Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, November 18, 2018 07:18:37 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Quashing proceeding of case pending before the court below

By
08th-Sep-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

High Court Division :
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Moyeenul Islam
Chowdhury J
Md Ashraful Kamal J
AKM Zakaria Hossain
Choudhury ..... Petitioner
vs
Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Dhaka and
others     Respondents
Judgment
Judgment, May 21,st, 2018
Constitution of Bangladesh, 1972
Article 102(2)
For quashing the proceedings of complaint case pending before the Court below, the proper remedy for the accused-petitioner lies in the miscellaneous jurisdiction of the High Court Division under Section 561 A of the Code. As the petitioner has failed to cross the threshold of the writ jurisdiction of the High Court Division under Article 102 of the Constitution, we refrain from making any observation on the mens rea or any other dimension of the case touching upon its merit.  (17)
Cost
As it is a thoughtless, slapdash and frivolous application, some exemplary costs should be imposed on the accused-petitioner. The writ petition is rejected in limine with costs of Taka 50,000 (fifty thousand) only . ...... (18 & 19)
Shafiqul Islam (Md) vs Bangladesh, 68 DLR 283; Bangladesh vs Iqbal Hasan Mahmood alias Iqbal Hasan Mahmood Tuku, 60 DLR (AD) 147 Jahangir Hossain Howlader(Md) vs CMM, Dhaka 58 DLR 106; Chairman, Anti-Corruption Commission vs Enayetur Rahman, 64 DLR (AD) 14; Golam Nabi vs Anti-Corruption Commission, 65 DLR 181 and Anti-Corruption Commission vs  Mehedi Hasan, 67 DLR (AD) 137 ref.
Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury Advocate-For the Petitioner.
Md Motaher Hossain (Sazu) DAG with Muhammad Jaber,  DAG with Purabi Rani Sharma, AAG with Purabi Saha, AAG and Md Mizanur Rahman. AAG-For the Respondents.
Judgment
Moyeenul Islam Chowdhury J :  Let the supplementary-affidavit do form part of the main application.
2. This is an application under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People's Republic  of Bangladesh.
3. Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner, submits that the petitioner is an accused in Complaint Case No. 367 of 2018 under Section 138 read with Section 140 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 filed by the respondent no. 2 complainant, now pending before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Dhaka.
4. Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury also submits that the offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is not a strict liability offence and that being so, the petitioner can set up defence pleas, if any, during the trial of the case. In support of this submission, Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury relies on the decision in the case of Shafiqul Islam (Md) vs Bangladesh reported in 68 DLR 283.
5. Mr Junayc Ahmed Chowdhury further submits that mens rea or criminal intent is an essential ingredient of any criminal offence; but stunningly enough, no mens rea was pleaded in the petition of complaint which was lodged with the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate of Dhaka and, as such, the Complaint Case No. 367 of 2018 cannot be proceeded with and in this perspective, the proceedings of the case are liable to be quashed. To buttress up this submission, Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury adverts to the decision in the case of Sunil Bharti Mittal and 3 others vs State of UP which was rendered by the Lucknow Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, India on 9-2-2017.
6. Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury next submits that the accused-petitioner did not invoke the criminal miscellaneous jurisdiction of the High Court Division under Section 561 A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 with a view to quashing the proceedings of the case and instead he has come up with the present Writ Petition for quashing the proceedings of the case, regard being had to the decision in the case of the Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh vs Iqbal Hasan Mahmood alias Iqbal Hasan Mahmood Tuku reported in 60 DLR (AD) 147.
7. Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury also submits that a Division Bench of the High Court Division has already held in the case of Jahangir Hossain Howlader (Md) vs CMM, Dhaka reported in 58 DLR 106  filing of an application under Section 561 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is not an adequate alternative remedy as contemplated under Article 102(2) of the Constitution and by that reason, he has invoked the writ jurisdiction of the High Court Division under Article 102 of the Constitution and on that score, the Writ Petition is maintainable.
8. We have heard the submissions of the learned Advocate Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury and perused the Writ Petition, Supplementary Affidavit and relevant Annexures annexed thereto.
9. Indisputably the Cognizance Court No. 27 of Dhaka Metropolitan Magistracy took cognizance of the offence punishable under Section 138 read with Section 140 of the Negotiable Instruments Act on 18-2-2018 on the basis of the petition of complaint lodged by the respondent no. 2 complainant under Section 190(1 )(a) of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Court summoned the petitioner to appear before it on 17-4-2018. But the accused-petitioner did not appear before the Court below on 17-4-2018 as summoned; rather he surrendered before the Court of first instance on 13-5-2018 and was enlarged on bail. Anyway, what is curious is that without submission of the petitioner to the jurisdiction of the lower Court, the constituted attorney of the petitioner sworn the affidavit of the instant Writ Petition on 18-3-2018. It is ex-facie clear that at that point of time, the petitioner was a fugitive from law.
10. What we are driving at boils down to this: without submitting to the jurisdiction of the Court below, the accused-petitioner, or for that matter, his attorney cannot swear any affidavit in support of the Writ Petition before this Court. In this regard, we reiterate that it is a settled proposition of law that a fugitive from law is not entitled to get any relief from any Court of law. This practice of swearing any affidavit by any accused or his attorney while the accused is still at large cannot be countenanced at all. We strongly deprecate this practice. On this count alone, the accused petitioner cannot cross the threshold of the writ jurisdiction of the High Court Division under Article 102 of the Constitution.
11. In the case of the Chairman, Anti- Corruption Commission vs, Enayetur Rqhmar: reported in 64 DLR (AD) 14, it has been spelt out in paragraph 7:
"7. This Court on repeated occasions argued that Article 102(2) of the Constitution is not meant to circumvent the statutory procedures. The High Court Division will not allow a litigant to invoke the extra-ordinary
jurisdiction to be converted into Courts of appeal or revision. It is only where statutory remedies are entirely ill-suited to meet the demands of extra-ordinary situations, that is to, say, where vires of a statute is in question or where the determination is mala fide or where any action is taken by the executives in contravention of the principles of, natural justice or where the fundamental right of a citizen has been affected by an act or where the statute is intra vires, but the action taken is without jurisdiction and the vindication of public justice requires that recourse may be had to Article 102(2) of the Constitution."
12. The facts and circumstances as stated in the present Writ Petition, according to us, do not attract any of the extra-ordinary situations that have been specified in Paragraph 7 of the decision reported in 64 DLR (AD) 14.
13. In the decision in the case of Golam Nabi vs Anti-Corruption Commission reported in 65 DLR 181, it has been clearly, unambiguously, categorically and unmistakably held that the decision reported in 64 DLR (AD) 14 has ousted the jurisdiction of the writ Court to quash the proceedings of a criminal case unless the 'vires' of any law is found to have been challenged.
14. In the decision in the case of Anti-Corruption Commission vs Mehedi Hasan reported in 67 DLR (AD) 137, it has been observed in paragraph 27 that there is no scope for quashing a criminal proceeding under the writ jurisdiction, under Article 102 of the Constitution unless the 'vires' of the law involved is challenged.
15. Admittedly the 'vires' of any of the provisions of the Negotiable Instruments Act has not been challenged in the Writ Petition before us. So the question of quashing the proceedings of Complaint Case No. 367 of 2018, now pending before the Court below, is out of the question.
16. Mr Junayed Ahmed Chowdhury has emphatically relied upon the decision in the case of the Government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh vs Iqbal Hasan Mahmood alias Iqbal Hasan Mahmood Tuku reported in 60 DLR (AD) 147 for his 'standing' under Article 102 of the Constitution. We have gone through that decision with a tine tooth-comb. It does not transpire that the decision reported in 60 DLR (AD) 147 and the decision reported in 67 DLR (AD) 137 are fundamentally, perceptively and notionally conflicting to each other. In the facts and circumstances of the case reported in 60 DLR (AD) 147, the Appellate Division maintained the 'standing' of the writ petitioner under Article 102 of the Constitution. But reverting to the case in hand, we 'find that the decision reported in 60 DLR (AD) 147 has no manner of application ; rather the decision reported in 67 DLR (AD) 137 fits in therewith.
17. From the foregoing discussions, it is abundantly clear that for quashing the proceedings of Complaint Case No. 367 of 2018, now pending before the Court below, the proper remedy for the accused-petitioner lies in the miscellaneous jurisdiction of the High Court Division under Article 561A of the Code of Criminal Procedure. As the petitioner has failed to cross the threshold of the writ jurisdiction of the High Court Division under Article 102 of the Constitution, we refrain from making  any observation on the mens rea or any other dimension of the case touching upon its merit.-
18. As it is a thoughtless, slapdash and frivolous application, some exemplary costs should be imposed on the accused-petitioner.
For all the reasons stated above, the writ petition is rejected in limine with costs of Taka 50,000 (fifty thousand) only.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

Neymar penalty punishes Uruguay in feisty friendly


Neymar kept his cool to score the controversial penalty that fired Brazil to a 1-0 win over Uruguay in a full-blooded friendly on Friday.Brazil captain Neymar was subjected to some ferocious fouls from Uruguay as the clash between the South American rivals boiled over at Arsenal's Emirates Stadium.But the Paris ...

Cricket »

Shakib returns as BCB announces squad for 1st Test against WI


The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) on Saturday announced the squad for the first Test of two-match series against the West Indies (WI) with ace all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan returned to the squad.Another big-name inclusion in the squad is Soumya Sarkar, whose last Test appearance came on the tour of South ...

Editorial »

Pro-people police is the demand of time


THE Police Investigation Bureau (PIB) has unveiled the mystery behind a spine-chilling crime where a middle-aged woman passenger was killed inside a running bus at Ashulia in the outskirts of Dhaka city. It took hardly seven days for them to crack the case. Police have already arrested the murderers along ...

International »

US opposes UN resolution condemning Israel's occupation of Golan Heights


AFP, United Nations :For the first time, the United States voted Friday against an annual UN resolution condemning Israel's occupation of the Golan Heights, dropping its practice of abstaining in the vote.The non-binding resolution was adopted in a General Assembly committee by a vote of 151 to 2, with the ...

Entertainment »

Aupee Karim returning to big screen


Entertainment Desk :Actress Aupee Karim is returning to the big screen after 15 years , with a film titled "Debris of Desire."Aupee made her debut in cinema with Mostofa Sarwar Farooki's 'Bachelor,' for which the actor won the Bangladesh National Film Award for Best Actress in 2004. The film is ...

City »

BFUJ Secretary General Saban Mahmud receiving posthumous 'Ratnagarva Ma Gold Medal-2018' on behalf of his mother Momtaj Salam at a ceremony organised by Society for Enlightening Nation (SOFEN) in the auditorium of the Institution of Diploma Engineers, Bangladesh in the city on Friday.


Editorial »

Only condemnation not enough, ensure safe return of Rohingyas to Myanmar


US Vice-President Mike Pence expressed the Trump administration's strongest condemnation about Myanmar's treatment towards Rohingya Muslims. He told Aung San Suu Kyi that "persecution" by Myanmar's military was "without excuse" in a meeting with her on November14. Mr Pence also pressed Suu Kyi to pardon two Reuters journalists who were ...

City »

Former Parliament Member of Moulvibazar-2 constituency MM Shaheen joined Juktofront by giving bouquets to Juktofront Chief Prof Dr AQM Badruddoza Chowdhury at the party office in the city's Baridhara on Friday.


.

Football »

Croatia stun Spain as Jedvaj strikes twice to keep hopes alive


AFP, Zagreb :Spain passed up the chance to seal progress to the Nations League finals as they were beaten 3-2 by Croatia on Thursday, undone by a 93rd-minute winner from Tin Jedvaj.Jedvaj's late strike leaves Group 4 wide open ahead of its final fixture between England and Croatia on Sunday. ...

Entertainment »

Deepika-Ranveer wedding: First pics of the gorgeous couple spell magic


Deepika Padukone and Ranveer Singh got married at the picturesque locale of Lake Como in Italy. The much-in-love duo got married in a traditional Konkani wedding ceremony on November 14 and today solemnised their wedding as per Sindhi tradition. After managing to keep their wedding pictures well-guarded, the couple has ...

International »

May fights for survival after Brexit deal sparks crisis


Reuters, London : British Prime Minister Theresa May was fighting for survival on Friday after a draft divorce deal with the European Union provoked the resignations of senior ministers and mutiny in her party.More than two years after the United Kingdom voted to leave the EU, it is still unclear how, ...

Editorial »

Mass awareness needed if NBR wants more people under tax net


THE countrywide 'Income Tax Fair -2018' has already drawn a huge crowd. The authorities hope more people would be brought under tax net this year too. Finance Minister AMA Muhith while inaugurating the fair said out of country's 16 crore population, the number of taxpayers is around one crore. There ...

International »

US could lose war against Russia or China, warns panel


AP, Washington :The United States military has "lost its edge" and could potentially lose a war against Russia or China, a report by a bipartisan panel established by Congress says.The report by the National Defense Strategy Commission on November 14 said U.S. military superiority has "eroded to a dangerous degree" ...

Football »

Switzerland`s Kevin Mbabu (left) is challenged by Qatar's Abdelkarim Hassan during an international friendly soccer match between Switzerland and Qatar at the Cornaredo stadium in Lugano, Switzerland on Wednesday.


.

City »

Bangabandhu Sangskritik Jote formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Thursday in protest against setting fire on police van in front of the BNP Central Office in the city's Nayapalton.


.

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news