Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Saturday, December 15, 2018 11:21:00 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Afghanistan — the land of political instability

Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

M. I. Rahman :
(From previous issue)
In 1838, the governor-general of India Lord Auckland declared war on Afghanistan, triggering the first Anglo-Afghan War. The East India Company, in tandem with the ruler of Punjab, Maharaja Ranjit Singh, launched a two-pronged invasion of Afghanistan-through the Khyber and Bolan Passes.
The objective was to unseat the Afghan ruler, Amir Dost Mohammad Khan, whom the British accused of collusion with the Russians, and replace him with Shah Shuja ul-Mulk. The invasion was executed swiftly. Except Ghazni, no Afghan city put up much of a resistance.
In August of 1839, Shah Shuja ul-Mulk was installed on the throne of Kabul, with British bayonets. The following year, the dethroned Amir Dost Mohammad Khan surrendered to the British, and was sent to India as a hostage.
Initailly, everything seemed to have been under control. But it was only a matter of time before the whole country would rise in rebellion. To make matters worse, the British lacked the experience and know-how to occupy a country with complex tribal rivalries and rough terrain that didn't generate much revenue.
Wazir Mohammad Khan son of Dost Mohammad Khan rose in revolt, assassinaled the British envoy William macaghten, the defas to British ruter of  Afghanistan.
In the following month, an entire British army numbering 16,500 (4,500 troops and 12,000 camp followers) was destroyed in the passes and gorges between Kabul and Jalalabad.
In April 1842, General Pollock, leading the Army of Retribution, forced through the Khyber pass to relieve the British garrison at Jalalabad and recapture Kabul.
To avenge the massacre of British troops, General Pollock briefly occupied and burned down parts of Kabul and Istalif, a village to the north of Kabul.
However, the new governor-general of India. Lord Ellenborough, ordered the British troops to  evacuate Afghanistan before the cold weather set in.
The following year Wazir Mohammad Akbar Khan received his father Amir Dost Mohammad at Ali Masjid, and escorted him up the Khyber Pass to Kabul to assume his throne as the Afghan ruler.
It is fascinating to observe that the First Anglo-Afghan war began with the objective to topple Amir Dost Mohammad Khan. yet, the same war ended with the restoration of Amir Dost Mohammad Khan as the ruler of Afghanistan.
When the British withdrew, they controlled Kabul, Kandahar, Ghazni, and Jalalabad. That's four out of six large cities in Afghanistan, with Herat and Mazar being out of their control.
Still, the war ended in a strategic defeat for the British, as they failed to achieve any of their stated objectives.
The Fist Anglo-Afghan War was therefore considered the single largest military catastrophe  for the British Empire in the 19th century.
The Fist Anglo-Afghan War set up a pattern that would be followied in subsequent invasions of Afghanistan.
The pattern has four phases:
First, swift invasion and occupation of Afghanistan without much resistance; second, resistance to foreign forces increases with the passage of time; third, the war is condemned to stalemate; fourth, withdrawal (or retreat) of foreign troops.
The events of the second Anglo-Afghan War 1879-1880, the soviet Invasion 1979-1989, and the US and NATO mission in Afghanistan corroborate the statement.
It is interesting to see that each one of these military adventures was headed by a superpower of its time, and each one of these military adventures followed the pattern of the First Anglo-Afghan War.
16 years ago in October, the US launched its invasion of Afghanistan. With America's Afghan war entering into the 17th year, the First Anglo-Afghan War offers stark lessons. Al- though there are visible differences between the two wars, the four phased pattern in both wars remains the same.
First, the US invasion of Afghanistan was swift., second, resistance to US miliary presence grew over time. Third, American officials have publicly admitted that there is a stalemate on the battlefield. Fourth, the US has largely withdrawn its troops from Afghanistan, and the remaining troops no longer operate in a combative capacity.
In a face-saving effort, the US has encouraged negotiations with the Taliban, Back in 2001, things were different. When in December that year, Hamid Kazai suggested to Us Defense secretary Donald Rumsfeld that Mullah Omar wanted to retire to a local village in Kandahar in exchange for a safe exit from Kandahar City, Donald Rumsfeld rejected Hamid Karzai's suggestion.
Now it's proving challenging to bring the Taliban to the negotiating table. The Us embarked on a costly war to topple the Taliban regime, but it is very likely that the same war will come to an end after the US-backed Afghan government reaches some sort of power-sharing agreement with the Taliban.
Or even worse, if the US abandons Afghanistan once again (as it did after the end of the Cold war) and Afghanistan's neighbours and major regional power's like China and Russia do not reach an agreement about the future of the country, it is very likely that the Taliban might overrun much of the country again.
Then one could argue that the very war that was launched to topple the Taliban, has come to an end after power was restored to the Taliban.
The cost of this long war that the Afghans have paid in blood and the US  have paid in treasure will be in vain. Everything will be back to square one.
Regional consensus on Afghanistan's future
History suggests that Afghanistan enjoyed periods of stability when competing powers' interests were not on a collision course in Afghanistan.
The Tsarist Russia and British India agreed on a buffer state status for Afghanistan. As a result, even though Afghanistan's foreign affairs were under British supervision, the country was generally peaceful and stable from 1880 to 1919.
Later, during the two world war and first three decades of the cold war, Afghanistan, unlike its immediate western and eastern neighbours, remained neutral.
Afghanistan's neutrality preserved what may be called a Balance of Interest (BOI) between major powers.
Forces of chaos and instability were unleashed when the BOI was upset as a result of a Communist coup in 1978. The soviet Union not only did not help to restore the BOI, but totally destroyed it when it invade Afghanistan in 1979.
Peace and stability will return to Afghanistan when the BOI is restored again. However, the longer the Afghan war drags on, the more complicated will it get, and the more difficult will it be to restore that balance.
Certainly the US presence will not help mitigate the crisis. The US has lost regional support for its presence in Afghanistan. It is fair to say that except India, no other country in the region wants to see US troops in Afghanistan anymore.
When that's the case, it is likely that the countries that remain opposed to US presence in Afghanistan will work (together if possible) to make life harder for the US.
The total withdrawal of US troops will help tremendously with restoring the BOI in Afghanistan, providing regional players prevent a total collapse of state institutions.
That being said, the good news is as we move from a unipolar world, (with the US as the only global power) to either a bipolar (the US and China as world powers), or a multipolar world, the chances of restoring the BOI through a regional consensus will increase.
Peace and stability in Afghanistan will further facilitate regional connectivity, trade, and tourism between south and Central Asia, and the Middle East and East Asia. Pakistan, Iran, China, Russia, and to an extent India are in a better position than the US to work with Afghanistan to find a long-term, sustainable solution to the Afghan war.
For one thing, the US, no matter how much resources it can spend right now, or how strong its military is, is an outside power and a temporary guest.
President Donald Trump once said that the US commitment to Afghanistan is not `unconditional'. Sooner or later, the US will pack and leave. It will be for the countries in the region to clear up the mess that it will leave behind.

Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Entertainment »

Mim`s new movie Thai Curry

Sheikh Arif Bulbon :End of this year is becoming something new for the National Film Award winner actress Bidya Sinha Saha Mim. At the end of this year, she has started shooting of a new movie. Now she is staying in Bangkok to take part in shooting of the movie. ...

Business & Economy »

In presence of Mohammed Monirul Moula, AMD of Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited, Abu Reza Md. Yeahia, DMD of the Bank and Dr. M. Easin Ali, Chairman of Dhaka City Physiotherapy Hospital, exchanging an agreement signing document at the Banks head office in the city on Wednesday. Under the deal, VISA and Khidmah Card holders of the Bank will get attractive discount in treatment services of the Hospital. Top officials from both the organizations were also present.


Cricket »

Malinga named captain for ODI, T20I series against New Zealand

Sri Lanka pacer Lasith Malinga, who until recently was out of favour with the selectors, has been appointed as the captain for the upcoming ODI and T20I series against New Zealand. He replaces Dinesh Chandimal, who led the side in the recently concluded ODI series and Thisara Perera, who captained ...

International »

US Senate votes to end support for Saudi-led Yemen war, blasts crown prince

The US Senate dealt President Donald Trump a double blow over Saudi Arabia on Thursday, approving a resolution to end US military support for Riyadh's war in Yemen, and another holding the Saudi crown prince responsible for the murder of Jamal Khashoggi.Though largely symbolic, the two bipartisan measures deliver a ...

International »

Islamic State not defeated, just transforming: Experts

Even as the last pockets of resistance in eastern Syria hold their ground, the Islamic State group is shapeshifting into a new, but no less dangerous, underground form, experts warn.Also known as ISIS, or the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, the group had long been ready to cede the ...

Editorial »

Time to avail the golden opportunity to explore Japan`s rich market

BANGLADESH wants to explore the potentials of sending skilled workers to Japan as the country is likely to open its job market for foreign workers. The matter is likely to be raised at Foreign Secretary-level talks scheduled to be held on December 17 in Tokyo.Foreign Secretary M Shahidul Haque and ...

Editorial »

Involve the youths in decision making process

A RECENT survey rightly indicated that unified and quality education system for all is imperative to turn today's youth into skilled manpower for future Bangladesh. Ahead of the 11th National Election, the survey findings clearly echoed the youth voice who emphasised meritorious teacher recruitment at primary school to tertiary level ...

International »

Pompeo says journalist Khashoggi`s death still being probed

Reuters, Washington  :U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Wednesday said investigations into the killing of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi were still ongoing but that the United States would hold those found responsible accountable for his death.Pompeo's comments to Fox News echoed U.S. President Donald Trump's stance on the killing ...

Sports »

Memphis Grizzlies guard Mike Conley (11) drives against Portland Trail Blazers guard Damian Lillard in the first half of an NBA basketball game in Memphis on Wednesday.


Entertainment »

Chanchal, Shahnaz Khushi pair up in new TV serial

Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Viewers always enjoy the on screen chemistry between National Film Award winner actor Chanchal Chowdhury and popular TV actress Shahnaz Khushi. In their acted TV play or telefilm or faction play, there must have a message for the viewers. For this reason, viewers always show their keen ...

Editorial »

Outstanding performance of our farmers

FARMERS of Pirojpur district have successfully used marshlands to grow up paddy saplings which would help meet sapling shortage in the waterlogged areas during paddy cultivation. In the district, farmers devoid of sapling during the Boro season as most uplands, where Boro seedlings usually grew, have been used for cultivating ...

International »

France hunts gunman after three killed at Strasbourg Christmas market

AFP  :Hundreds of police hunted Wednesday for a gunman who shot dead three people and wounded 13, eight seriously, at a famed Christmas market in Strasbourg, on the French border with Germany.The attack took place Tuesday around 8 pm (1900 GMT) in the heart of the medieval city as the ...

City »

A faction of BFUJ and DUJ staged a demonstration in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Wednesday in protest against closure of 54 online news portal.


Cricket »

Mashrafe regrets not getting another 20-25 runs after loss

UNB, Dhaka :Bangladesh lost the second ODI of the three-match series on Tuesday at Sher-e-Bangla National Cricket Stadium to the Windies by four wickets. The hosts' captain Mashrafe Bin Mortaza regrets more 20-25 runs at the end of the match.Bangladesh posted 255 for seven wickets in the first innings after ...

Entertainment »

Priyanka Gope in discussion with her new song

Sheikh Arif Bulbon :It is mostly happened in case of many singers where despite having outstanding lyrics and mind blowing composition many songs do not hit among the music lovers. For this reason, many singers cannot create attention among the listeners. National Film Award winner singer Priyanka Gope has rendered ...

Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Write a comment to this news