Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Tuesday, March 19, 2019 12:37:32 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Demand for encashment of Bank Guarantee cannot be injuncted

By
14th-Apr-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

(From previous issue) :
Therefore such breach of contract will automatically give rise to a claim for damages by the respondents and since the respondents suffered loss and damages due to the non performance of contract by the petitioner they rightly demanded encashment of the aforesaid Bank Guarantees.
5. Mr Sheikh Md Morshed, the learned Advocate for the petitioners submits that the respondents without, giving any prior showcause notice or opportunity of being heard decided to forfeit and encash the tender security money by encashing the Bank Guarantees which is illegal and without lawful authority and in breach of the principles of natural justice. The learned Advocate further submits that the petitioner did not violate any of the provisions of the Public Procurement Act and Rules there under and the impugned action of the respondents is liable to be declared to have been made without lawful authority and of no legal effect. The learned Advocate further submits that the petitioner did not violate any of the provisions of the tender documents and did not sign any formal, contract with the respondent's and their demand for encashment of the Bank Guarantees is illegal and without lawful authority. The learned Advocate further submits that the respondents awarded the contract to other suppliers after the petitioner expressed his inability to perform and she respondents have not incurred any loss and therefore their remand for encashment of the Bank Guarantees is without any basis and designed to harass the petitioner and that he should be discharged from his obligation under the said Bank Guarantees.
6. The learned Advocate for me petitioner has drawn our attention to the case of Continental Construction Ltd. vs Sailuj jal Vidhut Nigam Ltd. a decision of the Indian High Court reported in 2006 (1) ARBLR 321 Delhi where it has been held that encashment of a Bank Guarantee may be restrained by a Court on the ground of special equities i.e. irretrievable injustice. In the instant case the petitioner submits that the Bank Guarantees are of a huge amounted and that if it is allowed to be encashed then the petitioner is going to suffer irreparable loss end cause him great hardship and prays for at order to stop the encashment of the said Bank Guarantees.
7. As against this, Mr Shaikh Mohammed Zakir Hossain the learned Advocate for the Respondent No.1 submits that by issuance of the Notifications of Awards the Respondents accepted the petitioner's tender offer which is  which is itself a contract at his refused to sign the performance contract within the stipulated time by his clear statement that he is unable to supply the tender goods after getting the Notifications of Awards is a non-performance of the said contract for which the respondents have suffered loss and damages and that they have rightly demanded encashment of the Bank Guarantees. The learned Advocate further submits that due to the petitioner's failure to supply the tender goods and materials the respondents were constrained to retender the same and award the contract to another supplier at a higher rate causing loss of over seven crore and it is not correct to say that the respondents suffered no loss due to the petitioner's failure to supply the goods. The learned Advocate finally submits that the Bank Guarantees issued in favour of the respondents at the instance of the petitioner is a security for performance of tender work i.e. supply of the materials and on-his failure to do so the demand for encashment was rightly made and no interference is called for by this Court in the instant matter and the Rules are liable to be discharged.
8. We have considered the submissions of the learned Advocates.
9. It appears that the aforesaid Bank Guarantees were provided by the petitioner as security for supply of certain materials pursuant to the aforesaid tenders floated by the respondents. Each Bank Guarantee states as follows:
 "Bank Gurantee No: 159/2015
For Taka : Tk 35,00,000
Issue date: 6-10-2015
Validity: 4-3-2016
At the request of the Tenderer, we, Export Import Bank of Bangladesh Limited, Motijheel Branch, Sharif Mansion" 56-57, Motijhee1 C/A, Dhaka-1000, hereby irrevocably undertake to pay you, without cavil or argument, any sum of sums not exceeding in total an amount of BDT 35,00,000 (BD Thirty Five Lac) only upon receipt by us of your first written demand accompanied by a written statement that the Tenderer is in breach of its obligation(s) under the Tender conditions, because the Tenderer:
a. has withdrawn its Tender after opening of Tenders but within the validity of the Tender Security; or
b. refused to accept the Notification of Award (NOA) within the period as stated under Instructions to Tenderers (ITT); or
c. failed to furnish Performance Security within the period as stipulated in the NOA; or
d. refused to sign the Contract Agreement by the time specified in the NOA; or
e. did not accept the correction of the Tender price following the correction of the arithmetic errors in accordance with the ITT; or
This guarantee will expire:
(a)    if the Tenderer is the successful Tenderer, upon our receipt of a copies of the contract signed by the Tenderer and the Performance Security issued to you in accordance with the ITT; or if the Tenderer is not the successful Tenderer, twenty eight (28) days after the expiration of the Tenderer's Tender validity period, being 4-3-2016.
Consequently, we must receive at the above-mentioned office any demand for payment under this guarantee on or before that date.
For and on behalf of
Export Import Bank of Bangladesh Ltd Motijheel Branch, Dhaka.
Sd/ Authorised person"
10. The aforesaid Bank Guarantees appear to be encashable on the first written demand by the respondents or the happening of certain conditions including the refusal to sign the contractual agreement specified in the Notifications of Awards. In the instant case the petitioners did not sign the Notification of Awards and the respondents demanded encashment of the Bank Guarantees. It is admitted by the petitioner that he refused to sign the contractual agreement as specified in the Notifications of Awards. In such Circumstances the question arises whether the EXIM Rank which issued the Bank Guarantees is bound to honour its commitment of paying the respondents on the Bank Guarantees as demanded by them. The Bank Guarantee is a separate contract on the underlying contract between the parties. The Court will not look at disputes between the parties while considering the demand for encashment of a Bank Guarantee.
11. The general rule regarding Bank Guarantees is that they are liable to be encashed on demand by the beneficiary otherwise trade and commerce will suffer but the demand for encashment can be refused if it is not made in accordance with the terms of the Bank Guarantee. The only exception recognized by the Courts is the existence of fraud and the Bank has knowledge of it before encashment. A Bank Guarantee is a unconditional undertaking to make payment on demand and when the beneficiary of the Gurantees makes such a demand for encashment the Bank is bound to comply and make the payment.
12. In Volivintar Oil SA vs Chase Manhattan Bank (1984) 1 All ER 351 it has been held that, in an exceptional case an injunction may be granted where it is proved that the bank knows that any demand for payment already made or which may thereafter be made will clearly be fraudulent but the evidence must he dear, both as to the fact of fraud and as to the bank's knowledge. The uncorroborated statement of the customer will not be sufficient in this regard as irreparable damage can he done to a bank's credit in the relatively brief time which must elapse between the granting of such an injunction and an application by the bank to have it discharged.
13. The rule, is well established that a bank issuing guarantee is not concerned with the underlying contract between the parties to the contract. The duty of the bank under a performance guarantee is created by the document itself. Once the documents are in order the bank giving the guarantee must honour the same and make payment unless there is clear evidence of fraud.
14. In Nuvista Pharma Ltd. vs Chairman, National Board of Revenue 65 DLR (AD) 302 the Appellate Division reiterated their earlier view in Uttara Bank vs Macneill & Kilburn, 33 DLR (AD) 298 where it was held that
"a court will not interfere by granting an injunction from performing discharging the contractual obligations. Such is the case here. The letter of or guarantee was given in this case by the plaintiff and the defendant placed it for the encashment of the letter of guarantee. The bank (chartered bank) is only obliged to comply with the demand made by the appellant Uttara Bank. It is nobody's case that there is any fraud of which the bank got notice."
15. In view of the aforesaid decisions and judicial pronouncements it is clear that the demand for encashment of Bank Guarantees cannot be injuncted by a Court unless there is clear evidence of fraud and the Bank has notice of it.
16. The Bank is not concerned about the disputes between the parties and the demand for encashment of Bank Guarantees cannot be stopped. The petitioner is at liberty to file appropriate case in the civil court for damages and other relief if he has suffered any loss due to the action of the respondents and this court will not go into the merit of the petitioner's claim on that score. The performance guarantees as stated earlier are separate commitments by the bank and it cannot be stopped due to a dispute between the parties.
17. Accordingly, these Rules have no merit and they are discharged. Our interim orders of stay are hereby recalled and vacated.
There will be no order as to costs.
(Concluded)

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

Bangladesh Ambassador in Nepal meet women booters


Bangladesh's ambassador in Nepal Mashfee Binte Shams yesterday paid a surprise visit at Xenial Hotel to motivate the Bangladesh eve football team ahead of the Bangladesh's semifinal clash of the SAFF Women's Championship, according to message received here from Bangladesh Football Federation.Mohammed Al Alamul Emam (Councilors and Head of Chancery) ...

Football »

PSG shrug off fan protest to beat rivals Marseille


Angel Di Maria scored twice as Paris Saint-Germain eased to a 3-1 victory over Marseille on Sunday to extend their long unbeaten run against their arch rivals and move 20 points clear at the Ligue 1 summit.A group of PSG ultras were boycotting the opening stages of the game over ...

International »

US-backed force says it has taken positions in IS Syria camp


Reuters, Baghouz, Syria :U.S.-backed fighters said they had taken positions in Islamic State's last enclave in eastern Syria and air strikes pounded the tiny patch of land beside the Euphrates River early on Monday, a Reuters journalist said.Smoke rose over the tiny enclave as warplanes and artillery bombarded it. Another ...

International »

New gun laws to make New Zealand safer after mosque shootings, says PM Ardern


Reuters, Christchurch :New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern said on Monday she would announce new gun laws within days, after a lone gunman killed 50 people in mass shootings at two mosques in the city of Christchurch.Australian Brenton Tarrant, 28, a suspected white supremacist, was charged with murder on Saturday. ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Dr. Khondkar Mosharraf Hossain speaking at a memorial meeting on former Secretary General of BNP Khondkar Delwar Hossain at the Jatiya Press Club on Monday on the occasion of the latter's 8th death anniversary.


Editorial »

Rohingya criminals: A new challenge for Bangladesh


ROHINGYA refugee crisis is getting critical day by day. Now unlawful activities of some Rohingya criminal groups have become headache of law enforcement agencies. A Cox's Bazar court on Sunday sent 13 Rohingyas to jail as two groups of the refugees clashed in Ukhiya's Kutupalong camp on Saturday night. Police ...

Entertainment »

Tanuja and Kajol welcome Pranutan to Bollywood


Actress Pranutan who is marking her debut with Salman Khan’s Notebook receives the sweetest message from Kajol and Tanuja. The actress, who is living her dream as she embarks on her Bollywood journey with Notebook, has received an endearing message from Kajol and Tanuja, who are her family members. Hailing ...

Football »

Zidane enjoys winning start but Atletico beaten in Bilbao


Zinedine Zidane brought Real Madrid's outcasts in from the cold and they repaid him with a win over Celta Vigo on Saturday but La Liga's title race could well be over after Atletico Madrid were beaten by Athletic Bilbao. Isco and Gareth Bale each scored in Madrid's 2-0 victory over ...

Editorial »

Land officials` wealth reports should be made public


THE Land Minister after taking charge in January openly declared a crusade against the corruption, and directed the officials and employees to submit their wealth reports by February 28. As per his order, the wealth reports have been submitted but these were not made public.  Rather, Land Secretary says the ...

International »

New Zealand digs graves as mosque massacre toll rises to 50


AP, Christchurch, New Zealand :Anguished relatives were anxiously waiting Sunday for authorities to release the remains of those who were killed in massacres at two mosques in the New Zealand city of Christchurch, while police announced the death toll from the racist attacks had risen to 50.Islamic law calls for ...

International »

Joe Biden (almost) announces he is running for President


AP, Dover :For a brief moment, former Vice President Joe Biden placed himself in the crowded field of Democratic presidential candidates during a speech on Saturday night. Biden seemingly described himself as one of the people "running" while noting he gets criticized by some progressives."I have the most progressive record ...

Entertainment »

Mim in web series


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Few days ago, National Film Award winner actress Bidya Sinha Saha Mim acted in a web series titled Beauty & Bullet under Animesh Aich’s direction. Tahsan Khan was her co-actor in that series which yet not aired till now. Meanwhile, Mim has started shooting of Golam Sohrab ...

International »

US-Afghan tensions erupt over Kabul's exclusion from peace talks


Reuters, Washington  :The United States and Afghanistan clashed publicly on Thursday over U.S. peace talks with the Taliban, with a visiting Afghan official accusing the chief U.S. negotiator of "delegitimizing" the Kabul government by excluding it from the deliberations.The remarks by Hamdullah Mohib, a former ambassador to Washington who serves ...

Football »

FIFA votes for new Club World Cup, Euro clubs confirm boycott


FIFA will go ahead with a new 24-team Club World Cup starting in 2021, its President Gianni Infantino said on Friday, setting the world soccer governing body in conflict with Europe's top clubs.Infantino, speaking at a news conference, said FIFA had made the decision at its council meeting on Friday.The ...

City »

Children are engrossed in painting at a drawing competition organised by the Jatiya Press Club on the occasion of birthday of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and National Children's Day at the club on Saturday.


 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news