Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Wednesday, January 24, 2018 09:15:48 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

NGOs not free from conflicts of interest

By
18th-May-2017       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Tamar Kogman :
Imagine the EU commissioning Volkswagen to lead the implementation of its emission policy, while also paying it to help introduce future testing technologies and draft regulations accordingly. After all, the car manufacturer is an expert with on the ground experience.
The absurdity is glaring, not only because of the emission scandal involving Volkswagen. Such a selection by the EU would completely evade government responsibility for initiating appropriate checks and balances regarding invested parties. Governments must be able to prevent the regulated from dictating official regulations, and not turn a blind eye to bias and conflicts of interest.
As in the example above, it is unacceptable for government bodies to rely on the accounts of stakeholders or to act without independent reviews. The same holds true regarding major government funding for organisations to provide information and analysis on issues in which they have a vested interest.
While such conflicts are clearly unacceptable for businesses, unions, and other lobbies, they are a matter of course for non-governmental organisations (NGOs). European governments provide hundreds of millions of euros to NGOs, with little oversight. German CDU lawmaker Markus Pieper (EPP) recently took up this issue, commissioning a study on democratic accountability and budgetary control of EU-funded NGOs and subsequently drafting a report calling for stricter funding regulations.
Pieper's report was immediately met with vehement opposition, a recurring argument being that the report unjustifiably singles out NGOs. Belgian Green MEP Bart Staes argued that the report implies that NGOs are problematic. Valentina Caimi, a policy adviser for Social Platform, bristled at the notion that NGOs should be regarded as lobbyists since they are often funded for the provision of specific services.
These two points fail to acknowledge that many EU-funded NGOs do, in fact, carry out lobbying activities, and some are funded for the explicit purpose of lobbying the EU's own institutions - a dimension that is, in fact, very specific to NGOs. A clear example is Caimi's own Social Platform, an EU-funded NGO network with stated objectives of influencing EU policies and legislation.
Another example of this phenomenon is the European Peacebuilding Liaison Office (EPLO), a network of NGOs with the explicit objective of obtaining increases in EU grants for peacebuilding activities.
Not only is EPLO EU-funded, it has also established a Civil Society Dialogue Network, linking members of civil society with EU policymakers. The Network is co-financed by the European Union (Instrument for Stability) and EPLO, and managed by EPLO in co-operation with the European Commission (EC) and the European External Action Service (EEAS).
EPLO member organisations include Oxfam International and Cordaid. Together, these two NGOs received €67 million in 2015 for the implementation of EU projects, according to the EU's Financial Transparency System.
In other words, an EU-funded network lobbies the EU for more money and preferred policies, and its members receive major amounts in a lucrative cycle.
Additional criticism of Pieper's report focuses on a paragraph that prevents funding to groups that spread falsehoods and with objectives that run contrary to EU values of democracy, human rights and the strategic objectives of European Union institutions. As argued by Caimi, imposing such limitations on funding to NGOs is inconsistent with an article of the EU Treaty, which explains that institutions are required to give citizens the opportunity to exchange opinions and perspectives on areas concerning the EU.
According to Caimi's reasoning, giving EU citizens and groups the opportunity to express themselves is equivalent to funding them. If that is the case, the EU is institutionally discriminating against all persons and groups not currently receiving EU funds.
Interestingly, those who condemn Pieper's report do not take issue with the EU's code of conduct for lobbying, which requires of stakeholders to do their best to ensure that the information they provide is not biased or incomplete. An EP library briefing notes that breaching this code can result in sanctions.
The dissonance, perhaps, is because NGOs are not considered parties that are liable to conflicts of interest, and therefore the EU's code of conduct does not apply to them. As argued by MEP Staes, 95% of NGOs work for the common good and are not involved in lobbying. According to such logic, NGOs are unequivocally good for everyone, and there is no reason to scrutinise their claims or hold them accountable - even when they are entrusted with taxpayer money. Unfortunately, this is not the case as many NGOs abuse this optimistic misconception and use it for their own self-interested financial and political gain.
In fact, NGOs are currently given astounding leeway in comparison to other interest groups, all while being funded excessively without appropriate accountability. Addressing this anomaly does not single out NGOs. But systematically ignoring it does.
If the EU wants to support a thriving, diverse, and actively participant civil society, it should keep its engagement with powerful interest groups in check - and NGOs must not be an exception.

(Tamar Kogman is an associate researcher at NGO Monitor).

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

EC must upgrade database urgently


THE database of Election Commission (EC) containing elaborate information of about 10.5 crore voters may crash at any time  as they have not upgraded the hardware and software, including the automated fingerprint identification system, in due time. Besides, storage capacity of Oracle Exadata system has also expired which has increased ...

International »

Abbas seeks EU recognition to State of Palestine


AFP, Brussels :Palestinian leader Mahmud Abbas on Monday urged the EU to "swiftly" grant official recognition to the state of Palestine as he sought support in Brussels amid a bitter row with Washington over the US plan to move its embassy to Jerusalem.Abbas told EU diplomatic chief Federica Mogherini that ...

Business & Economy »

L'Oreal hijab model pulls out of campaign after backlash over tweets


Evening Standard :A beauty blogger who was the first ever hijab-wearing model to front a mainstream haircare ad has pulled out of a campaign with L'Oreal after a backlash over tweets she wrote in 2014. Amena Khan wrote on Instagram that she had decided to step down from the campaign ...

Cricket »

Tamim joins 6000 runs ODI club


Southpaw opener Tamim Iqbal reached another milestone as he joined 6000 runs ODI Club during the 5th ODI of the triangular series against Zimbabwe at Sher-e-Bangla National Cricket Stadium art Mirpur on Tuesday.The dashing opener Tamim, who hit his third consecutive fifties in this series so far, needed 66 runs ...

Sports »

Denmark's Caroline Wozniacki hits a forehand return to Spain's Carla Suarez Navarro during their quarterfinal at the Australian Open tennis championships in Melbourne, Australia on Tuesday.


Entertainment »

Fahmee to debut in big screen


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Though she has been acting in small screen for many days but Fahmida Sharmeen Fahmee had a dream to work in the big screen. At last, her dream comes into true. Finally she has been selected to cast in role of Farzana in Mizanur Rahman Labu’s movie ...

Entertainment »

SRK gets special honour at WEF


Bollywood superstar Shah Rukh Khan was at his wittiest best in Davos on Monday when he asked actress Cate Blanchett for a selfie publicly and immediately quipped that it may leave his children embarrassed, sending the audience into peals of laughter. Khan received the 24th Crystal Award on Monday at ...

City »

BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia appeared before the special court on Alia Madrasha premises in the city's Bakshibazar on Tuesday on two cases filed by Anti-Corruption Commission.


Editorial »

Banking sector is doomed, merger or no merger


FINANCE Minister AMA Muhith has recommended Bangladesh Bank to start merger of problem banks, but experts fear that such a move would not stop the rot the country's banking sector is facing. On December 28, Muhith wrote a letter to BB Governor Fazle Kabir pointing out that it was the ...

Sports »

Romania's Simona Halep celebrates after defeating Japan's Naomi Osaka during their fourth round match at the Australian Open tennis championships in Melbourne, Australia on Monday.


International »

Turkey in new assault on Kurdish militia on Syria


AFP  :Turkey on Monday shelled Kurdish militia targets in Syria and claimed progress in a cross-border offensive that has stoked concern among its allies and neighbours.The Turkish military on Saturday launched operation "Olive Branch", its second major incursion into Syrian territory during the seven-year civil war.The operation, where Turkish war ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Gayeshwar Chandra Roy, among others, at a protest rally organised by Akhtar Hossain Mukti Parishad at the Jatiya Press Club on Monday demanding release of all BNP leaders including Organizing Secretary of Dhaka Mahanagar Uttar Akhtar Hossain.


Entertainment »

Yami Gautam applauds India’s win at Blind Cricket World Cup 2018


Bollywood actress Yami Gautam took to Twitter to applaud the victory of India at the Blind Cricket World Cup 2018. India retained Blind Cricket World Cup title after beating Pakistan by two wickets in a thrilling final played at the Sharjah Cricket Stadium in UAE on Saturday. India had previously ...

Entertainment »

Razzak’s birthday today


Entertainment Report :If he would alive today he will turn into 77. He died on August 21 of 2017. His sudden demise made a gap in the field industry. He was basically a guardian in film arena. Today is birthday of legendary film actor Razzak. Younger son of Razzak, Khalid ...

Editorial »

Migrant workers` early death should worry our govt


A NATIONAL daily reported that at least 3,480 Bangladeshi workers died abroad in 2017, mostly due to stroke or heart attack. Unbearable physical and mental stress, workload, malnutrition, ill health care, thin sleep and rest time, and unhygienic living decrease the life expectancy of the Bangladeshi expatriates workers working in ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news