Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, May 20, 2019 09:46:36 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Hamas Needs to Learn a Lesson

Israel's Strategy To Keep Control On Palestine

By
12th-May-2019       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Dr. Alon Ben-Meir :
Netanyahu has served as Prime Minister for the past 11 years, coinciding with Hamas' rule over Gaza ever since it usurped power in 2007 from the Palestinian Authority after a brief violent confrontation between the two sides. During this period, Netanyahu has deliberately perpetuated the conflict with Hamas as a means by which to promote his sinister political agenda. At no point has he contemplated finding a mutually acceptable solution that could end the hostilities and gradually lead to peaceful coexistence. Instead, he has portrayed Hamas as an irredeemable foe committed to Israel's destruction, insisting there is nothing that Israel can do other than maintain the status quo and handle Hamas with force.
The recent flare-up between the two sides is just another violent episode in a continuing bloody conflict, including three wars that killed thousands of Palestinians and scores of Israelis, not to speak of the massive destruction inflicted on Gaza and the social and economic dislocation that the Israelis endured.
Netanyahu often uses disproportionate force to 'teach Hamas a lesson'. He knows, however, that the humanitarian crisis in Gaza is of such magnitude that it is impossible for Hamas and the public to accept, as in the past, incremental and temporary relief while the blockade remains in place and hopelessness and despair continue to reign. Predictably, the vicious cycle of violence continues, and managing rather than solving the conflict has been Netanyahu's strategy all along.
Netanyahu is resisting calls from his own party, as well as from some of the opposition members, to invade Gaza and decapitate Hamas' leadership-as Energy Minister and Security Cabinet member Yuval Steinitz described it to Army Radio on Monday, "to get rid of Hamas, we have to conquer Gaza." He and others foolishly believe that such a drastic move would guarantee calm and lead to a peaceful transition from Hamas to the PA, which is nothing short of a pipedream. Unless Israel occupies Gaza permanently, a new cadre of Hamas leaders will rise almost overnight who will be even more militant and resilient than the current leadership.
Netanyahu objects to another incursion, fearing that this time Hamas will not agree to any ceasefire that does not permanently provide relief and lead to the lifting of the blockade, which he vehemently opposes.
He also refuses to reoccupy Gaza, as this would force the Israeli government to care for nearly two million Palestinians, which would be nothing short of a nightmare. Not only would such an ill-conceived move require the establishment of a massive security apparatus that will constantly put the lives of soldiers at serious risk, it would also cost hundreds of millions of dollars annually to sustain.
Netanyahu has constantly strived to prevent any reconciliation efforts between the PA and Hamas, which allows him to claim that there is no negotiating partner. And when the PA and Hamas have agreed twice in the past to form a unity government, Netanyahu refused to enter peace talks, insisting that he won't negotiate with a Palestinian government that includes Hamas.
Netanyahu often accommodates the Egyptians in dealing with Hamas, given Egypt's important role in mediating between Israel and Hamas. Egypt is interested in maintaining calm in Gaza, but does not mind the punishing blow that Israel frequently inflicts on Hamas. As Hamas is an off-shoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, which Egypt has designated as a terrorist organization, it imposes serious restrictions on the crossing of Palestinians from Gaza into Egypt.
Finally, Netanyahu consistently opts to maintain pressure on Hamas by seizing any opportunity to interrupt the flow of goods and building materials to ensure that Hamas remains vulnerable and dependent on Israel's goodwill. He wants the Palestinians in Gaza to blame Hamas and Islamic Jihad for their plight, hoping to instigate unrest-which has not materialized in any significant way. He skillfully led the majority of Israelis to believe that Hamas is a mortal threat while ignoring the irreversible facts on the ground, which he must face in order to find a permanent solution to the conflict with Hamas.
Gaza is in effect a large open-air prison with nearly two million destitute Palestinians that cannot be wished away. Gaza is territorially separated from the West Bank and is governed by Hamas, which embraces a different ideology than the PA. There is no prospect that the PA and Hamas will reconcile their differences; Hamas will not relinquish power and surrender their arsenals to the PA, which, from its perspective, is tantamount to capitulation. Hamas' priority is to end the Gazans' 'imprisonment' and it will continue to fight and sacrifice to achieve an end to the blockade.
It should be made clear though that Hamas has been its own worst enemy. Even though it knows Israel is here to stay and no power can dislodge it, it openly calls for Israel's destruction, which plays directly into the hands of Netanyahu and a majority of Israelis. Hamas' militancy and buildup of military arsenals provides further proof to many Israelis that Hamas is an irredeemable enemy that deserves what has befallen it.
The validity of this argument, however, does not change the reality that the Palestinians in Gaza are largely living under subhuman conditions. And regardless of Hamas' bellicose narrative against Israel, it too wants to end the conflict without being humiliated in the process. The solution to the conflict with Hamas is not another incursion into Gaza, or raining destruction from the air, or decapitating Hamas' leadership, and certainly not re-occupying Gaza. Instead, Israel needs to treat Gaza as a separate entity from the West Bank, as there is hardly anything in common between the two sides.
Hamas has proposed time and again a long ceasefire (Hudna) for 15-20 years, during which Israel would allow Hamas to embark on building infrastructure, housing, hospitals, schools, seaports, and other development projects. This would create thousands of jobs and an improved quality of life that every Palestinian in Gaza yearns for.
These projects should be implemented under the supervision of a special international commission to ensure that all funds raised from donor countries, including the US, the EU, and the oil-rich Arab states, are channeled to these projects. Hamas would certainly develop a vested interest in safeguarding the new development, and would therefore refrain from provoking Israel, and rein in Islamic Jihad to maintain the calm.
Hamas knows that Israel will always be able to wreak havoc on Gaza should it not fully adhere to the terms of the ceasefire. A long-term ceasefire in conjunction with confidence-building measures will certainly change the nature of the bilateral relations between Israel and Hamas, which could gradually lead to lifting the blockade altogether. Furthermore, a resolution to the conflict between Hamas and the PA can and should take place, provided that it will not in any way undermine Israel's national security, after Israel resolves its separate conflict with the PA.
There are many cynics who believe that peace between Israel and Hamas is nothing but an illusion. On the contrary, anyone who maintains that the current situation is sustainable is misguided, as they ignore both the turmoil and the bloodshed over the past 12 years, and the reality on the ground that cannot be changed.

Dr. Alon Ben-Meir, Professor of international relations at the Center for Global Affairs at NYU. He teaches courses on international negotiation and Middle Eastern studies; email: alon@alonben-meir.com)

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

Qatar officials say 48-team World Cup will not be 'imposed'


AFP, Doha :The organisers of the 2022 Qatar World Cup said on Saturday that "there will be no decision imposed" on the country to extend the tournament to 48 teams.Anticipation is mounting ahead of the final decision, due to be announced in Paris at the beginning of June, whether to ...

Editorial »

Protect the rivers from grabbers


THE National River Conservation Commission has warned a dozen of government officials for their inaction to free the River Meghna from grabbers and take action within seven days. The Commission had earlier directed the authorities to take action against the grabbers but nothing had happened. Frustrated, the Commission on May ...

International »

Pope pays tribute to journalists who were killed; says press freedom vital


Reuters, Vatican City  :Pope Francis paid tribute on Saturday to journalists killed while doing their jobs, saying media freedom is a key indicator of a country's health.In an address to the Foreign Press Association in Italy, he urged journalists to shun fake news and continue reporting on the plight of ...

City »

Dr T Rahman Cardiac Care Foundation brought out a rally at Malibagh area in the city yesterday in observance of the World Hypertension Day 2019 to create awareness among people about hypertension and cardiac illness.


Entertainment »

Nisho, Mehazabien`s Eid telefilm Sheshta Sundor


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Viewers’ choice popular pair of the small screen of present time Afran Nisho and Mehazabien Chowdhury worked together for an Eid telefilm titled Sheshta Sundor directed by Mizanur Rahman Aryan. They earlier worked together under same director’s last year’s Eid telefilm titled Buker Ba Pashey. Therefore, the ...

Sports »

Toronto Raptors' Kawhi Leonard shoots between Milwaukee Bucks' Brook Lopez and Ersan Ilyasova during the second half of Game 2 of the NBA Eastern Conference basketball playoff finals in Milwaukee on Friday. The Bucks won 125-103 to take a 2-0 lead in the series.


Cricket »

Tri-Nation Series win a boost for Tigers in World Cup


Bangladesh got a timely boost ahead of the World Cup journey, as they ended the final jinx, whacking West Indies past by five wickets, a victory that captain Mashrafe Bin Mortaza cited as 'confidence booster' to chase any kind of total.Having set a 210 runs to victory in 24 overs ...

Editorial »

Assault on freedom of speech


THE New York-based Human Rights Watch on Friday slammed Bangladesh authorities following the recent arrests of some dignified persons under much-debated Digital Security Act. The HRW pointed finger about the raising worries among the common people over the freedom of speech and freedom of expression. According to media reports, poet ...

International »

Maduro hails start of Norway-brokered talks with opposition


AFP, Caracas : President Nicolas Maduro welcomed Friday the "beginning of talks" with the Venezuelan opposition in Norway, after months of bloody clashes between the two sides. "The talks have begun nicely to move toward agreements of peace, agreement and harmony, and I ask for the support of all Venezuelan people to ...

International »

Australian election vote count reveals close contest


AP, Canberra :The vote count in Australia's general election on Saturday was proving closer than opinion polls had predicted, with the ruling conservative coalition appearing more likely to form a government than the favored center-left opposition party.Opposition Labor Party deputy leader Tanya Plibersek had said in early counting that she ...

City »

BNP Standing Committee Member Barrister Jamir Uddin Sircar speaking at a press conference at the party central office in the city's Nayapalton on Saturday demanding release and proper treatment of BNP Chief Begum Khaleda Zia.


Entertainment »

Tragedy hits the sets of Amitabh,Chiranjeevi's next


Last week, a fire on the sets of Amitabh Bachchan and Chiranjeevi starrer Sye Raa Narasimha Reddy erupted, However, no one was hurt during it. But seems like another tragedy has struck the sets of the film. This week a 38-year-old Russian actor named Alexander died on set due to ...

Editorial »

China can`t be a bystander when Rohingya crisis turns critical


BANGLADESH Foreign Minister on Thursday stressed the need for strong support of China for resolving the prolonged Rohingya crisis with early repatriation of the displaced people. China's strong support would be necessary so that 'Myanmar moves in the right direction for resolving the Rohingya crisis,' the Minister told Chinese ambassador ...

City »

Secretary General of Manik Mia Foundation Syed Tosharaf Ali presented key speech at a discussion on 'Problems of Banking Sector' at the conference room of the Foundation at the Ittefaq Bhaban in the city on Friday with Prof Abul Kashem Fazlul Haque in the chair. The discussion was also addressed, among others, by Probir Dutta, Taposh Pramanik, Zakir Hossain Didar, Nasirul Haque Nabab, Rafiqul Islam Liton, Dr Sadiqur Rahman, Suvash Bhattachariya, Hari Prosad Mitra, Shafiqul Islam and Chitta Francis Rebeiro. After the discussion the participants were given Iftar.


.

International »

Taiwan legislature approves Asia's first same-sex marriage law


AFP, Taiwan : Taiwan's parliament legalised same-sex marriage on Friday in a landmark first for Asia as the government survived a last-minute attempt by conservatives to pass watered-down legislation.Lawmakers comfortably passed a bill allowing same-sex couples to form "exclusive permanent unions" and another clause that would let them apply for ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news