Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, November 18, 2018 02:25:46 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Commentary

Protection of rights, not police power is justice

photo by

By MAINUL HOSEIN
20th-Nov-2016       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Justice is much more than law and police power. Justice demands to apply law in the context of prevailing circumstances as held by Justice Diplock and Lord Denning, the two eminent British jurists. Our Appellate Division of the Supreme Court agreed with them.
The surprise victory of Donald Trump as President of The United States of America, the least experienced man with the most unAmerican temperament  and values, has added to the worries not only to many in his own country but also the world outside. Some states are threatening to secede saying Donald Trump is not their President, he being so unAmerican.  
But one thing is sure that because of the power of the government institutions and patriotism of the public functionaries, the President-elect will have to change himself or will find the system challenging him all the way. Not just election democracy, but people's democracy will be at work.
We are unlucky in that hardly anybody is willing to take the responsibility of making the democratic institutions of the government strong. Unless this responsibility is taken seriously we shall not have good and just governance and our personal rights will remain under threat. The country will lean towards a police state. Violence and disunity afflicting our safety, security and happiness.  
The reliance on justice of police power, instead of protection of law and the Constitution has proved not
 to be the right answer to the problems of peace, order, unity or economic progress in our country. Denial of justice is not merely a personal tragedy, it is a national calamity. Where justice is not ensured the situation is hopeless for protection of law and good governance.
 Any friction between the Law Ministry and the Supreme Court over administrative matters of the judiciary is self-defeating and must be avoided. The need for close cooperation between the Supreme Court and the Law Ministry is essential for dispensing impartial justice under the rule of law and nothing should be done to make it otherwise.
Lately the Supreme Court had to seek explanation how the Law Ministry could serve a show cause notice on a Session Judge without its prior consent.
The people must have faith in the impartial justice system under the rule of law. The police power without the restraining need of impartial justice, will not make police efficient and trustworthy. If this is allowed, the police will be wrecking the justice system by prevailing police power over the power of law and justice.
Already there are disturbingly high numbly of police officials who feel free to break law and commit crimes. Only last Friday a policeman was caught red-handed in the capital city when snatching Tk.44,000/- from an egg trader. Not just snatching, even their complicity as murder is not so uncommon. Killing people by police in cross-fire is not considered a crime. Imagine if a large number became law breakers, what that would mean for social order. If we cannot protect the justice system against abuse of police power, police will cease to be police.    
It is wrong to think that social order and peace can be maintained without protecting an impartial justice system. If justice system is undone, nothing remains of civilized existence.  
We did not have terrorism but now the government finds terrorism everywhere. Whatever is the truth about terrorism, most of our police remain busy looking for terrorists and yet fear of terrorism is rising. Hundreds of cases are pending relating to the offence of terrorism. Initiating a police case alleging terrorism has become too easy for abusing police power easily.
Thousands of police cases are keeping thousands of people in jail without trial. Recently the High Court Division finding that an accused in an alleged murder case spent 17 years in jail without trial set him free. Though he does not know where to go or what to do with his freedom. He does not even know where his family is. It is learnt that two more cases of gross failure of justice have been identified. Things would have been different if getting bail was not so hard paving way for innocent persons to be victimised helplessly.    
It cannot be denied that we had no communalism but now for the over-enthusiasm of anti-communal politics of a particular lobby, communalism has emerged in its uglier and bolder form. In all such cases the men in power were found provoking the human tragedy for personal benefit. The recent attacks on Santals lasting for days were shocking. Lives were lost, properties were grabbed and houses were burnt yet the government appeared helpless because their own men were involved. The police also was not quick to act knowing that government's own men were behind the crimes. The situation was so helpless that a High Court Division had to come forward to the aid of victims. This is like many other instances where our Supreme Court had intervened as no other authority cared for the victims of human rights violation.    
The Anti-Corruption Commission has been claiming to be tough by chasing big fishes but not a single big fish is being investigated. Corruption is endemic at every level of the government because the big ones are protecting the small ones. Anti-Corruption officers are chasing the weak ones to make their life miserable. Even the Anti-Corruption officials can now arrest anybody they want. Thus they have acquired more power to abuse. Public outcry against corrupt Anti-Corruption officials go unheeded. Many more innocent people are suffering imprisonment than those found guilty after trial in court. We cannot provide all the facts to support our claim but we are sure we shall not be far wrong.
In this backdrop of abuse of power and corruption, the main concern of our judicial system should be how to save people from the injustices of abuse of power and greed. More than ever before, the principle of justice that one is innocent before found guilty by the court through trial should be given highest consideration that it deserves.
The principle of innocence is more than a principle, it is recognised by the Universal Human Rights Declaration of the United Nations as a legal right.
By relying too much on police power, we have now lawlessness everywhere. Blaming the police is not the whole answer when the police are politicised and not allowed to remain impartial. The reality is we cannot be sure when police are enforcing politics and when they are enforcing law.
We have also a problem of judicial culture. An arrested person is treated more often surely as guilty if the allegation is about a serious crime. In most cases an accused suddenly finds himself as a non-entity. He is totally at the mercy of police forwarding report. All his fundamental rights are of no help. The presumption of innocence is not recognised as a legal right.  
All his fundamental rights to be free is thrown overboard by a paper allegation endorsed  by the police. For not granting bail, he has no freedom to claim his innocence also as a free citizen. The major source of corruption in the judicial system is filing of false cases and business of bail. The most damaging is people's faith in the judiciary as dispenser of impartial justice.
An individual's protection of law guaranteed under the Constitution has to be meaningful in the context of police harassment or not for anything.
Our system is habituated to be in favour of the police to have all the freedom to deal with anyone they suspect to be an accused. The common saying is: They must be given a chance to investigate. He will be available for police interrogation is not enough. Despite Supreme Court's caution against police remand, police are too often obliged so that an accused can be taken into their custody for interrogation. This is an unholy situation for the sanctity of justice.
In India, the process of justice has not been weakened by granting anticipatory bail, or releasing a person on condition that he will be available for interrogation. We had also law for granting anticipatory bail, but now it is considered dead.
Scope of abuse of police power and corruption among them are contexts for judicial acknowledgement for doing justice. But from the prosecution side all efforts and fury are employed painting a man as a dangerous criminal not to be enlarged on bail before any evidence has been produced against him.
To deny bail is a big success for police but total loss of all the freedoms for the accused.
Our educated people have a unique gift of amnesia to forget what our people had fought for, so as to know what we must protect and preserve. Bangladesh will never be a country of yesterday living in fear of authority without protection of law.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

Neymar penalty punishes Uruguay in feisty friendly


Neymar kept his cool to score the controversial penalty that fired Brazil to a 1-0 win over Uruguay in a full-blooded friendly on Friday.Brazil captain Neymar was subjected to some ferocious fouls from Uruguay as the clash between the South American rivals boiled over at Arsenal's Emirates Stadium.But the Paris ...

Cricket »

Shakib returns as BCB announces squad for 1st Test against WI


The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) on Saturday announced the squad for the first Test of two-match series against the West Indies (WI) with ace all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan returned to the squad.Another big-name inclusion in the squad is Soumya Sarkar, whose last Test appearance came on the tour of South ...

Editorial »

Pro-people police is the demand of time


THE Police Investigation Bureau (PIB) has unveiled the mystery behind a spine-chilling crime where a middle-aged woman passenger was killed inside a running bus at Ashulia in the outskirts of Dhaka city. It took hardly seven days for them to crack the case. Police have already arrested the murderers along ...

International »

US opposes UN resolution condemning Israel's occupation of Golan Heights


AFP, United Nations :For the first time, the United States voted Friday against an annual UN resolution condemning Israel's occupation of the Golan Heights, dropping its practice of abstaining in the vote.The non-binding resolution was adopted in a General Assembly committee by a vote of 151 to 2, with the ...

International »

US-China discord dominates APEC summit in Papua New Guinea


Reuters, Port Moresby :The United States and China swapped barbs over trade, investment and regional security at an Asia Pacific Economic Co-operation (APEC) summit on Saturday, as growing fault lines among members suggested little prospect of consensus at the weekend meeting.Speaking in the Papua New Guinean capital, U.S. Vice President ...

Entertainment »

Aupee Karim returning to big screen


Entertainment Desk :Actress Aupee Karim is returning to the big screen after 15 years , with a film titled "Debris of Desire."Aupee made her debut in cinema with Mostofa Sarwar Farooki's 'Bachelor,' for which the actor won the Bangladesh National Film Award for Best Actress in 2004. The film is ...

City »

BFUJ Secretary General Saban Mahmud receiving posthumous 'Ratnagarva Ma Gold Medal-2018' on behalf of his mother Momtaj Salam at a ceremony organised by Society for Enlightening Nation (SOFEN) in the auditorium of the Institution of Diploma Engineers, Bangladesh in the city on Friday.


Editorial »

Only condemnation not enough, ensure safe return of Rohingyas to Myanmar


US Vice-President Mike Pence expressed the Trump administration's strongest condemnation about Myanmar's treatment towards Rohingya Muslims. He told Aung San Suu Kyi that "persecution" by Myanmar's military was "without excuse" in a meeting with her on November14. Mr Pence also pressed Suu Kyi to pardon two Reuters journalists who were ...

City »

Former Parliament Member of Moulvibazar-2 constituency MM Shaheen joined Juktofront by giving bouquets to Juktofront Chief Prof Dr AQM Badruddoza Chowdhury at the party office in the city's Baridhara on Friday.


.

Football »

Croatia stun Spain as Jedvaj strikes twice to keep hopes alive


AFP, Zagreb :Spain passed up the chance to seal progress to the Nations League finals as they were beaten 3-2 by Croatia on Thursday, undone by a 93rd-minute winner from Tin Jedvaj.Jedvaj's late strike leaves Group 4 wide open ahead of its final fixture between England and Croatia on Sunday. ...

Entertainment »

Deepika-Ranveer wedding: First pics of the gorgeous couple spell magic


Deepika Padukone and Ranveer Singh got married at the picturesque locale of Lake Como in Italy. The much-in-love duo got married in a traditional Konkani wedding ceremony on November 14 and today solemnised their wedding as per Sindhi tradition. After managing to keep their wedding pictures well-guarded, the couple has ...

International »

May fights for survival after Brexit deal sparks crisis


Reuters, London : British Prime Minister Theresa May was fighting for survival on Friday after a draft divorce deal with the European Union provoked the resignations of senior ministers and mutiny in her party.More than two years after the United Kingdom voted to leave the EU, it is still unclear how, ...

Editorial »

Mass awareness needed if NBR wants more people under tax net


THE countrywide 'Income Tax Fair -2018' has already drawn a huge crowd. The authorities hope more people would be brought under tax net this year too. Finance Minister AMA Muhith while inaugurating the fair said out of country's 16 crore population, the number of taxpayers is around one crore. There ...

International »

US could lose war against Russia or China, warns panel


AP, Washington :The United States military has "lost its edge" and could potentially lose a war against Russia or China, a report by a bipartisan panel established by Congress says.The report by the National Defense Strategy Commission on November 14 said U.S. military superiority has "eroded to a dangerous degree" ...

Football »

Switzerland`s Kevin Mbabu (left) is challenged by Qatar's Abdelkarim Hassan during an international friendly soccer match between Switzerland and Qatar at the Cornaredo stadium in Lugano, Switzerland on Wednesday.


.

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news