Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Tuesday, January 16, 2018 07:46:36 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Commentary

Judgement was an ominous mistake and ruinous for democracy

By
10th-Jan-2017       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Editorial Desk :
We knew this question would be raised. The Supreme Court's judgement on election time caretaker government has created insurmountable obstacle in the way of holding free and fair election by insisting that the election time government has to be elected otherwise basic structure of democratic Constitution will be negated.
The judgement was delivered by majority of one during the time when Justice A.B.M. Khairul Haque was the Chief Justice. Out of 8 amici curiae 7 supported the need of a caretaker government. One of their Lordships held that election is a political matter and should remain outside the jurisdiction of the court. Another Lordship found the non-party caretaker arrangement under the 13th Amendment is essential for the democratic Constitution.
Now his Lordship the incumbent Chief Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha inviting constructive criticism of the court's judgments and seeking answers from those who say that a judgment of the Supreme Court has the affect of destroying democracy.
We reproduce below excerpts from one of our many commentaries published about the time the judgment was delivered :     
Under the parliamentary system nowhere in the world the elected government remains in power for holding the next election. It is an absurd impossibility. There is no need for arguing that with the dissolution of parliament for election every elected member ceases to be elected. This is as simple as that.
Yet a gigantic mistake has been committed insulting to a nation.
The prime minister of the outgoing government is requested to continue as caretaker government for conducting the day to day affairs. Otherwise there will be no government.
It should be beyond anybody's understanding that after the parliament is dissolved how any government or member of parliament could continue as elected? There can also be no general election without dissolving the parliament and its seats falling vacant.
In a recent judgement of the Supreme Court, on unelected election time caretaker government a blueprint has been given how a general election is to be held. The parliament will be dissolved 42 days before the election, though the Constitution requires elections to be held within 90 days of dissolution of the parliament. The most surprising part of the judgement is the declaration that the general election has to be held under the elected government. To have an unelected caretaker government during the election time is unconstitutional and undemocratic. The government was pleased with the judgement as it was too eager to amend the Constitution for requiring the general election to be held with them in power.  
When the ministers or members of parliament will not contest the election with others on the same level playing field, the election itself will be liable to be questioned for the well-established principle of discrimination and inequality.
As the Supreme Court's judgement is binding so the next general election is to be arranged without dissolving the parliament or the government. Such an arrangement is so unreasonable and against common sense that nowhere under a parliamentary system this idea has any acceptance.
It is also most unusual for the Supreme Court, by a majority of one the judgement to deny the parliament its constitutional power of making laws or amending the Constitution. To declare something as illegal is different from declaring something as unconstitutional. Unconstitutionality goes deep into the core of the parliament's power. Their Lordships themselves have given divided and conflicting judgements over the parliament's core power. The constitutional experts will be able to see how the judiciary paved the way for destroying democracy.
On another occasion their Lordship declared 5th amendment to the Constitution passed by the parliament as unconstitutional. If the parliament cannot indemnify the past unconstitutional acts for beginning anew the constitutional process then how constitutional process will be restored safely is not understandable.
General Ershad who is active in politics should be tried for treason. He took over the government unconstitutionally and the indemnity he obtained should also be found unconstitutional. But that was not even considered.
As a lawyer I am hurt that the judgement of the Supreme Court will be seen as contributing to unconstitutional political ambition of a few.
The true purpose of the caretaker government was to help the Election Commission to act without interference from the partisan government. The sitting government's desire not to allow free and fair election has now become a built-in arrangement. It will do everything during the whole time in power that the election is a full-proof set up for it to win.     
Their Lordships by their own conflicting and contradictory judgements unnecessarily implicated the Supreme Court in aggravating the political crisis of denying peaceful change of the government. At least Justice Muhmmmad Imman Ali has decided to leave the matter for the parliament to sort out. The non-party caretaker government is essential if any transfer of power should be made possible peacefully under a free and fair election.
I am also personally against non-party and non-politician caretaker government. What cannot be denied is that it is the politicians who do not trust each other. Once in power they do everything to remain in power against popular wish. For their corruption and misdeeds they indulged in freely, the members of the sitting government don't want to give up power to make them unsafe and lose election.
Bangladesh will earn a unique position of shame for using conveniently the judgement of the Supreme Court to eliminate democracy and with it the rule of law. It is strange that those who most vociferously project themselves as freedom fighters are the ones most viciously active against democracy. If they are freedom fighters freedom under democracy then it is a different issue. But the people's Liberation War was for freedom and democracy.    
For the purpose of clarity, the full order as published with the full judgement is reproduced below:
1.     By majority judgement, the appeal is allowed. The
impugned judgement and order of the High Court Division is set aside.
2.     The Constitution (Thirteenth Amendment, a 1996 Act 1 of 1996) is ultra vires of the Constitution and hereby     declared void prospectively.
3.     The Civil Petition to Appeal No 596 of 2005 is  accordingly disposed of.
4.     The government is hereby directed to pay honorarium of Tk.20,000/- to each of the Junior Advocates of the learned amici curiae.
5.     There shall be no order as to costs.
They say that the devil is in the detail. Although there was total omission of the order as regards the caretaker government in the full judgement, both Mr. Justice A.B.M. Khairul Haque and Mr. Justice S.K. Sinha in the text of their individual judgements representing the majority judgement, have, however, reiterated the two more terms for the caretaker system.
But Justice A.B.M. Khairul Haque has added a caveat making it a precondition that even that caretaker government has to be elected. He went a step farther to direct that the parliament is to be dissolved 42 days before the elections. These deviations from the order declared in the open court caused no small stir.
Justice Md. Abdul Wahhab Miah expressed surprise and raised objection to the changing aspects of the full judgement. The general consensus is that the judgement announced in open court cannot be changed outside the court.
My purpose is not to add to the controversy the Supreme Court has landed itself, though as a practicing lawyer I  am no doubt gravely disturbed by the controversy  over such an important judgement delivered by the highest court of the country.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

CEC must seek govt.`s cooperation to dissolve parliament


MORE than just holding small and big scale elections, it's time the Election Commission realise that it is essential to ensure the national elections is held in a free, fair and credible manner.  The Election Commission is a constitutional body and its responsibility is to hold election directly on the ...

International »

`I`m not a racist`, Trump says


AFP  :"I'm not a racist. I am the least racist person you have ever interviewed," Trump told reporters at the Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida, where he was having dinner with Republican House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy.Trump appeared to give up for dead an immigration deal, ...

Football »

Suarez, Messi lead Barcelona to 4-2 comeback win at Sociedad


AP, Barcelona :Barcelona has broken its curse at Anoeta Stadium.Luis Suarez scored twice before Lionel Messi completed Barcelona's 4-2 comeback win at Real Sociedad on Sunday, giving the Catalan club its first league win at the Basque Country team since 2007.Barcelona was behind by two goals when Suarez set up ...

Sports »

The newly elected Executive Committee of Special Olympics Bangladesh pose for a photo session in the city's Tejgaon on Saturday.


Entertainment »

Shabnur, Purnima in a common frame


Entertainment Report :Shabnur and Purnima are two popular actresses in Dhaka film arena. Both of them have already got the National Film Award for single time. Shabnur got the National Award for acting in Mostafizur Rahman Manik’s movie Dui Noyon-er Alo. On the other hand, Purnima received the award for ...

City »

Nagorik Oikya Convenor Mahmudur Rahman Manna speaking at the press conference on 'Four Years of the Government and Year of Election' organised by the party at the Jatiya Press Club on Monday.


Editorial »

We do not want to see police as killers


HUMAN rights campaigner Odhikar said that at least 139 people fell victims to 'crossfire' and 86 to enforced disappearances in Bangladesh in 2017. Besides, 59 people 'died' in jail and 77 people were killed in political violence while 783 people became victims of rape, 242 were subjected to sexual harassment. ...

International »

Netanyahu begins 6-day India visit today with focus on defence, security


AP, Ahmedabad :Prime Minister Narendra Modi broke protocol to receive Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and his wife Sara, at Ahmedabad airport on Sunday ahead of his six-day visit to India with focus on defence and security. PM Modi will host Netanyahu for dinner on Sunday night. In the past, ...

Sports »

Federer says he's too old to be Australian Open favourite


AFP, Melbourne :Defending champion Roger Federer says rivals Rafael Nadal and Novak Djokovic should be seen as leading contenders for the Australian Open as he is too old to be considered favourite.The 36-year-old is bidding for a record 20th Grand Slam title and is in form and fit, unlike the ...

Entertainment »

Shomi Kaiser on her birthday


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Today is birthday of country’s one of the popular actresses Shomi Kaiser. She is one of the brightest names in the field of acting in TV plays arena. Many actors came into this field after being inspired by her though Shomi is not regular in acting now. ...

City »

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, among others, offering `Akheri Munajat`in the first phase of Bishwa Ijtema from Ganobhaban on Sunday.


Editorial »

Our winters have also become seasons for acute gas crisis


FOR the past decade our winter months have become the months for acute gas crisis across the capital. Once more, many areas in the city, including Mohammadpur, Bosila, Adabar, West Agargaon, Shewrapara, Kazipara, Kafrul, West Dhanmondi, Lalbag, Sobhanbag, Indira Road, Tanti Bazar, Shakharibazar, Kamrangirchar, Uttara, Dakhinkhan, Uttarkhan, South Banasree and ...

Sports »

Zia shares 3rd slot in Delhi Rating Chess


GM Ziaur Rahman Zia of SAIF Sporting Club now in 3rd position in the points table along with other 15 players with 5.5 points after 7th round games in the 16th Delhi Open International Rating Chess tournament now being held in New Delhi, India, Bangladesh Chess Federation press release said.In ...

Entertainment »

Priyanka Chopra is back with season 3 of Quantico


Priyanka Chopra has taken over Hollywood like a boss lady. There's nothing she's not tried and succeeded at. From a rocking singles that topped charts to becoming a part of a legendary franchise like Baywatch, Pee Cee has only just began. She took the primetime TV by storm when she ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Barrister Moudud Ahmed, among others, at a discussion on ' False Cases Against Khaleda Zia and Future of Democracy' organised by Democratic Movement at the Jatiya Press Club on Saturday.


 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news