Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, November 18, 2019 10:51:32 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Venture funds: Argentine experiences

By
10th-Aug-2014       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Alan Furth :
It is easy to see moral irony in the arguments of those who support Argentina's President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner's government in the ongoing dispute against a group of so-called vulture funds, led by the highly litigious Elliot Associates. Anyone even slightly familiar with the corrupt shenanigans of Fernandez, her late husband - former president Nestor Kirchner - and their cronies over the last 11 years is entitled to roll their eyes at claims that the interests of the Argentine people motivate Fernandez's government to resist the vulture funds' attempt to get paid in full for bonds the country defaulted on in 2002 (the largest debt default the world had ever seen until then - surpassed only by Lehman Brothers in 2008).
Egregious as the recent past of the Kirchner administration is, what truly adds insult to injury is the Kirchners' earlier history. During the mid 1970s, Fernandez and her husband established a law firm in Rio Gallegos, in the Patagonian province of Santa Cruz. The firm thrived during those years, especially right after a sharp devaluation of the peso in 1980 caused by the disastrous economic policies of the military junta ruling the country at the time. When inflation-indexed rates on mortgage loans soared to sky-high levels, forcing desperate debtors to sell their homes at fire sale prices, the Kirchners cashed in handsomely, enforcing evictions on behalf of several financial houses and banks.
The methods they used for this purpose could easily be classified as "vulturesque." Lawyer Rafael Flores - a fellow Peronist who would become one of the Kirchners' main detractors during the '90s - took up the case of Mrs. Ana Victoria de Aaset, a distressed mortgage-holder who successfully sued the Kirchners for allegedly keeping Asaet's promisory notes rather than shredding them after payment. When Flores ran onto Fernandez right ouside the courtroom and asked her why she and her husband were doing this, she famously answered: "We want to get into politics, and for getting into politics, we need some serious dough." Tony Montana couldn't have said it better.
Sadly, Fernandez's domestic political opponents, who include most local mainstream libertarians, have pathetically sided with the vulture funds, engaging in one of the most outrageous exercises of false free-market rhetoric the country has seen ever since the Menem years.
Their arguments amount to nothing more than crass rehashes of the well-PR'd statements championed by Elliot's Paul Singer and others at the hedge fund community. As Jim Armitage put it in a recent article at The Independent: "The vultures argue that, were it not for the threat of relentless and unflinching court room battles, tinpot dictators, kleptocrats and plain old irresponsible populist leaders have nothing to prevent them racking up huge debts, wasting (or stealing) the money, and then disappearing off into the distance."
The most outrageous fallacy in this line of reasoning is the conflation of the political class of a country with its citizenry at large. Whenever vultures succeed in collecting the full value on defaulted government bonds, the ones who end up paying are, obviously, the taxpayers, the general citizenry of a given country. The local politicians who borrowed the money in the name of the people, obtaining enormous personal financial gains in process, won't contribute to paying those debts any more than the regular Joe who does real work for a living. How can anyone in their right minds think that will discipline the political class into fiscal frugality of any kind? How can anyone claiming to defend any minimally substantive notion of human freedom advocate for socializing the losses of creditors who lend to corrupt, unaccountable governments, effectively subjecting the common people to government-debt peonage on behalf of crony financial operators?
Actually, many "free-market," pro-Elliot pundits are so eager to counter Fernandez's government at any cost that they end up defending Judge Griesa's bizarrely heterodox interpretation of the pari passu clause in sovereign bonds. As financial blogger Felix Salmon recently pointed out, the clause "is a piece of hoary financial boilerplate that means absolutely nothing in a sovereign context."
The traditional interpretation of pari passu by market players in international financial transactions is that it prevents the borrower from incurring obligations to other creditors that rank legally senior to the debt instrument containing the clause. Outside the framework of typical corporate-bankrupcy proceedings, the notion that a pari passu clause implies that equally-ranking debt must be paid equally is an utter fallacy.
No one with a minimum of common sense and intellectual honesty should portray financial operators specialized in extracting rents through unscrupulous legal manipulation as if they were free-market players seeking to enforce fair contractual terms - especially not those who call themselves "libertarians."

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

No medicine should be marketed without testing


THE people of Bangladesh have no way to know about the quality of medicine as the controlling authority has the capacity to test less than 10 per cent of the drugs sold in the country. The government-run drug testing laboratories in the country do not have the ability to test ...

Sports »

Thiem dethrones Zverev to set up London final against Tsitsipas


Dominic Thiem beat defending champion Alexander Zverev on Saturday to join Roger Federer's conqueror Stefanos Tsitsipas in the final of the ATP Finals in London.The Austrian fifth seed saw off the big-serving German 7-5, 6-3 after Greece's Tsitsipas, making his debut at the tournament, had earlier beaten Federer 6-3, 6-4.Thiem ...

Entertainment »

It feels surreal to act with Thalapathy: Soundarya Nandakumar


Singer and actress Soundarya Nandakumar, who is known for her work in the TV soap Pagal Nilavu and the viral short film Yours Shamefully, has been roped in for Lokesh Kanagaraj’s #Thalapathy64. Ask the actress how she landed the role, and she says, “They had approached me after seeing my ...

International »

Johnson's Conservatives have highest support since 2017: Polls


Reuters, London :British Prime Minister Boris Johnson's Conservative Party have the highest level of support since 2017, according to opinion polls published on Saturday.The Dec. 12 election was called to end three years of disagreement over Brexit that has sapped investors' faith in the stability of the world's fifth largest ...

International »

Taiwan President chooses running mate who Chinese paper wanted arrested


Reuters, Taipei :Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen has named as her running mate for 2020 elections a former premier who angered Beijing so badly last year with his support for the island's formal independence that a major Chinese paper called for his arrest.Self-ruled and democratic Taiwan is claimed by China as ...

City »

Jatiyatabadi Ainjibi Forum, a platform of pro-BNP lawyers, on Sunday observed a 'foot march' program on the Supreme Court premises demanding BNP Chairperson Khaleda Zia's immediate release from jail. Advocate Khandker Mahbub Hossain, Convener of the Jatiyatabadi Ainjibi Forum, Member Secretary of the Forum Adv Fazlur Rahman, Co-Conveners Adv Mir Mohammad Nasir Uddin, Adv Zainul Abedin, Barrister A M Mahbub Uddin Khokan, Adv Masud Ahmed Talukder and Barrister Kayser Kamal, among others, were present on the occasion.


Editorial »

Bolivia's political crisis and the role of US


Political crisis in Bolivia has taken a crucial turn. The landlocked country in western-central South America region has been witnessing political unrest after a presidential election held by former president Evo Morales allegedly to stay in power for the fourth time. Getting an asylum, Bolivia's first indigenous president Morales fled ...

Cricket »

Captain of Bangladesh National Cricket (ODI) team Mashrafe Bin Mortaza, MP, inaugurating the Pran-DRU Media Cricket Tournament by releasing the balloons as the chief guest at the Maulana Bhashani National Hockey Stadium on Saturday.


Sports »

Nadal bows out on top of the world


Rafael Nadal was unable to crown his season with a first ATP Finals title but he ends it as world number one and with a chance to lead Spain to Davis Cup glory.The Spaniard, who came to London under an injury cloud, had a terrible start to his week at ...

Entertainment »

Actress Tisha to make debut as film producer


Entertainment Desk :Two-time National Film Award winning actress Nusrat Imrose Tisha made her film debut with 'Third Person Singular Number' for which she was awarded Meril Prothom Alo Award in Best Film Actress (Critics') category.Tisha started her acting career through the drama 'Shat Prohorer Kabbo' in 1998. Now  near after ...

International »

US Air Force Chief of Staff calls for Gulf Arab unity to counter Iran


Reuters, Dubai :United States Air Force Chief of Staff David Goldfein on Saturday pressed Gulf Arab states to reconcile differences and unify military capabilities as tensions with Iran simmer.Washington sees an ongoing dispute that Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and non-Gulf state Egypt have with Qatar as a ...

Editorial »

Development unmet due to prevailing corruption


GLOBAL Bribery Risk Index put Bangladesh in the top position "Country with the highest risk" in terms of bribery threats in South Asia, in the updated index report titled Trace Bribery Risk Matrix, Bangladesh scored 72 out of 100 this year, which is two points higher than last year and ...

Entertainment »

Shahnaz Khushi wants to work in big screen


Entertainment Report :Creating hype among the viewers to mark in the field of acting by playing challenging roles on the small screen, Shanaz Khushi is now a household name to all. Shahnaz Khushi is a successful actress on the small screen. But she was never seen appearing in any movie ...

International »

North Korea rejects US offer of December talks


Reuters, Seoul :  North Korea said on Thursday it had turned down a U.S. offer for fresh talks, saying it was not interested in more talks merely aimed at "appeasing us" ahead of a year-end deadline Pyongyang has set for Washington to show more flexibility in negotiations.Kim Myong Gil, North ...

Editorial »

Industrial Policy


Jomo Kwame Sundaram and Anis Chowdhury :Industrial policy refers to the promotion of new investments and technology by governments to encourage the growth and development of specific economic sectors. However, scepticism persists about the feasibility and desirability of using industrial policy, especially of the ability to 'pick winners', often accused ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news