Friday, June 22, 2018 10:54:04 PM
Cian McCarthy :
Throughout and since the Brexit campaign in the UK, we constantly heard of the "benefits and obligations" of EU membership. You can't enjoy the benefits without bearing the obligations, our leaders would say.
Eurosceptics argue that access to a larger economic market is not worth the burdens of unrestricted immigration, overbearing regulations and loss of judicial autonomy.
Pro-EU campaigners argue that we should accept these costs, as they are heavily outweighed by the many gains to society that the EU brings about.
The fatal mistake that the Remain campaign made was to engage in this argument in the first place. Europhiles should not accept that the free flow of people, the harmonisation of standards across the continent and the supremacy of the European Court of Justice are "burdens" to be borne by EU countries.
Accepting this characterisation not only puts the pro-Europe side on a much weaker footing, but it also forgoes the opportunity to make a positive case for the true benefits that those so-called obligations actually lead to for all EU countries.
The Brexit battle may have been lost by the Remain camp, but there are many, perhaps more consequential, conflicts looming on the horizon. Pro-EU groups in France, Germany and the Netherlands-three of the founding members of the EU project-are facing stiff competition from anti-EU political parties.
It's time that those wanting the survival of the EU engage in the battle to reframe the debate.
Modern politics is littered with examples of effective framing. Consider the term "tax-relief". Who do you think benefits more from this becoming a familiar phrase: those who want to lower taxes, or those wishing to raise taxes to increase government spending?
The word "relief" implies that some suffering or hardship will be relieved, presumably by a benevolent leader. If those wishing to raise taxes accept the phrase and try to argue against tax-relief, they are fighting a losing battle.
Similarly, by engaging within the framing that certain aspects of EU policy are obligations, rather than benefits, EU supporters have conceded a potentially effective argument for the continuity of the European Union.
Once it has become customary to call immigration an obligation, any discussion of immigration will only favour those who want to stop the free flow of people. But what if we changed to rules of the game and refused to engage with these frames?
If we could reframe these issues as further benefits of the EU, then we could potentially change the debate in a way that could save the European project.
Reframing these issues as benefits is not an impossible task. Take the hot topic of the day: the free flow of people. Not only is migration from poorer to richer European countries good for the poorer countries, by raising wages and cutting unemployment within them, but it also is good for the receiving countries as well. Immigrants are generally young and diligent workers who fill important gaps in the economy.
A report by the British government found that immigrants contribute to 15% of the country's GDP growth, and make a net contribution of £2.5 billion to the Westminster's finances. And yet, the desire to stem the flow of immigration was a key factor for people voting to leave the EU.
If the Remain campaign had done a better job of making the point that immigration is good for the UK economy, rather than merely arguing that other benefits are worth letting migration happen, perhaps there might have been a very different debate, and a different result.
Another issue often decried by the Leave side was overly burdensome regulations handed down by the EU to small UK businesses. Boris Johnson, a leader of the campaign and now the UK's foreign minister, continually trivialised EU standards and regulations, painting them as unnecessary and costly.
But EU regulations are not designed purely to make life hard for businesses without any basis in fact or reason. Many of the agricultural regulations that Johnson made light of were created to protect consumers from disease. The idea of having common product standards for goods and electronics is not to arbitrarily create more red-tape, it's to reduce it.
Businesses can cut costs by only having to deal with one set of standards in the Single Market, as opposed to 28 sets of varying standards and regulations.
These are the types of arguments that pro-EU activists need to highlight. People are largely aware of some of the established benefits of EU membership.
They know they can easily go on holidays in Spain or Italy. They know that the Single Market makes it cheaper for them to import French wine or Irish beef.
But many have decided that these benefits are not worth the supposed obligations that come along with them. Rather than trying to convince them that the benefits are worth the costs, the EU and its supporters need to show them that the costs are not costs at all.
(Cian McCarthy is a Master of Arts in Law and Diplomacy student at Massachusetts' Tufts University).
LIKE many other countries, World Refugee Day was observed in the country on Wednesday at a time when the world's third largest refugee group Rohingya is living in the overcrowded camps in Cox's Bazar. The UNHCR reported that 68.5 million people are living in different refugee camps across the world. ...
Neetu Kapoor will soon be turning 60 on July 8 and if the latest reports are to be believed, the actress already has special plans. Neetu Kapoor will soon be flying to Paris to ring in her birthday with husband Rishi Kapoor, son Ranbir Kapoor, daughter Riddhima Kapoor Sahni and ...
Priyanka Chopra and Salman Khan are ready to be seen together on the big screen after a decade in Bharat. The film also stars Disha Patani and is an adaptation of South Korean film, Ode to My Father. Directed by Ali Abbas Zafar, this project has been in the limelight ...
AP, Ankara :Since he took office in 2003, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has given a name to each stage in his consolidation of power in Turkey. First he called himself the apprentice; then the journeyman; and latterly the master. Now, he says a new five-year term would elevate him to ...
Salman Khan's film Race 3 is unstoppable. The film, which hit screens on June 15, is giving all sorts of reasons for the star cast to celebrate. The Remo D'Souza directorial had already crossed the benchmark of Rs 100 crore at the Indian box office. But interestingly, the Salman fever ...
THREE more activists of Parbatya Chattogram Janasanghati Samity (MN Larma) and United People's Democratic Front (Democratic) were shot dead at their homes in Rangamati and Khagrachhari districts between Friday and Sunday. Conflicts between different groups in Chattogram Hill Tracts have led to the death of at least 22 people in ...
Reuters, Beijing : Chinese President Xi Jinping told visiting North Korean leader Kim Jong Un on Wednesday that with the joint efforts of the two countries, the Korean peninsula will definitely be peaceful and stable, official news agency Xinhua said.Xi made the comments during a meeting at Beijing's Diaoyutai state guest ...
AFP, Moscow :The Kremlin on Wednesday said Vladimir Putin did not watch Russia's surprise win over Egypt in the World Cup because he was on a plane but added that he reacted "very positively, like the whole of our country". "Unfortunately, he did not watch the match itself. It so ...
NO sooner had the Eid vacation come to an end but another murder shocked us all. The decapitated body of Sumon Zahid, a witness in a war crimes case and also the son of martyred journalist Selina Parvin was found dead in the capital's Khilgaon the day before yesterday. There ...