Saturday, July 21, 2018 08:20:34 AM
A. Mannan :
A sizeable quantum of heated exchange, though seems to be rational from each one's view point, has, of late, been generated, inter-alia, by the EC, various political parties on both side of the divide, elite/civil society, NGO's, election watchdogs on the key issue to incorporate a system of casting 'No Vote' in the upcoming national election. There is as yet no hopeful end in sight.
Conflicting arguments are pouring in as it is raining cats and dogs in a heavy monsoon. Alas! I have not seen or smelt the basics of such claims and counter-claims for and against such move within a basketful of laws normally maintainable.
However, and there is always a 'however', a critical analysis is the utmost need before one says 'yes' or 'no' on a 'no-vote' system in the light of Constitutional provisions, RPO, historical background of voting system along with the method of counting and calculation of votes for the final outcome.
Amongst others, we have got to filter and pass through for a prismatic analysis the ingredients of a 'no-vote' system for and against before making a rational and judicious approach to it. Anything else hastily done or adopted may jeopardise the whole holy effort. Let us think twice before we leap, for there is a possibility to go down on the edge an abyss.
The key points for discussion, inter-alia, may be the following:
To recognize the voting pattern and behaviour of the past records and data.
To find out modus operandi of a methodology for calculation of vote-counting and declaration of results.
How to settle the score of a tie issue to declare the winner?
Should the counting and declaration be on a 'fast past the goal post' basis or to think about a proportionate representation system or another more appropriate and logical method?
The above mentioned issues at stake may open a flood gate for dialogue and discussion amongst many stake holders as follows:
Issue of declaring cancellation of registration of political party as per the present half-hearted RPO, as it seems to be so.
That of creating bottleneck for new registration.
That of a single party (alone or with its allied parties e.g. election of 2014), and getting more than 50% of the total seats uncontested.
Difficulties to be faced in ripping the harvest of no-vote system which is, at present, a meaningless no-vote type, Actual results of votes shown in the following chart speak of the in-depth dynamics and inertia of the whole gamut.
The existing system in different segments as narrated above need be dovetailed for a harmonious solution. We all know where problem is one, its solutions are too many. The undermentioned problems and suggested solutions are of my own schools of thought, though others may have different schools of thought. They can, however, prompt and promote their ideas in order that the issue as a whole is enriched.
Our existing problems and solutions therefor may be looked for as follows:
Election system in our case is 'first past the goal post', traditionally the oldest system. Proportionate representation like that of the New Zealand type may be worthwhile to think of.
Presently, where there is a tie in the result as per the existing system it is then decided by a lottery. In football games tiebreaker has replaced the age-old lottery system. In election the lottery system may be abolished. Instead fresh election amongst only the tie holders may be held or a better alternative based on new ideas conscientiously, consciously and logically may be adopted.
In an election to a constituency where only one party participates due to a boycott by other political parties and absence of any independent candidates, the election in that constituency be held when it becomes a participatory one.
Similarly, at the evaluation stage on the validity of nomination papers when only one nomination paper remains valid, action as in (iii) above be pursued.
The actual results mentioned in the chart at (e) above have wide variations and divergence. It is, as a matter of fact, difficult and impossible to draw a statistical line of best fit even based on interpolation for a meaningful conclusion. In a sum up we may say that a proportionate representation system is likely to bring in a more competitive result in order to fulfil the aspirations of the people.
Similarly, 'no-vote' system may be fruitful provided that a fresh election is held when 'no-vote' percentage is the higher than that of the highest candidate in the election results and wins the race like that of the 'fast past the goal post'. In such a situation a fresh election is obviously needed beyond doubt. Just keeping a provision of more than 50% of the votes cast and valid for a 'no-vote' to invalidate the election results and mandate a fresh election may not be quid pro quo and will bring about no good.
Should a candidate get the highest vote he wins the race, likewise 'no-vote' should also have the privilege as that of a candidate, the difference being elected in case of a candidate and achieving authority in case of 'no-vote' to invalidate the election results for a fresh election.
(Abdul Mannan, Fcma (UK) is a former State Minister, Ministry of Civil Aviation & Tourism and Textiles. former Member of Parliament (Dhaka-2) and former President, South Asian Federation of Accountants (SAFA). E-mail : email@example.com)
ROHINGYA refugees reaching Bangladesh said violence, including torture, persists against them in Myanmar and the overall environment remains "menacing" for ethnic and religious minorities. UN human rights investigators carried out the Rohingya's plight after a five-day visit to the refugee camp of Kutupalong in Cox's Bazar where they interviewed new ...
AFP, Los Angeles :Juan Mata grabbed the 78th minute equalizer as Manchester United opened their pre-season with a 1-1 draw against Club America on Thursday in Phoenix, Arizona.A header from Henry Martin in the 59th minute - past substitute goalkeeper Joel Pereira - had put Mexican outfit America in the ...
Sheikh Arif Bulbon :There was a family relationship between Kolkata’s popular film actress Rituparna Sengupta and Bangladeshi popular late hero Manna and his wife Shelly Manna. As a result, when Rituparna came to Bangladesh she always met Shelly Manna at her residence. Manna’s production house Kritanjali Chalachchitra is going to ...
AP, New Delhi :Congress party leader Rahul Gandhi accused the government of failing to live up to its promises as the Indian Parliament on Friday debated a no-confidence motion moved by the opposition against Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government.Gandhi, the scion of the Nehru-Gandhi political dynasty, accused the government of ...
BBC Online :US opposition politicians are calling for Donald Trump's interpreter to testify before Congress about his summit talks with Vladimir Putin.The lead Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Robert Menendez, called for Marina Gross to be subpoenaed to appear at the committee.Controversy has raged over the summit, with ...
THE government has been referring to a Supreme Court "order" on the reservation of 30 percent quota for the children of freedom fighters for the last few days, arguing that it cannot be changed. But the fact is that it was an observation of the court and the government has ...
Entertainment Report :Internationally renowned singer Runa Laila is going to receive Personality Award today. She will receive the award at 6:00pm at Hotel Sonargaon. Since 1996 Shako Telefilm has been awarding different cultural personalities for their contributions. As a part of its continuation, Runa Laila will receive the award. Nazmul ...
Bangladesh Bank on Tuesday refuted the allegation that one of the gold bars kept in its highly secured vault by the customs department was adulterated. Following a report published by a vernacular daily that quoted Customs Intelligence Investigation Department report, the central bank comes up with the observation that "the ...
AFP, Johannesburg :Former US president Barack Obama on Tuesday singled out the African heritage of many players in France's World Cup-winning football team in a speech paying tribute to Nelson Mandela.Speaking in Johannesburg to mark 100 years since Mandela's birth, Obama said that embracing diversity "delivers practical benefits since it ...