Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, June 21, 2018 10:11:55 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Legitimacy of writing judgment after retirement

By
19th-Nov-2016       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Md Raisul Islam Sourav :
All the world over true peace depends not upon gunpowder but upon pure justice"  Mahatma Gandhi  
The writing of a judgment is one of the most important tasks among other activities performed by a judge. Very recently a debate has been arising in our country whether a judge can write verdict after retirement. However, neither the Constitution nor the Supreme Court of Bangladesh Rules (both High Court Division and Appellate Division) have any clear cut provision regarding the timeframe to write a judgment. Indeed in this country there is no time limit to finish the writing of a judgment It totally depends upon the discretion to the concerned judge. Never-theless it is a time consuming task and it takes major part of judge's work. Moreover, backlog of cases has put a great pressure on the judges to accomplish their duties timely.
The judgment writing offers occasions for judicial officers to express his/her own ability and his/her worthiness to be a member in the high tradition of moral integrity and social rutility. The judgment is also a reflection of the conscience of a judge, who writes it and evidences his impartiality, integrity and intellectual honesty. However, a judgment is not written only for the benefit of the parties concerned. It is also written for the benefit of legal profession, other judges and the appellate courts ultimately. Before scripting a judgment a judge must consider that he is performing a public act of communicating his opinion on the issues brought before him and after the trial by observing fair procedures. It is basically a communication to the parties coming before him for a decision.
However, there is a golden saying that "Judgment delayed is judgment denied".
It is perfectly understandable that litigants should expect to know of the outcome of their cases and the reasons behind it as soon as practically possible. Depending on a number of factors, including time, constraints, the nature of the evidence led and the complexity of the matter, both in terms of facts or the applicable law and the importance and urgency of the case, one is expected to deliver a judgment soon after the case is finalised.
However, it be comes a custom in our country that judge pronounces the decision in open court immediately after completing the trial processes and delivering detail judgment at his own convenience even after retirement. It is expected by all that no judge should delaying in deliver his judgment.
However, a judge may seat for hearing till his last day of service which makes the thing difficult. Problem arises when a judge pronounced his/her decision during his tenure and giving detail verdict at a latter time after his service period. Due to absence of any clear cut provision, a question has arisen whether it is legal.
There is no law or judgment on this particular matter. Nevertheless unreasonable delay may bring severe consequences for the justice seekers even it can frustrate the outcome.
Invariably this result in inordinate delays and worse may result in the judicial officer not being able to recall the reasons which prompted him/her to make the order that he/she made.
Now question comes whether a retired judge can handle public document.
The answer to this question is not too easy. Generally he cannot. But what happen if it requires to give the full judgment what s/he declared earlier? Again there is no law or ruling on this point.
Though he announced his decision and needs to show his contention hence he may be permitted to do it within possible shortest time unless contrary is being enacted hy the parliament or settled by the court. Otherwise, many of the earlier landmark decisions will become invalid.
Additionally, a Supreme Court judge has some embargo even after his retirement. So mere retirement may not ceasing his capacity to write judgment. Furthermore, in this particulars case, he only deals with the documents relating with his given decision which is necessary to accomplish the whole process of justice.
If one is not allowed to do it then something must be invented to give redress to the justice seekers.
On the contrary, in some exceptional cases, a judge may not being able to reach his/her decision without being conversant with the matter appropriately. In that case he may take time to declare his decision. However, in Anil Ray vs State of Bihar AIR (2001) SC 3173 the Indian Supreme Court held that as the pronouncement of the judgement is a part of justice dispensation system, it has to be without delay and the court bind the time limit to three months to deliver judgment. In addition, it suggested some ways to the Chief Justice of India to make the process speedier. Similarly our Chief Justice can take necessary steps to make it binding to deliver judgment within possible shortest time.
However, according to Justice Sunil. Ambwani of Allahabad High Court, India; there is a difference between neutrality and impartiality. Impartiality requires cool reason uncontaminated thinking without being influenced by personal commitments biases and preconceptions. The neutrality on the other hand means the judge is non-aligned. A Judge may being neutral and continue to be so in the process of the trial, but at the end he has to decide the case in favour of either of the parties without any partiality. Impartiality requires a judge to rise above all values and perspectives.

(Assistant Professor and Coordinator, Department of Law at Dhaka International University)

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Entertainment »

Race 3 inches towards Rs 200 cr mark


Salman Khan's film Race 3 is unstoppable. The film, which hit screens on June 15, is giving all sorts of reasons for the star cast to celebrate. The Remo D'Souza directorial had already crossed the benchmark of Rs 100 crore at the Indian box office. But interestingly, the Salman fever ...

Editorial »

Unfortunately government has no political leadership to restore peace in Chattogram Hill Tracts


THREE more activists of Parbatya Chattogram Janasanghati Samity (MN Larma) and United People's Democratic Front (Democratic) were shot dead at their homes in Rangamati and Khagrachhari districts between Friday and Sunday. Conflicts between different groups in Chattogram Hill Tracts have led to the death of at least 22 people in ...

Business & Economy »

Shibbir Mahmud, Chairman, Board of Directors of Islamic Finance and Investment Limited, presiding over its 236th meeting at its head office in the city recently. AZM Saleh, Managing Director, Rezakul Haider, Anis Salahuddin Ahmad, Vice-Chairmen, Anwar Hossain Chowdhury, EC Chairman, Md. Jahidur Rahman, Audit Committee Chairman, SM Bakhtiar Alam, Hossain Mahmud, Liaquat Hossain Moghul and KBM Moin Uddin Chisty, Directors of the company were also present.


International »

China-N Korea joint efforts to bring peace, stability in Korean peninsula, hopes Xi


Reuters, Beijing : Chinese President Xi Jinping told visiting North Korean leader Kim Jong Un on Wednesday that with the joint efforts of the two countries, the Korean peninsula will definitely be peaceful and stable, official news agency Xinhua said.Xi made the comments during a meeting at Beijing's Diaoyutai state guest ...

Football »

Putin missed Russia-Egypt match but 'happy' at win


AFP, Moscow :The Kremlin on Wednesday said Vladimir Putin did not watch Russia's surprise win over Egypt in the World Cup because he was on a plane but added that he reacted "very positively, like the whole of our country".  "Unfortunately, he did not watch the match itself. It so ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Barrister Moudud Ahmed speaking at a prèss conference at the party central office in the city's Nayapalton on Wednesday in protest against his confinement by police in Noakhali.


Editorial »

Death of another prosecution witness : Too difficult to accept as an accident


NO sooner had the Eid vacation come to an end but another murder shocked us all. The decapitated body of Sumon Zahid, a witness in a war crimes case and also the son of martyred journalist Selina Parvin was found dead in the capital's Khilgaon the day before yesterday. There ...

Business & Economy »

A delegation headed by Farzana Chowdhury, CEO of Green Delta Insurance makes a courtesy call with Dr. M Khairul Hossain, the newly appointed Chairman of Security Exchange Commission recently. Additional Managing Director and Company Secretary Syed Moinuddin Ahmed and Deputy Managing Director Wafi S M Khan of the company were also present.


Football »

England beat Tunisia 2-1


AFP, Volgograd :Captain Harry Kane came to the rescue with two goals, the second a dramatic injury-time winner, as England began their World Cup Group G campaign with a stuttering 2-1 win over Tunisia on Monday.  Gareth Southgate's men almost paid a heavy price for missing a slew of first-half ...

Football »

Harry Kane : England's new prince


AFP, Volgograd :Harry Kane rose emphatically to the World Cup challenge in England's opening match against Tunisia, scoring a last-gasp winner to give Gareth Southgate's side lift-off in Russia.It was a remarkable World Cup debut for Kane, who bore the added pressure of the captain's armband and the weight of ...

Entertainment »

I`m indebted to J.P. Dutta for life : Pooja Bhatt


Actress-filmmaker Pooja Bhatt said she is indebted to veteran director J.P. Dutta for not only making her a part of 'Border' but also for encouraging her to never change. 'Border' on Wednesday completed 21 years of its release and Pooja took to Twitter to thank Dutta for casting her in ...

International »

US won`t be made a migrant camp


President Donald Trump vowed on Monday that the United States would not become a "migrant camp" as he faced mounting pressure to stop families being separated as a deterrent to illegal immigration."The United States will not be a migrant camp, and it will not be a refugee holding facility," Trump ...

City »

Pedestrians passing through a muddy road as the authority concerned does not repair the road for long time. The snap was taken from Bibir Bagicha area in the city's Jatrabari on Tuesday.


Editorial »

Save the flood victims and take adequate measures for post-flood rehabilitation


INCESSANT rainfall in the last few days has triggered floods in the country's East and South East districts. Thousands of people of Moulvibazar, Habiganj, Feni and Chattogram districts have been marooned as floodwater crawled to inundate their homestead and damage crops and livestock. The New Nation recently reported that Khowai, ...

Football »

A Mexico soccer fan celebrates her team victory against Germany after their group F match at the 2018 soccer World Cup in the Luzhniki Stadium in Moscow, Russia on Sunday.


 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news