Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Monday, December 18, 2017 06:37:24 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Unique verdict but how practical it is as an example is a big question

By Editorial Desk
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

The verdict of the High Court Bench comprising Justice Zinat Ara and Justice Kazi Md Ejarul Haque Akondo on Sunday asking the accused in a road accident to pay Tk 4.61 crore compensation to filmmaker Tareque Masud’s family is indeed a unique one. So far no court ruled this way asking the accused of road accidents to pay victims’ families. The credit goes to Masud's wife and her lawyers for working very hard for securing this judgement holding the driver and owner of the vehicle responsible.       The verdict is special in the sense it recognized the right of the victims to demand compensation.

But the verdict seems unrealistically high having admitted that no big amount of money can be enough as compensation for the loss of a very creative life like Tareque Masud’s in practical sense of the term. But we are not sure whether in similar cases of road accidents will it be possible for the court to give equal or equitable justice to all. Last year alone 6055 people died in road accidents according to some estimate and the casualties were yet bigger at 8,642 in the previous year.

We believe every such death deserves fair justice but they are denied justice by our justice system. Death in road accidents is treated as an act of destiny, not from neglect of drivers and transport operators. What is important this judgment for the first time has broken with the ongoing system of impunity to allow offenders go escort free. It has established killing on roads and highways would not go unpunished.

However in our view the verdict is not enough without an effective and functional system for implementation of the verdict. We also believe verdicts can’t be special in special cases; justice must be dispensed to all in equal situation and our legal system must set practical standard to give justice in all such cases.

Justice remains inaccessible to all victims of road accidents throughout the country. Law provides for a tribunal in every district to deal with compensation cases related to road accidents. But not every district has this tribunal and they are inoperative where they exist in absence of cooperation of police and lower judiciary.    

Masud and four others including noted TV programme producer Mishuk Munier, a crewman and the driver of their microbus were crashed in that bus accident at Manikgonj in August 2011. Mishuk’s family has also demanded Tk 5.5 crore in compensation in a separate case and the same High Court Bench is scheduled to give verdict in that case in February next.

In Masud’s case three owners of the bus are required to pay Tk 3.30 crore equally. The bus driver, who was sentenced to 30 years imprisonment early this year triggering nationwide transport strike for two days, has been asked to pay Tk 30 lakhs while the insurer to pay Tk 80 lakhs. The penalty money is likely to be almost double after the verdict in Munier’s case.

Money can’t be a substitute for life but a strong message has been delivered by their Lordships for bus drivers who have become infamous for callous driving.

In fact Transport Workers Unions and Bus Owners Associations are so powerful that they can force the government to compromise rule of law. We don’t know what happened to the bus driver who was given long imprisonment in the accident case.  Question also arises whether families of two others killed in the accident will get compensation and at what rate? It is not also clear whether their families have sued for the compensation.

Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Myanmar`s criminal generals should be brought to book

ACCORDING to the medical charity MSF sources, at least some 6,700 Rohingyas got killed in the very first month of the Myanmar army's crackdown on the ethnic minority in Rakhine State. But it appears Myanmar government is trying to deceive the world by  avoiding to take back Rohingya refugees. It ...

Football »

Roma's Federico Fazio (hidden) celebrates with teammates after scoring the decisive goal during an Italian Serie A soccer match between AS Roma and Cagliari, at the Olympic stadium in Rome on Saturday.

Entertainment »

Athiya Shetty turns fashion designer

Ever since her debut, the 25-year-old actress has been in news for her chic sartorial choices. A source reveals, “According to the label, Athiya is known for her fashion sensibilities. She is a hit when it comes to red carpet appearances and nails the high street fashion.” “So, after meetings ...

Entertainment »

Virat-Anushka holidaying in heaven

The power couple, Virat Kohli and Anushka Sharma, who recently set some major wedding goals with their Italian destination ceremony, is now giving fans a glimpse into their post-married life. The ethereal couple tied the knot at a picturesque location in Italy on December 11. The 29-year-old newlywed, who is ...

International »

Trump allies say Mueller unlawfully obtained thousands of emails

Reuters, Washington :An organization established for US President Donald Trump's transition to the White House a year ago said on Saturday that the special counsel investigating allegations of Russian meddling in the 2016 election had obtained tens of thousands of emails unlawfully.Kory Langhofer, counsel to the transition team known as ...

City »

Ganoforum President Dr Kamal Hossain speaking at a discussion on 'Independence: Expectation, Achievement and Role' organised by 'Jatiya Oikya Prokriya' at the Jatiya Press Club on Friday.


International »

Trump promises `giant tax cut` as `Christmas gift` to Americans

PTI, Washington :US President Donald Trump today said the Congress has reached an agreement on tax legislation that will deliver more jobs, higher wages, and "massive tax relief" for American families and domestic companies.Trump recognised the tax reform as a campaign promise during his run-up to the 2016 presidential election, ...

Editorial »

Muslim leaders must continue to act together not to be ignored

WE welcome the OIC's (Organisation of Islamic Cooperation) decision declaring East Jerusalem as capital of Palestine at a summit at Istanbul on Wednesday as the most appropriate and timely action to denounce US President Donald Trump's unilateral declaration that Jerusalem is the capital of the state of Israel. Their call ...

Football »

Players of A Level team, the champions of the Inter-Class Victory Day Football Competition of Manarat Dhaka International School & College with the teachers of Manarat Dhaka International School & College pose for a photo session at Manarat College field on Thursday.

Entertainment »

Meryl Streep is the most Golden Globe-nominated actor

Meryl Streep has begun her Hollywood award season dominance by bagging her 31st Golden Globe nomination, which is a record in the 75-year history of the award show. Streep won the nomination in the best actress, drama category for her portrayal of the Washington Post publisher Kay Graham in Steven ...

Entertainment »

Porimoni, Zayed Khan`s Antorjwala releases today

Entertainment Report :Today across the country in 175 cinema halls Malek Afsari directed and Porimoni-Zayed Khan acted much awaited movie Antorjwala is set to be released. On the occasion its releasing Pori and Zayed will enjoy the movie along with director Malek Afsari in Dhaka’s Modhumita, Shyamoli and Sony halls.While ...

City »

Speaker Dr Shirin Sharmin Chowdhury handing over ICT Award to Director General of Health Department Prof Dr Abul Kalam Azad for his contribution in using digital technology in health services at Bangabandhu International Conference Center in the city on Tuesday.

Weekend Plus »

Quick recipes for the burger-lover in you

Weekend Plus Desk :If you are a burger lover or want to fix a burger quickly for uninvited guests, here are a few recipes which can save the day. Recipes by Chef Gaurav Chadha, in-house chef, Dr Oetker India Pvt Ltd:* Chicken and egg burger: Heat oil in a kadhai ...

Editorial »

Attack on New York City is disgusting

AN attempted terrorist attack in a New York City bus terminal by a US national of Bangladesh origin has caused widespread surprise and condemnation here and also in the Bangladesh community in the USA. The person Akayed Ullah at his 27 is a taxi driver in New York City and ...

International »

US embassy unlikely to move to Jerusalem before 2020: Tillerson

Xinhua, Washington :U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said Tuesday the U.S. embassy in Israel was unlikely to be moved to Jerusalem before 2020, national media outlets reported."It's not going to be anything that happens right away," U.S. news daily the New York Times quoted Tillerson's speech at the State ...

Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Write a comment to this news