Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, May 21, 2018 04:36:47 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Once promoted, one can't be demoted without cogent reason(s)

By
26th-Nov-2016       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Appellate Division :
(Civil)
Nazmun Ara Sultana J
Syed Mahmud Hossain J
Md Imman Ali J
Md Anwarul Haque J
Judgment
January 27th, 2014
Government of Bangladesh and others ... Petitioners
vs
Md Abul Kashem
…… Respondent
Police Training College Manual Part III (A) Rule 64
Once promotion is given and there cannot be any demotion without given a second chance or given any notice of his impending demotion or any starting departmental proceedings leading to a punishment, or any lak of available post.
Once promotion is given, there cannot be any demotion unless there is departmental punishment or lack of available post. The report recommended to allow Md Abdul Quddus Shikder to undertake training again at the Academy. The respondent claimed that he and Md Abdul Quddus Shikder received training at the same time and both were shown as unsuccessful in the oral examination. In the  case of Abdul Quddus Shikder departmental proceedings were drawn and it was decided that he could not be demoted. In the case of the respondent no departmental proceeding was drawn up, and yet he was demoted. Upon consideration of all the aforementioned facts and circumstances, the Administrative Tribunal allowed the respondent's case. ….(5)
Rajik-al-]alil, Deputy Attorney-General, instructed by B. Hossain, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioners.
Sufia Khatun, Advocate-on-Record, on behalf of Abu Siddique, Advocate-on-Record-For the Respondent.
Judgment
Md Imman Ali J: This civil petition for leave to appeal is directed against judgment and order dated 26-8-2009 passed by the Administrative Appellate Tribunal, Dhaka in AAT Appeal No. 22 of 2008 dismissing the appeat thereby upholding the judgment and order dated 20-8-2007 passed by the Administrative Tribunal-I, Dhaka in AT Case No. 141 of 2005.
2. Facts of the case in brief are that the respondent, Md Abul Kashem was promoted from the post of police constable to ASI on 1-1-1990 and to SI on 4-5-2000. On 21-4-2005, the authority issued an order under Rule 64 of the Police Training College Manual Part III (A) cancelling his probationary period and demoting him to the rank of ASI on the ground that he was unsuccessful in the final supplementary examination at the Police Academy, Sharoda. The Administrative Tribunal upon hearing the parties allowed the case of the respondent declaring that the impugned order dated 21-4-2005 was illegal and not binding upon the respondent.
The direction was given to reinstate the respondent to the rank of SI and to pay all arrears and benefits. The government filed an appeal before the Administrative Appellate Tribunal Dhaka, which upon hearing the parties concerned was dismissed. Hence the government has filed the instant civil petition for leave appeal.
3. The learned Deputy Attorney-General, Mr Rajik-Al-Jalil submitted that the respondent was unsuccessful in the final examination and was duly demoted as provided by the Police Training College Manual Part III (A). He pointed out that Rule 64A Group-B III C(4) provides that "a departmental cadet who fails to pass the final examination and is not allowed an other chance by the Inspector-General of Police (vide Rule 59) shall be permanently revert (sic) to the rank Assistant Sub Inspector and returned to his district". However he was not able to tell us clearly whether the respondent had been given a second chance. On the other hand, the learned DAG submitted that giving of a second chance was a discretion and did not create any right in favour of the respondent.
4. We have considered the submissions of the learned Deputy Attorney-General, perused the impugned judgment and order as well as other papers on record.
5. In the judgment of the Administrative Tribunal we find a report of the Additional Superintendent of Police, Bagerhat dated 4-9-2005 in respect of SI Md Abdul Quddus Shikder. From this report it appears that "once promotion is given, there cannot be any demotion unless there is departmental punishment or lack of available post. The report recommended to allow Md Abdul Quddus Shikder to undertake training again at the Academy. The respondent claimed that he and Md Abdul Quddus Shikder received training at the same time and both were shown as unsuccessful in the oral examination. In the case of Abdul Quddus Shikder departmental proceedings were drawn and it was decided that he could not be demoted. In the case of the respondent no departmental proceeding was drawn up, and yet he was demoted. Upon consideration of all the aforementioned facts and circumstances, the Administrative Tribunal allowed the respondent's case.
6.  The Administrative Appellate Tribunal found that the authority did not serve any show cause notice to the respondent and arbitrarily issued the impugned order. It was observed that the authority could not show that there were any materials against the respondent for passing the order impugned as per Rule 64 of the Police Training College Manual Part III (A). Thus, the petitioner's appeal was dismissed.
7. We find that the judgment and order of the Administrative Tribunal contains cogent reasons for declaring the impugned order of the police authority as illegal and not binding on the respondent.
There is nothing on record to show that the respondent was given a second chance, or given any notice of his impending demotion, or any indication that there was any departmental proceeding leading to a punishment, or any lack of available post. In such circumstances, the impugned demotion of the respondent was clearly illegal.
We do not find any illegality in the judgment and order of the Administrative Appellate Tribunal, and accordingly we find no merit in this Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal, which is dismissed.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

RAB must not prove we are unfit to save life of our own citizens


IN the last 15 days, nine alleged criminals were killed during "gunfight" with Rapid Action Battalion (RAB). Of them, three alleged drug traders were killed in Jassore early Friday, according to a newspaper report. Besides, six other people were killed in shootouts with RAB in different parts of the country, ...

Entertainment »

Shaon renders song under Nachiketa’s composition


Entertainment Report :Meher Afroze Shaon is popularly known as both an actress and a singer. Few days ago, she gave her voice for a playback song. Till now the listeners did not hear the song. After Eid, Shaon is coming with that song. For the first time Shaon has rendered ...

Sports »

Germany`s Alexander Zverev reacts after winning a point to Croatia's Marin Cilic during their semifinal match at the Italian Open tennis tournament in Rome on Saturday.


Football »

Union rout Real Salt Lake 4-1


AP, Chester :Marcus Epps and Borek Dockal scored in the first half and the Philadelphia Union added two more in the second to beat Real Salt Lake 4-1 on Saturday night.Fabrice-Jean Picault had a 40-yard run up the left channel to set up the opening goal in the 21st minute, ...

City »

DMP Mobile Court conducted drive in city's 9 New Market 'Fast Food' Pizza Fried Rice Shops, penalises Taka four lakh 30 thousand for preparing rotten food. This photo was taken on Sunday.


International »

Cleric Sadr meets Iraq PM Abadi, hinting at coalition


Reuters, Baghdad  :Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi met with Moqtada al-Sadr on Saturday, less than 24 hours after the Shi'ite cleric's bloc was declared winner of Iraq's parliamentary election, the clearest sign yet they could work together to form a coalition."During our meeting, we agreed to work together and with ...

Sports »

Toronto FC forward Jordan Hamilton (22) and Orlando City defender Mohamed El-Munir (13) chase the bouncing ball during the first half of an MLS soccer match in Toronto on Friday.


Sports »

Jordan Spieth watches his tee shot on the first hole during the second round of the AT&T Byron Nelson golf tournament at Trinity Forest Golf Club in Dallas on Friday.


Entertainment »

Raazi`s first week collections become the 5th highest of 2018


Raazi has been sailing smoothly on its journey towards the prestigious Rs 100 crore club and it will be no shocker if the film grosses over it. The cast and crew of the film recently held an event to celebrate the success of the film with the media as well ...

Entertainment »

Kareena says she'll never be on social media


Shashanka Gosh's Veere Di Wedding is all set to bring the gorgeous Kareena Kapoor Khan back to the big screen after a gap of two years. The actress took a break after giving birth to Bollywood's most popular toddler Taimur Ali Khan. Kareena will be seen alongside Sonam Kapoor, Swara ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Dr Khondkar Mosharraf Hossain speaking at a discussion on 'Acceptable Election and Role of the Present Election Commission' organised by 'Nagorik Adhikar Andolon Forum' at the Jatiya Press Club on Saturday.


Editorial »

Myanmar will take back their people: We are unconcerned about the terrorists


AS the monsoon threatens the Rohingya refugees with the outbreak of vector-borne epidemics and diarrhoeal diseases, the repatriation process seems to be getting more and more complex. However, Bangladeshi officials at a meeting in Dhaka on Thursday urged Myanmar to hand over a 'specific list' of members of Arakan Rohingya ...

International »

White House pushes ahead with Mideast peace plan


AP, Washington  :The Trump administration is aiming to roll out its much-hyped but long-delayed Middle East peace plan next month amid signs it may further alienate the Palestinians by slashing millions of dollars in funding for humanitarian and development projects in the West Bank and Gaza.Five U.S. officials and a ...

Editorial »

Don`t ignore the UNHRC`s report : Be respectful to human rights and be with the people


THE UN Human Rights Council (HRC) has adopted a draft report on the human rights review of Bangladesh, with recommendations on taking steps to deter forced disappearances, extra judicial killings, and to ensure freedom of expression in media, politics and religion. During the 30th Session of the Universal Periodic Review ...

Football »

Richet Gomez of Bolivia's The Strongest (left) fights for the ball with Guzman Pereira of Uruguay's Penarol during a Copa Libertadores soccer game in Montevideo, Uruguay on Thursday.


.

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news