Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Saturday, August 24, 2019 06:42:50 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Education spending and learning outcomes

By
03rd-Feb-2019       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

David Evans :
How much does financing matter for education? The Education Commission argued that to achieve access and quality education "will require total spending on education to rise steadily from $1.2 trillion per year today to $3 trillion by 2030 (in constant prices) across all low- and middle-income countries." At the same time, the World Bank's World Development Report 2004 showed little correlation between spending and access to school, and the World Development Report 2018 (for which I was on the team) shows a similarly weak correlation between spending and learning outcomes. (Vegas and Coffin, using a different econometric specification, do find a correlation between spending and learning outcomes up to US$8,000 per student annually.)
And yet, correlation is not causation (or in this case, a lack of correlation is not necessarily a lack of causation)! Last month, Kirabo Jackson put out a review paper on this topic: Does School Spending Matter? The New Literature on an Old Question. This draws on a new wave of evidence from the United States' experience, moving beyond correlations to efforts to measure the causal impact of spending changes. (Jackson and various co-authors have contributed significantly to this literature.) I'll summarize his findings and then discuss what we might expect to be the same or different in low- or middle-income contexts.
Does money matter? Yes.
In the U.S., many states have undergone reforms in how they finance education. Historically, most primary and secondary education was financed by local property taxes, so richer areas had better funded schools. But between 1971 and 2010, more than two dozen states had to reduce inequality in spending due to judicial decisions. This led to changes in school spending that were not related to other variables - like local commitment to education - that normally make it hard to parse out the link between financing and education. Using the variation in spending coming from the first wave of reforms, "a 10% increase in per pupil spending each year for all 12 years of public school leads to 0.31 more completed years of education, about 7% higher wages, and a 3.2 percentage-point reduction in the annual incidence of adult poverty. They also find that the effects are more pronounced for children from low-income families."
A study of more recent school finance reforms finds that "a one-time $1,000 increase in per-pupil annual spending sustained for 10 years increased test scores by between 0.12 and 0.24 standard deviations." Another study finds that in states with strong teacher unions, school districts tended to match increases in state funding, which "led to larger increases in student achievement." Other work looks at the impact of these financing reforms on high school graduation rates: "Seven years after reform, the highest poverty quartile in a treated state experienced an 11.5 percent to 12.1 percent increase in per-pupil spending, and a 6.8 to 11.5 percentage point increase in graduation rates." Beyond school finance reforms, the Great Recession (2007 to 2009 in the United States) provides an additional natural experiment. State tax revenues fell much more suddenly than local or national revenues, so states that relied more on state revenues had a disproportionate drop in financing. Researchers found that "a 10 percent school spending cut reduced test scores by about 7.8 percent of a standard deviation." Another study finds comparable results: "a 10 percent increase in spending improves…student test scores by 0.05 to 0.09 standard deviations."
In sum, out of 13 multi-state studies, Jackson finds that 12 show a positive, statistically significant relationship between education spending and student outcomes. And remember: these aren't just correlations. These are all studies that have tried to tease out the actual impact of spending on learning or attainment.
Does how you spend the money matter? Yes.
Jackson then reviews studies on how much different types of spending matter. He finds that unrestricted spending increases led to better student outcomes (8 out of 9 studies show positive results), textbook spending improves outcomes in primary school (just one study), a mixed bag on construction spending (4 out of 7 studies show positive results), and that spending targeted to low-income schools in New York City had unclear (but likely null) effects.
Jackson's takeaway? "On average, money matters," but "this is not always so in all settings or in all contexts." There is much more detail in the review; I recommend reading it in full. There are also lots of ideas for different approaches to making causal estimates, at least some of which could translate to middle- or low-income contexts.
How might these results translate to low- and middle-income environments?
The fact that a range of studies in a high-income country have shown positive impacts might lead us to expect even bigger impacts in countries where fewer resources are currently spent on students. The marginal value of an additional dollar (or shilling or peso) may be higher when students have very few resources to begin with. On the other hand, if resources intended for education are less likely to reach the schools in countries with weaker institutions, then there could be a smaller impact. In a study in Uganda from the 1990s (thus not necessarily representative of current institutions), "less than 30 percent of funding intended for non-salary public spending actually reached the schools in 1991-95."
Money matters, and it's impossible to imagine increasing the primary school completion rate in low-income countries from its current 67 percent to every child finishing elementary school without increasing spending, just in terms of construction and teachers for all these additional students. (And that's without even thinking about middle-income countries or secondary school!) But how we spend the money also matters: Not every form of spending is equally effective in the United States, and the same will be true in lower income environments.
So increase school spending, track its use, measure its impact, and adjust.
(David is a Lead Economist in the Chief Economist's Office for the Africa Region of the World Bank).

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

We cannot repatriate Rohingyas without UN supervision


NO Rohingya refugees were repatriated till Thursday noon as none of them showed "willingness" to return to Myanmar. In a fresh attempt, 3,450 Rohingya people were scheduled to be repatriated to Myanmar. Before any repatriation takes place, refugees are taken to transit camps and kept there for two to three ...

Entertainment »

Chanchal, Mamo as pair can attract the viewers in film


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :In last Eid, National Film Award winner two actors Chanchal Chowdhury and Zakia Bari Mamo-starred three dramas were telecasted in different TV channels. These dramas are: SA Haque Alik’s Sorry Bolo, Sokal Ahmed’s Byaktitto Babul and Ratan Hasan’s Nobboi Din. They got the viewers attention to play ...

International »

Macron backs more Brexit talks but insists no concessions


AFP, Paris :French President Emmanuel Macron on Thursday backed holding further talks to avoid Britain crashing out of the EU without a deal but rejected major concessions, as he hosted Prime Minister Boris Johnson just over two months ahead of the planned British exit.Echoing comments by German Chancellor Angela Merkel, ...

Entertainment »

Radhika Apte has given us character to remember forever


Indie Star Radhika Apte became the talk of the town for her earthy and unconventional character. It was the actress’ character from Manjhi: The Mountain Man which made us all believe in how chaos in beautiful and garnered appreciation from all across. Celebrating the highly critically acclaimed film, Radhika is ...

Editorial »

ACC fails to gain trust of common people


THE 11 ACC officials whose faulty and biased investigation led to wrongful imprisonment of Jaha Alam for three years have been promoted to senior ranks. Even the Anti-Corruption Commission's (ACC) own investigation acknowledged that Jaha Alam had to lose three years of his life in prison because these officials "erroneously ...

Cricket »

Afghanistan Test a preparation platform for Indian series: Mominul


Bangladesh will take the one-off Test match against Afghanistan as part of their preparation for the two-match Test series against India, with which they will begin the journey of ICC World Test Championship.As India is blessed with some world class spinners who could demolish any side at their home den, ...

International »

Putin says US missile test raises new threats to Russia


AP, Helsinki :Russian President Vladimir Putin said Wednesday that the test of a new U.S. missile banned under a now-defunct arms treaty has raised new threats to Russia and will warrant a response.The U.S. tested a modified ground-launched version of a Navy Tomahawk cruise missile that accurately struck its target ...

Editorial »

Muhith can't be blamed, he is part of the system


National Board of Revenue has allowed former finance minister AMA Muhith to release an imported car under the duty-free scheme meant for the Members of Parliament. The NBR on Monday issued a special order exempting Muhith from payment of all types of import duty, value-added tax and supplementary duty to ...

Editorial »

We have to see positive results in our relations with India


INDIAN External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Monday reconfirmed his government's stance on most-hyped Teesta water-sharing treaty that remained "unchanged" and "mutually acceptable formula" for sharing water of 54 common rivers. The three-day visit of the top Indian envoy has taken place at a time when the Indian government is ...

Football »

Ribery set for two-year deal at Fiorentina pending medical


Franck Ribery has landed in Florence and will undergo a medical ahead of completing a free transfer to Fiorentina.The 36-year-old left Bayern Munich in June after 12 years at the club and will now sign a two-year deal with the Serie A side worth almost £4.1m (€4.5m) per season, according ...

Entertainment »

Swastika shuts down malicious troll like a boss


As we say, ‘no one is perfect,’ the myth of ‘perfect body’ is quite a tough role to live up to and our silver screen celebrities have always been under a constant surveillance of the hypocritical body shamers. For even an ounce of extra weight gain or a shred from ...

International »

Johnson, Merkel to face off in first Brexit talks


AFP, Berlin :British Prime Minister Boris Johnson visits Berlin on Wednesday to kick off a marathon of tense talks with key European and international leaders as the threat of a chaotic no-deal Brexit looms.On his first foreign visit since taking office, he will seek to convince German Chancellor Angela Merkel, ...

International »

US ready to resume nuclear talks with North Korea


AFP, Seoul : The United States is ready to sit down with North Korea to resume long-awaited working-level nuclear talks, a US envoy said on Wednesday.Nuclear discussions between Washington and Pyongyang have stalled since a second summit in Hanoi in February ended without an agreement over differences on the extent of ...

Editorial »

DCCs' dengue drama


AS Bangladesh, especially the capital is reeling under massive dengue outbreak, mobile courts run by Dhaka's two city corporations are penalising the residents keeping public places and government establishments hosting aedes mosquito breeding grounds out of purview.Dengue has already claimed at least 113 lives and at least 55,000 dengue patients ...

Cricket »

'Frightening' Archer won't let-up against Australia, says Stokes


England's Ben Stokes has told Australia to expect more bouncers from Jofra Archer in the remainder of the Ashes."It's part of the game and a big part of Jofra's game, being aggressive, not letting batsmen settle," said Stokes.World Cup-winning fast bowler Archer produced a hostile and compelling display on debut ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news