Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, October 23, 2017 10:03:00 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Valuation of suits in service matter suits and/or recovery of arrear salaries therein

By
21st-Jan-2017       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Md Mukhlesur Rahman :
It is our study that the laws relating to valuation of suits and payment of court fees in various types of suits of this country, i.e. the Suit Valuation Act, 1887 and the Court-fees Act, 1870, are very much technical, complicated and intricate. Besides, so far our study, there are no direct provisions respecting ascertainment of value of suits in respect of several varieties of suits for establishing various types of rights in service matters which are to be filed in civil courts. For that reason, numerous types of practices/traditions had been, even somewhere has been, followed in the country. For the said reasons, it had been being practiced in our country that the suit for declaration that the plaintiff's suspension/dismissal from service, and/or suit for mandatory injunction for reinstatement him in the service and/or payment of arrear salaries would fall u/s. 7 para (i) or (iii) of Court-fees Act and thereby plaintiff would had to value his suit at an amount as per his salary's basic's last year's (i.e. 12 month's) total amount's 15 times and had to pay an ad valorem court fees upon this value; that is to say the plaintiff, who is distressed due to driven from service, had to pay a huge amount of court-fees for his suit for establishment of his right in the service.
So far our query, we find no judicial pronouncement early to 2008 in our country on this issue; and even we do not know whether there is any foreign authority on this point. But on 5-6-2008, the present Hon'ble Chief Justice of Bangladesh Mr Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha, when he was Judge of the Hon'ble High Court Division of the Supreme Court, gave an authoritative and epoch-making judgment on this issue in the case of Country Director International Bank of Reconstruction and Development vs Ismat Zerin Khan reported in 14 MLR 61, and which decision has already been upheld by the Appellate Division too as reported in 18BLT (AD) 1, and which is a ratio decidendi in the country now.
This decision brought a new age in the field that such suits for establishment any right in service do not fall u/s. 7 para (i), (ii) or (iii) of the Court-fees Act; rather it falls u/s. 7 (iv) (c) of Court-fees Act. Therefore, such categories of suits having no objective standard of valuation, it is the plaintiff's will what will-value his suit. In our little knowledge" and I beg pardon making reference, we may say that in the said judgment his Lordship by his scholar and vivid interpretation clearly showed us what the statutes are in the concerned field and how those should be applied.
Now we may place the very judgments in concise herein bellow:
Plaintiff filed the suit for declaration that non-confirmation of her appointment and termination of her employment is illegal; by amendment she, included prayer for mandatory injection directing the defendants to pay her emoluments.
Upon such amendment the plaintiff valued the suit at Tk, 1,000. Defendants alleged that there  is objective standard of valuation for the relief and the plaintiff is required to pay ad valorem court fees on the basis of her salaries.
The learned Assistant Judge observed that the plaintiff did not pray for any specified amount of salary and the therefore objective standard of valuation was ascertainable for the relief claimed. Held: Plaintiff has sought for some declarations and prayed for mandatory injunction in the declaratory form. The suit does not falls within meaning of suits u/s. 7 para (i) or-(ii); rather it falls u/s. 7 (iv) (c) of Court-fees Act and as such plaintiff, has rightly valued the suit. Because, there is no objective standard of valuation available in the relief claimed.
If any objection is raised as to the payment of court fees, if the suit falls within provisions of para (iv) of Clause (c) of Section 7; the Court should accept the value of the relief stated in the plaint, both for the purposes of court fees as well as for the purposes of determining the jurisdiction of the Court to try the suit, 14 MLR 61, NB. This decision, was upheld  by the Appellate Division as reported in 18 BLT (AD) 1.
The HCD also held that "there is no objective standard of valuation available in the reliefs claimed". The learned advocate for petitioner submits that the HCD committed illegality in holding that there is no objective standard of valuation of the suit having regard to the nature of the prayer sought for recovery of arrear salaries by way of mandatory injunction. Held: The HCD upon correct assessment of the materials on record arrived at a correct decision, 18 BLT (AD) 1.
We may conclude this study saying that his lordship Mr. Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha has brought a remarkable clarification by his aforementioned authority judgment in making valuation in suits for service-matters and thereby opened an easy access to justice for the upset citizens of the Republic.
We do not know whether this ratio decidendi/ precedent has been noticed by and have been being followed in all the courts of the country. But, as per mandate of Article 111 of the Constitution, we must follow this law as declared by the Supreme Court, and thereby shall serve the nation better.
NB. The discussions in this essay relates only to the suits in the civil courts; but the suits which are exclusively triable by the Administrative Tribunals, shall be filed therein and these laws have no application of these provisions in the said Tribunal. However, The Administrative Tribunals Act, 1980 being special law and there being no specific provision for valuation of suits and court fees for suits in the Administrative Tribunals, the provisions of Article 12(viii) of Schedule II to the Court Fees Act shall apply before those Tribunals, and thereby a fixed court fee of Tk. 300 shall have to be paid there.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Govt can`t pay for losing jute mills


 A LEADING daily reported Sunday that the Textiles and Jute Ministry has demanded to the Finance Ministry for allocating Tk 800 crore in loan so that it can pay workers and employees of state-owned jute mills the allowances that remained overdue for years. The jute industry is a losing concern ...

Sports »

National senior Table Tennis begins tomorrow


The 37th National senior Table Tennis Championship will be beginning on Tuesday (October 24) at Shaheed Tajuddin Wooden Floor gymnasium in the city with the participation of 45 teams. Commerce Minister Tofail Ahmed is expected to inaugurate the six-day meet as chief guest. A total of 240 players - 180 ...

Sports »

Steffi Graf (left) and Andre Agassi arrive for the David Foster Foundation 30th Anniversary Miracle Gala and Concert, in Vancouver, British Columbia on Saturday.


Entertainment »

Shraddha Kapoor sprains her foot due to exertion


Shraddha Kapoor who has been on a rigorous shooting schedule for her next film Saaho along with the Bahubali actor Prabhas, injured her ankle due to over exertion. The actress is also simultaneously prepping up for the Saina Nehwal biopic besides shooting for Saaho in Hyderabad. Shraddha recently uploaded a ...

City »

Speakers at a press conference organised by Citizens for Good Governance in DRU auditorium on Sunday in protest against proposal for the cancellation of pledge by poll candidates.


International »

ISIS` end `in sight`, says Trump after historic Raqa victory


AFP, Washington :US President Donald Trump said Saturday a transition can soon begin to set conditions for lasting peace in Syria now that the end of the ISIS "caliphate is in sight" with the fall of Raqa.The United States and its allies will support diplomatic negotiations "that end the violence, ...

Editorial »

Rains halt life: City fathers cannot cope, govt too happy with lies of success


WATERLOGGING has long been an inevitable part of our urban scenario that causes immense suffering to the city dwellers almost all the year round. After torrential rain, most parts of Dhaka, Chittagong, and other major cities go under knee-to-waist-deep water for several hours to few days. Despite, pouring millions of ...

Sports »

Injury ends Tamim's SA tour


Left handed opener Tamim Iqbal has been ruled out of the South Africa tour after aggravating a thigh injury. The 28-year-old opener is expected to return home tomorrow (Sunday) and will not be part of third ODI and the upcoming two-match T20Is series. The dashing opener sustained the injury to ...

Entertainment »

Have Salman Khan and Katrina Kaif fallen back in love?


They're one of the most loved on-screen couples of our times. Ever since Salman Khan introduced Katrina Kaif to Bollywood, his influence on her career has been immense. He's always looked after her and she's always sought advice from him. Even though either of them never made it public, it ...

Entertainment »

What happened when Aaradhya Bachchan met Rekha?


The Ambani's love throwing 'em lavish parties at their Mumbai residence Antilla. And off late, they've been throwing one party after another for our Bollywood celebs. Be it Ganpati or Diwali… the best of Bollywood heads to South Mumbai for the lavish festivities.  A tad late but an insider present ...

City »

SNAPSHOTS ON FLOOD SITUATION IN CITY


International »

UN has `tremendous potential` under new leadership: Trump


AP, Washington :President Donald Trump said Friday that the United Nations has "tremendous potential" but has been underutilized in recent years.Trump praised U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, who has led the 193-member world organization since January, during an Oval Office meeting. It was their first extended meeting.The White House said the ...

Football »

Giroud`s overhead kick gives Arsenal 1-0 win at Red Star


Agency :Olivier Giroud scored late in the second half for Arsenal to maintain its perfect Europa League campaign with a 1-0 win over 10-man Red Star Belgrade on Thursday.Five minutes after Milan Rodic was sent off for a second yellow card, Giroud struck with an overhead kick five minutes before ...

Entertainment »

Ali Fazal and Shriya Pilgaonkar come together for Web Series


Shriya Pilgaonkar who was appreciated for her Hindi film debut as Shahrukh Khan’s love interest in Fan and for her viral short film Jai Mata Di, is now going to be seen in a web show called Mirzapur produced by Farhan Akhtar and Ritesh Sidhwani for a global online platform ...

Editorial »

Flood victims yet to get enough support


GOVERNMENT and aid agencies have provided emergency relief for flood victims but not sufficient to settle flood victims as per media reports quoting Center for Policy Dialogue (CPD) researchers who tried to figure out the distribution system in the Haor areas. Over 37 lakh people were affected in the floods ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news