Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Tuesday, August 20, 2019 11:07:27 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter
BREAKING NEWS:

Will Trump's nominee turn the World Bank against China ?

By
10th-Feb-2019       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Michael Igoe :
In the wake of U.S. President Donald Trump's announcement on Wednesday that he will nominate David Malpass to be the next president of the World Bank, Malpass' record as a critic of the bank - and particularly of its relationship with China - has some staffers and development experts worried.
As the United States trade war with China continues, and as the administration's global development leaders increasingly describe their missions as part of a battle for influence with Beijing, many have interpreted Malpass' nomination as a signal that the White House might enlist the World Bank in this economic and geopolitical struggle. Whether Malpass approaches his nomination as an opportunity to forward this part of the Trump agenda, or with a commitment to the best interests of an international institution could mean the difference between his success or rejection.
"As a Treasury official, Malpass has sought to unwind seemingly every aspect of the World Bank's relationship with China. As bank president, this would not be a viable posture toward his third-largest shareholder. Presumably, the Chinese will be seeking assurances about which Malpass they're going to get," Scott Morris, senior fellow at the Center for Global Development, wrote in an email to Devex. Currently under secretary of the treasury for international affairs, Malpass has repeatedly criticized World Bank lending to China and China's role as a development actor in general.
Speaking at the Council on Foreign Relations in 2017, he said, "the World Bank's biggest borrower is China. Well, China has plenty of resources. And it doesn't make sense to have money borrowed in the U.S., using the U.S. government guarantee, going into lending in China for a country that's got other resources and access to capital markets."
In written testimony to a Senate Foreign Relationship Subcommittee in November, Malpass said, "we are working with allies and like-minded countries to guide the MDBs [multilateral development banks] away from what could be viewed as endorsement of China's geopolitical ambitions."
That guidance includes convincing countries to endorse standards for transparency in procurement, financing, and safeguards, which the Trump administration says Chinese financing fails to deliver. Former World Bank President Jim Kim adopted a mostly collaborative stance with Beijing, welcoming China's massive Belt and Road Initiative as another source of badly needed infrastructure finance and frequently quoting Chinese President Xi Jinping on the inevitability and potential of globalization.
Despite his grievances, Malpass played a key role in negotiations over the World Bank's $13 billion capital increase that shareholders agreed to last April. That deal included a commitment from the bank to curtail costs, particularly by limiting staff salary growth, and it introduced lending reforms that include higher rates for developing countries with higher incomes, such as China. Many viewed the agreement as an unlikely victory for the bank in the face of skeptical Trump administration officials such as Malpass, who have labeled the institution's growth a symptom of bureaucratic multilateral sprawl.
"I was a bit surprised actually that that agreement allowed lending at the amounts indicated … I think it's a reasonable compromise," said Yukon Huang, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and former World Bank country director for China, noting that the issue of lending rules for emerging economies appears to have been mostly settled in that agreement.
Some inside the World Bank are worried Malpass could seek to drive a bigger wedge between the World Bank and China at the Trump administration's behest. American representatives to the bank already "try to block any lending to the country," one World Bank official told Devex on the condition of anonymity, calling these efforts by the U.S. executive director "ridiculous," "shortsighted," and "extremely counterproductive."
"If it has become difficult with simply trying to get the board to approve projects in China, what will happen if there is a president tasked with advancing Trump's bidding rather than having purely the interest of development in mind?" the official said in an email.
The official was not sure what a World Bank president with an aggressive stance toward China would actually attempt to do to influence the bank's position, but noted that it seems unlikely the administration would be so "brazen" as to try to pursue policies directed solely at China.
More likely, according to the official, would be "changes to terms and conditions of borrowing for [International Bank for Reconstruction and Development] countries as well as safeguard requirements and the expectations of the types of projects."
The governance structure of the World Bank could provide some reassurance. While changes such as these would have wider-reaching consequences, they would likely also require board approval, the official noted.
When the bank was created - and the agreement with Europe ensured its president would be an American for the foreseeable future - the purpose of establishing a sitting board of directors was partly to offset the American president's power, Huang said. If the president appeared to be acting in the interests of the administration that nominated him instead of in the interests of the institution, it would be the board's responsibility to do something about it.
"Can the president do what he wants on behalf of the administration? If he actually went down that route it would create a real problem within the institution," Huang said. Given that the capital increase deal - which was negotiated over the course of many months and represented a consensus view among the executive directors - already put new lending rules in place, additional changes seem unlikely at this point, according to Huang.
"Is something going to change in terms of the bank's approach to China? ... Probably not in the short term," he said. "They've already reached an understanding as to what that lending program will be."
In Huang's view, the argument that the bank shouldn't lend to China is based on several misunderstandings - the first being that China is somehow taking advantage of the World Bank and its shareholders by borrowing money from it.
As a financial institution, the bank's solvency depends on lending to creditable borrowers like China, Huang said, adding that loans to China tend to return better than average results - which can generate lessons for other borrowers - and are routinely paid back ahead of schedule.
"In some ways, you could say that the World Bank needs China more than China needs the World Bank," Huang said. China's interest in keeping an open line to World Bank finance is largely related to the institutional, technological, and knowledge transfer that accompanies these long-term projects, he said.
Malpass made a similar observation in his testimony last year. "China is absorbing decades of financial know-how into its institutions in a few short years, a similar pattern to its absorption of manufacturing technology," he told Congress. While that statement sounds like a criticism or complaint, it also reflects a basic mission of the World Bank and a key reason it was created in the first place. "The whole precept for the World Bank rested on the proposition that developing countries, to grow faster, need to learn from developed countries," Huang said. That raises a fundamental question about how well Trump's nominee understands the institution's purpose - and whether that purpose aligns with America's interests.
"What is the objective of the Trump administration? Do they support the transfer of knowledge and strengthening of institutions from rich countries to poor countries? Because that was the purpose of the World Bank. That's why it was created," Huang said.
"If it doesn't, then, of course, the whole institution is nonsensical. It doesn't make any sense," he added.
(Michael Igoe is a Senior Reporter with Devex, based in Washington, D.C).

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

In 1 game, Bale shows he can still contribute at Real Madrid


AP, Madrid :Just like that, Gareth Bale is part of the solution for Real Madrid again.After only one game back as a starter, the player who wasn't wanted by coach Zinedine Zidane a few weeks ago showed he can still contribute to the team.Zidane started Bale in the team's Spanish ...

International »

Sudanese army and civilians seal interim power-sharing deal


Reuters, Khartoum :Sudan's main opposition coalition and the ruling military council on Saturday signed a final power-sharing deal that paves the way for a transitional government, and eventually elections, following the overthrow of long-time leader Omar al-Bashir.Tens of thousands of people of all ages took to the streets of the ...

Entertainment »

Bindu Kona’s Eid celebration


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Bindu Kona is a popular singer of present time. Eid celebration of the singers is really exceptional to them specially for whom who has to be engaged with stage shows round the year. Bindu Kona has to engage with stage shows round the year in and outside ...

Football »

Bayern Munich target Coutinho arrives for medical ahead of loan move


Philippe Coutinho has arrived at Bayern Munich to complete his medical as he edges closer to sealing his loan move from Barcelona.The Brazilian midfielder has agreed to join the Bundesliga champions on a season-long loan deal - with Bayern having the option to make the deal permanent at the end ...

Editorial »

Find out a sustainable solution to protect leather market


ALTHOUGH tanners were supposed to start buying rawhide at the government-fixed rates, merchants refused to sell, demanding the payment of a "considerable" portion of their arrears. It comes after seasonal traders, farmers and madrasas across the country threw away thousands of pieces of rawhide of sacrificial animals, approximately Tk 100 ...

International »

British MPs press Johnson to recall parliament over Brexit


British Prime Minister Boris Johnson came under pressure Sunday to immediately recall lawmakers from their summer holiday so parliament can debate Brexit.More than 100 MPs have written to Johnson to urge him to reconvene and let them sit permanently until October 31 - the date Britain is due to leave ...

City »

Aporajeyo Bangladesh, a social organisation, formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club yesterday demanding punishment to the persons responsible for low-price of hide and skins.


Editorial »

Jugglery of growth figures failed to create jobs


BANGLADESH'S economic growth though mesmerising, it has been proved over the past decade that jobs could not be created proportionately for the youths keeping adjustment with the growth. Besides, female participation in the labour force shrank in the last nine years, especially in rural areas. As a result employment elasticity, ...

Cricket »

Mashrafe seeks two months to ponder about his retirement


The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) has shelved the idea of arranging a one-off ODI against Zimbabwe to give Mashrafe Bin Mortaza a grand farewell after the ODI captain asked the board to give him two months to think about his future.The decision to cancel the plan came after BCB president ...

Football »

Guardiola backs Sterling to reach 30-goal mark


AFP, Manchester :Pep Guardiola wants to see the on-form Raheem Sterling break the 30-goal barrier for the first time in his career this season, but will only judge the England forward on his overall contribution to the Manchester City team.Sterling has started the new campaign in prolific form, scoring in ...

City »

Bangabandu Sangskritik Jote paid tributes to Poet Shamsur Rahman by placing floral wreaths at his grave in the city's Banani on Saturday marking the 13th death anniversary of the poet.


International »

Hundreds defy restrictions, join protests in Kashmir


AP, New Delhi :Hundreds of people protested an unprecedented security crackdown and clashed with police Friday in Indian-controlled Kashmir, as India's government said it was constantly reviewing the situation in the disputed region and the restrictions there will be removed over the next few days.The U.N. Security Council met on ...

International »

Discussions on Afghan peace deal go ‘very well’, says Trump's spokesman


The White House says President Donald Trump's talks with his national security advisers to discuss Afghan peace talks went "very well" and that negotiations with the Taliban "are proceeding."Officials on August 16 said Trump was meeting with his top advisers to review negotiations with the extremist group about a possible ...

Entertainment »

Kona finally admits her secret marriage


Entertainment Desk :Popular singer Dilshad Nahar Kona revealed  on Thursday  that she had tied the knot with the person she loved, on April 21 of this year. Her husband, Golam Md Iftekhar, is a businessman, and has been in a relationship with Kona for seven years.Kona was heard saying to ...

Editorial »

Clashes among groups of govt followers on national mourning day


NEWSPAPERS reported that at least 22 people, including former Awami League lawmaker of Nilphamari-3 and upazila unit AL vice-president Golam Mustafa, were injured in a clash between two rival groups of the party in Jaldhaka of Nilphamari on Thursday. The clash took place when the groups hosted separate programmes to ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news