Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, August 20, 2018 10:35:06 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Delay in disposal cannot be a ground for commuting sentence

By
19th-May-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Appellate Division (Criminal) :
Surendra Kynar  Sinha CJ
Syed Mahmud Hossain J
Hasan Foez Siddique J
Shahidul Islam @
Shahid ………….
………………..Petitioner
vs
State ……………
............ Respondent
Judgement
March 5th, 2017
Code of Criminal Procedure (V of 1898)
Section 374
Delay in the disposal of the case cannot by itself be a ground for commuting the sentence of death to one of imprisonment for life since the crime committed by the petitioner was premeditated senseless, dastardly and beyond all human reasonings. .. .... (8)
Sections 374 and 376
From the nature of the offence it appears to us that the petitioner is not anyway entitled to get any sympathy. We do not find any mitigating or extenuating circumstances on record for commutation of the sentence of death…………(8)
Laxman Naik vs State of Orissa, AIR 1995 SC 1387 and Molai vs State of Modhya Pradesh, AIR 2000 SC 177 ref.
Nikhil Kumar Saha, Senior Advocate, instructed by Sufia Khatun, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioner:
Khondaker Diliruzzaman, Deputy Attorney General instructed by Haridus Paul/, Advocate-on-Record-For the Respondent.
Judgment
Hasan Foez Siddique J : This criminal review petition is directed against the judgment and order dated 2-8-2016 passed by this Division in Jail Petition No.13 of 2006 dismissing the petition,
2. Mr, Nikhil Kumar Saha, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner, submits that the petitioner is in death cell for about 14 years which is a circumstance to commute the sentence so death sentence awarded to him may be commuted to one of imprisonment for life.
3. Mr. Diliruzzaman, learned Deputy Attorney-General appearing for the State, submits that in view of the evidence and nature of offence committed by the petitioner, this Division rightly upheld the sentence of death of the petitioner and that there is no error of law apparent on the face of the record in the judgment of this Division.
4. At about 10-00 pm on 23-4-1998 Shajneen, an unfortunate girl of 15 years, was killed most inhumanly and brutally after rape in her bedroom which was her most secured place. This Division, upholding the findings of the tribunal and High Court Division observed that it has been proved all reasonable doubt that victim Shajneen was raped before murder. Confessional statement of the petitioner recorded under section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, post-mortem report, evidence and statement of the appellant made before the tribunal at the time of his examination under section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure there is no doubt that not only this vulture pounced upon the body of the victim but it had jeopardised the victim's parents her other family members and conscience of the society at large. It was a cold-blooded murder and where rape was committed on an innocent and helpless girl, which was a treacherous and cowardly act of the petitioner.
5. It is not possible to catalogue the reasons which may justify the pass of death sentence but when the murder has been committed in a brutal manner on a helpless child the same may be awarded. It is a crime against society and the brutality of the crime shocks the judicial conscience that the Court has the duty to impose the death sentence. The petitioner was servant of PW I whose duty was to defend and protect the family members instead he, out of his sexual lust, did not bother to kill a child of 15 years old assaulting mercilessly. It was gruesome murder so dilution of sentence would be a case of misplaced sympathy and gross miscarriage of justice. The crime committed by the petitioner was grotesque, diabolical and revolting, Since heinous crime was committed in cruel and diabolical manner, death sentence is justified punishment. It is true death for death may be, to some extent, inhuman but it is equally true that when a man becomes a beast and menace to the society, he can be deprived of his life. The nature of the crime reveals that the petitioner is a menace to the society and sentence of imprisonment would be altogether inadequate.
6. In the case of Laxmon Naik vs State of Orissa repoted in AIR 1995 SC 1387 the accused committed rape on his brother's daughter aged 7 years in a lonely place in forest and thereafter killed her. Supreme Court of India observed that the evidence on record indicated how diabolically the accused had conceived of his plan and brutally executed it and such a calculated, cold-blooded and brutal murder of a girl of a very tender age after committing rape on her would undoubtedly fall in the category of rarest of the rare case attracting no punishment other than the capital punishment.
7. In the case of Molai vs State of Modhya Pradesh reported in AIR 2000 SC I77 Supreme Court of India expressed similar view. In the said case victim, a 16 year old girl alone in house preparing for her examination. Both accused, taking advantage of she being alone, committed rape on her and then killed her. It was observed.
"We have very carefully considered the contentions raised on behalf of the parties. We have also gone through various the decisions of this Court relied upon by the parties in the Courts below as well as before us and in our opinion the present case squarely falls in the category of one of the rarest of rare cases, and if this be so, the Courts below have committed no error in awarding capital punishment to each of the accused. It cannot be overlooked that Naveen, a 16 year old girl, was preparing for her 10th examination at her house and suddenly both the accused took advantage of the being alone in the house and committed a most shameful act of rape. The accused did not stop there but they strangulated her by using her under-garment and thereafter took her to the septic tank along with the cycle and caused injuries with a sharp edged weapon. The accused did not even stop there but they exhibited the criminality in their conduct by throwing the dead body into the septic tank totally, disregarding the respect for a human dead body. Learned counsel for the accused (appellants) could not point any mitigating circumstance from the record of the case to justify the reduction of sentence of either of the accused. In a case of this nature, in our considered view, the capital punishment to both the accused is the only proper punishment and we see no reason to take a different view than the one taken by the Courts below."
8. From the nature of the offence it appears to us that the petitioner is not anyway entitled to get any sympathy. We do not find any mitigating or extenuating circumstances on record for commutation of the sentence of death. Delay in the disposal of this case cannot by itself be a ground for commuting the sentence of death to one of imprisonment for life since the crime committed by the petitioner was premeditated senseless, dastard by and beyond all human reasonings.
Accordingly, we do not find any substance in the petition. Thus, the review petition is dismissed.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Growing violence in hills: No serious investigation into the killings


Seven people, including three leaders of United People's Democratic Front (UPDF), were killed and six others injured in two gun attacks in Khagrachhari town on Saturday. With these, 33 people have so far been killed in violence in Rangamati and Khagrachhari this year. The UPDF alleged that it was a ...

Football »

Messi, Coutinho get Barcelona off to winning start


AFP, Madrid :Two goals from Lionel Messi either side of a Philippe Coutinho strike allowed Barcelona to start their defence of the Spanish title with a 3-0 win over Alaves at the Camp Nou on Saturday night.Wearing the captain's armband following the departure of Andres Iniesta to Japan, Messi stepped ...

Entertainment »

I like to do something that challenges me: Jennifer Winget


Bepannaah actress Jennifer Winget likes to challenge herself with each of her projects. “I like to do something that challenges me. I like to do something different from my previous characters,” Jennifer told IANS. “I have been fortunate enough to be offered characters and projects that challenge me and that ...

City »

Dhaka South City Corporation (DSCC) Mayor Sayeed Khokon speaking at a gathering of cleaners on quick disposal of wastes of sacrificial animals yesterday.


.

International »

Russian President Putin steals the show at Austrian FM`s wedding


Reuters, Vienna :Russian President Vladimir Putin danced arm-in-arm with Austria's foreign minister Karin Kneissl at her wedding on Saturday, after receiving an invitation that opposition critics said undermined the West's stance against Moscow.Mr Putin arrived in a car carrying a bouquet of flowers and accompanied, local media said, by a ...

Editorial »

Sanctions by USA and European Union are welcome but more effective measures will be needed


IN the latest development, the US Treasury on Friday slapped sanctions on four Myanmar military and police commanders and two army units for involvement in "ethnic cleansing" and other human rights abuses against the country's Rohingya minority. In response to Myanmar's crackdown on the Rohingyas, the sanctions are so far ...

Sports »

Bolt arrives in Australia on football quest


Usain Bolt says he's deadly serious about becoming a professional footballer and plans to show the world what he's capable of after arriving in Australia Saturday for a trial stint with an A-League club.The superstar athlete has been given the chance to prove his worth by the Central Coast Mariners, ...

Entertainment »

Sonali Bendre`s son posts an emotional message


Family and close friends of Bollywood actress Sonali Bendre have come out as the biggest support in her journey of fighting cancer. The actress who has been diagnosed with high-grade cancer is undergoing her treatment in New York. Being a true fighter, Sonali has not shied away from sharing her ...

Entertainment »

Poet Shamsur Rahman's 12th death anniversary observed


Entertainment Desk : The 12th death anniversary of Shamsur Rahman, one of the major poets in modern Bengali literature, was observed on Friday in a befitting manner.Marking the anniversary, different socio-cultural organisations placed wreaths at the grave of the poet at Banani graveyard and arranged Doa Mahfil.Jatiya Kabita Parishad and Kabi ...

City »

BNP Vice-Chairman Advocate Khondkar Mahbub Hossain speaking at a discussion on 'Next National Election Under Interrogation Without Reform of Election Commission' organised by 'Chetona Bangladesh' at the Jatiya Press Club on Saturday.


International »

Ex-CIA directors issue unprecedented Trump condemnation


AFP, Washington :Former CIA directors and another half dozen of America's most senior spies have issued an unprecedented condemnation of President Donald Trump, after his decision to blacklist their colleague John Brennan.In a statement, ex-CIA bosses appointed by Republican and Democratic presidents - including Robert Gates, George Tenet, Porter Goss, ...

Editorial »

US editors slam Trump for exerting power over free press and strength of democracy


THE rebuke of the US President Donald Trump by over 350 US dailies and other media outlets in their editorials on Thursday has come as a coordinated response to Trump's dirty war against the media and in defense of the press freedom. His sustained attack on free media as 'fake ...

Sports »

Serena learned just before Konta loss that half-sister's killer had been freed


Serena Williams says she discovered just minutes before her match against Johanna Konta last month that the man convicted of killing her half-sister had been released on parole.Briton Konta inflicted the worst defeat of Williams' career by winning 6-1 6-0 in the first round of the Silicon Valley Classic in ...

City »

Convenor of Jatiya Oikya Prokriya Dr Kamal Hossain, among others, at a solidarity meeting organised by prokriya at the Jatiya Press Club on Friday demanding unconditional release of students who were arrested during quota reform movement.


Entertainment »

Radhika Apte gears up for her upcoming project in Mumbai


Radhika Apte who has been juggling multiple projects efficiently is in Mumbai currently promoting her upcoming series on an OTT.  The actress has a lot on her plate as she's currently promoting her upcoming Netflix original Ghoul which is her third project with Netflix followed by the success of her ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news