Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, September 24, 2018 10:42:12 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Lending banks' liability in pledge loan

By
30th-Jun-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Appellate Division :
(Civil)
Surendra Kumar Sinha CJ
Syed Mahmud Hossain J
Hasan Foez Siddique J
Mirza Hussain Haider J
Nimal Chandra Biswas ………….Petitioner
Vs
Sonali Bank, Dhaka and another ………..Respondents
Judgment
March 20th, 2016
Artha Rin Adalat Ain (VIII of 2003)
Sections 40 and 44Ka
In case of pledge loan, firstly, the borrower has to furnish a certain amount as agreed between lender bank and the borrower as margin, which in this case was 30% of the loan amount; secondly, in case of pledge loan facility, pledge goods remain under the custody of lender bank. The Adalat rightly found that it could not legally compel the defendants to refund the pledge loan when pledged goods were misappropriated from the bank's custody. . ..... (13)
Probir Neogi, Senior Advocate, instructed by Taufique Hossain, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioner (In CP No. 818/12).
Khaled Ahmed, Advocate, instructed by Syed Mahbubar Rahman, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioner (In CP No. 950/12)
None Represented-For the Respondents (In CP No.818/12).
Probir Neogi, Senior Advocate, instructed by Taufique Hossain, Advocate-on-Record-For the Respondents (In CP No. 950/12).
Judgment
Syed Mahmud Hossain J : Both the civil petitions for leave to appeal are directed against the judgment and order dated 24-8-2011 passed by the High Court Division in First Appeal No.42 of 2005 along with Cross Objection No.4 of 2009 dismissing the appeal and cross objection and affirming the judgment and decree dated 14-9-2004 passed by the learned Joint District Judge and Artha Rin Adalat No.2, Jhenaidah in Artha Rin Case No. 1 of 2002 decreeing the suit in part.
2. The facts, giving rise to these civil petitions for leave to appeal, in a nutshell, are:
The Sonali Bank (Kaligonj Branch, Jhenaidah) as the plaintiff filed Artha Rin Suit No.1 of 2002 in Artha Rin Adalat No.2, Jhenaidah against defendant No.1, Nimai Chandra Biswas and others, praying for a decree of Taka 1,17,70,424.67 as outstanding dues against CC hypothecation and CC Pledge loan. The plaint case, in a nutshell, was that defendant No.1 prayed for loan from the plaintiff-bank for the purpose of his business on 30-10-1995. The bank by a memo dated 20-11-1995 sanctioned loan of Taka 40,00,000 as pledge and Taka 10,00,000 as hypothecation in total Taka 50,00,000.
Defendant No.2 executed mortgage deed, Power of Attorney and other charge documents in favour of the plaintiff-bank. It was stipulated in the sanction letter that the said loan was to be repaid within one year. On 5-2-1997, the bank sanctioned another loan of Taka 10,00,000 as pledge and Taka 2,00,000 as hypothecation. After rescheduling of loan, the bank sanctioned Taka 20,00,000 as pledge and Taka 3,00,000 as hypothecation. Thus, the sanctioned amount rose to Taka 85,00,000 in total The plaintiff-bank wrote several letters to defendant and verbally asked to repay the loan money, and on 23-3-2000, a legal notice was served upon defendant No.1 who did not repay the loan money. Up to 30-3-2002 the total outstanding dues was Taka 19,46,667,67 as hypothecation and Taka 98,23,737 as pledge in total Taka 1,17,70,424.67. On 30-3-2000, the defendants refused to pay the outstanding dues, and hence, the suit.
3. Defendant No. 1 (petitioner in Civil Petition No.818 of 2012) contested the suit by filing written statement denying all the material statements made in the plaint, contending, inter alia, that the suit was not maintainable and a premature one. The substantive case of the defendants, in short, was that the plaintiff-bank sanctioned a loan on 12-12-1999 amounting to Taka 15,00,000 as hypothecation and Taka 70,00,000 as pledge and according to sanction letter, the plaintiff-bank received the entire goods from defendant No.1 against pledge loan and it was under lock and key of the plaintiff-bank, that is, the pledged goods were under the custody of the bank. The employees of the bank misappropriated the goods and replaced goods by the bran of paddy, and thereby misappropriated Taka 70,00,000. The Manager of the Bank filed a criminal case on 14-3-2000 against defendant No.1 being Kaligonj PS Case No.4/2000 (GR Case No.33/2000) under Sections 406/409/420 of the Penel Code and after investigation final report was submitted on 26-3-2000 in favour of defendant No.1. Thereafter, Md Habibur Rahman, Assistant General Manager, Sonali Bank, Regional Office, Jhenaidah as the informant lodged another case against three  bank employees and defendant No.1 which is under investigation. As such, the suit is liable to be dismissed.
4. The learned Joint District Judge and Artha Rin Adalat No.2, Jhenaidah by the judgment and order dated 14-9-2004 decreed the suit in part.
5. Against the judgment and decree of the Arthil Rin Adalat, the plaintiff-bank preferred First Appeal No 42 of 2005 and defendant No.1 also filed Cross Objection No.04 of 2009 before the High Court Division claiming the amount constituting 30% margin of the pledge loan deposited by defendant No.I. The learned Judges of the High Court Division, upon hearing the first appeal and the cross objection by the judgment and order dated 24-4-2011 dismissed the appeal and the cross objection.
6. Feeling aggrieved by and dissatisfied with judgment and order passed by the High Court Division, defendant No. 1 as the leave-petitioner filed Civil Petition No. 818 of 2012 and the plaintiff-bank as the leave-petitioner filed Civil Petition Appeal No. 950 of 2012 before this Division.
7. Mr Probir Neogi, learned Senior Advocate, appearing on behalf of the leave-petitioner of civil petition No. 818 of 2012 , submits that chapter 7 of the Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003 comprising Sections 40 to 44ka deal with appea1s and revisions, and section 40 provides that provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure shall apply in the proceedings of appeal and revision arising out of Artha Rin suits provided those are not inconsistent with any provisions of Artha Rin Adalat Ain. He further submits that there being nothing in Artha Rin Adalat Ain, 2003, which is in conflict with or contrary to the provision of Rule 22 Order XLI of the Code of Civil Procedure, the High Court Division was wrong in holding that the cross objection was not maintainable without assigning any reason whatsoever. He then submits that in a pledge loan the domination over the pledged goods remains with the pledgee, that is, in the instant case, the bank, which has been correctly found by the Artha Rin Adalat. But the Artha Rin Adalat in spite of such finding failed to pass the decree in appropriate terms directing the adjustment of the dues of defendant No.1 for 30% margin deposited by him in obtaining the pledge loan with the bank's dues against hypothecation loan as decreed. He also placed the judgment of Special Case No. 1 of 2003 wherein bank employees in charge of godown have been convicted and defendant No.1 was acquitted.
8. Mr Khaled Ahmed, learned Advocate, appearing on behalf of the leave-petitioner of Civil Petition No.950 of 2012, submits that the Artha Rin suit should have decreed the suit in full and that the cross-objection filed by defendant No.1 was not maintainable and the  High Court Division rightly dismissed the cross-objection.
9. We have considered the submissions of the learned Senior Advocate and the learned Advocate of both the civil petitions, perused the impugned judgment and the materials on record.
10. The petitioner in Civil Petition No. 818 of 2012 by an additional paper-book has brought on record the judgment and order passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, First Court and Special Judge, Jhenaidah in Special Case No.1 of 2003 which was delivered on 9-6-2014, that is, after delivery of the impugned judgment of the High Court Division on 24-8-2011. It appears from the judgment in Special Case No.1 of 2003 that defendant No.1 Nimai Chandra Biswas, who was accused No.1 in the said criminal case was acquitted of the charge along with accused No. 2 and two other accused, namely, Hayatur Rahman, godown-keeper and Nasiruddin, godown-chowkidar, both employees of the  bank were convicted and sentenced to 7 (seven) years rigorous imprisonment and to pay a fine of Taka 5,000 each, in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for 6 (six) months.
11. On consideration of the evidence on record, the Artha Rin Adalat came to a finding that the plaintiff-bank showed utter negligence in preserving and protecting the pledged goods and that the said fact is evident by the fact that an Assistant General Manager of the Bank filed a criminal case on 28-3-2000 against the Manager, the godown-keeper and the chowkider. The Artha Rin Adalat further found that while the pledged goods were in custody of the plaintiff-bank those were removed there from and that the plaintiff-bank could not return those goods to defendant No.1 The plaintiff-bank could not prove that defendant No. 1 stole or misappropriated or sold those pledged goods beyond the knowledge of the plaintiff-bank. The Artha Rin Adalat also found that at the hearing of the suit, the plaintiff-bank tried to implicate accused defendant No.1 by producing antedated and collusive documents.
12. Having considered the evidence of PW I, the High Court Division came to the finding that the pledged goods were under lock and key of the plaintiff and that the defendants did not remove it. The High Court Division, however, found that the learned Judge of the Artha Rin Adalat after calculation of the exhibits found that the plaintiff was entitled to
a decree of Taka 18,56,687.
13. It is an established banking practice that in case of pledge loan, firstly, the borrower has to furnish a certain amount as agreed between lender bank and the borrower as margin, which in this case was 30% of the loan amount; secondly, in case of pledge loan facility, pledge goods remain under the custody of lender bank.
So, we find that the Artha Rin Adalat rightly found that it could not legally compel the defendants to refund the pledge loan when pledged goods were misappropriated from the bank's custody. The Artha Rin Adalat also rightly held-
ÒAwaKšÍ †cøR F‡Yi 30% gvwR©b wnmv‡e 1 bs weev`xi †cøRK…Z gvjvgv‡ji g~‡j¨i Dci Zvnvi AwaKvi _vwKqv hvq|Ó
14. But the Artha Rin Adalat failed to pass the decree in proper terms for adjustment of defendant No. 1's dues as 30% margin of pledge loan with the bank's dues against hypothecation loan as decreed, although it legally and reasonably follows from the Adalat's own finding. The High Court Division totally failed to take notice of and address this vital aspect of the case.
15. In the light of discussion made above, we are of the view that the ends of justice would be met if the decree passed by the Artha Rin Adalat is modified to the effect that the 30% margin of pledge loan deposited by defendant No.1 shall be adjusted with the decretal amount of Taka 18,31,687.67, and the decree in question is modified accordingly.
Thus, Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No. 818 of 2012 is disposed of and Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No.950 of 2012 is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Attack on Iran`s elite guards


IRANIAN Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei accused US-backed Gulf Arab states of carrying out a shooting attack on a military parade that killed 25 people, almost half of them members of the country's elite Revolutionary Guards. Khamenei ordered security forces to bring to justice those responsible for one of the ...

Sports »

Bertens defeats Tomljanovic to secure Korea Open win


AFP, Seoul :Kiki Bertens defeated Australia's Ajla Tomljanovic in the Korea Open final on Sunday, securing her third WTA Tour singles title of the season to continue her career-best year.The second-seeded Bertens came back from break down in the deciding set to defeat the Australian in two hours and 22 ...

International »

World leaders gather at UN under threat from unilateralism


AP, United Nations :With rising unilateralism challenging its very existence, the United Nations convenes its annual meeting of world leaders Monday and will try once more to tackle problems together as a community of nations, addressing threats ranging from Mideast conflicts to the effects of global warming - and also ...

City »

National Professor Anisuzzaman seen among others at the cover unveiling ceremony of a book marking the 80th birthday of eminent writer Hasan Azizul Haq organised by Bangladesh Culture at Jatiya Press Club yesterday.


Entertainment »

Nazira Mou to debut in film with Indraneil


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Viewers’ choice popular actress Nazira Mou has been acting in small screen for many days. She got many offers for acting in big screen. But she did not agree to act due to disliking stories and her roles in those works. When Mou got the proposal from ...

Editorial »

CPJ reveals weakness of journalists by appealing to President


THE Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) in a letter to the Bangladesh President has expressed deep concern about the Digital Security Act 2018, which was passed by the Parliament on September 18, and urged him to return it to Parliament for a review afresh.   If this legislation was allowed to ...

International »

Modi faces calls for resignation over French jet deal


Reuters, New delhi :Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi faced calls for his resignation over allegations of corruption in a military jet deal with France after former French president Francois Hollande was quoted as saying New Delhi had influenced the choice of a local partner.Indian political parties have been gunning for ...

International »

US official in Russia probe suggested taping Trump: Report


Reuters, Washington: The US official who oversees the federal investigation into Russia's role in the 2016 U.S. election suggested secretly recording President Donald Trump last year and recruiting Cabinet members to invoke a constitutional amendment to remove him from the White House, the New York Times reported on Friday.Deputy Attorney ...

Football »

Tabarez renews with Uruguay until Qatar World Cup


AFP, Montevideo :Despite failing health the veteran coach Oscar Tabarez has signed a four-year contract extension to remain at the Uruguay helm until the end of the 2022 World Cup in Qatar, the South American country's football federation said on Friday.Tabarez, who suffers from a nerve disorder that forces him ...

City »

People of the Shia community brought out a Tazia procession in the city on the occasion of Holy Ashura. The snap was taken from Azimpur area on Friday.


Entertainment »

Rishi Kapoor, Juhi Chawla to reunite for a comedy The film will reunite Kapoor and Chawla 22 years after their last film 'Daraar'


Frequent collaborators Rishi Kapoor and Juhi Chawla will reunite for a family comedy produced by Sony Pictures International and MacGuffin Pictures, reported Variety.The untitled film will be co-written by Hitesh Bhatia and Supratik Sen (Parched, Kai Po Che!), and directed by Bhatia. The film will reunite Kapoor and Chawla 22 ...

Editorial »

Rohingya crisis: UN is helpless without active cooperation of int'l community


THE United Nations was established with a mission to stop brutality and promotion of human rights across the globe but at present is apparently helpless to stop the Myanmar military atrocity on Rohingya ethnic community. Though the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the ...

Cricket »

India rout Pakistan by eight wickets in Asia Cup


AFP, Dubai :India crushed Pakistan by eight wickets in their long-awaited Asia Cup match which failed to live up to its hype in Dubai on Wednesday.Pace spearhead Bhuvneshwar Kumar (3-15) and part time off-spinner Kedar Jadhav (3-23) sent Pakistan, who won the toss and batted, collapsing to just 162 all ...

Football »

We aim to play SAFF U-16 Women's final: Choton


Bangladesh U-18 national women's football team head coach Golam Rabanni Choton said they aim to play the final of the SAFF U-18 Women's Championship which is scheduled to be held from September 28 to October 7 in Thimpu, Bhutan.He was speaking at a pre-departure press conference on Thursday at the ...

International »

US-North Korea relations making 'tremendous progress': Trump


President Donald Trump on Wednesday said US relations with North Korea are making "tremendous progress" from the days before his presidency when the two countries appeared close to "going to war."Trump said a recent letter from North Korean leader Kim Jong Un confirmed the positive track, which he said has ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news