Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, June 18, 2018 05:35:43 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Debate over MNC workers' posting within EU

By
08th-Sep-2017       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Frederic De Wispelaere and Jozef Pacolet.
What is posting? :
An employee may be sent to another EU country by his employer to work there for a certain period of time. This is called intra-EU posting. Also self-employed persons can post themselves. The posted person remains subject to the social security system of the country of origin for a period of up to 24 months. This principle is established in EU legislation on social security coordination. In addition, a 'hard core' of terms and conditions of employment, including minimum wages, set out in the host country should be respected. These provisions are defined in the Posting of Workers Directive. It is worth noting that posted self-employed persons are not covered by the Directive.
Intra-EU posting currently represents 0.4% of the total employment in the EU. Nevertheless, in some host countries and sectors of activity the impact of intra-EU posting is far greater. For instance, the number of posted workers makes up 30% of total employment in the Belgian construction sector. In France, where posted workers account for approximately 1% of total employment, the relative impact is significantly lower. This makes the prominent role of France in the current debate on intra-EU posting all the more striking.
In the current public and political debate, posting is, unfortunately, too often linked to social dumping, social fraud and the displacement of domestic jobs.
This prevailing negative perception makes that there is an urgent call for change, especially coming from countries that are confronted with high numbers of posted workers. In this regard, the European Commission's proposal to review the Posting of Workers Directive addresses a number of relating concerns.
The proposal to revise the Directive was launched in March 2016, under the slogan 'equal pay for equal work in the same place'. But no political agreement on the issue has been reached yet.
This being said, an approach that focuses exclusively on reviewing the Posting of Workers Directive is simply too narrow. The recent launch of two other proposals to review European legislation on the matter adds to this opinion. They also have a direct impact on intra-EU posting. Therefore, they can't be overlooked in the coming debates.
Firstly, at the end of 2016, a review of the EU legislation on social security coordination was launched (in which the existing main principle that social security contributions are paid in the country of origin remained unchanged). Secondly, specifically for the transport sector, another proposal was made in May 2017 to change a number of European provisions that also have important implications.
In addition to these proposals, countries were required to incorporate provisions that safeguard compliance with the Posting of Workers Directive in their national legislation by mid-2016 at the latest. These provisions were established in the Enforcement Directive. However, it is too soon to make a statement about the latter's impact.
The need for a broader approach and debate
The aforementioned European Commission initiatives are clearly linked and should therefore be viewed as a whole. In order to perform an effective assessment of the potential impact of these initiatives on the future development of posting, it is recommended that the debate takes place within a broader framework that pays attention to all the related aspects.
The existing applicable European legislation has put labour costs and working conditions under pressure. Therefore, on the one hand, changes to the Posting of Workers Directive and the EU legislation on social security coordination could reduce the risk of social dumping. On the other hand, other relevant objectives must also be taken into account. Think about promoting mobility within the European Union and economic integration, as well as avoiding additional administrative burdens.
With this in mind, it seems to concern a balanced political package of proposals launched by the European Commission. In any event, the grievances of 'receiving' member states (via the proposal to change the Posting of Workers Directive) and those of the 'sending' member states (by not changing the main principles in the EU legislation on social security coordination) are partially taken into account. This serves to illustrate the value of maintaining a view of the bigger picture during the current political debate.
… as well as the socio-economic impact of intra-EU posting
At the same time, in spite of a sharp focus on the negative consequences of intra-EU posting, a more nuanced debate on the impact of the practice is more than welcome. The benefits of intra-EU posting from the perspective of the 'sending' country (such as tempering the negative effects when countries are confronted by an economic crisis) as well as that of the 'receiving country' (in response to labour shortages) are hardly ever cited.
The French proposal as a good example of a broader debate
Currently, these proposals are not discussed simultaneously at the political level. Or are they? The proposal made by France, presented at the EPSCO council in June, appears to signal change in this area. France's proposal to limit posting to 12 months not only involves the Posting of Workers Directive, but also the EU legislation on social security coordination. This also applies to a number of other topics in the proposal made by France. As a result the framework is made broader. This is an important step. The next step is having a more substantive discussion based on facts and figures. This is the only way to address the various countries' current conflicting positions.

(Frederic De Wispelaere is a senior research associate and Prof. Dr. Jozef Pacolet is head of the welfare state and housing research group at HIVA Research Institute for Work and Society KU Leuven).

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Eid Mubarak


EID UL FITR is an important religious event celebrated by Muslims worldwide that marks the end of Ramadan, the Islamic holy month of fasting (sawm). The Eid (Muslim religious festival) is the first and only day in the month of Shawal during which Muslims are not permitted to fast. The ...

Cricket »

History-making Afghanistan get baptism of fire in Test cricket


AFP, Bangalore :Afghanistan were handed a bruising introduction to Test cricket by India on Thursday as they capped their astonishing rise from war and refugee camps to joining the sport's elite.Afghan skipper Asghar Stanikzai called it a "very proud moment" as he strode onto the field at Bangalore's M. Chinnaswamy ...

Football »

Orlando City midfielder Josue Colman kicks the ball away from Montreal Impact defender Rod Fanni during the second half of an MLS soccer match on Wednesday in Montreal.


Football »

German Chancellor Angela Merkel (center) and the former German national soccer team player and integration commissioner of the German soccer association, Cacau (right) attend a women soccer training session at a soccer club in Berlin, Germany on Wednesday.


International »

World can `sleep well` after North Korea summit: Trump


A jubilant-sounding President Donald Trump declared Wednesday that his "deal" with Kim Jong Un has ended the North Korean nuclear threat, as his top diplomat said he hoped to see "major disarmament" of the country by 2020.Despite the lack of detail, or binding terms in the joint statement agreed with ...

International »

UN rights office calls for int’l probe in Kashmir


AP, Geneva :The U.N. human rights chief called Thursday for an independent, international investigation into reports of rights violations in the disputed region of Kashmir, laying blame for civilian deaths and injuries on the actions of both India and Pakistan.In its first report on the region, the office of Zeid ...

City »

Air Chief adorned with Air Marshal rank badge


A ceremony marking the adorning of rank badge of new Chief of Air Staff Air Marshal Masihuzzaman Serniabat was held at the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) on Thursday.In the presence of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, Chief of Army Staff General Abu Belal Mohammad Shafiul Huq and Chief of Naval Staff ...

Entertainment »

Sylvester Stallone under probe for sexual assault


Los Angeles prosecutors said on Wednesday that their sex crimes team was reviewing a case against Rocky actor Sylvester Stallone. Los Angeles District Attorney's office spokesman Greg Risling did not give details but said the case was presented by police in the California beach city of Santa Monica.Representatives for Stallone, ...

Editorial »

Pay the workers immediately, let them celebrate the Eid


NEWS media reported that nearly 40 percent of the garment factories, most of which are small and not members of any trade bodies like the BGMEA or the BKMEA, are yet to pay the workers' salaries or festival bonus although Eid-ul-Fitr is knocking at the door. Most of the 4.4 ...

International »

N Korean state media hails Kim-Trump summit success


Reuters, Seoul  :US President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un were splashed across North Korea's official party newspaper on Wednesday as state media hailed Tuesday's historic summit between the two men.The North's state media framed Tuesday's summit as a win for Pyongyang as it listed concessions made ...

Entertainment »

Secrets of Punam Priyam`s success


Entertainment Report :Punam Priyam is a popular media personality in Bangladesh. She is an anchor, producer and writer. In an interview with The New Nation, she has shared her life story and her views on different professional and personal issues. Details below:1. In our male dominated society men are still ...

Cricket »

Rahane says 'ruthless' India will not take Afghans lightly


AFP, Bangalore :Top-ranked India will be "ruthless" and not take Afghanistan lightly when they make their Test debut in Bangalore, skipper Ajinkya Rahane said Wednesday.It will be a historic moment for Asghar Stanikzai's team when they step out on Thursday for their maiden five-day outing against the world's number one ...

City »

Railway Minister Majibul Huq visited Kamalapur Railway Station in the city on Wednesday to witness the Eid journey of home-bound passengers.


Editorial »

Take urgent steps to prevent further landslides in hill region


AT least 11 people have been killed in separate incidents of landslides triggered by heavy rainfall in Rangamati and Cox's Bazar. Among the deceased, 10 were killed in Naniarchar upazila of Rangamati and one in Maheshkhali upazila of Cox's Bazar, as per a local daily report.In Naniarchar, landslides in Boro ...

Entertainment »

Chitrangda Singh wears the producer's hat!


Recently, 'Soorma' trailer starring Diljit Dosanjh and Taapsee Pannu in lead roles was released. While actress Chitrangda Singh who is been staying away from onscreen for a while has now overtaken the role of a producer for the movie, 'Soorma'. After Anushka Sharma and Priyanka Chopra trying their hands as ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news