Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Wednesday, June 28, 2017 11:26:59 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Valuation of suits in service matter suits and/or recovery of arrear salaries therein

By
21st-Jan-2017       Readers ( 330 )   0 Comments
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all (0) »

Md Mukhlesur Rahman :
It is our study that the laws relating to valuation of suits and payment of court fees in various types of suits of this country, i.e. the Suit Valuation Act, 1887 and the Court-fees Act, 1870, are very much technical, complicated and intricate. Besides, so far our study, there are no direct provisions respecting ascertainment of value of suits in respect of several varieties of suits for establishing various types of rights in service matters which are to be filed in civil courts. For that reason, numerous types of practices/traditions had been, even somewhere has been, followed in the country. For the said reasons, it had been being practiced in our country that the suit for declaration that the plaintiff's suspension/dismissal from service, and/or suit for mandatory injunction for reinstatement him in the service and/or payment of arrear salaries would fall u/s. 7 para (i) or (iii) of Court-fees Act and thereby plaintiff would had to value his suit at an amount as per his salary's basic's last year's (i.e. 12 month's) total amount's 15 times and had to pay an ad valorem court fees upon this value; that is to say the plaintiff, who is distressed due to driven from service, had to pay a huge amount of court-fees for his suit for establishment of his right in the service.
So far our query, we find no judicial pronouncement early to 2008 in our country on this issue; and even we do not know whether there is any foreign authority on this point. But on 5-6-2008, the present Hon'ble Chief Justice of Bangladesh Mr Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha, when he was Judge of the Hon'ble High Court Division of the Supreme Court, gave an authoritative and epoch-making judgment on this issue in the case of Country Director International Bank of Reconstruction and Development vs Ismat Zerin Khan reported in 14 MLR 61, and which decision has already been upheld by the Appellate Division too as reported in 18BLT (AD) 1, and which is a ratio decidendi in the country now.
This decision brought a new age in the field that such suits for establishment any right in service do not fall u/s. 7 para (i), (ii) or (iii) of the Court-fees Act; rather it falls u/s. 7 (iv) (c) of Court-fees Act. Therefore, such categories of suits having no objective standard of valuation, it is the plaintiff's will what will-value his suit. In our little knowledge" and I beg pardon making reference, we may say that in the said judgment his Lordship by his scholar and vivid interpretation clearly showed us what the statutes are in the concerned field and how those should be applied.
Now we may place the very judgments in concise herein bellow:
Plaintiff filed the suit for declaration that non-confirmation of her appointment and termination of her employment is illegal; by amendment she, included prayer for mandatory injection directing the defendants to pay her emoluments.
Upon such amendment the plaintiff valued the suit at Tk, 1,000. Defendants alleged that there  is objective standard of valuation for the relief and the plaintiff is required to pay ad valorem court fees on the basis of her salaries.
The learned Assistant Judge observed that the plaintiff did not pray for any specified amount of salary and the therefore objective standard of valuation was ascertainable for the relief claimed. Held: Plaintiff has sought for some declarations and prayed for mandatory injunction in the declaratory form. The suit does not falls within meaning of suits u/s. 7 para (i) or-(ii); rather it falls u/s. 7 (iv) (c) of Court-fees Act and as such plaintiff, has rightly valued the suit. Because, there is no objective standard of valuation available in the relief claimed.
If any objection is raised as to the payment of court fees, if the suit falls within provisions of para (iv) of Clause (c) of Section 7; the Court should accept the value of the relief stated in the plaint, both for the purposes of court fees as well as for the purposes of determining the jurisdiction of the Court to try the suit, 14 MLR 61, NB. This decision, was upheld  by the Appellate Division as reported in 18 BLT (AD) 1.
The HCD also held that "there is no objective standard of valuation available in the reliefs claimed". The learned advocate for petitioner submits that the HCD committed illegality in holding that there is no objective standard of valuation of the suit having regard to the nature of the prayer sought for recovery of arrear salaries by way of mandatory injunction. Held: The HCD upon correct assessment of the materials on record arrived at a correct decision, 18 BLT (AD) 1.
We may conclude this study saying that his lordship Mr. Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha has brought a remarkable clarification by his aforementioned authority judgment in making valuation in suits for service-matters and thereby opened an easy access to justice for the upset citizens of the Republic.
We do not know whether this ratio decidendi/ precedent has been noticed by and have been being followed in all the courts of the country. But, as per mandate of Article 111 of the Constitution, we must follow this law as declared by the Supreme Court, and thereby shall serve the nation better.
NB. The discussions in this essay relates only to the suits in the civil courts; but the suits which are exclusively triable by the Administrative Tribunals, shall be filed therein and these laws have no application of these provisions in the said Tribunal. However, The Administrative Tribunals Act, 1980 being special law and there being no specific provision for valuation of suits and court fees for suits in the Administrative Tribunals, the provisions of Article 12(viii) of Schedule II to the Court Fees Act shall apply before those Tribunals, and thereby a fixed court fee of Tk. 300 shall have to be paid there.

0 Comments. Share your thoughts also.
Write a comment
Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Eid Mubarak


THE nation is set to celebrate EID-UL-FITR on Monday subject to sighting of the moon of Shawal. It is also known as the 'Feast of Breaking the Fast' through the whole month of Ramzan. Preparations are afoot throughout the country to end the fasting through festivities. Eid is an important ...

Cricket »

Danielle Hazell claimed the wicket of Punam Raut in the match of the ICC Women`s World Cup between England and India in Derby on Saturday.


.

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Gayeshwar Chandra Roy speaking at a protest rally organised by Jatiyatabadi Projanmo Dal at the Jatiya Press Club on Saturday demanding release of BNP leader Barkat Ullah Bulu.


.

Entertainment »

Shahrukh is not doing a cameo in Jagga Jasoos


It was recently reported that Shah Rukh Khan will do a cameo in Ranbir Kapoor’s Jagga Jasoos, however contrary to the rumours it emerges that Shah Rukh Khan will not be seen in Anurag Basu’s musical adventure featuring Ranbir Kapoor and Katrina Kaif. Sources close to the film rubbishes the ...

International »

Ivanka ordered to testify in dispute with shoe company


AP, New York :Ivanka Trump must testify in a dispute with an Italian shoemaker over one of her company's shoe designs, a judge said Friday.U.S. District Judge Katherine Forrest rejected a request by the senior White House aide's lawyers that she be blocked from submitting to a deposition in the ...

Editorial »

Safety on highway must be high on card


AS the Eid-ul-Fitr is knocking the door, home-bound passengers are taking long journey on highways and using Railways and Waterways to reach families overnight. There is acrimonious scene all over and we must say the government must ensure discipline at critical places to avoid mishap. The weather is however good ...

Back Page »

Iftar Mahfil welfare approach


Abdul Muqit Chowdhury :Iftar Mahfil has become a tradition in the Holy Ramzan. Such gathering, if it is a positive approach to contribute to fraternal relation in the society, is surely acceptable. Sharing the joy of fasting irrespective of social status and class is praiseworthy.This reflects allegiance to the Islamic ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Barrister Moudud Ahmed, among others, at a discussion on 'Attack on Mirza Fakhrul Islam Alamgir and Amir Khasru Mahmud Chowdhury and Future of Clean Politics of Bangladesh' organised by Swadhinata Forum at the Jatiya Press Club on Friday.


.

Entertainment »

Alia is Raazi for Meghna Gulzar`s next


Alia Bhatt is all set to feature in Meghna Gulzar’s next, Raazi. The actress would be seen playing a Kashmiri girl marries to a Pakistani army officer in the espionage thriller. Raazi portrays the story of a Kashmiri girl married to a Pakistani army officer who would provide Indian intelligence ...

International »

Senate Republicans unveil Obamacare replacement bill after months of closed-door crafting


Reuters, Washington :U.S. Senate Republicans on Thursday unveiled their version of legislation that would replace Obamacare, proposing to kill a tax on the wealthy that pays for it and reduce aid to the poor to cut costs.With Democrats deeply opposed to Republican attempts to overhaul former President Barack Obama's signature ...

Editorial »

Mayors must do more to contain chikungunya in city


THE outbreak of mosquito borne diseases like a new type of fever called chikungunya, in addition to dengue fever in the city and elsewhere is causing additional concern to city dwellers and public health authorities how to protect people from this danger. People in most families in the city are ...

Back Page »

Zum'atul Wida


Abdul Muqit Chowdhury :The last Friday of the Holy Ramzan is called 'Zum'atul Wida'. It means 'departing Zum'a'. The musallies with due religious fervour join the Zum'a congregation and bid farewell to this month of patience and self-restraint. Al-Quran imposes obligation of the Friday prayer in the followingverses : "O ...

Cricket »

Malinga in hot water over 'monkey' comment


AFP, Colombo :Sri Lanka fast bowler Lasith Malinga faced an investigation Thursday after he compared a government minister to a monkey following criticism that the country's cricketers were too fat.Sports minister Dayasiri Jayasekera said he ordered an inquiry after Malinga lambasted him for questioning the endurance of Sri Lankan players ...

Entertainment »

Harry and Sejal grooving on Radha


Jab Harry met Sejal’s first song Radha is out and it’s as refreshing as it can get. The song features Shah Rukh Khan and Anushka Sharma dancing to the tunes of Sukhwinder Singh and Sunidhi Chauhan on the streets. The peppy number with its foot tapping music and catchy lyrics ...

Entertainment »

Samia Rahman’s Eid reality show Rupantor


Entertainment Report :A reality show will be telecasted in five days of Eid holidays and its result will be announced during this time. This short-term reality show Rupantor is planned by Samia Rahman. She will moderate the show. She will select 30 university females among hundred students. Produced by Samia ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news