Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Wednesday, June 26, 2019 09:24:25 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Trump's Criminality

In The Eyes Of A Critical Observer

By
13th-Jun-2019       
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Jennifer Rubin :
Two law professors, Joyce White Vance and Barbara McQuade, together with former White House counsel and Watergate figure John Dean, did more on Monday afternoon to educate Americans about President Trump's repeated acts of obstruction of justice than Democrats have done since the Mueller report was released in mid-April.
Dean, appearing elegant and restrained, especially in the face of unhinged Republican committee members ranting (to which he responded with some witty jibes), made the case effectively that Trump's dangling of pardons in front of aides and former aides, which special counsel Robert S. Mueller III documented, is analogous to President Richard M. Nixon's conduct. As someone who held former White House counsel Donald McGahn's job decades earlier, Dean was well situated to appeal to McGahn to testify, and to interpret McGahn's conduct in a favorable light (e.g., McGahn wouldn't fire Mueller because it would look like the infamous Saturday Night Massacre).
"In both situations, the White House Counsel was implicated in the cover-up activity. While I was an active participant in the cover-up for a period of time, there is absolutely no information whatsoever that Trump's White House counsel, Don McGahn, participated in any illegal or improper activity - to the contrary, there is evidence he prevented several obstruction attempts," Dean said during his opening remarks, "But there is no question Mr. McGahn was a critical observer of these activities."
Dean also stressed that any efforts to prevent McGahn's testimony by assertion of "absolute immunity" are bogus. From Dean's opening remarks: "McGahn's loyalty is to his client, the Office of the Presidency, not the occupant. He had only a limited attorney-client privilege when interacting with the President and advisors and the privilege belongs to the Office in any event."
The stars of the hearing were the two unflappable law professors who explained in direct and concise opening statements, and in their answers, the essential facts of the Mueller case that Trump has tried to either ignore or flat-out lie about. Vance explained that Mueller had declined to make a prosecutorial recommendation, but had left that job to Congress. "Mueller explained the elements prosecutors must establish to indict an obstruction charge, laid out the evidence his investigation had revealed for each instance of conduct he investigated, and analyzed whether there was sufficient evidence to establish each element," she said. "But he left the ultimate conclusions about the President's conduct to the American people and their elected representatives, and possibly for future prosecutors to consider when the President is no longer in office."
She then proceeded to lay out the elements of an obstruction charge (an act, a nexus to an investigation and corrupt intent), pointing out 10 categories of conduct in which "Mueller was investigating an attack on our democracy by a hostile foreign power, and on multiple occasions, the President tried to thwart it, curtail it, or end it completely, either by removing the Special Counsel outright or interfering with his ability to gather evidence." This may be news to Republicans and to those who haven't read the report, but there was, in other words replete evidence to indict Trump had he not been a sitting president. Vance drilled down on one especially egregious category of conduct - Trump telling McGahn to get rid of Mueller, and later telling him to deny he was asked and to falsify the record. And she reminded the committee and public that about 1,000 former prosecutors have opined that had Trump not been president, they'd have indicted him.
For her part, McQuade reiterated the seriousness of obstruction of justice, explaining why the absence of an underlying crime cannot exonerate a defendant. (If that were the case, we would never prosecute someone who successfully blocked an investigation, leaving law enforcement with no evidence of a crime.) Not only is this a serious crime that strikes at the heart of our criminal justice system but, in this case, McQuade pointed out, it was a threat to national security. By blocking or attempting to block Mueller's investigation, the president was seeking to thwart an investigation into a foreign power's interference in our election, "which would diminish our ability to detect and defend against future threats." She reminded the committee that in four instances ("counts" in an indictment), all three elements of obstruction were found. (She focused in depth on the efforts to get then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions to unrecuse himself so he would be in a position to curtail the investigation.)
Questioning by Democrats was stronger than usual, in part because they focused on (and read from) episodes in the Mueller report. Republicans blustered and berated Dean but, of course, chose not to focus on the undisputed facts nor on the clear legal principles the witnesses set out. Once more, they showed how unserious and irresponsible they are, devoid of any respect for their oaths of office. Again and again, McQuade and Vance came back to the facts: Trump's efforts to stop or derail the investigation were tied to contemporaneous reports that he was being investigated for obstruction.
The hearing demonstrated three things. First, Republicans must obscure the report and lie about its contents since it has no real defense to Trump's conduct. The amount of evidence is extensive. McQuade argued that this was worse than Watergate; Vance reaffirmed that this was not a close call and that there was substantial evidence of criminality.
Second, all witnesses and a number of congressmen made the strong case that McGahn's testimony is essential. Third, this is the beginning of a process that will, if committee chairman Jerrold Nadler (D-N.Y.) is successful, include fact witnesses who can bring to life what the panel explained on Monday. Whether it changes public opinion sufficiently to encourage Democrats to move to impeachment is unknown, but if part of the task here is to make an historical record, Democrats have certainly succeeded. And if Trump is paying attention, he'll want to get a pardon before leaving office; there are about 1,000 prosecutors who'd love to take up the case for which Mueller has documents.
(Jennifer Rubin writes for The Washington Post)

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Cricket »

Shakib now eying to beat India


Bangladesh ace all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan knows, beating an inform India will be a tough proposition but he refuses to give up hopes, saying that they would come all guns blazing against the sub-continent giants when they take them on July 2 at Birmingham.After reviving the side's semifinal hope, beating ...

International »

Venezuela's former spy chief says Maduro could yet fall


AFP :Venezuela's former intelligence chief, Cristopher Figuera, who fled the country after backing a failed uprising against President Nicolas Maduro in April, has told the Washington Post the regime could still fall."I'm proud of what I did," he said in an interview published online late Monday. "For now, the regime ...

International »

Russian, North American astronauts return to earth


AFP :The first crew to blast off to the International Space Station following a launch accident that deepened doubts over Russia's space programme returned to earth safely on Tuesday.NASA astronaut Anne McClain, veteran cosmonaut Oleg Kononenko of Roscosmos, and Canadian Space Agency record-holder David Saint-Jacques emerged from the space craft ...

Editorial »

Food adulteration business must stop


RESEARCHERS at Dhaka University on Tuesday said all the samples of milk products; edible oils and spices they tested were substandard. According to newspaper reports, they have found traces of detergent in pasteurised milk produced by five companies -- Pran, Milk Vita, Igloo, Aarong, and Farm Fresh. The DU researchers ...

Entertainment »

Mimi`s heartwarming wish for newly-wed Nusrat


No wonder Nusrat Jahan and Nikhil Jain's destination wedding in the picturesque town of Bodrum in Turkey became the talk of the town over the last two weeks. Tolly actress and newly elected MP Nusrat got hitched to Kolkata-based businessman Nikhil Jain on June 19. It was a cosy family ...

Editorial »

Train accident: Responsible persons must be punished


AT least five people, including three women, were killed and more than 100 injured as the Upaban Express -- a passenger train heading to the capital from Sylhet -- derailed on a bridge in Moulvibazar on Sunday night. One of the carriages of it fell into a canal while two ...

Entertainment »

Shirin Shila`s Lady Action


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :With the inspiration and assistance from noted film actress Rasheda Chowdhury Shirin Shila started her journey in film industry. Before starting acting in big screen Shila acted with Rasheda Chowdhury in a drama. Basically Rasheda Chowdhury inspired Shila to work in movie. Once she also introduced Shila ...

Cricket »

Shakib first Bangladeshi batsman to complete 1000 WC runs


Talismanic all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan became the first Bangladeshi batsman to complete 1000 runs in the World Cup during the match against Afghanistan at the Rose Bowl in Southampton on Monday.Starting the match with 965 runs and 35 runs shy of achieve the feat, Shakib flicked pace bowler Dawlat Zadran ...

International »

Saudi women use wedding contracts to assert right to drive


AFP, Dammam :Saudi salesman Majd had just begun his wedding preparations when his fiancee sought to enshrine in their marriage contract a condition already guaranteed by law-her right to drive.Wedding contracts have long been a safety net for brides in the deeply patriarchal society, used to guarantee demands that are ...

International »

Iran denies US cyber attack ahead of new sanctions


AFP  :Iran denied Monday it was hit by a US cyber attack as Washington was due to tighten sanctions on Tehran in a standoff sparked by the US withdrawal from a nuclear deal.Both nations say they want to avoid going to war, but tensions have spiralled as a series of ...

City »

Chief of Army Staff General Aziz Ahmed inaugurated a building of Baridhara Scholars International School and College in the city on Monday.


Cricket »

No six pack but Malinga still a big-game hunter: Mahela Jayawardene


Former Sri Lanka captain Mahela Jayawardene praised Lasith Malinga for his ability to step up in big games after the paceman inspired his country's shock World Cup win over England.Malinga returned figures of four for 43 to help Sri Lanka dismiss England for 212 as they stunningly beat the hosts ...

Editorial »

Banks must strengthen security systems to counter cyber heists


NEWS media reported that transnational scammers in May attacked three Bangladeshi commercial banks' networks and stole around Tk 25 crore from Dutch Bangla Bank Limited (DBBL) while two other banks — NCC Bank and Prime Bank — claimed they however managed to avert financial losses.Intelligence agencies said hackers planted malware ...

International »

UK's Boris Johnson under pressure to explain domestic 'row'


Boris Johnson, the strong favourite to become Britain's next prime minister, came under pressure from figures in his own party on Sunday to explain reports of a domestic 'row' that led to a police visit.Although still heavily backed to beat Jeremy Hunt to become Conservative Party leader, and therefore prime ...

International »

North Korean leader receives 'excellent' letter from Trump: KCNA


AFP, Seoul :North Korean leader Kim Jong Un received a personal letter of "excellent content" from US President Donald Trump, the country's state media said Sunday, amid a nuclear deadlock between Pyongyang and Washington.Talks have been stalled since the collapse of a second summit between Kim and Trump in Hanoi ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news