Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Tuesday, December 11, 2018 06:36:46 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Foreign Aid: A blessing (or a curse) in disguise?

photo by

By
12th-Oct-2018       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Lutfay Tariq Rahman &  Tanzid Nahid Mustafa Sundrin  :
Very recently both the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank have offered ‘financial aid’ to support Bangladesh with the Rohingya refugee crisis. Though it is unclear whether the aid will be provided in the form of grant or loan. Another issue is the signing of the 3rd Line of Credit (LoC) between India and Bangladesh worth $4.5 billion on October 4, 2017. So, there will be lots of capital inflow. However, in reality how much of these financial assistance help us? It is a much discussed and debated topic. Foreign Aid- a term much coined by the people of developing countries is the influx of financial assistance to developing countries from their developed counterparts. It is provided bilaterally or multilaterally in the form of grants, loans or technical assistance. Theoretically, it is provided to enhance the well-being of the recipient country’s citizens. However, in reality expected progress is hindered, and desired target not achieved. Effectiveness of aid is challenged all through the way from the time it is sanctioned till it is used to bring expected development. To highlight some of the few there is delay in loan processing and bureaucratic corruption. In return, countries receiving aid loose economic freedom become dependent and per capita debt increases. In Bangladesh in the year 2007 per head debt obligation was $144 and this year it rises to $169.
In the last two decades there has been a shift in investment from social sectors to infrastructural developments. In most cases, loan sanctions decisions between the donor-recipients involves less informed officials of the latter and therefore, in the long run the recipient country’s citizens become dependent on donation and are subject to domination and exploitation. Moreover, many of us are unaware of the underlying terms and conditions attached to loans and grants, and often foreign experts are hired with high salary to implement the projects. These foreigners are often not aware of the Bangladeshi context of working and interest of the locals.
Since the year 2010, Bangladesh and India have signed 3 Lines of Credit (LoC) worth 7.5 billion US Dollars. But Bangladesh’s utilization of Indian lines of credit has been nothing more than a sorry state of affairs in the past seven years. Till now, only $576 million have been used. Under the Lines of Credit Bangladesh would have to purchase 65 to 75 per cent of the goods and services from the Indian market. The credits carry a 1 per cent interest rate with repayment period of twenty years and a grace period of five years. And only Indian bidders can participate in projects implemented under Indian dollar credit and from now on, EXIM Bank will send a list of 10 to 12 Indian bidders to Bangladesh and the competitive bidding will take place among them. So, locals end up working as sub-contractors in our own country, despite being competent. The toughest and the least profitable part of any work are done by the natives, though we have a pool of talented young generation to support us in higher positions .Additionally, ranks have privileges. Also, in the 1st LoC, there was a condition that Bangladesh has to use Indian bricks for various projects.
The major findings by Paul Mosley, Professor of Economics at the University of Sheffield and others conclude that it is not possible to get any significant correlation between aid and growth rate of GNP in developing countries. One reason for this is the leakage of the aid into unproductive expenditure in the public sector. However, at a micro level, all donor agencies regularly report the success of most of their projects and programs. This contrast is known as the ‘micro-macro’ paradox. Mosley’s result was further confirmed by Peter Boone who argued that aid is ineffective because it tends to finance consumption rather than investments. Boone also affirmed the micro-macro paradox. Noted Zambian economist Dambisa Moyo has been a fierce critic to development aid, and calls it ‘the single worst decision of modern developmental politics.’ Her famous book ‘Dead Aid’ shows how aid has encouraged corruption, aid-dependency and how a series of detrimental economic policies have hindered development in Africa. She argues that foreign aid provides a windfall to governments which can encourage extreme forms of rent-seeking and through providing a positive shock of revenue, lead to ‘Dutch Disease.’ In economics, the ‘Dutch Disease’ is the apparent causal relationship between the increase in the economic development of a specific sector and a decline in other sectors. The mechanism is that as revenues increase in the growing sector (or inflows of foreign aid), the given nation’s currency becomes stronger (appreciates) compared to currencies of other nations. This results in the nations other exports becoming more expensive for other countries to buy, and imports becoming cheaper, making those sectors less competitive. And eventually this will lower a country’s competitiveness in international business and trade.
Now, the question is how to use aid in a more effective way. The Accra Agenda for Action states that transparency and accountability are essential ingredients for development results. Mutual accountability and transparency is one of the five partnership commitments of the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness. Through ‘transparency,’ donors and recipients can be held accountable for what they spend and aid can be made more effective by knowing the three Ws’ of transparency: Who gives money to which recipient? What project is being funded and for what purpose? And where is the money provided?
One challenge for assessing the effectiveness of aid is that not all aid is intended to generate economic growth. Some aid is intended for humanitarian purposes; some may simply improve the standard of living of people in developing countries. Therefore, to make aid effective it is imperative to have sound institutions and economic policies (i.e. open trade, fiscal and monetary discipline), accountable governance and self-sufficient capacity building.
Bangladesh has been receiving foreign aid since independence. Its contribution is evident from rebuilding a war-torn country, alleviating poverty to preventing diseases.
However, as we as a nation is stepping towards upper-middle income economy, we should attract foreign investments rather than being dependant on foreign aid, and also make proper use of our strategic resources in technologically feasible ways .
These will help us to have a self sustained economy, integrate the poor and also help a larger group of youth population become employed, who can work as representatives and in accordance to the interests of our mass population.

(Writers are students of Master's in Development Studies, Department of Development Studies, University of Dhaka)

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Entertainment »

Airin in web series for first time


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Celebrities are showing their keen interest to work in web series. For this reason, they are working one after another in web series. Viewers are also showing their interest to enjoy these worldwide. Film actress Airin has include her name in the list working in web series. ...

Editorial »

Ensure justice for rape victims and protect the witnesses


SPEAKERS at a conference demanded enactment of the Witness Protection Bill which was drafted in 2006 by the Law Commission aimed at ensuring security of rape victims and witnesses. They made the demand at a national conference on "Rape law Reform", organised by Bangladesh Legal Aid and Services Trust (BLAST), ...

Cricket »

India end 10-year win drought in Australia first Test nail-biter


AFP, Adelaid :India won their first Test on Australian soil in a decade Monday, bowling out the home side in a nail- biting finale to clinch the opening match of the series at Adelaide Oval with Rishabh Pant equalling a world-record along the way.The hosts were set an improbable target ...

Football »

Serie A golden boy Icardi looking to shine on bigger stage


AFP, Milan :Argentina striker Mauro Icardi is the golden boy of Italian football as much for his goal-scoring prowess with Inter Milan as his colourful lifestyle off the pitch.The heavily tattooed 25-year-old from Rosario - also the hometown of Lionel Messi - followed the same route as his illustrious countryman ...

International »

'I can't breathe' were Khashoggi's final words, report says


Jamal Khashoggi's final words were "I can't breathe," CNN said Sunday, citing a source who has read the transcript of an audio tape of the final moments before the journalist's murder.The source told the US network the transcript made clear the killing was premeditated, and suggests several phone calls were ...

International »

Top House Dems raise prospect of impeachment, jail for Trump


AP, Washington :Top House Democrats have raised the prospect of impeachment or the real possibility of prison time for President Donald Trump if it's proved that he directed illegal hush-money payments to women, adding to the legal pressure on the president over the Russia investigation and other scandals."There's a very ...

City »

Chief of Army Staff General Aziz Ahmed speaking at a seminar on 'Achieving Operational Readiness' at Bipsot in Rajendrapur Cantonment on Monday.


Editorial »

Ensure safe transportation of export items


SOME powerful syndicates are stealing different types of export items, edible oil and fuel oil from the goods-laden trucks, covered vans and oil tankers in open daylight on the busy highways. The exporters usually upload the goods on trucks from different factories in Dhaka and other parts of the country ...

Football »

A view of the football match of the Walton Independence Cup between Rahmatganj MFS and Nofel Sporting Club at the Bangabandhu National Stadium on Sunday. Rahmatganj defeated Nofel by three goals to nil.


International »

UK PM May expected to delay Brexit vote, demand better deal


Reuters, London :Britain's Prime Minister Theresa May is expected to delay Tuesday's key parliamentary vote on her Brexit deal and head to Brussels next week to demand better terms from the European Union, the Sunday Times newspaper reported.The newspaper cited "ministers and aides" who said they expected her to announce ...

International »

Miss Mexico Vanessa Ponce de Leon wins Miss World 2018 crown


Rappler : And we finally have a new Miss World, the winner of the pageant for the year 2018 and she is Miss Mexico Vanessa Ponce de Leon. The beautiful lady from Mexico won the title of Miss World from among 118 contestants from countries all over the world. Miss World 2017 Manushi ...

City »

Chief Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain addressing a discussion arranged by Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) marking the International Day against Corruption at Shilpakala Academy in the city yesterday .


Entertainment »

Aankh Marey receives thunderous reactions


Aankh Marey from Simmba was released yesterday and has expectedly taken the internet by storm. Owing to its unprecedented charm, the music video in 24 hours has garnered 19 million + eyeballs on Youtube, ruling the list at number 1 Sara Ali Khan and Ranveer with their hi-volt avatars are ...

Front Page »

Khaleda ineligible to contest: EC


Special Correspondent :The Election Commission (EC) on Saturday turned down all three appeals filed by BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia against rejection of her candidatures for Feni-1, Bogura-6 and Bogura-7 Constituencies.After appeal hearing, the EC declared her candidatures invalid as per a recent Supreme Court ruling, anonymous EC officials told ...

Editorial »

Question paper leakage threat to nation`s future


THE Serious Crime Unit of Detective Branch (DB) under Dhaka Metropolitan Police yesterday arrested seven persons from different city areas for their alleged involvement in leaking question papers through electronic devices in the recruitment test for Department of Narcotics Control (DNC). Some highly sophisticated devices, including USB drives, Bluetooths, SIM ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news