Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, April 23, 2017 11:49:00 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

The court is not obliged to detail-out ground(s) for framing charge(s)

By
18th-Feb-2017       Readers ( 301 )   0 Comments
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all (0) »

Appellate Division :
(Criminal)
Nazmun Ara Sultana J
Syed Mahmud
Hossain J
Md Imman Ali J
Judgment
May 29th, 2014
Muntasir Mamun Khan (Md) and others …….Petitioner
vs
State and another….Respondents
Code of Criminal Procedure (V of 1898)
Section 265C
If the Court/Tribunal, on examination of the records and also after hearing both the sides finds that there are sufficient materials for proceeding against the accused the court/tribunal shall frame charge against the accused persons, there is no requirement in law for recording the reasons for framing charge elaborately. Law does not require that the "sufficient materials" found by the court tribunal for framing charge should be stated elaborately in the order of framing charge.  ...... (10)
AJ Mohammad Ali, Senior Advocate instructed by Syed Mahbubar Rahman, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioners.
Haridus Paul, Advocate-on-Record -For Respondent No.2.
None Represented -Respondent No. 1.
Judgment
Nazmun Ara Sultana J : This Criminal Petition for Leave to Appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 8-6-2011 passed  by the High Court Division in Criminal Appeal No. 611 of 2009 dismissing the criminal appeal and thereby affirming the order dated 13-1-2009 passed by the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Tribunal, Jessore in Nari-o-Shishu Case No. 178 of 2008 framing charge against the present accused-appellant-petitioners under sections 11 (ga) and 11(ga)/30 of the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Ain, 2000 after rejecting their application under Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
2. The necessary facts for disposal of this Criminal Petition for Leave to Appeal, in short, are that one Nazrul Islam @ Robi, as informant, lodged an FIR with Kotwali Model Police Station, Jessore alleging that his younger sister Most. Moslema Afroz @ Ruma was given in marriage with the accused No. 1 Dr Md Muntasir Mamun Khan on 6-7-2007. At the time of marriage an amount of Taka 3,00,000 was demanded by the accused persons as dowry, out of which Taka 2,00,000 was paid. Subsequently on demand of remaining Taka 1, 00,000 as dowry, the accused persons started torturing Most. Moslema Afroz @ Ruma-the victim and at one stage, she was driven out from her husband's house.
Apprehending legal consequence, the cunning accused-husband Md Muntasir Mamun Khan instituted Family Suit No. 67 of 2008 for restitution of conjugal life. Subsequently on the basis of compromise, the victim was brought to the husband's house on 4-5-2008 and the said family suit was withdrawn.
But the accused persons again started to claim remaining Taka 1,00,000 as dowry and on such demand the accused persons assaulted the victim. Ultimately on getting information over telephone, the relatives of the victim girl went to the house of the accused and rescued the victim and took her to the hospital where she got treatment.
3. On the basis of the above FIR Kotwali Model Police Station Case No. 30 dated 8-5-2008 was started and the police, after investigation submitted charge sheet against all the FIR named accused persons under Sections 11(ga)/30 of the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Ain, 2000.
The case was ultimately sent to the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Tribunal, Jessore for trial. Before this tribunal the accused persons filed an application under Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure praying their discharge, but the tribunal, on hearing the learned Advocates of both the sides, rejected that application and framed charge under Section 11 (ga) of the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Ain, 2000 against the present accused petitioner No.1 and under sections 11(ga)/30 against the other two accused-petitioners by the order dated 13-1-2009.
4. Being aggrieved by the said order of the tribunal the accused-petitioners preferred the above mentioned criminal appeal under Section 28 of the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Ain, 2000 before the High Court Division. A Division Bench of the High Court Division, after hearing both the parties, dismissed that appeal by the impugned judgment and order.
5. Mr AJ Mohammad Ali, the learned Senior Advocate for the accused-appellant petitioners has assailed the impugned judgment and order of the High Court Division making submissions to the effect mainly that both the High Court Division and the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Tribunal did not consider at all the purpose of insertion of Section 265C in the Code of Criminal Procedure. The learned Advocate has argued that the Section 265C has been inserted in the Code of Criminal Procedure to check false and frivolous cases and thereby to ensure that the innocent persons are not harassed unnecessarily by being put to the trouble of undergoing trial and also to check the abuse of courts process and also wastage of court's valuable time.
The learned Counsel has contended that neither the Tribunal nor the High Court Division has examined the materials on record and without being satisfied that there were sufficient materials for framing charge the tribunal framed charge against the accused petitioners illegally and unjustly and the High Court Division also affirmed this order of framing charge most unjustly without taking into consideration the purport of Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure at all.
6. Mr Haridus Paul, the learned Advocate-on-Record for the informant respondent has made submissions supporting the impugned judgment.
7. We have considered the submissions made by the learned Advocates of both the sides and gone through the impugned judgment and order of the High Court Division and also the order dated 13-1-2009 passed by the Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Tribunal, Jessore in Nari-o-Shishu Case No. 178 of 2008.
8. It appears from the order dated 13-12009 passed in Nari-o-Shishu Case No. 178 of 2008 that the learned Judge of the Tribunal, before passing this order, heard the submissions made by the learned Advocate for the accused persons in support of the application under Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure and also the submissions of the special public prosecutor and examined the record and finding sufficient materials for framing charge against the accused persons rejected that application under Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure and framed charge against the accused persons as already mentioned above.
9. Section 265C provides:
"265C. Discharge.-If, upon consideration of the record of the case and the documents submitted therewith, and after hearing the submissions of the accused and the prosecution in this behalf, the Court considers that there is no sufficient grounds for proceeding against the accused, it shall discharge the accused and record the reasons for so doing."
10. Evidently, the tribunal took into consideration the mandate of Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure and also complied with the same before passing the impugned order of framing charge.
The learned Advocate for the accused-petitioners has argued also that the tribunal did not assign any reason for framing charge in the impugned order and for this defect also the impugned order of framing charge in liable to be set aside. But this argument of the learned Advocate also is not correct. From the above quoted section 265C it is evident that the court/tribunal requires to record the reasons for discharging the accused only, there is no direction either in Section 265C or in any other section of the Code of Criminal Procedure that the court/ tribunal will have to record the reasons of framing charge also.
If the Court/Tribunal, on examination of the records and also after hearing both the sides finds that there are sufficient materials for proceeding against the accused the Court/Tribunal shall frame charge against the accused persons, there is no requirement in law for recording the reasons for framing charge elaborately. In this present case as it appears from the impugned order of framing charge, the tribunal, on hearing both the sides and examination of record, found sufficient materials for framing charge against the accused persons and hence it rejected the application under Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure and framed charge against the accused-persons. Law does not require that the "sufficient materials" found by the court/ tribunal for framing charge should be stated elaborately in the order of framing charge.
11. The learned Advocate for the accused petitioners has made submissions questioning the truth of the prosecution case also by pointing out some facts and circumstances in support of defence case. But this submission also of the learned Advocate is not entertainable at this stage since all these are disputed facts which need to be adjudicated on taking evidence at the trial of the case.
The High Court Division rightly pointed out that the police investigated this case and finding the allegations against the accused persons prima facie proved, submitted charge sheet and that there are nothing on record to prove conclusively that the allegations made against the accused persons are false and that in the circumstances, before trial, the accused persons cannot be discharged.
12. We also, in agreement with the High Court Division and also the Tribunal, find that there are sufficient materials on record for proceeding against the accused persons and hence the impugned order passed by the Tribunal rejecting the application under Section 265C of the Code of Criminal Procedure and framing charge against the accused persons and also the order of the High Court Division affirming this impugned order passed by the Tribunal do not call for any interference by this Division.
Hence this Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal be dismissed.

0 Comments. Share your thoughts also.
Write a comment
Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Cricket »

Pacer Taskin becomes Atom Gum brand ambassador


Bangladesh pacer Taskin Ahmed has been appointed as the brand ambassador of Atom Gum, a product of PRAN Confectionery Limited, said a press release.It was announced by Shakhawat Ahamed, head of marketing of PRAN Confectionery Limited at a program held in the city's hotel on Saturday. The Tiger pacer will ...

Cricket »

Shakib new T20 I Captain of Bangladesh Cricket team


Sports Reporter :Shakib Al Hasan has been appointed Captain of Bangladesh National Cricket (T20 I) team.Earlier, Mashrafe Bin Mortaza, the Captain of Bangladesh National Cricket (ODI & T20 I) team declared his retirement from T20 I format. Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) announced on Saturday that best all-rounder of world cricket ...

Editorial »

Dengue : Now an annual visitor


THE capital is yet again experiencing an early outbreak of dengue and untimely rains may be to blame. Like last year, Aedes mosquitoes, transmitter of the dengue virus, have bred early this year alarming authorities and city dwellers and health officials say there are chances their number would be larger, ...

Entertainment »

Mosharraf, Jui`s Eid play Shob Choritro Kalponik Noi


Entertainment Report :On the occasion of coming Eid, popular celebrity couple Mosharraf Karim and Robena Reza Jui worked together in a special play titled Shob Choritro Kalponik Noi. They also acted in the play like real life characters. Shooting of the play was done recently in the city’s Uttara area. ...

Entertainment »

What Kangana has to say about Azaan controversy


Actress Kangana Ranaut says she has no problems with Azaan but feels what Sonu Nigam said should be respected and discussed.  Sonu Nigam, in a series of tweets, had described the use of loudspeakers to broadcast sermons and calls to prayers by mosques, temples and gurudwaras as hooliganism. When asked ...

City »

Human capacity for achieving SDGs underscored


Right based civil society organizations urged the government to put effective strategies and actions to increase human capacity locally in order to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). They also opined that the human capacity would see a surge once the government strengthens its institutional capacity and provides platforms for ...

International »

Russian FM presses Tillerson over Syria probe


AFP, Moscow :Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov voiced "regret" in a phone call with his US counterpart at Washington's opposition to a Moscow-backed plan to investigate an alleged chemical attack in Syria.In the call with Secretary of State Rex Tillerson which "took place at US initiative," Lavrov raised the probe ...

Editorial »

Over-dependence on Indian electricity supply


ENERGY sector deals signed with Indian companies so far clearly indicate how India has been singularly un-tapping our energy market making us disproportionately dependent on the big neighbour. These contracts as reported by a national daily on Friday including those signed early this month had already handed over the largest ...

Entertainment »

Neel Monihar Lucky Akhand


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :When we recall the memories of old sad romantic songs the name of legendary singer-composer Lucky Akhand will come first. He will last long forever in the minds of many music lovers by virtue of his outstanding rendering style and composition who died on April 21 after ...

Cricket »

Inhabitants of Satkhira unhappy as Mustafiz cannot play in IPL


Sports Reporter :The inhabitants of Satkhira are not happy as Mustafizur Rahman cannot play in Indian Premier League (IPL) 2017. Earlier, 'Wonder Boy' Mustafizur Rahman showed a gimmick performance in his debut of IPL. He played for Sunrisers Hyderabad and played a key role for Sunrisers Hyderabad to clinch the ...

City »

Bangladesh Krishak Samity and Bangladesh Khetmajur Samity staged a demonstration in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Friday to meet its various demands including declaration of flood-affected haor areas as disaster-prone areas.


.

International »

Putin says Russian people will choose his successor via ballot box


Reuters, Moscow :Vladimir Putin said on Thursday that only the Russian people will choose who succeeds him as president, through the electoral process.Russia will hold a presidential election in March next year. Putin has not said whether he will run or not, but is widely expected to go for what ...

Editorial »

Stop false cases to keep in jail without trial


SUPREME Court Legal Aid Committee (SCLAC) Chairman Justice M Enayetur Rahim said on April 18 a specific law is required to rehabilitate people released after languishing in custody for long periods due to delay in trial proceedings, as per a report of a local daily. Under the law of tort, ...

Sports »

Serena expecting baby this year


Sports Desk :It's another love game for Serena Williams: She is pregnant - and, based on the timeline she offered, she already was when she won the Australian Open.A spokeswoman for Williams, Kelly Bush Novak, wrote in an email to The Associated Press on Wednesday: "I'm happy to confirm Serena ...

City »

BNP Secretary General Mirza Fakhrul Islam Alamgir, among others, at a rally organised by the party at the Jatiya Press Club on Thursday in protest against enforced disappearance of the party leaders including M Ilias Ali.


 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news