Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, February 22, 2018 05:06:17 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Professional diary of an Advocate be consulted first to estimate his Income-Tax

By
05th-Nov-2016       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

High Court Division :
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
AFM Abdur Rahman J
FRM Nazmul Ahasan J
Judgment November 15th, 2012
Ashraful Kamal
 (Md) ………
Assessee--Applicant
vs
Commissioner of  Taxes Dhaka …………    
........... Respondent
Income Tax Ordinance (XXXVI of 1984)
Sections 35(4) and 83(2)
The DCT can resort to the provisions of Section 35(4) of the ordinance even for a professional, but in order to deal with the assessee, who is an Advocate of the Bangladesh Supreme Court, the exact way to estimate the income lies in the consultation of his professional diary he maintains and if he fails to furnish the diary, upon notice under the provisions of Section 83(2) of the Ordinance, then only the estimation on the basis of other documents can be resorted to but on whim and caprice of the DCT concerned. . ..... (12)
Mosharaf Hossain, Advocate-For the Assessee-Applicant.
Abu Amzad, DAG with Mahfuza Begum, AAG-For IT Department.
Judgment
AFM Abdur Rahman J : In this IT Reference application, under Section 160 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 1984, the following questions have been formulated by the Assessee-applicant seeking an opinion of this court;
(1) In the circumstance and on the facts whether the Taxes Appellate Tribunal, Division Bench-3 Dhaka was justified estimating professional income of the applicant without having any definite information or basis and ignoring the past record?
(2) In the circumstances and on the facts whether the Taxes Appellate Tribunal Division Bench-3, Dhaka, was justified estimating the family expenses in reducing form ?
Facts of the Case
2. It has been asserted in the application that the Assessee-Applicant Mr Ashraful Kamal is a professional person practicing as an Advocate in the Supreme Court of Bangladesh and an income tax payer, having tax identification No. (TIN) 249-200-5421/Circle-87 Taxes Zone-8. The Assessee-Applicant derives income from the profession of Advocacy who submitted his tax return for the assessment year 2008-2009 showing a total income of Taka 10,50,334. Subsequently, the Assessee Applicant produced relevant documents supporting the income and expenses, in support of the return, pursuant to the notice as has been served by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxes, Circle-87, Taxes Zone-8, Dhaka, who after hearing the representative of the Assessee Applicant most arbitrarily ignored the shown income in the return and estimated the total income of the Assessee-Applicant at Taka 23,33,333 upon estimating exaggerated professional income of the Assessee-Applicant along with enhancing the family expenses and adding the same with total income determining the total income of the Assessee-Applicant arbitrarily.
3. Being aggrieved with and highly dissatisfied by the said assessment, the Assessee-Applicant preferred two unsuccessful appeal before the Appellate Joint Commissioner of Taxes, Appellate Range-4, Taxes Appeal Zone-2, Dhaka and also the Taxes Appellate Tribunal Division Bench-3, Dhaka.
4. Being aggrieved with and highly dissatisfied with the said order passed by the taxes Appellate Tribunal in appeal, the Assessee Applicant upon formulating aforementioned the questions filed the instant IT Reference for an opinion from this court.
5.Upon service of the notice, the learned Deputy Attorney-General Mr Abu Amzad along with Assistant Attorney-General Ms Mahfuza Begum appeared on behalf of the income tax department, while the learned Advocate Mr Mosharaf Hossain represented the Assessee-Applicant before this court at the time of hearing.
6. We have heard the learned Advocate Mr Mosharaf Hossain and the learned Deputy Attorney-General Mr Abu Amzad and perused the materials on record.
Argument of the parties.
7. It has been argued by the learned Advocate Mr Mosharaf Hossain that the concerned DCT is not empowered to ignore the statement of income of the Assessee-Applicant without any definite knowledge or without considering any further evidence specially the professional Diary maintained by each and every Advocate that the Assessee-Applicant has earned much higher income then the claim in the concerned return, since no method of accounting although has been employed by Assessee-Applicant, yet as he has disclosed his all income through filing the bank statement and also the relevant papers and documents, the concerned DCT cannot rely upon the provision of Section 35(4) of the income tax ordinance 1984 and apply his unfettered discretion on the so called ground that the actual income is not deducible from the account as has been submitted by the Assessee-Applicant.
8. These arguments have been refuted by the learned Deputy Attorney-General Mr Abu Amzad, appearing on behalf of the IT Department through the assertion that the provision of Section 35(4) of the income tax ordinance 1984 has empowered the DCT to ignore any account of a professional, as sub-section (1) of the said section provided that the professional, which includes· Advocate of Bangladesh Supreme Court, who does not employ regular method of accounting for which the actual income is not deducible then the DCT may recourse to the estimation process as has been provided in sub-section (4) of Section 35 of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984 upon exercising his discretion and since in the instant case the Assessee-Applicant admittedly has not employed any regular method of accounting, the concerned DCT had lawfully resorted to the Provisions of Section 35(4) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984.
Deliberation of the Court
9. It appears that the Assessee-Applicant filed his return for the Assessment year 2008-2009 showing an income of Taka 10,50,334. But the concerned DCT discarded the statement of income of the Assessee-Applicant and made an estimation of the income of the Assessee-Applicant upon expressing his view in the following language;
করদাতা সুপ্রীম কোর্টের একজন আইনজীবী হিসাবে পেশাগত আয় প্রাপ্ত হন। করদাতা আয় প্রাপ্তির সমর্থনে বিধি-৮ অনুযায়ী হিসাবের খাত সংরক্ষণ করেন না। হিসাবের খাতাপত্রের অবর্তমানে প্রদর্শিত আয় যাচাই করা গেল না। করদাতার দাখিলকৃত ৩টি ব্যাংক বিবরণী পরীক্ষায় দেখা যায় যে, (১) প্রাইম ব্যাংক লিঃ, সঞ্চয়ী হিসাব নং-২১০৪৭০৬৮ তে মোট টাঃ ২,৮০,০০০ (২) প্রাইম ব্যাংক লিঃ সঞ্চয়ী হিসাব নং-৭৫০০১৮০১ তে মোট ২,৮২,৮০০ (৩) সোনালী ব্যাংক, সুপ্রীমকোর্ট শাখা, সঞ্চয়ী হিসাব নং-৩৪০৪৪৬৮ তে জমা টাঃ ১৯,৫৯,৮১১ (৪) ন্যাশনাল ব্যাংক বিটিএমসি ভবন, কাওরান বাজার শাখা সঞ্চয়ী হিসাব নং-০০৩-৪০৪৭-৩৩২ তে জমা মোট ১,০০,০০০। চারটি ব্যাংকে মোট জমা টাঃ ২৬,২২,৬১১। করদাতা একজন আইনজীবী হিসাবে ব্যাংকের মাধ্যমে লেনদেনের পাশাপাশি নগদ প্রাপ্তি থাকা স্বাভাবিক বিধায় আয় সম্পূর্ণরূপে ব্যাংক বিবরণী দ্বারা সম্ভব নহে। তাহা ছাড়া করদাতার সুনাম, অভিজ্ঞতা, খ্যাতি/ইত্যাদি সার্বিক বিচেনায় প্রদর্শিত আয় কম বলিয়া প্রতীয়মান হয়। এমতাবস্থায় প্রদর্শিত প্রাপ্তি নাকচ করিয়া উপর্যুক্ত আলোচনার ভিত্তিতে নিম্নরূপে আয় প্রাক্কলন করা হইল।
10. The reason for resorting to the Provisions of Section 35(4) of the income tax ordinance 1984 is that the four bank accounts, of whose statement submitted by the Assessee-Applicant before the concerned DCT, does not tally as to the income shown by the Assessee-Applicant. But it further appears that the concerned DCT while considered the Ki`vZvi mybvg, AwfÁZv, L¨vwZ BZ¨vw`, did not consider whether the Assessee-Applicant is a very senior lawyer of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh or he has a long standing in the profession deriving high income from the immense client which can be easily ascertained by the concerned DCT asking the evidence to be produced by producing the professional diary etc. It appears from the member's list of Supreme Court Bar Association that the Assessee-applicant was a junior lawyer at the time of filing of the return for the assessment year 2008-2009. Therefore, the finding that he had huge income in the income year 2008-2009 without being supported by any of the document or by the Diary of the Assessee-Applicant, the same appears to be a exaggerated exercise of the discretion rendered to the DCT through the provision of Section 35(4) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984 and, as such, not only without any basis also arbitrary. Any finding made upon exercising of discretion under the provision of Section 35(4) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984, which will affect the Assessee-Applicant adversely, the same is required to be supported by definite evidence before the DCT.
11. Herein the instance case the concerned DCT may call for farther document under the provision of Section 83(2) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984, specially the professional diary of the Assessee-Applicant and the Supreme Court Bar Association list in order to satisfy himself as to the real standing of him, the quantity of clients and the income of such a junior Advocate of the Bangladesh Supreme Court and without having considering such evidence the DCT most arbitrarily resorted to the Provisions of Section 35(4) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984 and estimated the income of the Assessee-Applicant. Therefore, this court finds the question as has been formulated by the Assessee-Applicant is required to be answered in negative and in favour of the Assessee- Applicant.
12. Although this court is in agreement with the learned Deputy Attorney-General Mr Abu Amzad that the DCT can resort to the Provisions of Section 35(4) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984 even for a professional, but in order to deal with the instant Assessee-Applicant, who is an Advocate of the Bangladesh Supreme Court, the exact way to estimate the income lies in the consultation of his professional diary he maintains and if he fails to furnish the said diary, upon notice under the Provisions of Section 83(2) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984, then only the estimation on the basis of other documents can be resorted to but on whim and caprice of the DCT concerned. That being not done in the instant proceeding by the DCT and the same not being considered by two lower appellate authority we are inclined to allow the instant reference application answering the questions in negative and in favour of the Assessee- Applicant.
13. Accordingly the IT Reference succeeds.
14. The questions as has been formulated by the Assessee-Applicant are answered in negative and in favour of the Assessee-Applicant.
However, there shall be no order as to costs.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Ekushey tells us to be free and fearless against injustice


THE Nation celebrates 'Amar Ekushey' today with due solemnity and colourful festivities to remember the Martyrs of the 1952 Language Movement. It is a landmark occasion and a day of awakening in the history of Bengali people that gave us the clear realization that we have our own language and ...

Cricket »

Captain of Bangladesh National Cricket (ODI) team Mashrafe Bin Mortaza handing over a crest of honour to Hafiz Yasin Arafat at the Bashundhara International Convention Centre in the city recently. Yasin Arafat became Hafiz-e-Quran in 86 days. He was a student of Tanjimul Ummah Hifz Madrasah of Cox's Bazar. Ahlul Huffaz Foundation Bangladesh arranged the reception programme.


Sports »

Medalists in the ice dance, free dance figure skating (from left) : Gabriella Papadakis and Guillaume Cizeron, of France (silver), Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir of Canada (gold) and Maia Shibutani and Alex Shibutani of the United States (bronze) pose during their medals ceremony at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea on Tuesday.


International »

Trump backs improved background checks on gun buys


US President Donald Trump signaled support Monday for improving background gun checks amid mounting pressure for reform in the wake of the Florida school shooting, as the accused gunman appeared in court.Nikolas Cruz, charged with killing 17 people, sat silently with his head bowed during a procedural hearing in Fort ...

International »

Nepal wants to deepen ties with China: K P Oli


PTI, Kathmandu : Nepal's new Prime Minister K P Oli has said he wants to deepen ties with China to explore more options and get more leverage in his dealings with India "in keeping with the times". Mr Oli, widely regarded as pro-China, also said he wants to "update" relations with ...

Business & Economy »

M Fakhrul Alam, Managing Director of ONE Bank Limited and Rezaul Islam, General Manager of Bangladesh Bank sign a participatory agreement regarding use of JICA assisted Foreign Direct Investment Promotion Project fund recently. Governor Fazle Kabir, Deputy Governor Abu Hena Moh. Razi Hasan, Executive Director Ahmed Jamal of Bangladesh Bank, chief representatives of JICA Bangladesh office Takatoshi Nishikata and among other were also present on the occasion.


Entertainment »

Inspired by the journey of Deepika and Anushka: Nidhhi Agerwal


Nidhhi Agerwal who hails from Bangalore and is living independently in Mumbai currently believes Deepika and Anushka's journey to the top has inspired her a lot. Just like the other two Bollywood divas, Nidhhi also went through her part of the struggle to make it to Bollywood. The young actress ...

City »

Law enforcers intercepted women leaders and activists of Jatiyatabadi Chhatra Dal when they were going to visit BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia with fruits at Old Dhaka Central Jail on Tuesday.


Sports »

Medalists in the women's 12.5-kilometer mass start biathlon (from right) Belarus' Darya Domracheva (silver), Slovakia's Anastasiya Kuzmina (gold) and Norway's Tiril Eckhoff (bronze) pose during their medals ceremony at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea on Sunday.


Entertainment »

I am very excited about working with Akshay Kumar: Parineeti


Parineeti Chopra, who will be sharing screen space for the first time with Akshay Kumar, says she is excited to work with the superstar in Kesari.The film, being directed by Anurag Singh, will see Akshay essaying the role of Havildar Ishar Singh, while Parineeti plays his wife."(I) am very excited ...

Editorial »

We welcome UK`s removal of ban on direct air cargo


THE UK government has fully withdrawn the two-year-long ban on direct cargo flights from Dhaka to London ending the plight of exporters, particularly garment exporters who were facing difficulty to make emergency shipment of samples and other cargo to buyers within the stipulated time. The British government said it is ...

City »

Buyers flip through the books at a stall of Amar Ekushey Book Fair on Bangla Academy premises in the city on Monday.


International »

Syrian forces to back YPG` in fight against Turkey


Al Jazeera News :The Kurdish YPG fighters claim they have reached a deal to allow Syrian government troops to enter Afrin in the northwestern part of the border town.Nuri Mahmoud, a spokesman for the People's Protection Units (YPG), told Al Jazeera on Monday that they are calling on the Syrian ...

Editorial »

Cleansing operation to stop leakage of question


QUESTION leakage during the ongoing SSC examination showed that the government has no power and the Education Ministry has no control over the corrupt people handling the question papers. So far questions of all 10 tests were openly available around the examination centers in Dhaka city and other places from ...

Sports »

Simidele Adeagbo of Nigeria reacts in the finish area after the final run of the women's skeleton competition at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang, South Korea on Saturday.


 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news