Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, December 15, 2019 12:08:00 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Challenging the ideology of globalisation

By
01st-Nov-2018       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Quinn Slobodian :
Populist leaders are simply questioning the concept of free migration and relevance of global institutions
In a recent speech at the United Nations, US President Donald Trump railed against "the ideology of globalism" and "unelected, unaccountable global bureaucracy."
For those of us who came of age in the 1990s, there was an eerie sense of déjà vu. Then, too, there were protests against global institutions insulated from democratic decision-making. In the most iconic confrontation, my college classmates helped scupper the World Trade Organization meeting in Seattle in 1999.
The movement called for "alter-globalisation" - a different kind of globalisation more attentive to labour and minority rights, the environment and economic equality. Two decades later, traces of that movement are hard to find. But something surprising has happened in the meantime. A new version of alter-globalisation has won - from the right.
We often hear that world politics is divided between open versus closed societies, between globalists and nationalists. But these analyses obscure the real challenge to the status quo.
Trump and the far right preach not the end of globalisation, but their own strain of it, not its abandonment but an alternative form. They want robust trade and financial flows, but they draw a hard line against certain kinds of migration. The story is not one of open versus closed, but of the right cherry-picking aspects of globalisation while rejecting others. Goods and money will remain free, but people won't.
The current US trade war is a case in point. Commentators lament that Trump is tearing up the rules America itself created more than 80 years ago and conjure up visions of the 1930s, when nations and empires dreamed of total self-sufficiency. Yet they overlook the fact that the actions of the president and his influential trade representative Robert Lighthizer betray no desire to withdraw from the world market.
Quite the opposite. The express effort is to use unilateral action to bully other countries, China in particular, into better market access for American products. The point of comparison is not the dreams of economic self-sufficiency of the 1930s but Ronald Reagan's assault on Japanese competition in the 1980s. "The basic philosophy that we have is that we want free trade without barriers," Lighthizer explained to Congress.
In Britain, the Brexit campaign was built on the demand to "take back control" and fearmongering about refugees and immigrants. Withdrawal from the world economy was never on the programme. On the contrary, the Brexiteers championed a pivot from the European economy to the global one unfettered by the regulations of Brussels and the European Court of Justice. Almost all negotiations since the vote to leave have been in pursuit of a vision in which the free flow of goods and money across the channel can be preserved while labour migration can be squelched. A recent report from British and American think tanks close to the Brexiteers proposes a new free trade agreement between the two countries that could act as an embryonic World Trade Organization 2.0 that would target more directly Chinese state subsidies for industries and the lingering state-provided social services like the National Health Service.
The pattern of right-wing alter-globalisation is repeated in Germany and Austria, where the Alternative for Germany and the Austrian Freedom Party have recently recorded electoral wins. Neither party proposes national self-sufficiency or economic withdrawal. In their programmes, the rejection of economic globalisation is highly selective. The EU is condemned, but the language demanding increased trade and competitiveness is entirely mainstream. The Alternative for Germany takes fiscal conservatism to an absurd degree with criminal charges demanded for policymakers who overspend.
Free market capitalism is not rejected but anchored more deeply in conservative family structures and in a group identity defined against an Islamic threat from the East. Several of the Alternative for Germany's leaders are also members in a society named after Friedrich Hayek, often seen as the arch-thinker of free-market globalism.
Even the "alt-right," usually seen as the epitome of the fortress mentality of separatist survivalism, contains significant strains of alter-globalisation. Some of the alt-right's most prominent figures, from Richard to Christopher Cantwell (better known as the crying Nazi from the 2017 Charlottesville, Va., protest), have expressed their sympathies for the radical form of libertarianism known as anarcho-capitalism.
Many people on the alt-right - including the premier anarcho-capitalist thinker, the German economist Hans-Hermann Hoppe - believe that cultural homogeneity is a precondition for socio-economic order. Hoppe envisions a dissolution of the current world map of states into thousands of tiny units the size of Hong Kong, Andorra and Monaco without representative government and ruled only by private contract.
The varieties of right-wing alter-globalisation differ significantly in degrees of horror. What they share is a rejection not of the "postwar international order" but of the order of the 1990s. In the cross hairs are the products of that decade, above all, the crown jewels of neoliberal globalism: the WTO, the European Union and Nafta (which was recently renegotiated and renamed).
The right's alter-globalisers unite in a condemnation of the structures of multilateral governance that emerged from that decade along with their implication that democracy and capitalism were twins joined at the reported "end of history." Instead, in a forthright embrace of inegalitarianism, they question the ability of every country and every population to practice democratic capitalism and propose a departure from status quo democratic capitalism themselves.
The idea that openness is under attack is too vague. The formula of right-wing alter-globalisation is: yes to free finance and free trade. No to free migration, democracy, multilateralism and human equality.

(Quinn Slobodian is an author and history professor at Wellesley College.  Courtesy: NYT Syndicate).

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Entertainment »

Janhvi to cause scare Janhvi Kapoor


The actress says working on 'Ghost Stories' had a different energy from the monotonous work on films. Janhvi Kapoor has a handful of films in her kitty and amidst her busy schedule; she will also be seen in a short film.The first look of her short film 'Ghost Stories' was ...

Entertainment »

Mashrafe as a model


Entertainment Desk :Mashrafe Bin Mortaza, captain of  Bangladesh National ODI Team also the brand ambassador of Walton, has become a model in the   Walton smart refrigerator advertisement.The famous  cricket acted in the advertisement filmed in Cox's Bazar recently. Before taking part in the advertisement, he also visited the giant Walton ...

Business & Economy »

City Bank, American Express celebrates 10 years in BD


Business Desk :City Bank and American Express have celebrated 10 years of togetherness in Bangladesh. Officials of both companies unveiled new initiatives at the ten year celebration ceremony at Radisson Blu in the on Friday.To celebrate the decennary celebration, City Bank hosted a musical gala event which got a colorful ...

International »

UN climate talks in limbo as rifts among countries remain


AP, Madrid :Countries remained deadlocked Saturday in talks over combating climate change as U.N. talks dragged on beyond the official deadline with no end in sight.Chile's environment minister, Carolina Schmidt, who is chairing the two-week talks in Madrid, urged officials from almost 200 countries to recognize the "overall balance" of ...

International »

Pompeo warns Iran of ‘decisive response’ if US interests in Iraq harmed


AFP, Washington :Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Friday warned Iran of a "decisive" response if US interests are harmed in Iraq, after a series of rocket attacks on bases."We must ... use this opportunity to remind Iran's leaders that any attacks by them, or their proxies of any identity, ...

Football »

Rashford adds finishing touch to become complete striker


Marcus Rashford has always had the tools to become a world-class forward. Now he has added a clinical touch to his searing pace and box of tricks.The 22-year-old already has 13 goals for United this season - equalling his best-ever return for the club in a single campaign and is ...

City »

Editors of different newspapers and senior journalists at the inaugural ceremony of Muktijuddho Corner at the Library of the Jatiya Press Club on Saturday.


Front Page »

Martyred Intellectuals’ Day today


UNB, Dhaka :Bangladesh will observe the Martyred Intellectuals Day to commemorate the intellectuals killed by Pakistan occupation forces and their local collaborators just before the end of the Liberation War.On this day in 1971, some of the country's renowned academicians, doctors, engineers, journalists, artists, teachers and other eminent personalities were ...

Editorial »

Import coal but close those brick kilns which are using coals


Coal imports are soaring day by day. Hundreds of brick kilns are now using  an increasing quantity of coal to meet the growing demand of both public and private sectors. Newspapers reported, imports of the fossil fuel rose 70 percent year-on-year to 57.54 lakh tonnes in the fiscal year 2018-19. ...

Football »

Greenwood, Saka star as United and Arsenal youth shine in Europa League


AFP, Paris :Teenager Mason Greenwood again grabbed his chances for Manchester United, scoring twice in a 4-0 thrashing of AZ Alkmaar in the Europa League on Thursday.Earlier Arsenal came back from 2-0 down to draw 2-2 at Standard Liege and also make sure of a place in the last 32 ...

International »

EU ready for next round of Brexit after Johnson win


AFP, Brussels :EU leaders said Friday they were ready for the next phase of Brexit, just hours after the resounding victory of Prime Minister Boris Johnson's party that all but seals Britain's divorce from the bloc.The Europeans had widely expressed hope for a convincing victory in the British vote to ...

Editorial »

Save the jute mill workers


AT least 29 jute mill workers fell ill from starvation and dehydration on Wednesday in Khulna, on the second day of the indefinite hunger strike being observed by thousands of workers --  and their family members -- of nine state-owned jute mills in the Khulna-Jashore industrial belt. Around 31,000 people ...

Football »

Jesus 'cannot stop scoring' as hat-trick lifts Man City's mood in Zagreb


Gabriel Jesus said he cannot afford to stop scoring goals after a hat-trick helped Manchester City put their Premier League woes to one side with a 4-1 Champions League win over Dinamo Zagreb in the Croatian capital on Wednesday.The Brazilian is making the most of his extended run in the ...

Football »

Neymar makes impression as PSG crush Galatasaray


AFP, Paris :Neymar marked his first start in a Champions League game in a year by scoring one goal and setting up two more as Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) cruised to a 5-0 win over Galatasaray on Wednesday.Mauro Icardi and Pablo Sarabia netted in the first half at the Parc des ...

International »

Support Gambia to prove genocide in Myanmar


The governments of all the countries and international community have been urged to extend all possible support to The Gambia to ensure justice for the victims of genocide committed against the Rohingyas in the Rakhine State by Myanmar authorities. The call was made at a reception hosted in honour of ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news