Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, June 27, 2019 01:29:54 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Hate speech destroying political discourse

By
11th-Sep-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Martin Leng :
Hate-mongering such as this brings to mind the worst chapters of human history. Indeed, in Europe, such angry, fearful attitudes are nothing new - they have been dusted off time and again in the service of demagogues and dictators. They are the spark which ignited a thousand pogroms. They are paving stones on the path to Auschwitz.
It is, therefore, a source of great sadness to see such words on the pages of Facebook and Twitter - modern tools of openness and dialogue in the service of tired old prejudice. Not only because they remind us of the worst of humanity, but because words such as these have terrible consequences.
Recently published research has uncovered parallels between hate-fuelled Facebook posts and an increase in racially-motivated attacks on refugees in Germany, with material from the German Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) party page under the spotlight.
This was starkly illustrated by new research highlighted by EurActiv in August. It found a correlation between instances of xenophobic comments on social media and real-world violence targeting refugees and migrants. "The most common incidents include damage to refugee housing, assaults, anti-refugee demonstrations and arson attacks," according to the findings.
And while this particular analysis focused on Germany, the problem is truly European in scale. This begs the question: should the response be European, too? For better or for worse, the EU is closely associated with migration policy in the public consciousness - and given the current "blood and soil" political discourse in many of its member states, Brussels can hardly rely on some national capitals to address hate speech with any seriousness.
The EU has already taken some tentative steps towards addressing the issue. In May 2016, it brokered the agreement of a "code of conduct on countering illegal hate speech online," signed by Microsoft, Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. Other digital giants have since added their names, and the initiative has seen some progress, with 70% of hate speech flagged up by users being removed. The Commission has also made (limited) funding available for civil society projects aimed at countering violent and dehumanising speech on the internet. But the challenge is about more than just securing private sector buy-in, or hopeful grantmaking. The rise of online hate speech is a symptom of a wider malaise in public life, epitomised by a retreat into partisan echo chambers and mass distrust in the "establishment".
Increasingly, we shout over those who hold different points of view and regard inconvenient facts as biased or even conspiratorial. EU Justice Commissioner Vera Jourová stood by the EU's principles that freedom of speech was not absolute at a panel discussion held in Brussels, saying that attempts to regulate hate speech were justified but her comments prompted a fierce debate.
Like hate speech itself, such impulses are nothing new, but the algorithms and anonymity of the internet have surely aggravated the situation massively. It's for sociologists to determine whether Facebook and Twitter provoked this deterioration in our public life, or merely facilitated the rot. But in any case, Pandora's Box has been opened and we can't turn the clock back to an age of analogue civility. So what to do?
In his recent report, David Kaye - the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression - suggests moving away from so-called "viewpoint regulation" on the internet.
Yes, calling for the gassing of refugees on Facebook is repugnant - but a great deal of online xenophobia is less explicit, and it's hard to draw a clear line between so many shades of grey. Defining hate speech is a subjective endeavour, and Kaye warns that we run the risk of censorship by casting the net too widely.
Instead, he argues for more clarity about what is and is not acceptable, and encourages the EU to further invest in civil society organisations which support the "development of positive narratives and critical thinking".
The idea, then, is to win the arguments instead of stifling them. A great example of this is the Swedish #jagärhär ("I am here") movement, a thousands-strong network of volunteers who "drown out" hate speech on social media with positive messages and links to facts which disprove xenophobic statements. Refuting hate speech with empirical evidence and dialogue will not put an end to anti-migrant hatred - neither on your Twitter feed, nor in real life.
(Martin Leng is the Communications Coordinator for the Quaker Council of European Affairs (QCEA), based in Brussels. QCEA advocates for peace building and human rights in Europe on behalf of tens of thousands of Quakers across the continent).

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Cricket »

Clive Lloyd calls for West Indies tons to match talent after World Cup woe


Clive Lloyd has called on the current crop of West Indies cricketers to add application to their talent after a disappointing World Cup campaign so far.The West Indies have won just one of their opening six games in England and look almost certain to miss out on the semi-finals."West Indies ...

Business & Economy »

NRBC launches mobile banking app "Planet"


Staff Reporter :NRB Commercial Bank (NRBC) Limited on Wednesday launched its mobile banking app "NRBC PLANET" to bring comfort and mobility in the banking services. The app was launched at a ceremony held at the bank's head office in the city.Sheikh Fazle Fahim, President of FBCCI, attended the ceremony as ...

Entertainment »

Kona again as judge in a reality show


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Last year RTV started a new reality show titled Campus Star to discover talented youngsters in music, dance and acting. This year its new season is set to kick off soon. Popular singer Dilshad Nahar Kona will be also seen playing the role of a judge in ...

Entertainment »

No love triangle in Dabangg 3: Sonakshi Sinha


Actress Sonakshi Sinha, who is reprising her role as Rajjo in Dabangg 3, says there will be no love triangle in the upcoming instalment of the movie. Sonakshi spoke about it at the launch of salon brand Streax Professional’s retro remix collection on Monday. There has been buzz that Dabangg ...

Editorial »

Keep liver transplant affordable


IN the latest development, surgeons at Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib Medical University have successfully performed liver transplant at a government hospital for the first time. Media on Tuesday reported that, a team of 50 doctors conducted simultaneous surgeries on a 20-year-old man and his 47-year-old mother, who donated a portion of ...

International »

Shocking photos of drowned Salvadoran father and child spark outrage


AFP, Ciudad Victoria, Mexico :Shocking images of a drowned Salvadoran migrant and his two-year-old daughter who died while trying to cross the Rio Grande river from Mexico to the United States have sparked outrage, underscoring the dangers faced by asylum-seekers.Twenty-five-year-old Oscar Martinez Ramirez fled El Salvador with his 21-year-old wife ...

International »

Iran 'never seeks war' with US, says Rouhani


AFP :Iran "never seeks war" with the United States, President Hassan Rouhani said as he sought to rein in soaring tensions Wednesday between the two countries."Iran has no interest to increase tension in the region and it never seeks war with any country, including (the) US," the president said, quoted ...

Cricket »

Shakib now eying to beat India


Bangladesh ace all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan knows, beating an inform India will be a tough proposition but he refuses to give up hopes, saying that they would come all guns blazing against the sub-continent giants when they take them on July 2 at Birmingham.After reviving the side's semifinal hope, beating ...

International »

Venezuela's former spy chief says Maduro could yet fall


AFP :Venezuela's former intelligence chief, Cristopher Figuera, who fled the country after backing a failed uprising against President Nicolas Maduro in April, has told the Washington Post the regime could still fall."I'm proud of what I did," he said in an interview published online late Monday. "For now, the regime ...

International »

Russian, North American astronauts return to earth


AFP :The first crew to blast off to the International Space Station following a launch accident that deepened doubts over Russia's space programme returned to earth safely on Tuesday.NASA astronaut Anne McClain, veteran cosmonaut Oleg Kononenko of Roscosmos, and Canadian Space Agency record-holder David Saint-Jacques emerged from the space craft ...

Editorial »

Food adulteration business must stop


RESEARCHERS at Dhaka University on Tuesday said all the samples of milk products; edible oils and spices they tested were substandard. According to newspaper reports, they have found traces of detergent in pasteurised milk produced by five companies -- Pran, Milk Vita, Igloo, Aarong, and Farm Fresh. The DU researchers ...

Entertainment »

Mimi`s heartwarming wish for newly-wed Nusrat


No wonder Nusrat Jahan and Nikhil Jain's destination wedding in the picturesque town of Bodrum in Turkey became the talk of the town over the last two weeks. Tolly actress and newly elected MP Nusrat got hitched to Kolkata-based businessman Nikhil Jain on June 19. It was a cosy family ...

Editorial »

Train accident: Responsible persons must be punished


AT least five people, including three women, were killed and more than 100 injured as the Upaban Express -- a passenger train heading to the capital from Sylhet -- derailed on a bridge in Moulvibazar on Sunday night. One of the carriages of it fell into a canal while two ...

Entertainment »

Shirin Shila`s Lady Action


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :With the inspiration and assistance from noted film actress Rasheda Chowdhury Shirin Shila started her journey in film industry. Before starting acting in big screen Shila acted with Rasheda Chowdhury in a drama. Basically Rasheda Chowdhury inspired Shila to work in movie. Once she also introduced Shila ...

Cricket »

Shakib first Bangladeshi batsman to complete 1000 WC runs


Talismanic all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan became the first Bangladeshi batsman to complete 1000 runs in the World Cup during the match against Afghanistan at the Rose Bowl in Southampton on Monday.Starting the match with 965 runs and 35 runs shy of achieve the feat, Shakib flicked pace bowler Dawlat Zadran ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news