Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, August 21, 2017 02:09:57 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Immunity to physicians not well conceived

By
17th-Mar-2017       Readers ( 186 )   0 Comments
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all (0) »

THE draft Medical Care Protection Act that proposes to give immunity to healthcare providers for negligence in treatment has come under serious scanning from health experts and rights groups. Terming the move draconian, rights campaigners have rightly said the act will deprive common people getting justice for even wilful neglect in duty that at times may even cause death to patients. Amidst the mushrooming of private medical college producing poorly qualified physicians the risks are high.

Moreover patients' life has become increasingly vulnerable in recent time from sporadic strike by physicians, intern doctors, politicization of their profession and indifference to obeying hospital rules and discipline. When the country needs restoring professional discipline to improve the quality of treating patients, such immunity as proposed in the Draft Law will make healthcare services more vulnerable without accountability of any sort for professional failing.

The Draft Law says any act accomplished in good faith will not be considered a crime and complaints cannot be filed to the court against the physicians for the act. But question arises who will determine whether or not some casualties have taken place from action in good faith or from sheer neglect to duty. In many cases physicians give wrong treatment to patients causing immense suffering or death to patients. Surgeons leave bandage or operation knife inside stomach and such mindless actions can't be challenged because the doctor may say he was over worked and it was an unwilling mistake.

The Health Ministry draft justified the clause pointing to attacks on healthcare providers - doctors, nurses, hospital assistants and others from patients' relatives. This is true but doctors are blamed for neglect of duty on most occasions. The draft justifies the provision saying many physicians are now losing interests to hospital services fearing accusation of wrong treatment. It partly aims at mitigating the physicians fear.

But they can't rule out that physicians are not attentive to timely attending patients causing serious incontinences and even death. Only a judicial review of such complaints can make sure who is wrong and who is right. But now if a legal complaint can't be lodged or a wrong-doer enjoys legal immunity from being held accountable for a wrong treatment, chaos may only overtake healthcare services.

It appears that we are through a time when road transport workers are enjoying immunity from killing of people in road accidents on the highway saying it is not a wilful murder.  Law enforcers are enjoying immunity from torturing people before proving their guilt and ruling party men are enjoying freedom to act on their will. In our view such licensing will only spread chaos and people such as the physicians will become more and more irresponsible because they know that they are not punishable for neglect to duty. We would ask the government to review the clause.

0 Comments. Share your thoughts also.
Write a comment
Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

River erosion now adds to flood woes


REPEATED environmental disasters seem to take heavy toll on the people of this country this year. Followed by unprecedented off-season heavy rainfall, landslides, flash floods and the ongoing floods again, the newest woe that hits the people is unprecedented river erosions in the north and middle parts of the country. ...

Cricket »

Mominul to replace Mosaddek in 14-member national squad


A day after his omission from the team, top order batsman and most consistent performer in the longer version cricket Mominul Haque was recalled to the Bangladesh's squad on Sunday for the first Test against touring Australia scheduled to begin on August 27 at Sher-e-Bangla National Cricket Stadium (SBNCS) in ...

Entertainment »

I have left everything for films and there is no looking back: Srinidhi Shetty


Miss Supranational 2016 Srinidhi Shetty is an engineer, model and soon to be actress. Srinidhi started her pageant career after she finished her engineering degree from Bengaluru. She then participated in Yamaha Fascino Miss Diva 2016 and Miss Supernational 2016. 2016 has been Srinidhi's reigning year as Miss Supranational and ...

International »

Iraq begins battle to retake Tal Afar, IS bastion near Mosul


AFP, Baghdad :Iraqi forces on Sunday launched an assault to retake the northern city of Tal Afar from the Islamic State group, after ousting the jihadists from Mosul last month.Tal Afar lies around 70 kilometres (45 miles) west of second city Mosul, which Iraqi forces recaptured in early July in ...

City »

Chairman of Awami Juba League (AJL) Omar Faruque Chowdhury speaking at a memorial meeting on August 21 grenade attack victims organised by (AJL) at Shilpakala Academy in the city on Sunday.


Cricket »

Members of Australian Cricket team during their practice session at the Sher-e-Bangla National Cricket Stadium in Mirpur on Saturday.


Sports »

Farah bids to give British fans memorable farewell


British athletics great Mo Farah will hope his final track race on home turf on Sunday will have a happier ending than last Saturday's world 5,000 metres final. The 34-year-old, who will compete in the 3,000 metres at the Diamond League meeting in Birmingham, produced a courageous performance just falling ...

Editorial »

Berlin confce to protect Sundarbans


A EUROPEAN conference on Sundarbans started in German capital Berlin yesterday to discuss how to protect the world's greatest mangrove forest from destruction at a time when our government is determined to continue with the construction of the giant Rampal Coal-fired Plant. It is being built as a joint venture ...

Entertainment »

Sonam to act in the film adaptation of The Zoya Factor


Sonam Kapoor had reportedly signed on for the movie adaptation of Anuja Chauhan's Battle For Bittora opposite Fawad Khan. But the film never materialised as relations between India and Pakistan soured. Now, the buzz is that she's been signed on for another movie adaptation of Anuja Chauhan's The Zoya Factor.  ...

City »

Road Transport and Bridges Minister Obaidul Quader, among others, at a discussion on 42nd martyrdom anniversary of Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and National Mourning Day organised by Bangladesh Awami Juba League in the auditorium of the city's Engineers' Institution on Saturday.


International »

India wildlife reserve park devastated by monsoon floods


AP, Guahati :Rising floodwaters have inundated large parts of a famous wildlife reserve park in northeastern India, killing more than 225 animals and forcing hundreds of other animals to flee, the park director said Saturday.Around 15 rhinos, 185 deer and at least one Royal Bengal tiger have died in the ...

Editorial »

Import is not enough; make sure people get rice at low cost


THE country is apparently facing acute food shortage; which is evident from a government decision to increase food grains import to 20 lakh tonnes this year from earlier announced import at 11 lakh tonnes. The cause of the sudden rise in import is that the country has lost over 20 ...

Sports »

Thailand`s Pornchai Kaokaew (center) kicks a ball against Indonesia's Saiful Rijai (left) and Syamsul Hadi during the men's Sepak Takraw Regu competition at South East Asian Games in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia on Friday.


.

Entertainment »

Friends & Family bring in Sangeeta Ahir`s birthday with a bang


Even though once and still considered a taboo, Suicide and depression are rarely the theme of films in Indian cinema. Depression is alarmingly rising in the youth and adults in India making it a major cause of concern. Depression is usually caused by traumatic experiences, bad relationships, anxiety, and low ...

International »

Civilian deaths surge in Raqqa as IS tactics slow US-backed advances


VOA News :As U.S.-backed forces continue to make slow progress in their offensive to oust Islamic State (IS) from its self-proclaimed capital of Raqqa, thousands of civilians who are trapped in the city face an increasing danger of getting caught in crossfire, rights organizations and local activists warn.Officials from the ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news