Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Wednesday, July 18, 2018 09:11:41 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Allowing witness to correct his deposition shall make cross-examination a mockery

By
08th-Apr-2017       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Appellate Division :
(Civil)
Md Abdul Wahhab Miah J
Nazmun Ara Sultana J
Md Imman Ali J
Md Nizamul Huq J
Judgment
July 28th, 2016
Sharifullah (Md) and
anothers .... Petitioner
vs
Md Tafazzal Hossain and another-Respondents
Code of Civil Procedure (V of 1908)
Order XVIII, rule 17
Evidence Act (1 of 1872)
Sections 137 and 138
A witness is not entitled to correct his deposition after putting his signature in the deposition sheet and if such a recourse is allowed to be practised by a witness, then the whole purpose of cross examination shall be frustrated and in the process the cross examination shall become a mockery. . ..... (7)
Aminul Haque Advocate instructed by Madhu Malati Chowdhury Barua, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioner.
Nurul Islam Chowdhury, Advocate-on-Record-For Respondent No.1.
None Represented -Respondent No.2.
Judgment
Md Abdul Wahhab Miah J : The delay of 15 days in filing the petition is condoned.
2. This petition for leave to appeal has been filed against the judgment and order dated 19-4-2012 passed by a learned Judge of the Single Bench of the High Court Division in Civil Revision No. 561 of 1999 making the Rule absolute with some direction.
3. Short facts necessary to dispose this petition are that respondent No.1 as the plaintiff filed Title Suit No. 284 of 1983 in the Court of Subordinate Judge, 4th Court, Dhaka for partition of the suit land. Subsequently the suit being transferred to the Court of Subordinate Judge and Artha Rin Adalat No. 4, Dhaka was renumbered as Title Suit No. 270 of 1985 and then again it was renumbered as Title Suit No.41 of 1992 on being transferred to the Court of Artha Rin Adalat and Subordinate Judge, Dhaka.
4. The suit was decreed exparte on 2-8-1993 against the defendant-petitioner herein and respondent No. 2. The defendant-petitioner along with the other defendant (respondent No. 2, herein) filed an application under Order IX, rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure (the Code) for setting aside the ex-parte decree. The application was registered as Miscellaneous Case No.27 of 1994.
5. Respondent No.1 as the plaintiff filed written objection to contest the miscellaneous case.
The case being ready for peremptory hearing, hearing commenced and after examination of the defendant-petitioner (in the miscellaneous case), the plaintiff-opposite party (in the miscellaneous case) was examined as OPW 1 on 19-11-1998.
Then on 17-1-1999 i.e. after almost two months he (the plaintiff-opposite party) filed an application under Sections 151 and 152 of the Code for correction of his depositions by expunging some portions of his statement in cross examination.
The trial Court by its order of the same date (17-1-1999) rejected the prayer. Challenging this order the plaintiff filed the above mentioned civil revision before the High Court Division. A learned Judge of the Single Bench by the impugned judgment and order made the Rule absolute directing the trial Court "to correct the deposition and cross examination of the OPW. I and to dispose of the case within 4(four) months from the date of receipts of this judgment and order in accordance with law"; hence this petition of leave to appeal.
6. Heard Mr Aminul Haque, learned Counsel for the petitioner and Mr Nurul Islam Chowdhury, learned Advocate-on-Record who entered caveat on behalf of plaintiff-respondent No. 1.
7. We have considered the provisions of Order XVIII of the Code and Sections 137 and 137 of the Evidence Act. These provisions of the respective law have dealt with the hearing of the suit and examination of witnesses.
From a reading of these provisions of laws it appears to us that a witness is not entitled to correct his deposition after putting his signature in the deposition sheet and if such a recourse is allowed to be practised by a witness, then the whole purpose of cross examination shall be frustrated and in the process the cross examination shall become a mockery.
But the High Court Division totally to consider the above mentioned provisions of the laws and also the impact of such a recourse resorted to by the plaintiff-opposite party and it, in a very casual manner, allowed the prayer of the plaintiff-opposite party.
So, the High Court Division committed an apparent error in making the Rule absolute with the direction as quoted hereinbefore, and as such, the impugned judgment and order cannot be sustained and that must be set aside.
Since we have heard the learned Counsel for the petitioner and the learned Advocate-on Record for plaintiff-respondent No.1, we are inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment and order in a summary manner without giving any leave, as if leave is granted it would cause delay in the disposal of the miscellaneous case, the case being of the year 1994. Accordingly, this petition is disposed of in the following terms:
8. The impugned judgment and order of the High Court Division is set aside and those of the trial Court is restored.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Entertainment »

Elnaaz surprised by Salman -Katrina controversy about Sacred Games


Actress Elnaaz Norouzi is surprised that there is a controversy about the characters of Karan Wahi and her in the Netflix series Sacred Games. The characters are alleged to have taken inspiration from real life incidents in Salman Khan and his ex-girlfriend Katrina Kaif's real lives.  "While shooting the episodes, ...

Entertainment »

Vidya Balan is all set to play her first Telugu film!


One can't refute the fact that Vidya Balan is one of the most versatile actresses in Indian Cinema today. The National Award Winning actress has never shied away from going off the beaten track and picking up complex and challenging roles. Needless to say, she has effortlessly nailed them all ...

Football »

Mbappe to donate US $500,000 World Cup winnings to charity


Sports Desk :French teenage sensation Kylian Mbappe will be donating his entire World Cup earnings to a charity that organises sporting events for children with disabilities.The 19-year-old reportedly earned about US$22,300 per game in the tournament and an additional US$350,000 for helping his country lift the World Cup trophy on ...

Editorial »

Trump‘s behaviour in meeting with Putin regarded as disgraceful


US President Donald Trump has defended Russia over claims of interference in the 2016 presidential election. After face-to-face talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin, Mr Trump contradicted US intelligence agencies and said there had been no reason for Russia to meddle in the vote, as per international media reports.Mr Putin ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee member Dr Khondkar Mosharraf Hossain speaking at an opinion sharing meeting on 'Role of Present Election Commission and Blue Print of the Government' organised by Bangladesh Youth Forum at the Jatiya Press Club on Tuesday.


International »

No reason to believe Russia behind election meddling


Reuters, Helsinki :U.S. President Donald Trump emerged from a meeting with Vladimir Putin on Monday saying he saw no reason to believe Russia had hacked the 2016 U.S. presidential election, and the Russian leader "was extremely strong and powerful" in denying it.Trump held his meeting just days after a special ...

International »

US, North Korea hold 'productive' talks on war remains: Pompeo


AP, Seoul :U.S. and North Korean officials held "productive" talks Sunday to discuss the return of U.S. service members' remains missing since the Korean War, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said.Pompeo, who was not part of the talks, said in a statement that working level meetings between U.S. and ...

Business & Economy »

American Tony Roma now in Dhaka


Business Desk :America's most favorite ribs & steak chain "Tony Roma's" opened officially in Bangladesh on Monday.The first flagship outlet was launched at the most aristocratic zone in the city, NEB (3B), Road#74, Gulshan-2 in Dhaka. US Ambassador to Bangladesh Marcia Bernicat attended the function as the chief guest.Tony Roma's ...

Editorial »

Govt`s pragmatic step is needed to save Bangladesh from adverse impact of global warming


A RECENT study has shown that Bangladesh is among the countries 'most at risk' as over one billion people in the world are lack of air conditioning and refrigeration to keep them cool and to preserve food and medicines while global warming increasing temperatures. More electricity demand for fridges, fans ...

Football »

Harry Kane wins Golden Boot


England captain Harry Kane has won the Golden Boot after finishing as the World Cup's top scorer with Croatia's Luka Modric winning the Golden Ball for being the player of the tournament.Belgium midfielder Eden Hazard was the second-best player, with France forward Antoine Griezmann third.His French team-mate Kylian Mbappe won ...

Football »

Luka Modric (left) poses with the Golden Ball with Kylian Mbappe holding his Young Player Award on Sunday.


Entertainment »

Mamo, Mehazabien together


Entertainment Report :Zakia Bari Mamo and Mehazabien Chowdhury came to showbiz from the common platform. Both of them have common respect to each other. They won the hearts of many viewers by virtue of presenting their acting skills in last Eid works. Directors can easily rely on them. In last ...

City »

President candidate of a faction of BFUJ Molla Jalal, among others, at a journalists' rally organised by 'BFUJ Nirbachane Dabi Adai Sangram Committee'at the Jatiya Press Club on Monday demanding declaration of BFUJ election result.


International »

Gaza mourns teenage boys killed in Israeli air raid


Al Jazeera News :Umm Luay zooms in on a photograph on her mobile phone and kisses the screen, again and again.In the photo, her son, Luay Kaheel, is seen smiling alongside his friend, Amir al-Nimra. The two teenagers, 16 and 15 respectively, died on Saturday minutes after an Israeli air ...

Editorial »

Nobody could enjoy freedom to foil peaceful movement of students


ONCE again, the activists of Bangladesh Chhatra League (BCL) yesterday assaulted some students and teachers of Dhaka University to foil their human chain programme at Central Shaheed Minar demanding release of three quota reformists. The reformist leaders Jashim and Moshiur were shown arrested in a case filed for the attack ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news