Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Friday, May 26, 2017 01:33:44 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

How much court fees shall have to pay in a suit for correction of record-of-rights before the 'Land Survey Tribunal'

By
19th-Nov-2016       Readers ( 375 )   0 Comments
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all (0) »

Md. Mukhlesur Rahman :
Preamble:
Earlier, during 1967 to 1975, the ordinary Civil were empowered to make orders for correction of the SA 'record-of-rights' in a summary proceeding; i.e. s. 143A was inserted in the State Acquisition Act, 1950 by making an application therefore. In respect of payment of court-fees this sec. 143A(12) of SAT Act (now repealed) provided that" An application under sub-section (I) or memorandum of an appeal under sub-section (7) shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the Court Fees Act, 1870, bear a fixed Court fee of rupee one." Therefore, in under said provision of law a fixed court fees of one taka was fixed by the law.
Now, for correction the present record-of-rights, namely BRS/RS/BS/Dhaka Mohanagar record etc., the State has provided a special tribunal being named "the Land Survey Tribunal" u/s. 145A of the SAT Act. But neither this sec. 145A SAT Act nor any other section of the Act does provide any provision for valuation of suit or payment of court-fees in suits correction of the record-of rights n/s 145A(4) of the Act.
Therefore, when this special provision of law of sec. 145A SAT Act does not provide any provision for payment of court-fees, then we may assume that the general provisions of the Court-fees Act, J870 and the Suit Valuation Act, 1887 will apply in such suits.
Now we may see the concerned provisions of Suit Valuation Act and Court-fees Act.
Valuation of the suit:
However no where I find that how to ascertain valuation of suits for correction of the record-of rights in Suit Valuation or in the Court-fees Act. In this respect sec. 7(xii) of the Court-fees Act provides that in suits not expressly provided for in this section, the amount of fee payable under this Act in suits next hereinafter mentioned (i.e. Schedules I & II to the: Act) shall be computed according to the value claimed, but such value shall not be less than a value which would attract a (Court-fee of less than fifteen taka.
Court fees: So far our inquiry, we do not find anywhere of the Court-fees Act whether advalorem or fixed court fees shall have to be paid in a suit for correction of the record-of-rights. In this respect Article 12(viii) of Schedule II to the Act provides that upon plaint in suits every other suit where it is not possible to estimate at a money value the subject-matter in dispute and which is not otherwise provided for by this Act fixed court fees of Taka 300 shall have to be paid.
A controversy upon payment of court fees in Land Tribunal Suits and our study in this respect:
Now a controversy has been arisen on the point that in a suit for correction of the record-of rights whether sub-article (ii) or sub-article (viii) of Art. 12 of Schedule II to the Court Fees Act shall apply.
For answering to this controversy we may first mention the concerned provisions:
Article 12: Plaint or memorandum of appeal in each of the following suits-
 (ii)     to alter or cancel any entry in a register or the names of proprietors of revenue paying estate; Taka 1000 shall have to be paid.
 (viii)     every other suit where it is not possible to estimate at a money value the subject-matter in dispute and which is not otherwise provided for by this Act; Taka 100 shall have to be paid.
Under such position of laws as prevailing, someone are of views that in suits for correction of record-of-rights before the Land Survey Tribunal sub-art. (ii) of Art. 12 of Sch II of the CF Act shall apply and therefore, for such suits court fees shall be Tk. 1,000.
But we have to first find out that what type of suit was meant in this art. 12(i i).
This article 12(ii) speaks that in a suit to alter or cancel any entry in a register or the names of properties of revenue paying estates. Sec 3(4) of the Bengal Tenancy Act gave definition of the term 'estate' speaking that "'Estate' means land including under one entry in any of the general registers of revenue-paying land and revenue free lands, prepared and maintained under the law for the time being in force by the Collector of the district, and includes government khas mahals and revenue free lands not entered in any register". Sec. 2(11) of the SAT Act has provided the same definition of the word "estate".
From these definitions as well as from various provisions of the BT Act and the SAT Act, as this term 'estate' was/has been used, we construe that 'estate' connotes zamindary-estate and during the period of zamindary system the Government wourd, under the BT Act, settle lands to the zamindars through its Collectors dividing the lands into various "estates" and the zamindars would settle the lands to the raiyats from their "estates".
We, may also refer to sec 104H BT of the then BT Act; which provided provisions for instituting suits in the civil courts by any person aggrieved by an entry of a rent settled in a Settlement Rent-roll prepared u/ss. I04A to I04F and incorporated in a record-of rights finally published u/s. 103A, or by all omission to settle a rent for entry in such Settlement
Rent-roll and if it appeared to the Court that the entry of rent settled is incorrect, it could declare that no rent is payable and/or also could settle a fair rent.
We have also to mention that' sec. 3(11) of the BT Act provided definition of the word proprietor speaking that "Proprietor" means a person owning an estate or a part of an estate. Therefore, proprietor meant the then owners of the estates or in other words the zaminders.
From a combined reading of the provisions of all these statues, i.e. secs.2(11) & 104H of the BT Act as well as sub-article (ii) of  Art. 12 of Schedule II to the Court Fees Act it is clearly construed that art. 12(ii) of CF Act meant two types of suits, i.e. either (i) for alternation or cancellation of any' entry of settlement rents settled u/ss. 104A to' I 04F of the BT Act or (ii) for alternation or cancellation of the names of owners of the estates.
Now, it is pertinent to mention that thereafter the SAT Act was enacted in 1950 for the purpose of abolishing of zamindary system. Sec. 3 of SAT Act empowered the Government to acquire rent-receiving interest of the upper tenants. Which came into force in 14th April, 1956 and thereby all. interests of rent-receivers were acquired by the Government- at that time. Then the Government made a survey and settlement of lands under section 17 of SAT Act for the raiyats who would pay rents to the then rent-receivers which was finally published in 1962-63 and thereby the then raiyats of zamindary period were upgrading into maliks (owners) of the recorded lands u/s. 82(8) of the Act.
It is also mentionable that the first phase of the SAT Act, i.e. secs. 3-78 of SAT Act provide provisions for acquisition of rent receiving interests, ascertainment of compensation assessment rolls of the rent-receivers as well as payment of compensation to them for such acquisition. In this first portion of the Act, it has used the term "estate" in several times.
From our study, we find it unambiguous and crystal clear that in everywhere this word 'estate' has been used to denote on by the zamindary estate. We also see that in the second phase' of the Act, i.e. secs. 79-152, which exclusively deals with the class, status, right and inabilities of the tenants (maliks), it does not utter this very term "estate" even in a single place. Therefore, when the existence of "estate's" had been abolished under first phase, i.e. u/ss. 3-78, of the SAT Act, and now only the second phase, i.e. ss. 79-152, of SAT Act are being dealt with, then application of art. 12(ii) of Sch II of CF Act is absurd.
However. it is interesting to mention that though all the interests of the rent-receivers were acquired u/s. 3 of SAT Act during 1962-63 and thereby the Bengal Tenancy Act itself was repealed u/s 80 of SAT Act and accordingly any suit u/s. 104H of said BT Act had become obsolete at that time, but the legislatures not only did no omit the provision of sub-art. (ii) of Art. 12 of Schedule 2 to CF Act but also have been increasing the amount of taka for such type of suits for alteration/ cancellation of entry of settlement of rents or name of owners In the zamindary estates. Whatever may be, under the situation of the BT Act having been repealed, sub-art. (ii) of Art. 12 of Schedule 2 to CF Act has become infructuous now. Whatever, the legislature might miss doing so absentmindedly, but we cannot say that this sub-article will be applicable in suits for correction of the record-of-rights, which has no nexus with the settlement of rents to zamindary estates or ownership of estates. We may make analogy that at enactment of the Family Courts Ordinance, 1985 all types of suits for dissolution of marriage or restitution of conjugal rights are within the ambit of exclusive jurisdiction of the family courts and civil courts have no such jurisdiction and even though the legislates have been increasing the amount of taka for such suits for dissolution of marriage or restitution of conjugal rights in art, 12(vii) of Sch 11 of the CF Act inattentively.
Our view: Under such study of concerned laws, we may come to an opinion that in respect of the  suits for correction of the record of rights before the Land Survey Tribunal a fixed court fee under Article 12 (viii) of Schedule II to the Court Fees Act, now Tk 300 may be paid.

0 Comments. Share your thoughts also.
Write a comment
Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

FDI flow low despite policy support


A recently held dialogue organised by the American Chamber of Commerce in Bangladesh (AMCHAM) revealed that the country is not getting foreign direct investments (FDIs) at an expected level in spite of the government's numerous initiatives to give easy access to such investment opportunities. Whether or not these 'initiatives' are ...

Entertainment »

`Baahubali: The Conclusiuon` all set to release in China


After conquering global Box-Office with staggering numbers, SS Rajamouli's magnum opus ' Baahubali 2: The Conclusion' is now all set to release in China.  Bollywood trade analyst Taran Adarsh shared the news of the release on his Twitter handle. He wrote, "Lots of speculation about #Baahubali2 release in China... The ...

City »

Inter-Religious and Inter-Cultural Dialogue Center formed a human chain in front of Aparajeya Bangla of Dhaka University on Thursday marking birth anniversary of National Poet Kazi Nazrul Islam.


.

International »

Obama gets rock-star welcome in Berlin, praises Merkel


AP, Berlin :Barack Obama received a rock-star welcome in Berlin as he appeared at a public debate Thursday with Chancellor Angela Merkel, whom he praised as one of his "favorite partners" during his presidency.Security was tight in front of the German capital's iconic Brandenburg Gate, where Obama and Merkel appeared ...

City »

Law Commission submits annual report to President


Law Commission submitted its Annual Report-2016 to President M Abdul Hamid at Bangabhaban here on  Wednesday afternoon.A four-member delegation, led by its Chairman Justice ABM Khairul Haque, submitted the report to Abdul Hamid, President's Press Secretary told BSS.Justice Khairul Haque apprised the President of the commission's overall activities and its ...

Entertainment »

Kriti reminisces her journey as Heropanti completes 3 years


Kriti Sanon went down a nostalgia trip as her debut movie Heropanti has completed 3 years yesterday. The beautiful actress recollected memories from her past for completion of 3 years of Heropanti. She terms her journey as the most special one of her life. Kriti took to twitter sharing, “3 ...

International »

Pope urges Trump to use his presidency for peace


AFP, Vatican City : Pope Francis urged Donald Trump to use his US presidency for peace as two leaders who have sparred repeatedly through the media finally met in a Vatican encounter that ended in broad smiles, for the cameras at least.Trump's audience with the pontiff, a keenly-anticipated highlight of his ...

International »

Xi urges Taiwan business lobby to back 'one China' principle


Reuters, Beijing :Chinese President Xi Jinping urged a business lobby for Taiwan enterprises on the mainland to support the "one China" principle and contribute to unity between Beijing and Taipei, state media said on Wednesday.China regards Taiwan as a renegade province to be recovered by force if necessary, after defeated ...

Editorial »

Chaos at Islami Bank is not to the nation`s interest


THE unrest in the Islami Bank -- the largest and most profitable bank in the country just over five months of its change over to a new management and ownerships liquidating the control of Jamaat people on the bank just shows the ominous sign of greater destabilization within the bank. ...

Cricket »

Mumbai Indians captain Rohit Sharma (center) Parthiv Patel (left) and bowling coach Shane Bond pose for a picture with the Indian Premier League (IPL) trophies from last three wins after a press conference after their IPL 2017 win in Mumbai, India on Monday.


City »

Jatiya Press Club General Secretary Farida Yasmin was accorded a grand reception for achieving US Special Congressional Award at the Jatiya Press Club Auditorium yesterday. Chief Guest of the function Information Minister Hasanul Haq Inu along with BFUJ Secretary General Omar Faruk and other special guests seen handing over the citation crest.


Entertainment »

Half Girlfriend is Shraddha`s fourth best opening


Shraddha Kapoor and Arjun Kapoor starrer Half Girlfriend has raked in a whopping 10 crores of moolah at the box office on its day one. This is Shraddha’s fourth best opening after Ek Villain, ABCD 2 and Baaghi, also withstanding the fact that all these films opened to a two ...

International »

Trump plays up ME peace hopes after talks with Abbas


Reuters, Bethlehem : US President Donald Trump talked up the prospects of peace between Israelis and Palestinians on Tuesday, saying he believed both sides were committed to an historic deal, but he offered no concrete proposals on how to get there.After an hour of talks with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas ...

International »

Outgoing WHO Chief says world 'better prepared' for health crises


AFP, Geneva  :The World Health Organization's outgoing chief Margaret Chan defended her legacy Monday, insisting the world had become better prepared to face health emergencies like Ebola on her watch.In her final address to WHO's member states, Chan acknowledged that mistakes had been made during her decade at the helm, ...

Editorial »

Police can`t commit excesses like politicians


MEMBERS of law enforcement agencies or police for that matter surely have the professional right to conduct search operations based on accurate tip-offs but that doesn't mean it can wreak havoc and cause chaos in the name of such professional duty. The police search operations at main opposition party BNP ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news