday needs, cocktails and mocktails are essential for the evening parties. Gone are the days when Cosmopolitan, Bloody Mary or Daiquiri were the only good ...

Editorial »

Blaming loan defaulters is not enough, reasons must be examined


IT is reported that the big loan defaulters have not paid the huge debt to the banks despite their rescheduling by Bangladesh Bank in 2015. Now instead of paying their old debts, many businesspersons are moving around banks for a fresh loan. The Central Bank allowed rescheduling of loans of ...

Football »

Minus-Messi, Argentina lose another World Cup qualifier


AP, Sao Paulo :Hours after Lionel Messi was suspended by FIFA for four World Cup qualifying matches, Argentina lost 2-0 to Bolivia in the altitude of La Paz on Tuesday and heightened its risk of missing a spot at Russia 2018.Argentina dropped from third to fifth place, remaining on 22 ...

City »

Air Officer Commanding of Bangladesh Air Force Base Bir Sreshto Matiur Rahman Air Commodore Sheikh Abdul Hannan awarding


Entertainment »

Emma Roberts knows how to step away from spotlight


Emma Roberts has lived most of her life in the spotlight and the actress says that now she has learned a lot about how to handle it. The 26-year-old actress talked about how she has become proficient in maintaining a certain level of privacy when it comes to more personal ...

International »

Scottish Parliament votes for new independence referendum


Reuters, Edinburgh :The Scottish parliament on Tuesday backed First Minister Nicola Sturgeon's bid for a new independence referendum, further complicating Britain's political situation just as years of talks on the terms of Brexit were about to begin.The United Kingdom's vote last year to exit the European Union has strained ties ...

Editorial »

India must not feel too confident about defence pact


THE proposed defence pact with India to be signed early next month on New Delhi's pressure is creating growing public misgivings and many believe that the government should make the deal public to remove people's concern. Media reports said discussants at a round-table including academics, former diplomats and defence experts ...

Cricket »

Taskin hits hat-trick : Lanka make 311


Sports Reporter :Sri Lanka made a fighting total of 311 off 49.5 overs in their first innings against Bangladesh in the second One Day International (ODI) match at Rangiri Dambulla International Stadium in Dambulla, Sri Lanka on Tuesday.Sri Lanka could add at least 15 to 20 runs in their total ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news