Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, March 30, 2017 02:54:13 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Heirs of the ex-employee entitled to full service benefits

By
15th-Oct-2016       Readers ( 256 )   0 Comments
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all (0) »

(From previous issue) :
Provided further that no such application shall be entertained by the Administrative Tribunal unless it is made within six-months from the date of making or taking of the order, decision or action concerned or making of the Decision on the matter by the higher administrative authority, as the case, may be.
(3) In this section "person in the service of the Republic 3[or of any statutory public authority]"  includes a person who is or has retired or is dismissed, removed or discharged from such service, but does not include a person in the defence services of Bangladesh 4[or of the Bangladesh Rifles].
8. It appears from the provision of section 4 of the Administrative Tribunal Act that a servant if being aggrieved by any order of the concerned authority, shall have to go to the Administrative Tribunal for his remedy first, but the present petitioners have no that scope to file any application before the Administrative Tribunal as they were not in the  service of the republic.
Section 7 A says:
2[7A. (1) Where a  person is dismissed or removed from service and an application is made under section 4 against such removal or dismissal and that person dies during the pendency of the ease, the right to sue of that applicant shall survive if his service had been pensionable under any law for the time being in force.
(2) Where the right to sue survives under sub-section (I), such legal representative of the deceased applicant who would have been entitled to the pensioner benefit at the event of the death or retirement of the deceased applicant may be substituted, upon an application, made to the Tribunal or, as the case may be, to the Appellate division within sixty days from the date of the earth of the applicant.
 (3) The legal representative of the deceased, as referred to in sub-section (2), shall be entitled to the pensionery benefit which would have been payable to that deceased if he had been removed or dismissed:
Provided that, such pensioner benefit shall not be payable unless the Tribunal or, as the case may the Appellate Division, declares the order of the dismissal or removal, as the case may be, as illegal or void:
Provided further that, for the purpose of this section, the applicant shall be deemed to have died or retired, as the case may be, on the day on which he was removed or dismissed.
9. It has been provided in section 7A that when all application against the dismissal or removal from service is pending before the Administrative Tribunal, if the employee or servant of the republic dies, than his/her heirs can be substituted in the pending proceeding as heirs of the deceased and right to so survive. But here there was no case pending against any dismissal or removal before the administrative tribunal when the employee died of cancer. Therefore, no question of substitution can be raised for the heirs of the deceased.
10. On plain reading of these sections it appears that only the servant of the republic may apply before the Administrative Tribunal or his heirs may be substituted in the case if he dies during pendency of the case filed by him against his removed or dismissal from service. But there is no such case pending in the Administrative Tribunal at the time of his death. In such view of the fact, the petitioners do rot have locus standi to file an application before the administrative tribunal as they are not servants in the republic.
II. In such a situation, the petitioners as heirs of the predecessor, have no other forum to seek relief rather to move this court with a writ petition invoking Article 102 of the Constitution. It is pertinent here to refer the case of Kazi Shamsunnahar vs Commandant RRF Khulna reported in 2 BLC 569 where their Lordships observed that
"Admittedly, the deceased government servant was not removed from service prior to his death but he was removed from service just after his death resulting thereby the government servant died while he was still in the service of the Republic for which the petitioners as heirs of the government servant are entitled to recover the service benefits as permissible under the law and the writ petition is maintainable".
12. In the instant case there is no dispute that Abdur Rouf Chowdhury was neither convicted nor removed, nor dismissed from service before his death. So the penalty imposed by the authority concerned upon the dead man is not legal in the eye of law. It is apparent that the petitioners are admittedly heirs of the deceased employee having no other forum except to invoke writ jurisdiction under Article 102 of the Constitution and since the predecessor of the petitioners was acquitted from the charge brought against him by the competent court of law, there is no bar to the petitioners as heirs of the ex-employee in obtaining full service benefits as per service rules. Furthermore, as the departmental proceeding was withdrawn by the concerned authority the service of the predecessor of the petitioners was seemed to be treated as regular one and all service benefits of the predecessor to be recovered by the petitioners as his heirs.
13. In view of the discussion as above, we are inclined to hold that the impugned orders (Annexures-H, E, F and FI to this writ petition) are ex-facie illegal and the same have been passed without any lawful authority and are of no legal effect, therefore, the petitioners as heirs of late Abdur Rob Chowdhury are entitled to get all service benefits including pension and arrear, if any, as permissible in law.
In the result the rule is made absolute without order as to costs. The impugned orders (Annexures-H, E, F and F1 to this writ petition) have been passed without lawful authority and are of no legal effect. The respondents are directed to pay full service benefits of late Abdur Rob Chowdhury to the petitioners as permissible under the law.
(Concluded)

0 Comments. Share your thoughts also.
Write a comment
Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Blaming loan defaulters is not enough, reasons must be examined


IT is reported that the big loan defaulters have not paid the huge debt to the banks despite their rescheduling by Bangladesh Bank in 2015. Now instead of paying their old debts, many businesspersons are moving around banks for a fresh loan. The Central Bank allowed rescheduling of loans of ...

Football »

Minus-Messi, Argentina lose another World Cup qualifier


AP, Sao Paulo :Hours after Lionel Messi was suspended by FIFA for four World Cup qualifying matches, Argentina lost 2-0 to Bolivia in the altitude of La Paz on Tuesday and heightened its risk of missing a spot at Russia 2018.Argentina dropped from third to fifth place, remaining on 22 ...

City »

Air Officer Commanding of Bangladesh Air Force Base Bir Sreshto Matiur Rahman Air Commodore Sheikh Abdul Hannan awarding


Entertainment »

Emma Roberts knows how to step away from spotlight


Emma Roberts has lived most of her life in the spotlight and the actress says that now she has learned a lot about how to handle it. The 26-year-old actress talked about how she has become proficient in maintaining a certain level of privacy when it comes to more personal ...

International »

Scottish Parliament votes for new independence referendum


Reuters, Edinburgh :The Scottish parliament on Tuesday backed First Minister Nicola Sturgeon's bid for a new independence referendum, further complicating Britain's political situation just as years of talks on the terms of Brexit were about to begin.The United Kingdom's vote last year to exit the European Union has strained ties ...

Editorial »

India must not feel too confident about defence pact


THE proposed defence pact with India to be signed early next month on New Delhi's pressure is creating growing public misgivings and many believe that the government should make the deal public to remove people's concern. Media reports said discussants at a round-table including academics, former diplomats and defence experts ...

Cricket »

Taskin hits hat-trick : Lanka make 311


Sports Reporter :Sri Lanka made a fighting total of 311 off 49.5 overs in their first innings against Bangladesh in the second One Day International (ODI) match at Rangiri Dambulla International Stadium in Dambulla, Sri Lanka on Tuesday.Sri Lanka could add at least 15 to 20 runs in their total ...

Entertainment »

The poster of Half Girlfriend launched


The first official poster of upcoming movie Half Girlfriend was launched yesterday. The cast and crew of Half Girlfriend were all geared up for the poster release of the film. Chetan Bhagat along with the lead cast of the film, Arjun Kapoor and Shraddha Kapoor, tweeted yesterday an image announcing ...

Entertainment »

Mizu Ahmed laid to rest


Entertainment Report :Legendary Dhallywood actor and producer Mizu Ahmed, best known for his negative roles, was laid to rest at own hometown’s graveyard in Kushtia yesterday. He died of cardiac arrest on Monday at 8:00pm at the age of 63. He breathed his last aboard a train at Airport Railway ...

International »

Worst humanitarian crisis hits as Trump slashes foreign aid


AP, Nairobi, Kenya :The world's largest humanitarian crisis in 70 years has been declared in three African countries on the brink of famine, just as President Donald Trump's proposed foreign aid cuts threaten to pull the United States from its historic role as the world's top emergency donor.If the deep ...

Editorial »

EU`s threat to scrap duty free export


THE European Union (EU) has asked Bangladesh to further improve the country's labour standard least to avoid suspension of duty free trade privileges. But it appears quite unjustified at a time when Bangladesh has significantly allowed Trade Union to workers  at factory level to represent their problems.  It appears that ...

Sports »

Bangladesh bag titles in Asian Zonal Chess


Bangladeshi emerged champions in both open and women's section in the Asian Zonal 3.2 Chess Championships Open and Women qualifying events of World Cup Chess and World Women Chess Championship that concluded on Monday in Kathmandu, Nepal. GM Mollah Abdullah Al Rakib became unbeaten champion in the open section. He ...

City »

Chairman of Northern University Bangladesh Trust Prof. Dr. A.Y.M. Abdullah confers a honourary crest to the Prime Minister's Economic Affairs Adviser Dr. Mashiur Rahman at a discussion and prize giving ceremony on its Banani campus on the occasion of 47th Independence Day on Saturday.


International »

61 bodies found in Mosul 10 days after air strike


Reuters, Mosul :Iraq's military said on Sunday that 61 bodies were recovered from a collapsed building that the militant Islamic State group had booby-trapped in west Mosul, but there was no sign the building had been hit by a coalition air strike.The military statement differed from reports by witnesses and ...

Entertainment »

Moushumi celebrates two eras of her film career


Entertainment Report :Popular film actress Moushumi celebrated two eras of her acting career on March 25.On this day in 1993, she started her acting career through Sohanur Rahman Sohan directed movie Keyamat Thekey Keyamat. To celebrate the day, Moushumi at her residence in the city’s Uttara area arranged a get-together ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news