Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, April 25, 2019 02:47:46 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Not to be above law must mean not to suffer abuse of law

photo by

By MAINUL HOSEIN
10th-Jul-2017       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

When two former Chief Justices namely Mr Justice A.B.M. Khairul Haque and Mr Justice Md. Tafazzul Islam have reminded us that nobody including a judge is above law with reference to a circular said to have been issued by the Registrar's Office of the Supreme Court to the effect that no corruption case against a sitting judge should be initiated without consultation with the Supreme Court, the matter raises some questions for clarification.

We can readily agree when there is the rule of law, the principle that nobody is above law is non-violable. But where abuse of law is the order of the day and submissiveness exists as a bad addiction among many we have to think twice.

The problem is not the law and its proper use but the abuse of law and its unjust use. We need to be sure that we have a system where abuse of law is not a prerogative of the power that be to have the confidence that the law is not abused to victimise anybody with an ulterior motive.

The judiciary is the institution that is vested with the power of protecting the constitutional supremacy and determine what is law and what is not. But the judiciary is under threat to make the will of the government the law. Law has to be the wish of the people. 

Mr Justice A.B.M. Khairul Haque is presently the Chairman of the Law Commission. His opinion deserves special consideration for the very reason that for him to protect the independence of the judiciary must be one of his very important areas of concern to make the Law Commission worth having.

Any fair application of law depends on how strong and independent is the judiciary. The independence of the judiciary means the judges should be able to act without fear.

In countries where the judiciary is independent, the judges enjoy absolute immunity for civil liability even if their judgements cause losses to others unless malice can be defected. So some form of consultation with the Supreme Court is necessary for the court to know why a judge cannot be sued for damages. Such consultation should be seen as proper and rightly warranted.

The next but the most important question is the question of public trust in the judiciary. Freedom for a judge is not a loose cannon. But he must be allowed, in public interest, to do justice without fear or favour. If the judges have to worry about abuse of power and false court case against them the independence of the judiciary will be denied the other way.

To find a sitting judge facing corruption cases is a serious matter as it affects public trust in the honesty of the judicial process. So it is a  legitimate concern of the Supreme Court to ascertain if the allegations justify corruption cases or not. This is not to say a judge is above law.

We are, somehow, proving to be a thoughtless nation most eager to serve self-interest. Thinking constructively for the greater interest of the country is a lonely and risky exercise for the few.

If criminal proceedings can be freely initiated against a sitting judge without the safety of consulting the Supreme Court first it is quite possible that the judiciary will be non-functional. There will be free abuse of law against the judges.

The Anti-Corruption Commission should be a very responsible body not to start corruption cases without weighing the damage done to the persons in terms of honour and social standing. Let them secretly convince themselves about the existence of a serious corruption case before publicly humiliating one.

The fact is after filing an FIR and making known about the corruption case, the authority takes few years to complete the investigation. Thereafter, there is no certainty when the case will be heard.  When the trial begins, nobody can say where it will be finished. So the public humiliation and personal sufferings go on. Our aim should be to build an honourable society.

In our view corruption is best fought by not dishonouring anybody unnecessarily. They (ACC) should not be interested in filing hundreds of corruption cases. The best way to fight corruption is to begin at the top. Corruption of the powerful ones must be dealt with bravely to put fear in the minds of others. Nobody is above law should mean no powerful man is above law. When corruption is not an easy game of the powerful ones, others will not be easily tempted.

In our country the tendency is to pass laws giving the authority arbitrary powers. Under the dominance of bureaucracy, the rights and liberty of the citizens are no consideration. The Anti-Corruption Law gives the authority the power of arresting for investigation before filing an FIR. The question is if fundamental rights have any value?

The Anti-Corruption Commission enjoys jurisdiction over wide number of offences. To deal with offences other bodies such as Board of Revenue, Income-tax authority or Customs people and RAJUK have become redundant. Any and every illegality should not be treated as corruption. But that is what is possible under the Anti-Corruption Law.

Our laws are passed so whimsically that for a person to be law abiding is almost impossible. Our laws are good for lawlessness. 

Arrogance of power is such among some that they do not care to know that we belong to a free country and our liberty is guaranteed as a fundamental right. Some authorities behave and act as if we are living in a police state.

The requirement of a sitting judge to be free from fear of Anti-Corruption Commission is essential. But that does not mean the criminal cases will not lie against a sitting judge; only need is to consult the Supreme Court.

Once investigation into an allegation of corruption is initiated the Chief Justice has no option but to withdraw the judge from hearing cases. The need of the Supreme Court to be satisfied about the justification of a criminal case against any of its judges must be seen as imperative for the protection of independence of the judiciary.

One simple sentence that nobody is above law is not so simple. The consultation with the Supreme Court can be seen as some immunity for the judges but it is not impunity against the law.

If we are aware of the situation in our country then it should not be unknown to anybody that the main problem in our country is how to protect oneself from the abuse of law and live with one's dignity.

Our selfless educated ones must be bold and active to show the world that we are capable of protecting justice and fair play for all like any other free country. We know a person does not become a criminal as soon as an FIR is filed. His fundamental rights must mean protection of his liberty till he is found guilty by a court of law.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

GDP data demanded by CPD won't be coming


Independent think-tank Center for Policy Dialogue (CPD) said when a government comes to power; it takes new initiatives in line with its electoral pledges. Yet nothing mentionable could be seen after the current government took office. It said an entrenched vested group is framing policies, taking the government in its ...

Football »

Long breaks fastest goal record as Gray snatches late point for Watford


Southampton striker Shane Long scored the fastest goal in Premier League history on Tuesday after netting just 7.69 seconds into his side's 1-1 draw at Watford, who snatched a point thanks to Andre Gray's late equaliser.Long's record-breaking goal came immediately after the kick-off when he blocked a clearance from Watford ...

International »

Pro-EU party launches election campaign as UK MPs return from break


A new anti-Brexit political party launched its campaign Tuesday for next month's European Parliament elections as British lawmakers returned from their Easter break with rumours of fresh bids to topple Prime Minister Theresa May.Change UK, formed by breakaway MPs from Britain's two main parties disgruntled at their stances on Brexit, ...

International »

Fake German heiress on trial in US for duping people of $275,000


AFP, New York :A jury in New York on Tuesday began deliberating the fate of a German-Russian woman charged with 10 counts of fraud and theft of $275,000 during the time she spent passing herself off as an heiress. Anna Sorokin, 28, is accused of inventing a new identity upon ...

Business & Economy »

Zarish Couture, an exclusive fashion house was inaugurated at house: 103, road: 13/A, block-C, Bananni in the city on Saturday. Farzana Rahman, Managing Director of the fashion house and Actor Siam Ahmed were also present.


Entertainment »

Sri Reddy writes an open letter to Chief Minister


Actress Sri Reddy who became a sensation for raising her voice against casting couch in Tollywood is back to making the headlines.  Sri Reddy, on Friday, wrote an open letter to K Chandrasekhar Rao, Chief Minister of Telangana and requested him to personally investigate about the sexual harassment that is ...

Entertainment »

Twitter user calls Priya Anand ‘bad luck’ for co-stars, actress hits back


Actress Priya Anand, who is popular for her roles in Telugu films 180, Ko Antey Koti and Leader, was trolled and called ‘bad luck’ for actors. Tamil actor JK Rithesh, who was recently seen in LKG, has passed away recently due to severe chest pain. Last year, actress Sridevi passed ...

National »

SIRAJDIKHAN (Munshiganj): Health Department, Sirajdikhan Upazila brought out a rally marking the National Nutrition Week yesterday .


International »

Probe shows Sri Lanka attacks 'retaliation for Christchurch': Govt


AFP :Islamist suicide bombings that killed more than 300 people in Sri Lanka at the weekend were carried out in revenge for last month's attacks on two mosques in New Zealand, the government said Tuesday, citing an initial police probe.The revelation came as the death toll in the Easter Sunday ...

Editorial »

Deadly gas pipe line blasts: Who will take responsibility?


THE gas line explosion that killed two garment workers and injured six others in a residential block in Narayanganj on early Monday is not an isolated incident, rather an explicit exposure of the danger of derelict, faulty and illegal gas connections and substandard gas burner uses. We observe that incidents ...

City »

Economist Debapriya Bhattachariya speaking at a media briefing on 'First One Hundred-Day of the Present Government: Independent Review of Bangladesh's Development' organised by CPD in CIRDAP Auditorium in the city on Tuesday.


Sports »

Houston Rockets guard Eric Gordon (10) defends against Utah Jazz guard Donovan Mitchell (center left) in the first half during Game 4 of a first-round NBA basketball playoff series in Salt Lake City on Monday.


Football »

Ronaldo '1,000 percent' with Juventus


Cristiano Ronaldo said on Saturday he is "1,000 percent committed" to staying with Juventus next season after claiming his first Serie A title.Massimiliano Allegri's side needed just one point to nail down its eighth straight league championship, which helped ease some of the pain of its shock Champions League exit ...

International »

Top Democrats leave open option of Trump impeachment after Mueller report


Reuters, Washington :Top congressional Democrats left the door open on Sunday to the impeachment of US President Donald Trump, but said they would first need to complete their own investigations into whether he obstructed justice in Special Counsel Robert Mueller's Russia probe.Some party leaders have cautioned against impeachment just 18 ...

National »

PIROJPUR: Floating Watermelon Bazar at Swarupkathi Upazila has gained momentum as the district has achieved bumper production of the summer fruit. This snap was taken on Monday.


 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news