Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Wednesday, December 19, 2018 04:45:41 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Special issue on 38th anniversary of the New Nation

Finance Bill 2017 and challenges involved

Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

A F Nesaruddin, FCA
There is no denying the fact that budget 2017 is the largest one in terms of its size in the history of Bangladesh. A country like Bangladesh struggling for enlistment in the middle income country should also be aggressive in a manner the Finance Minister indicated in various forums during budget discussion. Finance Minister also expressed his great satisfaction claiming the budget 2017 as one of the best budget in his life as long serving Finance Minister. There are long and ongoing debates about success of this large budget considering the overall capacity of the National Board of Revenue apart from impact on business and individuals.
The size of the total budget this year is Tk 400,266 crores and head-wise allocations are as follows:  
 As we see the source-wise allocations of revenue and expenses, one must admit that there is little scope for reducing expenditures because except for annual development plans including ongoing projects, it mostly relates to salary, benefits and other committed expenses. But if we look at the revenue aspects, there is a big challenge to meet the targets. Income tax has been depended on increasing taxes from existing taxpayers, new tax net as identified is unlikely to contribute any major amount to meet the target. Income from value added tax is depended on successful implementation of new VAT Act. Recording systems and transparency in book keeping is prerequisite for successful implementation of VAT but in our country, there is huge lacking in this regard giving scope for corruption and evasion of VAT. Complex adjustment and refund systems are also impediments to encourage tax payer to respond properly. This year, income projected on foreign aid and loans appear to be unrealistic. Highest foreign aid received so far was around Tk 22,000 crores while the amount projected this year is Tk 46,420 crores. Ultimately, deficit has to be financed from bank loans impacting on reduction in the capacity of private sector investment and higher interest burden from the government exchequer. Alternatively, annual development plans have to be downsized appropriately to match expenditures with revenues.
As we can see the Finance Bill 2017, many of the tax proposals are positive and they deserve appreciation. Some of them are - a) Raising the taxable threshold of income for physically or mentally challenged tax payments; b) Imposition of 2.5% surcharge on the income earned from production of Cigarette, bidi and other tobacco products. Other than these, tax rates for companies and individuals have been kept un-changed in general; c) The area of tax exemption for IT Enabled Service (ITES) has been expanded to include 8 new types of ITES; d) Tax rate for export Oriented readymade garments has been reduced from 20% to 15%. Moreover, the RMG Company which will earn internationally recognized "Green Building Certification" will pay tax at the rate of 14%; e) Any cash or other benefit received with national prize or awards or any allowance received from Bangladesh Muktijoddha Kalyan Trust are exempted total income; f) Income earned from running an "Elderly care home" is to be tax exempt; g) In the field of assessment section 82BB of the Income Tax Ordinance (relating to Universal Self Assessment) has been revised to provide, among other things, that an "amended return" may be submitted during the processing stage of a self assessment return. This will be a welcome measure for many tax payers; h) The bill introduces a provision to disallow salary expense of the employer if the salary is paid after Tax Day to an employee who is required to file tax return but has failed to do so within the specified time; i) Any loan or gift exceeding Tk. 500,000 taken by an individual, otherwise than through banking system is treated as taxable income for the recipient u/s-19(28) of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984. This year's budget proposes to make the provision that loans or gifts received from spouse or parents will not come within the purview of this law; j) Where imported goods on which tax has been deducted at import stage are supplied, tax deductible at supply stage will be the total amount of deductible on the value of supplies minus tax deducted at import stage; k) The value of gross wealth for compulsory submission of wealth statements by individual tax payers has been increased from Taka 20lac to 25 lac in section 80 of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984.
Further, in the administrative side also there are some positive proposals in the budget such as - i) Establishment of central withholding Tax Unit and introduction of electronic tax withholding system; ii) Establishment of two new tax zones in Jessore and Kustia; iii) Establishment of 103 new tax circle at upazilla level.
In addition, scope of tax net has been increased and in some cases, reemphasized for mandatory filing of tax returns and also mandatory furnishing of eTIN in certain category of people obtaining specific services.
These measures are expected to expand the tax base and improve tax collection. However, it must also be mentioned that this year's tax proposals in the budget have also given us genuine reason for frustration and disappointment. We shall now discuss some of those points and these are - a) For individual tax payers (general category) taxable threshold of income has been kept unchanged at Taka 250,000 for the 3rd year in a row. Even if we only consider the annual inflation rate (5% to 7% by conservative estimates) this amount should have been increased reasonably; b) In case of companies the existing tax rate (general) of 35% is considered pretty high compared to other countries of the region. There were demands from various quarters to reduce this rate. But this was kept unchanged; c) Two important section of the Income Tax Ordinance 1984 namely section 82BB relating to Universal Self Assessment Scheme and section 93 relating to reopening of cases have been totally replaced. But apparently they have been made more complicated and not at all tax-payers friendly. Further, there is no indication of transparency or accountability; d) There is no measure to curb the discretionary powers of tax assessing officials. These officials arbitrarily disregard audited accounts, make huge addition to tax payer's income and create a heavy tax burden. Tax payers do not get proper redress in many cases against these arbitrary assessments even in appeal or Taxes Appellate Tribunal. Thus they face a helpless situation and being harassed unjustifiably; e) Selection of self assessment returns for audit is still not done in any neutral or objective basis. It is done on personal choice of tax officials depending on their personal likes and dislikes or some other personal motive. No step has been taken in this year in this regard to improve the situation; f) It has been a long standing demand of tax professionals and others that there should be a judicial member in each bench of the Taxes Appellate Tribunal. Because, all members of the Tribunal are now Tax Commissioners on deputation and consequently the Tribunal has lost its neutrality and impartiality in a general sense; g) Certain emerging and employment generating industries like tourist industries are still kept out of tax holiday or reduced tax rates in the current tax laws; h) Tax rate for non-listed companies has been reduced nominally from 37.50% to 35%. But the corporate tax structure as a whole has been kept unchanged. Our corporate tax rate is quite high compared to other countries of the region. There has been continued request and appeal from concerned quarters to reduce and rationalize our corporate tax structure. Further, arbitrary and unjustifiable disallowances and additions to taxable income also lead to increase the effective rate of taxes. Mere increasing rate may apparently seems higher tax revenue but in reality, this encourages to have tendency for tax evasion. This issue need to be addressed for reasons which need no elaboration; k) Section 82C was introduced to simplify tax assessment procedures considering collected tax as final settlement. But in recent amendments, additional tax are also being collected over the tax collected under 82C. The charging additional tax under this provision is against the basic principle of "Final Settlement" and self-contradictory; l) Certain emerging and employment generating industries like tourist industries are still kept out of tax holiday or reduced tax rates in the current tax laws; m) Similarly, no fiscal incentives offered to potential investors in food and agriculture preserving installations like sophisticated and modern cold storage for ensuring fair price to agriculture producers and reducing price gap between producers and consumers levels; n) No provision appears with respect to investment by 'provident fund', 'gratuity fund' and 'pension fund'. In Bangladesh, no pension benefits are sponsored by the state and in such a situation, an incentive for investments by such funds was absolutely essential apart from avenues of investments (allowing tax-free easier investment in Sanchaypatra and similar other instruments).
Two critical points have been noticed this year and these are - a) imposition of excise duty @Tk 500 on bank deposits over Tk 100,000 and b) disallowances of salary payments made after Tax Day in case an employee defaults in filing tax returns within the Tax Day or extended time granted by the revenue authorities. In the first case, general people will be affected and there is no reason for imposing such levy when it is uncertain whether the bank depositor is an assesse falling minimum taxable threshold. On the other hand, in the second case, it will definitely increase cost of business. At present, Employer's obligation is to withhold tax from salary and no obligation about filing or monitoring of tax return by the employees. Monitoring of filing of tax returns is the responsibilities of the tax department. If the proposed amendment is enacted, employer will have to monitor filing of tax returns by employees. If any employee fails to file return on tax day or within extended period, any payment made thereafter for his/her salary will be inadmissible expenses in the hands of employer. In other words, payment of salary in such cases has to be suspended to avoid disallowance. No doubt, this is an illogical provision and very difficult to implement. For example, a RMG group having over 3,000 employees (having Tk 16,000 basic salary pm) will face severe problem to comply this regulations nor they can withhold salary which will antagonize the employees and create chaos in the business. Fundamentally, monitoring the filing of tax returns is the responsibility of NBR, not the employers. However, let us see, how business leaders reacts and what is finally approved in the Jatiyo Sangshad.
In fact, there are a numerous instances where NBR is shifting their responsibility to tax payers due to lack of their capability. No doubt, NBR needs capacity building otherwise implementation of any big budget is not only difficult but impossible.
Considering the people's expectation, reducing corruption and sufferings of the genuine tax payers, developing a good relationship between the tax payers and collectors (as opposed to existence of mistrust in many cases), lack of adequate manpower with required expertise in the tax department, weak tax administration structure in terms of close monitoring and application of fair judgment and many other related issues, it is pertinent to consider and review the issues discussed above for a realistic, pragmatic and achievable Finance Act 2017.
(A F Nesaruddin FCA is a practicing chartered accountant and a senior partner of Hoda Vasi Chowdhury & Co.)

Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Entertainment »

I always try to push negativity aside: Sunny Leone

Adult film star-turned-Bollywood actor Sunny Leone, who is often a target of sexist and disparaging remarks by people, says she is disturbed when "nonsense" gets highlighted."I always try to push negativity aside, but there are some things which I can't because I am also a human and I have feelings."I ...

Cricket »

Australia wins 2nd Test vs India by 146 runs, series 1-1

AP, Australia :Australia trounced India by 146 runs in the second Test to level the four-Test series 1-1 on the final day on Tuesday.Needing 287 runs to win, India resumed the day on 112-5 and was all out in a hurry for 140 in the second innings, and Australia was ...

Sports »

WTA changes rules affecting players returning from pregnancy

AP, St. Petersburg :The women's tennis tour approved rule changes Monday that are meant to ensure players are not penalized after they return from pregnancy or an injury that causes a long absence.The changes were prompted, in part, by the experiences of former No. 1 players Serena Williams and Victoria ...

Editorial »

The administration must prove its ability to hold free and fair polls

NEW United States ambassador in Dhaka Robert Earl Miller said that his country expected the upcoming December 30 elections in Bangladesh to be free, fair and credible as he paid a courtesy call on Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. The US Ambassador informed the PM that his country would send 32 ...

Business & Economy »

Parveen Haque Sikder, EC Chairperson of National Bank Limited, inaugurating its 201st branch at Hili Land Port on Tuesday. Ali Haider Mortuza, Vice-President, other officials of the Bank, local businessmen and elites were also present.

International »

Former FBI chief lashes out at Trump, Republicans for telling `lies`

CNN, Washington :Washington (CNN)Former FBI Director James Comey slammed Republicans on Monday for not speaking out against President Donald Trump's attacks on the FBI and strongly defended the agency's conduct, following his second round of questioning at a closed-door congressional interview."Somebody has to stand up and speak for the FBI," ...

Chittagong »

A discussion meeting was held at Chattogram University of Engineering and Technology (CUET) marking the Victory Day on Sunday. Prof Dr Md Rafiqual Alam, VC of the University was present as Chief Guest.

City »

Vice-Chancellor of Dhaka University Prof Dr Akhtaruzzaman poses for photo session with the recipients of Provost Awards of Bijoy Ekattor Hall of DU in its auditorium on Tuesday.

Entertainment »

Ankhi Alamgir enthrals Kolkata audience

Entertainment Report :   In the beginning of current year popular singer Ankhi Alamgir performed in Utsab at Jodhpur Park in Kolkata. In the meantime, she also went to Kolkata for several times. On December 14, she got the opportunity to perform as a leading singer of Bangladesh at outdoor pool ...

Business & Economy »

Choudhury Atiur Rasul, Chief Financial Officer of Agricultural Marketing Company Limited (AMCL), a sister concern of PRAN Group, receiving the 'ICMAB Best Corporate Award-2017' in the Miscellaneous Manufacturing Category from Finance Minister Abul Maal Abdul Muhith, at a programme held at a hotel in the city on Saturday. Dr. M Khairul Hossain, Chairman of Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission and Suvod Kumar Karn, President of South Asian Federation of Accountants were also present.


Cricket »

Shakib Al Hasan plays a shot during the first Twenty20 International match between Bangladesh and West Indies at Sylhet International Cricket Stadium on Monday. Shakib scored 61 runs.

Cricket »

Fizz moves to top five in ODI rankings

Mustafizur Rahman has made a big leap to enter into the top five ranks of ICC ODI bowling rankings. Other Bangladeshi players have also made progress in the rankings after the end of Bangladesh-Windies ODIs.The Fizz moved five places to no.5 in the rankings. He has career-best 695 points against ...

Editorial »

Dhaka must involve ASEAN nations for early Rohingya repatriation

MALAYSIAN Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad on Sunday asked the ASEAN nations to take tough measures for creating pressure on Myanmar and its de facto leader Aung San Suu Kyi to end atrocities against the Rohingya Muslims. More than 720,000 Rohingyas have fled Myanmar's strife-torn Rakhine State to Bangladesh since August ...

International »

Indian troops enforce lockdown to foil Kashmir public march

AP, Srinagar :Soldiers and police fanned out across Indian-controlled Kashmir on Monday to enforce a security lockdown for a second straight day to stop anti-India protests and foil a call by separatists for a march toward India's main military garrison in the disputed region.Government forces patrolled streets in the region's ...

Cricket »

Sri Lanka 275-9 at stumps on day 1, 1st Test vs New Zealand

AP, New Zealand :Tim Southee took 5-67 as New Zealand exploited an influential toss to contain Sri Lanka to 275-9 Saturday on the first day of the first cricket Test at the Basin Reserve.A late unbeaten half century by wicketkeeper Niroshan Dickwella helped swing the day a little in Sri ...

Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Write a comment to this news