Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Wednesday, October 23, 2019 12:21:41 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Democracy Indonesian Style

Voters Are Very Disappointed With This

Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Aris Arif Mundayat :
On the morning of July 18, a Yogyakarta radio station broadcast a long lecture on the urgency of an Islamic caliphate. The speaker said democracy was not in line with Allah's way, but rather the product of Western politics that marginalized Islam and restricted Muslims' role in politics.
Political parties, as a product of democracy, have split Muslims and pitted them against each other, so they are dubbed assobiyah zalim (cruel primordial groups). At the end of the lecture, the speaker said: "Seize the power, go into politics in the name of Islam and establish khilafah [Islamic State]!"
More or less around that day, the 212 Alumni Association leaders stated that khilafah Islamiyah must be upright in 2024. Then, they denounced their losing presidential candidate Prabowo Subianto as a traitor for agreeing to reconcile with Joko "Jokowi" Widodo, the reelected president. This boldness seems related to their feeling of success in gaining more than 68.65 million or 44.50 percent of the vote in the 2019 presidential race.
In the 1980s, the procaliphate movement promoted its aspiration through tarbiyah (education) as a moderation strategy to gain popular support, considering the fact that the New Order was tough against radical political Islam. At the same time, Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) engaged with vertical mobility through state politics, while Muhammadiyah focused on education. The public spaces in rural and urban areas left vacant by the two mainstream Islamic organizations were filled by prokhilafah groups.
Within five years, they recruited cadres who were fresh university graduates. They then worked as teachers, lecturer assistants or research assistants in state institutions. Three to five years later, they obtained master and doctorate degrees, and secured important positions in the state apparatus with all the influential consequences.
Their preachers started to control mosques in kampungs and housing complexes in major cities. The Muslim-only property business, meanwhile, has bloomed since late 1990s.
Procaliphate thoughts occupy the public mind in a systematic way. They have been disseminated through various strategies that enable them to develop across social strata, ethnicities and cultures.
The Indonesian professor Vedi Hadiz of Melbourne University, Australia, notes that Islamic populism has the ability to build popular solidarity for political purposes. Compared with Ikhwanul Muslimin in Egypt and the Justice and Development Party (AKP) in Turkey, Islamic populism in Indonesia lacks control over state institutions, a strong economic base and the discipline of organization. Thanks to their strict discipline, Ikhwanul and AKP rose to power.
In my observation, the prokhilafah movement has silently secured important posts in various state institutions through its cadres. Although the state has detected them and tried to cut them off, they have grown in number and spread their influence clandestinely.
They have also developed various economic resources like plantations outside Java, sharia student dormitories and Arabized commodities.
However, on a macro basis, those achievements are incomparable with existing oligarchs, therefore, they rely on state resources. They are confident with their social capital and seem to consider the possibility of formalizing sharia within the unitary state of Indonesia as a transition before they finally remove Pancasila when gaining power.
Khilafahism is more complex than just an ideology like communism. It is a "faithological" phenomenon as it combines rational reasons and religious belief. To build radical fervor they created the strong slogan "Kafir [infidel], no! Islam, yes!!" to encourage followers. Understandably, the NU responded with a fatwa that bans the use of "kafir" to refer to believers of religions other than Islam.
The NU and Muhammadiyah leaders consider the concept of syura in the Quran to be a form of deliberative democracy, but this is not the case in khilafahism. Majelis Syura (consultation assembly) in khilafah consists of Allah's chosen clerics, while in democracy it consists of people's representatives.
President-elect Jokowi and vice president-elect Ma'ruf Amin to some extent represent nationalist, secular and religious traditionalists, with their votes largely coming from Javanese. The idea of power here has to be understood in the context of the culture they gained support from.
The late American anthropologist Benedict Anderson once noted that legitimacy is not something to worry about in the Javanese idea of power. For example, politicians are concerned more about horse-trading for strategic political positions in the state than people's welfare.
Voters are very disappointed with this, but again, legitimacy is not the question. Due to this, institutionalization of the opposition is difficult to materialize, as parties are involved in this horse-trading. As a result, there is no ideological distinction between political parties. Khilafahism finally takes the oppositional position outside the state.
The prodemocracy group considers the prokhilafah movement to be a totalitarian movement that intends to replace the modern state of Indonesia and Pancasila. Those aspiring for khilafah dream of a leader of the Quraysh ethnicity as Allah's chosen and historically proven one to implement Islamic law. For those who are prodemocracy, this is equivalent to Hitler's totalitarian fantasy with the superiority of the Aryan nation.
In his book Theory of Militant Democracy, Alexander Khrisner explains how democracy in the West is challenged by extreme populism. The assumption is that popular antidemocratic groups do exist, and their interests to participate are legitimate. It is therefore a challenging and uneasy question to consider how democracy should treat khilafahism, which is clearly a rejection of democracy.
So far, at least in Indonesia, khilafahism has been treated undemocratically, by use of an authoritarian security approach. This is a grave political miscalculation, as it confirms the prokhilafah narrative of the political marginalization of Islam.
Finally, democratic militancy needs a strategy to transform the contestation into deliberation to seek political meeting points between democracy and khilafah Islamiyah. Militant democrats also need to develop inclusive participation rights so as to break the narrative that Islam is marginalized.
This is what Antonio Gramsci calls "compromise equilibrium". Building political inclusion in a multicultural society like Indonesia is a must for the sake of a healthy democracy.
(Aris Arif Mundayat, the writer lectures in sociology at the school of social and political sciences at Sebelas Maret State University, Surakarta, Central Java; also writes to Jakarta Post)

Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Killing by police and filing case against five thousand people are not solutions

At least four people were killed and more than a hundred others injured on Tuesday as religious men clashed with police in Bhola's Borhanuddin upazila over a hate conversation spread through Facebook and messenger. At one stage of the clash that broke out around 10:30am, law enforcers had to fire ...

Football »

'Gentle giant' Lukaku thriving at Inter Milan after Man United flop

AFP, Milan :Italian coach Antonio Conte has made his "gentle giant" Romelu Lukaku the focus of Inter Milan's attack this season where the striker has found his scoring touch again after leaving Manchester United.The Belgian got off the mark in his first league match against Lecce and has since scored ...

Football »

Sheffield United beat Arsenal 1-0 in Premier League

AP, Sheffield :Arsenal slumped to a 1-0 loss at promoted Sheffield United on Monday in the Premier League, upping the pressure on coach Unai Emery after another performance void of creativity and flair.Lys Mousset took advantage of poor defending from a corner to tap in from close range in the ...

City »

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina addressing a discussion at Krishibid Institution, Bangladesh in the city's Khamarbari on Tuesday marking National Safe Road Day.

International »

Trump says ‘small’ number of US troops remain in Syria

AFP, Washington :President Donald Trump said Monday that a "small" number of U.S. troops will remain in Syria amid blistering criticism from lawmakers in both parties who have denounced his previous decision to withdraw American forces."I'm trying to get out of wars. We may have to get in wars, too," ...

International »

Netanyahu fails to form govt before deadline, opportunity for rival

AP, Jerusalem :Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu informed Israel's president Monday he could not form a new government following deadlocked September elections, making way for his opponent Benny Gantz to try.The decision was an important defeat for Netanyahu as he seeks to continue his tenure as Israel's longest-serving prime minister, but ...

National »

PANCHBIBI (Joypurhat): Farmers at Joypurhat passing busy time preparing fields for potato cultivation. This snap was taken from Gangaprosad village yesterday.

Business & Economy »

Mohammad Ali, DMD of Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited, speaking at a View Exchange & Discussion meeting of Rural Development Scheme (RDS), organized by Rajshahi Zone of the bank at its Pabna Branch premises on Saturday. Md. Kawsar ul Alam, Rajshahi Zonal head, M Jubayer Azam Halali, EVP of the bank and local elites were also present.

Entertainment »

Pooja Zunjar, new born baby die as family fails to get ambulance

Pooja Zunjar, a 25-year-old Marathi actress, and her newborn baby died within hours of birth in Maharashtra's Hingoli district on Sunday due to the unavailability of an ambulance.  Relatives of the deceased actress claimed - she would have been alive had they managed to get an ambulance in time.  The ...

Editorial »

Government has to take blame for mismanagement in WASA

The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Undertakings has expressed utmost dissatisfaction over Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority for its failure in providing safe drinking water to citizens, dealing with the waterlogging problem and alleged widespread corruption of its officials. The JS body asked the Dhaka WASA managing director to ...

Cricket »

Rashid taken with first pick in Hundred draft as Gayle misses out

Afghanistan star Rashid Khan became the first player selected in The Hundred draft, but West Indies legend Chris Gayle wasn't selected for next year's tournament.Rashid has enjoyed a superb start to his international career, with 81 wickets at 12.03 in Twenty20 making him ideal for the new eight-team UK-based competition ...

Sports »

Andy Murray jokes 'I need to get back on the road' after European Open win

Andy Murray said he would reassess his goals after a "surprise" win at the European Open, and joked that he needed to get back on tour to stop his family growing too large.The Scot, 32, had hip surgery in January and won his first title in two years in Antwerp ...

Entertainment »

Faria in new TVC after two years

Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Viewers’ choice model and actress Faria Shahrin has returned to country few days ago after completing Honours in Media Marketing from Asia Pacific University of Malaysia. According to her, from now she will remain in country and will work in media regularly. She has already started work. ...

International »

Beijing says no one can stop Taiwan ‘reunification’

AFP, Beijing :China's defence minister made an uncompromising call Monday for the "reunification" of Taiwan with the mainland, telling a high level defence forum that the process was something "no force" could stop.Self-ruled Taiwan is viewed by China as a renegade province which will eventually be unified with the mainland, ...

International »

US troops in Syria heading to Iraq, not home as Trump claims

AP, Kabul :While President Donald Trump insists he's bringing home Americans from "endless wars" in the Mideast, his Pentagon chief says all U.S. troops leaving Syria will go to western Iraq and the American military will continue operations against the Islamic State group.They aren't coming home and the United States ...

Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Write a comment to this news