Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, April 26, 2018 03:13:29 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Selling decreed property at shocking price ignoring decree-holder`s objection

By
22nd-Oct-2016       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

High Court Division :
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Farah Mahbub J
Kazi Md Ejarul Haque
Akondo J
Dutch Bangl Bank
Limited ………Petitioner
vs
Judge, Artha Rin Adalat No.3, Dhaka and others ............. Respondents
Judgment
July 2nd, 2015
Artha Rin Adalat Ain (VIII of 2003)
Section 33(2ga)
If it has been informed by the decree holder bank that the proposed bid offer is shockingly low the Adalat upon endorsing the reason thereof may reject .the proposal of the highest bidder.
In the present case, such reason is absolutely absent for the Adalat has accepted the highest bid in spite of objection being raised by the decree-holder bank observing, interalia, সংঘাত কারণে ডিক্রিদার কর্তৃক নিলাম বাতিল করবার প্রার্থনায় আনিত গত ৪-২-১৩ইং তারিখের দরখাস্তটি না-মঞ্জুর করা হলো। Thus it is apparent that the impugned order has been  passed by the executing Adalat in derogation the requirement as prescribed under Section 33(2ga) of the requirement as prescribed under Section 22 (2ga) of the Ain, 2003.
Md Farrukh Rahman, Advocate-For the Petitioner.
None appears-For the Respondents.
Judgment
Farah Mahbub J : In this Rule, issued under Article 102 of the Constitution of 4-2-2013 and order No.6 dated 10-2-2013 respectively passed by Artha Rin Adalat No.3, Dhaka in Artha Execution Case No. 154 of 2012 rejecting the application of the petitioner-bank for cancelling the auction sale on the ground that the bid price was shockingly low, should not be declared to have been passed without lawful authority and hence, is of no legal effect.
2. Facts, in brief, are that in order to recover the defaulted loan amount to the tune of Taka 142,768,375.09 the petitioner-bank instituted Artha Rin Suit No.4 of 2010 before the Artha Rin Adalat No.3, Dhaka on 11-1-2011 impleading the respondents concern, who were· the defaulted loanees. The defendants duly appeared and contested the suit by filling written statement. However, at the time of recording evidence the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 did not appear. Subsequently, the suit was decreed ex-parte by the Adalat concern vide judgment and decree dated 10-7-2007.
The judgment debtors having failed to payoff the decretal amount within the prescribed period of time as stipulated in the judgment and decree the decree holder bank filed Artha Execution Case No. 154 of 2012 before the executing Adalat for recovery of the decretal amount to the tune of Taka 24,06,94170.70 (Annexure-B). The Adalat duly issued summons as required under Section 30 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003. On the expiry of the period as prescribed in the notice debtors as security to the loan amount, as described in the schedule of the execution case under Section 33(1) of the Ain, 2003.
Accordingly, 5 (five) bidders participated in the bid. The highest bidder, however, offered Taka 4,74,95,250. Since the offer was substantially low comparing to the present market price the decree holder bank raised objection upon making an application under Section 33(2ga) of the Ain, 2003 before the executing Adalat for cancellation of the bid, Upon hearing the decree-holder bank, the Adalat fixed 10-2-2013 for order.
However, on 10-2-2013 the Adalat rejected the prayer of the petitioner bank so made earlier quoting the reason- সংঘাত কারণে ডিক্রিদার কর্তৃক নিলাম বাতিল করবার প্রার্থনায় আনিত গত ৪-২-১৩ইং তারিখের দরখাস্তটি না-মঞ্জুর করা হলো Hence, the application.
3. Mr Md Forrukh Rahman, the learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner drawing attention to the impugned order No.6 dated 10-22013 submits that the prayer of the petitioner bank to reject the auction bid being shockingly low considering the present market value has been knocked down by the executing Adalat merely on the plea msঘাত কারণে ডিক্রিদার কর্তৃক নিলাম বাতিল করবার প্রার্থনায় আনিত গত ৪-২-১৩ইং তারিখের দরখাস্তটি না-মঞ্জুর করা হলো without citing any reason whatsoever, which is not only a violation of the mandatory requirement as Hence, he submits that upon making the Rule absolute the said impugned order is liable to be struck down.
4. No one appears on behalf of the respondents concern though on perusal of the office record it appears that the respective notices of the instant Rule Nisi have been duly served upon all the respondents concern and the Rule was ultimately made ready for hearing on 20-1-2014.
5. Considering the submissions of the learned Advocate for the petitioner bank we have gone through the impugned order dated 10-2-2013 passed by the executing Adalat in connection with Artha Execution Case No. 154 of 2010.
6. The main contention of the petitioner in support of the Rule is that the mortgage property, which is a part of the decree, has been sold out by the Artha Rin Adalat as executing Adalat in exercise of power as provided under Section 33(1) of the Ain, 2003 at a shockingly low price in spite of raising objection to that effect by the decree holder bank without citing any reason whatsoever.
7. The impugned order Nos. 5 and 6 dated 10-2-2013 are hereby quoted below-
“৫। অদ্য নিলামের দিন ধার্য আছে। ডিক্রিদার পক্ষ হাজিরা সহ পত্রিকার কপি দাখিল করিয়াছে। পদাতিক নিলাম ইস্তেহার রীতিমত জারী অন্তে ফেরত আসিয়াছে।
মোঃ আবুল কালাম আজাদ ১নং তপসিলের মূল্য =২,২৮,০০,০০০ টাকা ২নং হিসাবে=৩২,০০,০০০ টাকাে পে অর্ডার নং ০৭৭৬৫১৫ তারিখ ৩১-১-১৩ইং দাখিল করিয়াছে। (৩) জসিম উদ্দিন পিতামৃত মফিজ উদ্দিন -১,২,৩ নং তফসিলের মুল্য ২,৯৫,০০,০০০ টাকা নির্ধারণ করিয়া ১০% হিসেবে ২৯,৫০,০০০ টাকা পে অর্ডার নং ২৩৭৫১৮৫ তারিখ ৩-২-১৩ইং তারিখ দাখিল করিয়াছে। (৪) মোঃ আলী হোসেন পিতা ঃ মোঃ জাফর আলী ২নং তপসিলেল মূল্য ৯০,০০,০০০ টাকা এবং ৩নং তপসিলের মূল্য ১,৩০,০০,০০০ টাকা নির্ধারণ করিয় জনতা ব্যাংক লিঃ এর চেক নং ৩৩০০৮২০৩ টাকা ১,৯০,০০০ টাকা দাখিল করিয়াছে।”
(৫) সৈয়দ বাবর উদ্দিন পিতা গাজিউল হক ২নং তপসিলের মূল্য ১,০৬,০০,০০০ টাকা নির্ধারণ করিয়া ১০% হিসাবে ১০,৬০,০০০ টাকা পে-অর্ডার নং-০৫৩৭৪২০ তারিখ ৪-২-২০১৩ দাখিল করিয়াছে।
ডিক্রিদার পক্ষ দরখাস্ত দ্বারা সম্পত্তির মূল্য অপর্যাপ্ত হওয়ায় নিলাম বাতিলের প্রার্থনা করিয়াছে। দেখলাম আগামী ১০-২-২০১৩ ইং তারিখে উক্ত বিষয়ে আদেশ
স্বা-অস্পষ্ট
জজ
অর্থঋণ আদালত-৩
ঢাকা
৬। ১০-২-২০১৩ অদ্য আদেশের জন্য দিন ধার্য আছে।
ডিক্রিদারপক্ষ হাজিরা দিয়াছে। নথি আদেশের জন্য পেশ করা হইল।
নথি আদেশের জন্য নেয়া হলো । বিটসীটসহ অত্র আদালতের সেরেস্তাদারের গত ৪-২-২০১৩ইং তারিখের প্রতিবেদন দেখলাম ও নথি পর্যালোচনা করলাম। নথি পর্যালোচনায় দেখা যায় গত ৪-২-২০১৩ তারিখের নিলাম ডাকে মোট ৫টি দরপত্র দাখিল হয়েছে। তন্মধ্যে অত্র জারীকৃত মামলার দরখাস্তের তিনটি তপসিলের সম্পত্তি বাবদ ১নং ক্রমিকের মোঃ আবুল কালাম আজাদ সর্বোচ্চ ৪,৭৪,৯৫,২৫০ টাকার নিলাম দরপত্র দাখিল করছে।
এমতাবস্থায় সর্বোচ্চ দরদাতা মোঃ আবুল কালাম আজাদ কর্তৃক দাখিলীয় দরপত্রটি সন্তোষজনক পণ্যে গ"হীত হলেঅ। সত্বর পাউন্ডেজ ফি দাখিলের জন্য সর্বোচ্চ দরদাতাকে নির্দেশ প্রদান করা হলো। সর্বোচ্চ দরদাতার পে-অর্ডার ব্যতীত অপর পে-অর্ডার সমূহ ফেরত দেয়া হোক। আগামী ১১-৩-২০১৩ইং তারিখের মধ্যে নিলামকৃত বাকি টাকা জমা দানের জন্য নিলাম ক্রেতাকে নির্দেশ প্রদান করা হলো। সংগত কারণে ডিক্রিদার কর্তৃক নিলাম বাতিল করবার প্রার্থনায় আনিত গত ৪-২-২০১৩ ইং তারিখের দরখাস্তটি না-মঞ্জুর করা হলো। সংগত ৪-২-২০১৩ইং তারিখের দরখাস্তটি না-মঞ্জুর করা হলো।”
8. On perusal of the orders, as quoted above, it appears that the executing Adalat has accepted the bid of the highest bidder quoting Taka 4,74,95,250 in spite of the objection so raised by the decree holder bank under section 33(2ga) of the Ain, 2003.
(২গ) ডিক্রিদারের পক্ষে যদি লিখিতভাবে আদালতকে এই মর্মে অবহিত করা হয় যে, উপ-ধারা (২) এর অধীন দাখিলকৃত দরপত্রে সম্পত্তির প্রস্তাবকৃত মূল্য অস্বাভাবিকভাবে অপর্যাপ্ত বা কম এবং আদালত যদি উহাতে  একমত পোষণ করে, তাহা হইলে আদালত, কারণ লিপিবদ্ধ করিয়া, উক্ত দর প্রস্তাব অগ্রাহ্য করিতে পারিবে।
9. Vide sub-section 2(ga) of Section 33 it is the requirement of law that of it has been informed by the decree holder bank that the proposed bid offer is shockingly low the Adalat upon endorsing the reason thereof may reject the proposal of the highest bidder. In the present case, such reason is absolutely absent for the Adalat has accepted the highest bid in spite of objection being raised by the decree-holder bank observing inter-alia, msঘাত কারণে ডিক্রিদার কর্তৃক নিলাম বাতিল করবার প্রার্থনায় আনিত গত ৪-২-১৩ইং তারিখের দরখাস্তটি না-মঞ্জুর করা হলো। Thus it is apparent that the impugned order has been passed by the executing Adalat in derogation of the requirement as prescribed under Section 33(2ga) of the Ain, 2003.
10. Considering the above facts and  circumstances, observations and findings we find substance in the instant Rule and accordingly, this Rule is made absolute.
11. The impugned order No.5 dated 4-2-2013 and order No.6 dated 10-2-2013 respectively passed in connection with Artha Execution Case No. 154 of 2012 by the Artha Rin Adalat No.3, Dhaka are hereby.
12. The executing Adalat is hereby directed to proceed with the process of execution proceedings in strict compliance of law.
There will be no order as to costs.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Stop women harassment on running buses


A DHAKA court on Tuesday placed three staffers including driver of a Turag Paribahan bus in a case filed over sexually harassing a private university female student in the running bus on her way to campus. According to the case statement, on April 21, the girl boarded the bus on ...

International »

Trump, Russia and China media attacks `threaten democracy`


AFP, Paris :Press freedom around the world is under threat from a triple whammy of US President Donald Trump, Russia and China's bid to crush all dissent, a watchdog said Wednesday.Reporters Without Borders (RSF) warned that a "climate of hatred and animosity" towards journalists combined with growing attempts to control ...

Football »

Liverpool`s Mohamed Salah celebrates with teammates after scoring his side's opening goal during the Champions League semifinal, first leg, soccer match between Liverpool and Roma at Anfield Stadium in Liverpool, England on Tuesday.


Entertainment »

Yami hopes to help kids, one book at a time


Yami Gautam, actress of the upcoming Batti Gul and Uri posted on her social media that she has just supported and donated towards setting up a library for under privileged kids in Kohlapur, Maharashtra. Her donation will help over 400 children in the area to read, learn and imagine. The ...

City »

Human rights activist Dr Hamida Hossain, among others, at a seminar on 'Socio-economic Development of Dalit Women in Bangladesh and National Budget' organised by different organisations in CIRDAP Auditorium in the city on Wednesday.


Football »

Members of Dhaka Abahani Limited during their practice session at the Abahani Ground on Tuesday.


Sports »

Senior Operative Director (Head of Games & Sports Department) of Walton Group FM Iqbal Bin Anwar Dawn (second from left) speaking at a press conference at the Club House in Army Golf Club on Tuesday.


Entertainment »

Sonam to quit Bollywood!


Sonam Kapoor's wedding has been one of the most talked about topics of discussion in the industry. A lot of speculations are being made about Sonam-Anand's wedding. Recent reports suggested that Sonam will be shifting to London post her wedding with Anand.These speculations even gave rise to rumours that Sonam ...

Editorial »

Police must not feel free to abuse police power against police discipline


A MOTORCYCLE was stolen from in front of a high police official's residence last week. Motorbikes are the easiest target for thieves. They either stealthily take away the bikes or stop the riders at night and snatch away their bikes. Sometimes, the bikers are knifed or beaten up. Last year, ...

International »

Dinner over, Trump, Macron get down to business


AFP :After a friendly dinner at a US landmark, US President Donald Trump and his French counterpart Emmanuel Macron were to get down to business Tuesday on divisive issues like the Iran nuclear accord and international trade.They were to meet face to face for half an hour, and then again ...

Editorial »

Justice delayed justice denied


FIVE years have elapsed after the Rana Plaza collapse in Savar which is known as deadliest garment-factory accident in history, as well as the deadliest structural failure in the modern human history. At least 1136 garment workers were killed on the spot and 1169 received severe injuries when the multi-storied ...

Cricket »

Shakib, Tamim to play for ICC World XI against West Indies


Bangladeshi all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan and top order batsman Tamim Iqbal have been included in the ICC World XI to play West Indies team in a one-off T20I match at Lord's on May 31.The match is being organised to raise fund for the reconstruction of stadiums that were damaged in ...

Sports »

(Left to right)) Uttam Mundy, CEO, PGTI; Arshi Haider, Chairman of bti; Siddikur Rahman, Professional Golfer; Asif Ibrahim, President, BPGA; Johnson Poh, Professional Golfer, Honey Baisoya, Professional Golfer unveiling the bti Open 2018 Trophy on Monday.


Entertainment »

Shilpa Shetty Kundra is Inspirational Celebrity of the Year


A successful wellness guru Shilpa Shetty Kundra is one of cinema’s most loved names. Her rise has nothing short of meteoric. This actress turned entrepreneur has to her credit successful yoga DVDs, a health and fitness channel is also a top-selling selling author of two books based on her mantra ...

Entertainment »

Richa Chadha’s new song look inspired by Parveen Babi’s Jawani Janeman


Actress Richa Chadha is considered to be the front-runner in Bollywood for experimenting with her looks and character in the films she does. Right from playing an old woman Nagma Khatoon in her first commercial success hit, Gangs of Wasseypur series to her soon to release film Daasdev, Richa has ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news