Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, March 2, 2017 01:54:47 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Parental alienation syndrome : Fact or fiction?

photo by

By
30th-Oct-2016       Readers ( 306 )   0 Comments
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all (0) »

Tia Benjamin :
The theory of Parental Alienation Syndrome was advanced by Richard Gardner in 1987 through his self-published book, The Parental Alienation Syndrome and the Differentiation Between Fabricated and Genuine Child Sex Abuse.
Parental Alienation Syndrome-known as PAS-is a theoretical disorder that arises primarily in custody battles, in which one parent supposedly turns a child against the estranged parent with allegations of abuse or neglect. It's described as having three core components:
Programming. Garner argues that children are actively brainwashed and programmed by one parent against the other, alienating the child from that parent.
False Accusations. The theory suggests that one parent-typically the mother-makes false allegations of sexual or other abuse against the other parent, and uses this as a reason to deny visitation rights and compound the alienation. Through programming, the child may even believe the false accusations are true.
Deprogramming. Gardner recommends that to remedy the alienation, the child should be entirely removed from the alienating parent and placed with the alleged abuser for "deprogramming." During the first deprogramming period, all contact-even via telephone-with the alienating parent is prohibited.
The theory of PAS is extremely controversial. Disturbing cases are often cited in criticism of Gardner's theory. One example is the case involving a four-year-old girl, who returned home from unsupervised visitation with her father, and told her mom in detail about his sexual abuse of her. Because the little girl's story wasn't always consistent in her many later interviews with child protective services and various psychologists, the court deemed the mother an alienating parent, who had made up the abuse. As a result, the court gave full custody to the alleged abuser and ordered all contact with the mother must stop.
Over the years, PAS has received widespread criticism from child psychiatrists, abuse experts and attorneys for many reasons, not least because they fear the approach is not supported by the evidence, and puts vulnerable children at risk.
Biased. The theory has been accused of advancing inherent biases against women and children. Because women are statistically more likely to be the custodial parent, men are more likely to have problems with visitation. Distinguished Professor Emerita, Carol S. Bruch, at the University of California, Davis, says men are also "more likely to have money for expert services and 'coaching' for their trial attorneys."
Fails to Resolve Parenting Problems. Bruch observes that "claims of parental alienation turn the court's attention to the custodial parent, and means any parenting problems that might exist are largely ignored." She adds, "Instead of helping these men learn what they might do to make visits work better for their children, they are charged exorbitant fees for what cannot help the quality of their visits and may make things very much worse for their children."
Not recognized. The American Psychiatric Association does not recognize Gardner's theory as a formal psychiatric diagnosis, and his own personal credentials are overstated in the literature. Even the New York Times incorrectly cited Gardner as a professor of child psychiatry at Columbia University, when in fact he never held this title. Instead, he "was a clinical professor of psychiatry in the division of child and adolescent psychiatry-an unpaid volunteer," according to the paper's correction to its initial misstatement.
Not scientific. Gardner's books were self-published and were not subject to peer review. No formal research was undertaken-Gardner made his conclusions based on his observations of his own patients-and experts believe his assessments of the number of fabricated abuse cases, which he initially suggested were as high as 90 percent, are overstated and not factual.
Despite its flaws, Parental Alienation Syndrome continues to be raised as a defense in family courts around the country. In fact, the New York Times reported that Gardner testified in over 400 such child custody cases before committing suicide on May 25, 2003.
PAS isn't limited to American courtrooms-Bruch notes that the theory has spread around the world through continuing education courses, lectures and fathers' rights websites and media campaigns, to the despair of family law professors and mental health professionals.
Currently, supporters of the theory are lobbying for its inclusion in the upcoming DSM-5-the fifth edition of Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-in May 2013. Conversely, the American Psychological Association has joined forces with the British Psychological Society, Danish Psychological Association, American Counseling Association, American Psychoanalytic Association, The UK Council for Psychotherapy and a host of other organizations to send an open letter to the DSM-5, calling PAS "unsubstantiated and questionable" and stating it has "virtually no basis in the empirical literature."

0 Comments. Share your thoughts also.
Write a comment
Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Is amending law enough to save banks from family control


THE government is under pressure to amend the Banking Companies Act 1981 to increase the number of family members in the board of directors of private commercial banks. Officials said that the maximum number of directors from a family might increase to four from the existing two following demand by ...

Sports »

Roger Federer reveals plan to capture 2017 Wimbledon title to add to Australian Open win


Roger Federer has labeled his most recent win at the 2017 Australian Open a 'team victory' for all the sacrifices they had to make in the last years. The 18-time Grand Slam champion admitted that doubts had crept in after four-and-a-half years without a major title, but was delighted to ...

Football »

Finals of Bangabandhu & Bangamata Primary School Football today


Sports Reporter :The finals of the Bangabandhu Gold Cup Primary School Football Tournament and Bangamata Begum Fazilatunnesa Mujib Gold Cup Primary School Football Tournament will be held today at the Bangabandhu National Stadium. After the final matches, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina will distribute the prizes among the winners as the ...

Entertainment »

Dum Laga Ke Haisha changed my life: Bhumi Pednekar


Actress Bhumi Pednekar, who was seen playing a smart plus-sized girl named Sandhya in Dum Laga Ke Haisha, says the National Award winning film changed her life. Dum Laga Ke Haisha completed two years since its release on Monday. The 27-year-old actress says the film is special to her. “Two ...

City »

Barrister Ahmed Ehsanul Kabir, Assistant Professor of Law, Jagannath University and Barrister Shuvra Chowdhury, Assistant Professor of Law, Stamford University presenting their book on Media and Cyber Laws to President Abdul Hamid at Bangabhaban on Monday.


International »

Trump recommits to US allies but says must pay `fair share`


Reuters, Washington :President Donald Trump on Tuesday reaffirmed support for the United States' longstanding security alliances around the world but insisted that friends and partners from Europe to the Middle East to the Pacific must "pay their fair share of the cost."In his first nationally televised speech to Congress since ...

Editorial »

Criminals on job as security men


NEWS report said several accused charged with criminal cases were working as security guards at a Gazipur garment factory for about a month. They were hired from a security firm where they took the job concealing their identity and using fake names. They used their time with the new employers' ...

Sports »

BKSP Teakwondo team, the champions of the 1st BKSP Cup Teakwondo Competition with the guests and officials of BKSP pose for a photo session at BKSP in Savar on Tuesday.


.

City »

Bangladesh Swadhinata Parishad formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Tuesday in protest against unrest in the name of hartal.


.

Entertainment »

Vidyut & Adah`s special gesture for their fans


The promotions of Commando 2 are in full swing, with Vidyut Jammwal and Adah Sharma giving it their all to entertain their fans. The duo was in Pune at the ASM college, where they had an interesting interaction with the students.  Vidyut has been an inspiration for his martial arts ...

International »

Russian frigate heads to Mediterranean on Syria mission


Reuters, Sevastopol :The Russian frigate Admiral Grigorovich left the port of Sevastopol in Crimea on Monday for the Mediterranean where it will join the country's naval forces deployed near the Syrian coast, a naval official said.A Reuters witness saw the ship leaving its moorings in the naval port of Sevastopol."It ...

Editorial »

Banning some risky drug companies is not enough : Govt has to play its part


THE High Court on Monday asked the government to stop producing and marketing of antibiotic, penicillin and hormone drugs of 28 pharmaceutical companies within 72 hours beginning from the same day. Furthermore, the court also issued a rule asking the concerned authorities of the government to explain why the earlier ...

City »

Consumers Association of Bangladesh formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Monday demanding withdrawal of increased price of gas.


City »

Jatiya Party Chairman Hussain Muhammad Ershad , among others, holds the copies of a book titled `Bangladesh`s Politics` written by the party's presidium member Sahidur Rahman Tepa at its cover unwrapping ceremony in the auditorium of Kachi-Kanchar Mela in the city on Monday.


Entertainment »

Singer Richa Sharma to appear on small screen


Melody Queen Richa Sharma at Indian Idol Season 9! It would be the simplest thing in the world that Richa Sharma is a phenomenal singer and get done with it. But her talent isn’t that easy or slot or unravel nor is her genius easily classifiable or even observable. One ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news