Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Tuesday, August 20, 2019 01:28:32 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter
BREAKING NEWS:

Commentary

Treat bail as right to stop imprisonment without trial

photo by

By MAINUL HOSEIN
07th-May-2017       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

It should not have happened to the people of free Bangladesh but it is happening. The police power in fighting crime is being used for the innocent ones to fear the police and frighten the criminal justice system. The arrest by police is not for facing trial but near sure imprisonment without trial.

The torture in police custody cannot be ruled out. Our police would not have been so unjust and bold if the court had not cooperated easily. Both the courts and the police are also heard to complain of political pressure under the cover of fighting terrorism.

True fight against terrorism must mean speedy trial and quick exposure of the terrorists. We have special courts for speedy trial. But that does not happen.

The rule of law and human rights are not proving much by way of protection of law to our people. No government should feel secure where justice is not secured. The helpless people are helpless also for saving the government.

A national Bengali daily published a report Friday to reveal that some 600 prisoners are for 5 to 14 years in jail yet no trial has been completed. There are many excuses why the trials did not take place. The main one is failure to produce witnesses. Many other cases being baseless there will be only evasion of justice for delaying trials.

We had news earlier also pointing out persons spent 18 years  or so in jail without trial and the High Court Division granted them bail sou motto.

Justice is not just a matter of law, it is much more a matter of minds and hearts of the judges.  Among all the democratic institutions the judiciary is the most humane institution. Only money compensation from public funds for the years  they lost in jail cannot be enough. We must re-examine the working of the justice system. The situation is such that the Supreme Court has to do it.

The judges must be feeling the pain for not releasing them on bail although they must have been presumed innocent. For the refusal of bail criminal cases are being used to keep political opponents in jail without bail.
Impartial justice means it protects the innocent as strongly as it punishes the offenders. The presumption of innocence is the corner stone of the justice system. Granting of bail is never unconditional and the person so on bail remains in judicial custody. He remains under restraint.

Fighting for the judiciary is futile if people can be made to suffer imprisonment for years without trial. Speedy trial is not the complete answer to discouraging false cases. Granting bail is more effective against false and vindictive cases.

Oral battle of the Chief Justice in defence of the judiciary will have no impact unless the judiciary is also ready to be brave in protecting the people's liberty in doing justice. The judiciary is facing the challenge of its survival as an institution of justice and save the democratic Constitution as its protector. It is be remembered that the judiciary as an important people's organ for securing justice has to fall back on its popular base for its power to fight external interference.

We read news often to know how the under trial prisoners spend years under the rigorous regime of jail life away from family. By denying bail the courts have made it easy for the arrested ones to be kept in jail without the urgency of putting them on trial.

It is unfortunate that the judiciary is fighting a lonely battle for its meaningful existence. The lawyers are divided among the major two political parties as their activists. They are unmindful of their own role as defenders of the judiciary. They are party activists of undemocratic parties with no respect for the rule of law. Even the Law Minister who is otherwise well mannered is not aware that he is a minister only and the Chief Justice is the Chief Justice of Bangladesh.

Nothing could be more disappointing than when the lawyers are not loyal fighters for the independence of the justice system. In the same way the fourth pillar of democracy does not exist in Bangladesh. Because the journalists are mostly party activists seeking political favours and positions.

The judiciary alone cannot save democracy without which independence of the judiciary is unthinkable. But as long as the whole democratic Constitution is not buried the Constitutional position of the judiciary is worth defending.  If the judges can stand its ground together then no force will find it easy to make the process of justice powerless. There will be hope that though we do not have a functional democracy but we have saved ourselves from the worst of autocracy.

No court can think of doing justice without recognising one's liberty. Unless the accused has the liberty of defending himself freely justice becomes a one sided mockery.

The justice system in order to be effective as a justice system it must allow the accused the benefit of innocence before his guilt has been proved. We still have our fundamental rights under the Constitution on the side of the judiciary. These fundamental rights are obsolete if these are of no help when a person is arrested by the police for an alleged offence.

If a person can suffer imprisonment merely for suspicion of committing an offence then there is no need of impartial trial and credible evidence. To help police investigate the allegation a person should be refused bail is an easy denial of one's fundamental rights. Arrest first, investigation later cannot be acceptable before a court of law.

More particularly refusing bail before charge sheet should be an exception and not the rule. We start with the belief that there is nothing wrong to keep an arrested person in jail for some time. The FIR story is to be taken seriously than the presumption of innocence or his right to be free.

 We are making the country difficult for honest people to live in freedom and honour. If one is arrested for an alleged offence his reputation is in jeopardy. By the time his trial is finished and found innocent after long years in jail he is mentally and financially wrecked. He is not half the man he was. The justice system is to keep us civilised.

Impartial justice means it protects the innocent as strongly as it punishes the offenders. But in our system as soon as someone is arrested he ceases to be innocent.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

In 1 game, Bale shows he can still contribute at Real Madrid


AP, Madrid :Just like that, Gareth Bale is part of the solution for Real Madrid again.After only one game back as a starter, the player who wasn't wanted by coach Zinedine Zidane a few weeks ago showed he can still contribute to the team.Zidane started Bale in the team's Spanish ...

International »

Sudanese army and civilians seal interim power-sharing deal


Reuters, Khartoum :Sudan's main opposition coalition and the ruling military council on Saturday signed a final power-sharing deal that paves the way for a transitional government, and eventually elections, following the overthrow of long-time leader Omar al-Bashir.Tens of thousands of people of all ages took to the streets of the ...

Entertainment »

Bindu Kona’s Eid celebration


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Bindu Kona is a popular singer of present time. Eid celebration of the singers is really exceptional to them specially for whom who has to be engaged with stage shows round the year. Bindu Kona has to engage with stage shows round the year in and outside ...

Football »

Bayern Munich target Coutinho arrives for medical ahead of loan move


Philippe Coutinho has arrived at Bayern Munich to complete his medical as he edges closer to sealing his loan move from Barcelona.The Brazilian midfielder has agreed to join the Bundesliga champions on a season-long loan deal - with Bayern having the option to make the deal permanent at the end ...

Editorial »

Find out a sustainable solution to protect leather market


ALTHOUGH tanners were supposed to start buying rawhide at the government-fixed rates, merchants refused to sell, demanding the payment of a "considerable" portion of their arrears. It comes after seasonal traders, farmers and madrasas across the country threw away thousands of pieces of rawhide of sacrificial animals, approximately Tk 100 ...

International »

British MPs press Johnson to recall parliament over Brexit


British Prime Minister Boris Johnson came under pressure Sunday to immediately recall lawmakers from their summer holiday so parliament can debate Brexit.More than 100 MPs have written to Johnson to urge him to reconvene and let them sit permanently until October 31 - the date Britain is due to leave ...

City »

Aporajeyo Bangladesh, a social organisation, formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club yesterday demanding punishment to the persons responsible for low-price of hide and skins.


Editorial »

Jugglery of growth figures failed to create jobs


BANGLADESH'S economic growth though mesmerising, it has been proved over the past decade that jobs could not be created proportionately for the youths keeping adjustment with the growth. Besides, female participation in the labour force shrank in the last nine years, especially in rural areas. As a result employment elasticity, ...

Cricket »

Mashrafe seeks two months to ponder about his retirement


The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) has shelved the idea of arranging a one-off ODI against Zimbabwe to give Mashrafe Bin Mortaza a grand farewell after the ODI captain asked the board to give him two months to think about his future.The decision to cancel the plan came after BCB president ...

Football »

Guardiola backs Sterling to reach 30-goal mark


AFP, Manchester :Pep Guardiola wants to see the on-form Raheem Sterling break the 30-goal barrier for the first time in his career this season, but will only judge the England forward on his overall contribution to the Manchester City team.Sterling has started the new campaign in prolific form, scoring in ...

City »

Bangabandu Sangskritik Jote paid tributes to Poet Shamsur Rahman by placing floral wreaths at his grave in the city's Banani on Saturday marking the 13th death anniversary of the poet.


International »

Hundreds defy restrictions, join protests in Kashmir


AP, New Delhi :Hundreds of people protested an unprecedented security crackdown and clashed with police Friday in Indian-controlled Kashmir, as India's government said it was constantly reviewing the situation in the disputed region and the restrictions there will be removed over the next few days.The U.N. Security Council met on ...

International »

Discussions on Afghan peace deal go ‘very well’, says Trump's spokesman


The White House says President Donald Trump's talks with his national security advisers to discuss Afghan peace talks went "very well" and that negotiations with the Taliban "are proceeding."Officials on August 16 said Trump was meeting with his top advisers to review negotiations with the extremist group about a possible ...

Entertainment »

Kona finally admits her secret marriage


Entertainment Desk :Popular singer Dilshad Nahar Kona revealed  on Thursday  that she had tied the knot with the person she loved, on April 21 of this year. Her husband, Golam Md Iftekhar, is a businessman, and has been in a relationship with Kona for seven years.Kona was heard saying to ...

Editorial »

Clashes among groups of govt followers on national mourning day


NEWSPAPERS reported that at least 22 people, including former Awami League lawmaker of Nilphamari-3 and upazila unit AL vice-president Golam Mustafa, were injured in a clash between two rival groups of the party in Jaldhaka of Nilphamari on Thursday. The clash took place when the groups hosted separate programmes to ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news