Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, February 15, 2018 11:04:10 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Quota versus merit: Deserving candidates being deprived

By
16th-Feb-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

THERE are thousands of others who hold the existing quota system responsible for not getting the job a meritorious candidate deserves. Currently, only 44 percent are recruited on merit and the remaining 56 percent on privilege allocated under various quotas.

The quota system draws two strong criticisms. Firstly, it is hugely disproportionate and secondly, it remains enforced for ages. And it has left the nation with two grave consequences -- competent candidates being driven to other jobs and bureaucracy being devoid of merit in the long run.

A number of former top bureaucrats termed the system bizarre and warned that the government would be run by the mediocrities in future. During a lecture session at Dhaka University on January 20, Akbar Ali Khan, an adviser to a caretaker government, termed the quota system the biggest problem in the cadre service. He mentioned that there were 257 types of quotas.

The quota system was introduced through an executive order in 1972 and was amended several times. From 1972 to 1976, 20 percent was recruited on the basis of merit. Merit-based recruitment was increased to 40 percent in 1976 which continued until 1985 when the percentage of merit-based recruitment was upped to 45 percent. But in 2012, one percent quota was introduced for the physically challenged, reducing merit-based recruitment to 44 percent.

The quota provision is, however, not unusual. Many countries in the world have introduced the provision to ensure representation of society's disadvantaged groups in the service of the republic. But the quotas are applied differently. In the US, those eligible for quotas are given a head start with some marks, and then they compete for the jobs with everyone else in competitive exams.

The Bangladesh Public Service Commission (PSC) had recommended simplifying quota system for recruiting officials to public service due to the existing complexities in applying quota. The application of the existing quota related rules is complicated and a matter of multidimensional restrictions. Sometimes, it becomes impossible to select suitable candidates accurately by applying the quota system, said the Commission in its Annual Report-2016.

We think, it becomes essential to reform our quota system. Thirty percent jobs for freedom fighters children and their grandchildren are not necessary 47 years into our independence. Especially for the Grade 1 posts the number of meritorious candidates should be increased through reducing quota system.

Depriving those who do well in exams is also not just, either-- the exams are fiercely competitive  in reality as only one in every two hundred get jobs once the quotas are taken into account. There must be a middle ground which will be suitable for all.  


Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

International »

US Mideast peace plan fairly well advanced: Tillerson


Reuters, Amman :The United States has a fairly well advanced Middle East peace plan that has been under development for a number of months, U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said on Wednesday during a visit to Jordan.Tillerson also said that Iran and Iran-backed forces should withdraw from Syria where ...

Sports »

Gold medallist Jorien ter Mors of the Netherlands celebrates with the national flag after the women's 1,000 meters speedskating race at the Gangneung Oval at the 2018 Winter Olympics in Gangneung, South Korea on Wednesday.


Editorial »

China and India vying for strategic dominance in DSE


A CONSORTIUM of the Shanghai Stock Exchange and the Shenzhen Stock Exchange has proposed to purchase 45 crore shares of the DSE for Tk 22 each. It said it will also provide the stock exchange with a technical support involving $37 million (about Tk 300 crore). The consortium demanded one ...

City »

Dr Md Sabur Khan, Chairman, Board of Trustees, Prof Dr Yousuf M Islam, VC, Prof Dr SM Mahbub Ul Haque Majumder, Pro- VC, Daffodil International University along with other guests posed for a photograph with the winners of different contests in different categories at Daffodil ICT Carnival on Tuesday.


Entertainment »

New Poster of `Loveratri` is a perfect Valentine`s treat to all the garba lovers!


Salman Khan unveils the first ever poster of Loveratri which is all set to release on 21st September, 2018. Loveratri, set against the backdrop of Gujarat is a romantic drama which unfolds the love story of the leading couple over the span of Navratri. Going in sync with the film's ...

Editorial »

Expel the Minister, not the students


QUESTION paper leakages hit a new record high with the leak of physics question paper of the SSC examination yesterday. That means, all the question papers have been leaked and the examinees answered the leaked question papers. In some areas, the law enforcement agencies arrested a number of students and ...

Cricket »

Saif stars in Abahani's win in Premier Cricket


Opener Saif Hasan slammed a brilliant ton enabling Abahani Limited to register their third consecutive victories in the Dhaka Premier Division Cricket League crushing Brothers Union Club by 136 runs on Tuesday at Khan Shaheb Osman Ali Stadium in Fatullah.Asked to bat first by Brothers Union Club, Abahani Limited, rode ...

City »

A faction of Bangladesh Federal Union of Journalists and Dhaka Union of Journalists formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Tuesday demanding release of BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia.


Entertainment »

Gigi Hadid slams body shamers


Supermodel Gigi Hadid, after her appearances at New York Fashion Week, has hit out at body shamers for commenting on her weight fluctuations. Hadid, who was diagnosed with Hashimoto's disease -- in which the immune system attacks the thyroid -- made her feelings known through a passionate series of tweets, ...

Entertainment »

Amala Paul shares new details on sexual harassment incident


South Indian actor Amala Paul has issued a public statement in order to protect her manager Pradeep Kumar after a section of media reports suggested his hand in the sexual harassment incident faced by the actor. In the statement, she also revealed that the accused who approached her with ill-intentions ...

International »

Israeli settlements complicate peace process: Trump


HuffPost :"I don't know frankly if we are going to even have talks, we will see what happens," he said in an interview published Sunday with the Israeli newspaper Israel Hayom. "Right now, I would say the Palestinians are not looking to make peace, they are not looking to make ...

Editorial »

Keep watch on transport agencies dispatching drug nationwide


A SECTION of drug peddlers have been reported to operate by engaging transport agencies in Chittagong and Cox's Bazar to dispatch drugs under cover. According to insiders and investigators, the smugglers are shipping the lethal Yaba pills across the country from Chittagong in their own vehicles, especially covered vans, to ...

Football »

AFC Bournemouth's Jordon Ibe (center left) and Huddersfield Town's Rajiv van La Parra battle for the ball during their English Premier League soccer match at the John Smith's Stadium in Huddersfield, England on Sunday.


Sports »

Canada win Olympic figure skating team gold, Russians silver


AFP, Gangneung :Ice dance stars Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir inspired Canada to the figure skating team title to secure the Winter Games heavyweights' first gold at Pyeongchang 2018 on Monday.The Russians, with their teenage ice starlets Evgenia Medvedeva and Alina Zagitova, took their first silver of the Games. The ...

Entertainment »

`Hostiles` is existential movie for me: Rosamund Pike


Actress Rosamund Pike said 'Hostiles' is an existential movie with a simple story. "I didn't think of this as a genre film. This is very much an existential movie for me. The story is quite simple and yet there's so much," Pike said in a statement."The human landscape of it ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news