Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, January 28, 2021 05:37:59 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Lessons from Malaysian development

photo by

By
19th-Aug-2018       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Umme Tahira Sumiya :
Malaysia's economy is on its way to achieve high-income status. Its economy is resilient and continues to grow at a sustained pace despite external shocks. It is one of the most successful developing economies in the Asia-Pacific region, having achieved continuous high economic growth over several decades. Many of us believe that Bangladesh can take Malaysia as a development model and should follow the path and process of Malaysia to achieve the ultimate success. Reason behind this opinion is- In 1970s, economic condition of both Malaysia and Bangladesh was nearly same. Within almost 50 years Malaysia has been able to rank as one of the influential country based on raw materials (rubber and tin) to one that is among the strongest most diversified, and fastest-growing in South-east Asia. It is going to achieve its three decades periodic vision in year 2020. On the other hand, Bangladesh is on the peak of becoming middle income country. Bangladesh will be recognized as a middle-income nation if it achieves at least an average per capita income of $1,045 for three consecutive years. Bangladesh now aspires to be a middle-income nation by 2021, when the country will celebrate its 50th year of independence. A big question in the present time is, Should Bangladesh follow the path of Malaysia? Will it be good for Bangladesh to take Malaysia as a development model? To what extent Bangladesh can take lessons from Malaysia? How Malaysian model can help Bangladesh to achieve progress?
Before Starting discussion, we need to know about economic history of Malaysia as a nation. And also need to know how the sociological factors, ethnic composition, political environment, government policy and other subjects have contributed to figure the economic development of Malaysia. Then we will be able grant the idea of pursuing Malaysia as a development model.
Both Bangladesh and Malaysia were the British colony. To understand the situation, firstly need to think about the economic history of both Bangladesh and Malaysia at the beginning of their journey as a nation- the early years following these two countries independence from British. It is considered, as these two countries have achieved independence almost at the similar time period, after the Second World War, their initial condition was same. But, this consideration is unacceptable. Malaysia, a federal constitutional monarchy in Southeast Asia, achieved its independence in 1957. On the contrary, Bangladesh was shadow colony of Pakistan after the termination of British colonial period. In the colonial period the British oppressed and picked out resources from Indian Subcontinent but invested in Malaysia, especially on rubber and tin. The British desire was to protect their harvesting commodity product by keeping peace and political stability. Their economic interest was the driving force rather than a desire to govern. So, after independence, Malaysia had a prepared ground for investment by using natural resources.
The economy of Malaysia was predominantly an agricultural one. Majority of the population lived in rural areas. Prevalence of the poverty in the rural areas was the utmost. After independence first government of Malaysia has focused the poverty lying in rural areas and tried to improve not only the standard living of the majority, but also to increase political stability and social harmony. Government first focused on the making the most out of the fertile soil and rich metal and mineral resources, as a means of securing economic development and political stability. It is a worthy of remark that the economic development policies of the British for the Malay States had substantial influence on the social constitution and microeconomic configuration of the independent Malaysia. Nowadays the economy of Malaysia is the 4th largest in Southeast Asia and is the 38th largest economy in the world. Malaysian labour productivity is significantly higher than neighboring Thailand, Indonesia, Philippines or Vietnam due to a high density of knowledge-based industries and adoption of cutting edge technology for manufacturing and digital economy. According to the Global Competitiveness Report 2017, the Malaysian economy is the 23rd most competitive country in the world in the period of 2017-18.
Elsewhere, Bangladesh experienced tyrannical rule of the British and Pakistan over two hundred years. After the end of colonial and shadow colonial period, Bangladesh was worn out. It was difficult for Bangladesh to regain its losses. From that situation, at present the market-based economy of Bangladesh is the 43rd largest in the world in nominal terms, and 30nd largest by purchasing power parity; it is classified among the Next Eleven emerging market middle income economies and a Frontier market. According to the IMF, Bangladesh's economy is the second fastest growing major economy of 2016, with a rate of 7.1%.
Many other countries with similar history and social composition have not experienced the same success that Malaysia had. Main reason behind this was sharing of political power. Malaysian Government system was mainly authoritarian. State interference was in every arena of life. Yet Strict and effective leadership is thought to be the formula of Malaysian miraculous progress. Bangladesh experienced stratocracy and a significant number of revolutions took place after independence, one party led authoritarian government has not been endured for a long period.
The vast majority (about 98.5%) of Bangladeshis are of the Bengali ethno-linguistic group.
This group also spans the neighboring Indian province of West Bengal. Minority ethnic groups include Meitei, Tripura, Marma, Tanchangya, Barua, Khasi, Santhals, Chakma, Garo, Biharis, Oraons, Mundas and Rohingyas. The Bangladesh economy has long been dominated by the country's majority group, Bengali.
Here, has taken some policies to assimilate and upgrade the life of minority ethnic groups. Contrary, special opportunity is given to the Malays and the Bhumiputras who constitute the majority (about 60%) of the population. Once Malaysian economy has long been dominated by the country's Chinese and South Asian minorities. Since the early 1970s the government has championed a social and economic restructuring strategy, first known as the New Economic Policy (NEP) and later as the New Development Policy (NDP) that has sought to strike a balance between the goals of economic growth and the redistribution of wealth. The goal of the NEP and the NDP has been to endow the Malays and other indigenous groups with greater economic opportunities and to develop their management and entrepreneurial skills.
Malaysia has to make balance among its region according to need. In spite of ethnic variations and rigidities they formed an all-party coalition. They did prioritize the ethnic and communal assimilation through forming one-party-led government system. All party alliance, Barisan National whose members are ethnic based political parties such as UMNO, MCA and MIC, champions the ethnic groups they represent. This ethnic aspirations and expectations about growth and development have become an important factor in Malaysian policy formation. Political parties' interests are different according to ethnicity. Though it appears the policies were subjective towards the Malays, other portion of ethnicity had not been excluded or if to some extent they were deprived of, strong and authoritative leadership didn't allow anyone to oppose federal constitutional monarchy system of government. The NEP had attempted to assist the Malays and Bumiputras for socio-economic development, also aim to expand and modernize the economy so as to benefit all ethnic groups.
Malaysia is a multi-ethnic society but non-communicative because of language, occupational and cultural segregation. Since the socio-economic structure of Malaysia before and after independence is ethnically divided, it is not surprising that politics, responding to this reality, is also organized on this basis. Malays are mainly farmer. On the contrary, to exploit the natural resources of Malaysia the British hired cheap labor from India to work in their rubber estates and from china to work in the various tin mines. Because of above differences competition in economic sector is rarely seen in. Certainly, Malaysian government has taken some privatization policies to enhance the competition among these tri-ethnic groups for the betterment of the country. In Bangladesh, because of language, occupational and cultural similarity competition in economic sector is a common incidence. Even so, government has occupied several privatization process to augment growth.
Total amount of GDP of Bangladesh (around $30bl) is very much lower than total amount of GDP of Malaysia (around $ 300bl). Following financial express, Income inequality in Bangladesh has widened further despite decline in the rate of poverty, dropping to 24.3 per cent last year from 31.5 per cent six years back. The BBS survey finds Bangladesh's extreme poverty having also declined to 12.9 per cent of the total population in 2016 from 17.6 per cent in 2010. According to the HIES 2016, the income inequality in the urban areas has risen faster than in the rural areas.
According to the UNDP 1997 Human Development Report and the 2004 United Nations Human Development (UNHDP) report Malaysia has the highest income disparity between the rich and poor in Southeast Asia, greater than that of Philippines, Thailand, Singapore, Vietnam and Indonesia. The UNHDP Report shows that the richest 10% in Malaysia control 38.4% of the economic income as compared to the poorest 10% who control only 1.7%. However, according to official statistics from the Prime Minister's Department, inequality has been decreasing steadily since 1970 and the Gini-coefficient dropping. Where the report of HIES shows that Gini co-efficient, which is used to measure income inequality, in Bangladesh has increased to 0.483 at national level in 2016 from 0.458 in 2010 meaning that the rich became richer while the poor poorer during the period.
Malaysia is an Islamic country. But Islamic party is not allowed in their alliance. Religion based conflict is not extreme in Malaysia like Bangladesh. Religion based politics is amalgamated with the birth history of Bangladesh. Religious conflict is a common phenomenon in here. But Malaysian government has forbidden this extremism, strongly handled ethnic tension. Rule of law, high rate of quality public expenditure, privatization process, strong political devise for controlling ethnic tension were some of the most important achievements of Malaysian policy. Malaysian government has also been condemned for negligible freedom of speech, Social tensions, crimes, extremism, patronization, polarization, for implementing trickle down process.
Bangladesh has its own history, tradition, demography, geography, ethnicity, socio-economic dimension. It has own development policy considering the overall scenario of country. If Bangladesh want to take Malaysia as a development model, What Bangladesh can take from Malaysian experiences are effective leadership, rule of law, quality public expenditure - especially in education and health, social stability, forbidding extremism. Only economic growth with high rate of income inequality cannot be the indicator of effective development policy. Envisaging the entire situations, Bangladesh can follow the positive features of Malaysia only if can accept Malaysian treatments in the framework of Bangladesh. If Bangladesh follow the Malaysian development blindly, instead of any judgment, will not be able to reach in the eventual destination and ultimately development will be considered as curse.

(Umme Tahira Sumiya is a 3rd year student of Development Studies, University of Dhaka)

Tariff
Ibn Sina
Sonali
ACME
Estern_H
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Cricket »

Mehidy gains big in ODI Rankings


Bangladesh spinner Mehidy Hasan Miraz and Ireland all-rounder Paul Stirling have made notable gains in the MRF Tyres ICC Men's ODI Player Rankings after some fine performances in the ICC Men's Cricket World Cup Super League.Off-spinner Mehidy was the most successful bowler in the series against the West Indies which ...

Editorial »

Study groups not needed to understand what causes supply crisis


REPORT in a national daily on Wednesday said stockpile of rice, potatoes and onion remains big issues as the government so far measures failed to fix their supply and keep the prices stable. It said three study groups initiated by the government in October found that rice and potatoes prices ...

Business & Economy »

Mohammed Monirul Moula, Managing Director and CEO of Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited (IBBL) and Engineer Taqsem A Khan, Managing Director of Dhaka WASA, exchanging an agreement signing document at Hotel InterContinentalDhaka on Wednesday. Under the deal, clients of DWASA will be facilitated to pay the water and sewerage bills through branches, sub-branches and internet banking of IBBL. Muhammad Qaisar Ali, Md. Omar Faruk Khan, AMDs, Taher Ahmed Chowdhury, Md. Mosharraf Hossain, DMDs, Mohammad Jamal Uddin Mazumder, Md. Altaf Hossain, SEVPs, Md. Mizanur Rahman Bhuiyan, EVP of the bank and Muhammad Ibrahim, Additional Secretary (Water Supply Wing), Local Govt. Division and Engineer Uttam Kumar Roy, Commercial Manager of DWASA along with top executives and officials of both organizations were present.


.

International »

Nigerian President Buhari replaces top military commanders


Al Jazeera :Nigerian President Muhammadu Buhari has replaced the country's top military commanders after months of pressure over his response to the worsening security situation in the country.Leo Irabor was named to the powerful Chief of Defence Staff post, which oversees the main military branches, the spokesman for the presidency ...

City »

Artist Syed Lutful Haque passes away


Syed Lutful Haque, artist and member of National Press Club, passed away at a city hospital early on Wednesday. He was 72.He breathed his last at 5.30am at Dhaka Medical College and Hospital (DMCH), said a press release.He left behind two sons, numerous relatives, friends, colleagues and well wishers to ...

Editorial »

World leaders must think of growing inequality to rescue millions from hunger


BILLIONAIRES including Amazon's Jeff Bezos and Tesla founder Elon Musk have seen their wealth soar during the COVID-19 pandemic while the world's poor face years of hardship, charity Oxfam said on Monday as it demanded steps to tackle inequality.Nations have a "shrinking window of opportunity" to build a fair, green ...

Entertainment »

Priyanka regrets endorsing fairness creams


Actor Priyanka Chopra has spoken about the hostility she experienced after endorsing skin-whitening creams in India. She stopped participating in such campaigns after moving to Hollywood. In a new profile, she spoke about how normal it is for Indian actors to endorse fairness creams, a topic that she will explore ...

Entertainment »

Mizan lends voice to Mustafiz Shafi’s lyrics


Entertainment Report :Popular singer Mizan has lent his voice to a song titled Mon Kharap Meye recently. The lyrics of the song have been written by noted poet and journalist Mustafiz Shafi. The track has been released on YouTube under the banner of Dhruba Music Station recently. Has been composed ...

International »

At Least 21 dead, 33 injured in Southern Brazil bus accident


The Rio Times  :At least 21 people were killed and 33 injured, with seven in critical condition, after a bus crashed on Monday, January 25th, in the southern Brazilian state of Paraná, the Military Police Air Operations Battalion (BPMOA) reported.According to the BPMOA, which initially reported 10 dead and six ...

International »

Xi Jinping warns leaders against 'new Cold War'


AFP, Beijing :Chinese President Xi Jinping yesterday warned global leaders at an all-virtual Davos forum against starting a "new Cold War", and urged global unity in the face of the coronavirus pandemic.Having largely curbed the spread of the pandemic within its borders, Xi wants to position China as a key ...

Cricket »

Tamim expects tougher challenge from WI Test team


BSS, Chattogram :Despite sweeping the three-match ODI series against West Indies with incredible ease, Bangladesh opener Tamim Iqbal is expecting a tough challenge from the Caribbean side in the longer version format.Bangladesh won the three matches by a comprehensive margin of six wickets, seven wickets and 120 runs respectively.Tamim, the ...

Business & Economy »

The IBN SINA Pharmaceutical Industry Ltd." has won the ICSB National Award-2019 for Corporate Governance Excellence in Services Companies category. Managing Director of the organisation received award from The Commerce Minister Mr. Tipu Munshi at The Radission Blu Water Garden hotel in the city recently.


The IBN SINA Pharmaceutical Industry Ltd." has won the ICSB National Award-2019 for Corporate Governance Excellence in Services Companies category. Managing Director of the organisation received award from The Commerce Minister Mr. Tipu Munshi at The Radission Blu Water Garden hotel in the city recently.

Business & Economy »

EHL won ICSB National Award for Corporate Governance Excellence


Online DeskEastern Housing Limited (EHL) has won the ICSB National Award-2019 (Silver Award) for Corporate Governance Excellence in Services Companies category. Dr. Khondakar Shokat Hossain, Dy.  Managing Director (extreme left) and AKM Sahadat Hossain Majumder Sr. Executive Director (extreme right) of the company received the award from the Commerce Minister Mr. Tipu Munshi, MP and ...

International »

Indian farmers ride caravan of tractors into capital ahead of Republic Day


Reuters New Delhi :Caravans of tractors clogged a key highway in northern India on Monday as tens of thousands of farmers protesting against agriculture reforms streamed into the capital ahead of celebrations for Republic Day.India marks its founding as a republic on Tuesday with a military parade in the historic ...

Football »

Fernandes gem knocks Liverpool out of FA Cup, Chelsea ease pressure on Lampard


AFP, London :Bruno Fernandes' superb free-kick sent troubled Liverpool crashing out of the FA Cup as Manchester United beat their bitter rivals 3-2 in the fourth round, while Tammy Abraham's hat-trick eased the pressure on Chelsea manager Frank Lampard in a win over Luton on Sunday.Fernandes struck with 12 minutes ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news