Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Saturday, July 20, 2019 06:37:25 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Proceedings should not be stifled

Case shall be considered by facts and circumstances

By
04th-May-2019       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

High Court Division :
(Criminal Miscellaneous Jurisdiction)
Sheikh Abdul Awal  J } Abdul Awal (Md)…............    
(Bhishmadev      } …………Accused-Petitioner
Charabortty    J }         vs
Judgment         } State and another ………
January 7th, 2019        } ………………Opposite-Parties

Negotiable Instruments Act (XXVI of 1881)
Section 138
The proposition of law is well settled that on the basis of defence plea or materials, the proceedings should not be stifled before trial, when there is a prima-facie case for going to the trial.
The accused-petitioner on 9-5-2017 issued a cheque of Taka 30 Lac in favour of the complainant and thereafter, the complainant placed the said cheque in Shahjalal Islami Bank, Eskaton Branch, Dhaka for encashment on 14-5-2017 although the said cheque was dishonoured and thereafter, the complainant brought the matter to the notice of the accused-petitioner by sending a notice dated 1-6-2017 and on getting the notice the accused-petitioner requested the complainant to place the cheque on 11-6-2017 for encashment and accordingly, on good faith, the complainant placed the said cheque on 11-6-2017 for encashment and again the said cheque was returned unpaid. The matter did not end here.  Again on pretext the accused-petitioner requested the complainant to place the cheque on 6-9-2017 for encashment and accordingly, on good faith the complainant placed the said cheque for encashment and the said cheque was returned with a remark "account closed/ dormant/blocked" and thereafter, complainant finding no other alternative way filed this case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act……………… (6 & 4)
Sheikh Atiar  Rahman,  Advocate-For the Accused-Petitioner.
Md Fazlur Rahman Khan, DAG-For the State.
Sheikh Abdul Awal J : In this application under Section 561A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the accused-petitioner sought for quashing the proceeding of Sessions Case No. 1876 of 2018 arising out of CR Case No. 1114 of 2017, under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 now pending in the Court of the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 1st Court, Narayangonj.
2. Mr Sheikh Atiar Rahman, the learned Advocate appearing for the accused-petitioner submits that the impugned proceeding under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act is a clear violation of the provision of Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act inasmuch as in this case the complainant issued 3 times legal notice asking to pay the cheque's amount and as such, the prolongation of the case amounts to an abuse of the process of the Court and the impugned proceeding is liable to be quashed. This is the only ground urged by the learned Advocate for the petitioner. Mr Sheikh Atiar Rahman, the learned Advocate to fortify his argument has relied on the decision reported in 14 BLC 66.
3. Heard the learned Advocate and perused the application along with other papers including the petition of compliant as filed thereto.
4. On going through the petition of complaint, it appears that the accused-petitioner on 9-5-2017 issued a cheque of Taka 30 Lac in favour of the complainant and thereafter, the complainant placed the said cheque in Shahjalal Islami Bank, Eskaton Branch, Dhaka for encashment on 14-5-2017 although the said cheque was dishonoured and thereafter, the complainant brought the matter to the notice of the accused-petitioner by sending a notice dated 1-6-2017 and on getting the notice the accused-petitioner requested the complainant to place the cheque on 11-6-2017 for encashment and accordingly, on good faith the complainant placed the said cheque on 11-6-2017 for encashment and again the said cheque was returned unpaid. The matter did not end here. Again on pretext the accused-petitioner requested the complainant to place the cheque on 6-9-2017 for encashment and accordingly, on good faith the complainant placed said cheque for encashment and the said cheque was returned with a remark "account closed/ dorrnant/blocked" and thereafter, complainant finding no other alternative way filed this case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act on 8-11-2017.
5. From the above, it transpires that the accused-petitioner on various pretext again and again requested the complainant to place the cheque before the bank and accordingly the complainant on good faith placed the cheque in bank for 3 times for encashment but the cheque in question was returned unpaid in each time. The case as revealed from the petition of complaint that the complainant issued 3 legal notices time to time lastly on 13-9-2017 as per request of the accused petitioner on good faith and the cheque in question was bounced all along.
6. In the facts and circumstances of the case and law bearing on the subject, it is difficult to hold that there is any legal bar of the impugned proceeding or the continuation of the impugned proceeding will amount to an abuse of the process of the Court. The contention as raised by the learned Advocate is a disputed question of fact to be ascertained at the trial on taking evidence and when evidence is required to settle the dispute, the proceeding cannot be quashed.
The proposition of law is well settled that on the basis of defence plea or materials, the criminal proceedings should not be stifled before trial, when there is a prima-facie case for going to the trial.
7. Taking into consideration all of these aspects of the case as revealed from the materials on record, we are of the view that the petition of complaint undoubtedly discloses that the accused petitioner is liable for the offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act and, as such, the question of quashing the proceeding does not arise at all. In framing charge under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act, the learned Additional Metropolitan Sessions Judge, 1st Court, Narayangonj did not commit any illegality whatsoever. Whether a proceeding under Section 561A of the Code Criminal Procedure is to be quashed depends upon the facts of the case itself.
7. The principles as enunciated in the cited decision have no manner of application in the facts and circumstances of the instant case in as much as facts of the cited case are quite distinguishable from the facts of the present case. Every case shall be considered in the facts and circumstances of that case only. Therefore, we do not find any merit in this application.
8. In the result, the application is rejected summarily. 

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Corruption in WASA crosses all limits


THE Anti Corruption Commission has identified eight projects and three areas in Dhaka WASA where corruption takes place. The State enterprise keeps extending deadlines and increasing the costs of its projects to create room for corruption. In many cases, WASA did not carry out its work as per project designs ...

International »

UN reaches agreement with Yemen rebels to resume food deliveries


AFP, United Nations :The World Food Program has reached an agreement in principle with Yemen's Huthi rebels to resume food aid to areas they control, the agency's chief said on Thursday.Malnutrition is widespread in Yemen after four years of civil war, but the UN suspended deliveries of food aid to ...

Entertainment »

Shabnam Parvin’s Hurmoti film to be released after Eid


Entertainment Report :Viewers’ choice popular actress Shabnam Parvin has made a movie titled Hurmoti which is based on her own written story. Shabnam Parvin herself played the title role in the movie. Al Monjur wrote dialogue while script was also written by Shabnam Parvin herself. Shabnam Parvin informed that against ...

Editorial »

China funded projects: Delay would create problems


A JOINT working group has been formed to probe the slow progress of the 27 projects involving around $20 billion that China had agreed to provide during President Xi Jinping's Dhaka visit in October 2016. China has so far disbursed only $981.36 million -- less than 5 percent of the ...

Football »

Infantino reacts to Blatter criticism over Africa cleanup


AP, Cairo :FIFA president Gianni Infantino hit back at Sepp Blatter's criticism of the world soccer body's cleanup operation in Africa as a modern-day form of "colonialism."Infantino response on Thursday was: "I have to laugh about it."Blatter, the former head of FIFA who is serving a six-year ban from soccer, ...

City »

A vital portion of highway in Uttara near Armed Police Office is in dilapidated condition where big potholes and cracks following incessant rains for the last few days and works relating to metro-rail project, other development works. This photo was taken on Thursday.


International »

US against any country purchasing Russia's S-400 defence system: Pentagon


PTI, Washington :The US is keen to make its defence partnership with India stronger, the Pentagon has said, but made it clear that it is against any country purchasing military equipment, including the S-400 missile defence system from Russia, that is designed to counter America's sophisticated fifth-generation aircraft.The remarks by ...

International »

Sea-Watch captain Rackete faces Italian prosecutor over migrant rescue


AFP, Agrigento :German captain Carola Rackete, who sparked international headlines by forcibly docking in an Italian port with rescued migrants, faces questioning by an Italian prosecutor on Thursday over allegedly aiding illegal immigration.The captain of the Sea-Watch 3 is expected to be questioned in the southern Sicilian town of Agrigento ...

Entertainment »

Poppy supports Bobita’s remark


Entertainment Report :Nick name of internationally acclaimed film actress Bobita is Poppy. Due to acting in the big screen Bobita had to sacrifice her name Poppy. On the other hand, after starting acting in movies Poppy could keep her original name. Poppy sometimes feels pleasure when she recalls the original ...

Editorial »

Ensure hassle-free higher education for them


THE results of this year's Higher Secondary Certificate and equivalent examinations under country's 10 education boards were announced yesterday where the combined pass rate rose by 7. 29 percent - that means it's now 73.93 per cent from last year's 66.64 per cent. The number of GPA-5 achievers in the ...

City »

Students of the city`s Motijheel Ideal School and College exulting over the brilliant results of the HSC examination. The snap was taken from the premises of the institution on Wednesday.


.

International »

China gifts military warship to Sri Lanka in sign of deepening cooperation


PTI, Beijing : China has gifted a warship to Sri Lanka, in the latest sign of its deepening military cooperation with the strategically located island nation in the Indian Ocean. Also, China's rolling-stock manufacturer has announced that it would shortly deliver nine "new type" of diesel trains to Sri Lanka.The China-gifted ...

Entertainment »

Peya Bipasha`s Eid telefilm Opekkha


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Gleaming model and actress Peya Bipasha has recently acted in an Eid telefilm titled Opekkha under the direction of Maksudur Rahman Bishal. This was Peya’s first work for the upcoming Eid. In the telefilm, Peya Bipasha will be seen against Emon on the screen. Promising TV actress ...

Editorial »

Accidents at level crossings


A newly-married couple and eight others of the bridal party were killed when a Dhaka-bound train rammed their microbus at an unmanned level crossing in Sirajganj's Ullapara upazila on Monday evening. The fatal accident has spoiled unmet dream of the couple. It's due to utter negligence of the Railway Authorities ...

Football »

Argentine sport court member advices Messi to apologize


AP, Buenos Aires :Lionel Messi should apologize for his harsh comments at the Copa America in order to avoid a sanction, an Argentine member of sport's highest court said on Monday.Following defeats in the last two finals, Messi had another frustrating end to the tournament when he was sent off ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news