Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, February 23, 2020 01:46:27 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Discussing the Evidences

Trial Tribunal should have been more realistic, easy and comfortable

By
21st-Sep-2019       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

High Court Division :
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
ANM Bashir Ullah J
Mustafa Zaman Islam J     
Kamal Kha ……………..
………Convict-Appellant
                 vs
State……….. Respondent
Judgment
June 25th, 2018
Arms Act (XI of 1878)
Sections 19A & (f)
The tribunal in order to convict the appellants distorted the evidence of PWs 1-5 in his own way although they did not give any evidence regarding the recovery of arms on the showing of accused Kamal Kha. The tribunal should have been more, realistic, easy and comfortable to discuss the evidence as it is in the record but we do not know the reasons as to why he explained the evidence in his own way with some imagination which is not at all consistent with the testimony of PWs…………… (25)
AKM Faiz, Advocate-For the Appellant.
Md Aminul Islam DAG with Fatema Rashid AAG-For the Stale Respondent.

Judgment

ANM Bashir Ullah J : This criminal appeal, under Section 30 of the Special Powers Act, 1974 (in short, the Act) is directed against the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 31-1-1991 passed by Additional Sessions Judge, 1st Court and Special Tribunal No. 2, Brahmanbaria convicting the appellant under Sections 19(a) and (f) of the Arms Act sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 10 years in Special Tribunal Case No. 45 of 1990.
2. The facts relevant for disposal of the appeal, in short is that Police Inspector Md Iqbal, Officer in Charge of Nabinagar Police Station of district Brahmanbaria lodged the First Information Report (in short, the FIR) on 13-11-1989 with Nabinagar Police Station against the present appellant Kamal Kha alleging inter-alia that accused was arrested by the Police of the Sarail Police Station on 6-11-1989 thereafter he was shown arrested in connection of the Nabinagar Police Station Case No. 9 dated 22-8-1989 and on a remand of 5 days in the said case he was interrogated by the Police when accused Kamal Kha admitted that he has been possessing a cuta rifle (KvUv ivB‡dj) and 11 round bullets which he had kept in a ditch attached to the house of Samsu Kha of his own village at Jalsuka and accordingly the informant on 13-11-1989 at 12-00 o'clock had gone to the Jalsuka village in order to recover the said arms and they having been on the bank of the said ditch on the showing of accused Kamal Kha recovered' a cuta rifle and 11 round bullets from the said ditch. The accused could not show any paper of the said recovered arms and bullets which were seized under a seizure list in presence of witnesses Basu Mia, Nur Ahmad Kha and Harun Mia.
3. On the basis of the above noted FIR Nabinagar PS case No. 5 dated 13-11-89 corresponding to Brahmanbaria GR Case No. 123 of 1989 were started. The case was investigated initially by Police Inspector Md Iqbal, the informant of this case and later on Police Sub-Inspector Shahjahan Kamal who on completion of the investigation submitted report recommending the trial of the accused Kamal Kha under Section 19(a) and (f) of the Arms Act.
4. The learned Magistrate on receipt of the Police report transmitted the case record in the Special Tribunal and Sessions Judge, Brahmanbaria for trial where the case was registered as Special Tribunal Case No. 45 of 1990 and eventually the case was transferred in the Court of the Special Tribunal No.2 and Additional Sessions Judge, 1st Court, Brahmimbaria where charge under Sections 19(a) and (f) of the Arms Act were framed against the accused on 24-3-1990. The charges were read over and explained to the accused to which pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
5. The prosecution, in order to prove the charge examined as many as 6 witnesses and on completion of the recording of the evidence, the accused was examined under Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure when he repeated his innocence and made a statement which was recorded by the trial Tribunal.
6. The trial Tribunal on consideration of the evidence and other materials on record found the appellant guilty under Sections 19(a) and (f) of the Arms Act and sentenced him accordingly as mentioned hereinbefore. The appellant being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said judgment of the trial Tribunal preferred this appeal in this Court and after admission of the appeal the appellant was enlarged on bail on 13-3-1991 for a period of 6 (six) months later which was extended on 28-8-1991 for 3 (three) months but thereafter it was never extended.
7. Mr AKM Faiz, the learned Advocate appearing for the appellant supporting the appeal and assailing the judgment passed by the trial Tribunal submits that Police arrested the accused on 6-11-1989 thereafter when he was in the Police custody the present arms case was filed against him showing a recovery at his instance but, in fact, no such arms were recovered at the instance of this appellant and the prosecution in order to prove the charge examined as many as 6 witnesses out of which PWs 1,2,3,4 and 5 are the members of the recovery party at the same time they are the Police personnel but they did not support the prosecution case in any manner but the Tribunal without considering the evidence on record and without appreciating the evidence very arbitrarily found the appellant guilty.
8. The learned Advocate also submits that this a case where no evidence was led by the prosecution in order to prove the recovery of arms from the appellant but the trial Tribunal without applying his judicial mind distorted the evidence given by the prosecution witnesses in the judgment that the prosecution witnesses supported the prosecution case which is not at all consistent with the materials on record.
9. The learned Advocate also submits that this a case of nil evidence but even then the Tribunal found the appellant guilty, so the judgment and order of conviction and sentence are liable to be set aside.
10. Mr Md Aminul Islam, the learned Deputy Attorney General along, with Mrs. Fatema Rashid the learned Assistant Attorney General appearing for the state respondent No.1 supporting the judgment of the trial Tribunal and opposing the submissions of learned Advocate for the appellant made so far contends that the arms were recovered on the showing of the appellant and from the evidence on record it will be revealed that in his presence the arms and ammunition were recovered and the trial Tribunal on the right assessment of evidence and other materials on record rightly found the appellant guilty, so the judgment and order of conviction and sentence did not call for any interference from this Court, so the appeal is liable to be dismissed with cost.
11. We have considered  the above submissions of the learned Advocates of both the parties with profound attention and have gone through the materials on record particularly the FIR, order of framing charge evidence recorded by the trial Tribunal, the examination of the accused under Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and finally the judgment passed by the trial Tribunal.
12. Now in order to appreciate the arguments of the learned Advocates of both the parties let us have a look into the evidence on record.
13. PW 1 Police Constable Abdul Mannan, a member of the recovery party testified that on 13-11-1989 he under the leadership of the then Officer in Charge Md Iqbal had gone at Jalsuka village and they recovered 1 cuta rifle and 11 round bullets from a ditch and at the time of recovery Kamal was there (accused).
14. In cross examination of the defence PW 1 also stated that when arms were recovered Kamal was not present with them and he categorically stated that he could not say whether the arms were recovered at the instance of accused Kamal or not.
15. PW 2 Police Constable Mahbub Ali is another member of the recovery party stated that they recovered 1cuta rifle and 11 round bullets from a ditch of Jalsuka Village on 13-11-1989 a local people brought the said arms from the ditch and the Officer in Charge prepared the seizure list of the said goods.
16. In cross examination of the defence he stated that arms were not recovered from the possession and control of accused Kamal.
17.  PW 3 Police Sub-Inspector Shahidullah another member of the recovery party stated that on 13-11-1989 they recovered one cuta rifle and 11 round bullets from a ditch and the same were seized under a seizure list.
18. In cross examination he stated that Kamal was not with them at the time of recovery.
 19. PW 4 Police Constable Mir Harun-or-Rashid testified that on 13-11-1989 he under the leadership the then Officer in Charge had gone at Jalsuka village and they recovered 1 cuta rifle and 11 round bullets from a ditch.
20. In cross examination he stated that he cannot say who recovered the arms.
21. PW 5 Police Constable Mafiz Mia is the another member of the recovery party also stated that he had gone at Jalsuka village on 13-11-1989 under the leadership of the then Officer in Charge and they recovered 1 cuta rifle and 11 round bullets from a ditch. There is no significant of cross examination of PW 5.
22. PW 6 Md Shahjahan Kamal testified that on 14-12-1989 he was posted at Nabinagor Police Station and since the 1st IO Police Inspector Md Iqbal had been transferred to elsewhere the case was endorsed to him for investigation and on completion of investigation he submitted Police report recommending the trial of the accused.
23. These are the evidences that have been given by the prosecution in this case. From the evidence discussed above it appears that PWs 1-5 are the members of the recovery party while PW 6 is the Investigating officer of this case. The prosecution could not examine the seizure list witnesses. However, from the evidence discussed above it appears that all the prosecution witnesses namely PWs 1-5 almost in a chorus voice stated that on 13-11-1989 they have recovered 1 cuta rifle and 11 round bullets from a ditch at Jalsuka village under the leadership of the then Officer in Charge, Police Inspector Md Iqbal but there is no evidence in their testimony that the arms in question were recovered at the instance of accused Kamal Kha or on his showing.
24. The initial prosecution case was that after the arrest of the accused Kamal Kha when he was in Police remand he disclosed to the Police that he has possessing some arms and bullets and on his showing arms and bullets were recovered from a ditch attached to house of one Samsu Kha. Though prosecution examined 5 members of the recovery party who are the at the same time Police personnel also did not give any incriminatory evidence regarding the recovery of arms from the possession, knowledge or control of accused Kamal Kha. In fact, there appears no evidence regarding the recovery of arms from the possessions of the Kamal Kha although the evidence is very much consistence regarding the recovery of arms from a ditch only.
25. However, on going through judgment passed by the trial Tribunal we have been totally befogged to see the observation that the witnesses supported the prosecution case of recovery from the possession of accused Kamal Kha although we failed to discover a single word in the testimony of the 5 witnesses namely PWs 1-5 regarding the recovery of arms from the possession of accused Kamal Kha. We are very much sorry to say that the trial Tribunal in order to convict the appellants distorted the evidence of PWs 1-5 in his own way although they did not give any evidence regarding the recovery of arms on the showing of accused Kamal Kha. The trial Tribunal should have been more, realistic, easy and comfortable to discuss the evidence as it is in the record but we do not know the reasons as to why he explained the evidence in his own way with some imagination which is not at all consistent with the testimony of PWs 1-5. In fact, this a case of nil evidence regarding the recovery of arms from the possession of the appellant, so we find it difficult to maintain the conviction and sentence of the appellant.
26. In the result, the appeal is allowed. The judgment and order of conviction dated 31-1-1991 passed by Additional Sessions Judge, 1st Court and Special Tribunal No.2,  Brahmanbaria and in Special Tribunal Case No. 45 of 1990 is hereby set aside. The convict appellant Kamal Kha be acquitted of the charge levelled against him in this case.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Govt incapable of deciding how to deal with Rohingya crises


NEWSPAPERS reported that the government is shifting its previous stance on sheltering one lakh Rohingyas to remote Bhashan Char due to constant objections from the international community, especially the aid agencies. Bhashan Char is only 25 kilometres from Sandwip Island and it has a fast siltation rate. There is also ...

Football »

Lewandowski double edge Bayern past bottom side Paderborn


Bundesliga leaders Bayern Munich squeezed past bottom side Paderborn 3-2 on Friday as Robert Lewandowski netted twice to spare goalkeeper Manuel Neuer's blushes in their final game before facing Chelsea in the Champions League.Lewandowski now has a league-leading tally of 26 goals in the top flight, illustrating his importance to ...

Entertainment »

Priyanka wishes Sophie a happy birthday


Priyanka Chopra has shared a sweet birthday wish for sister-in-law and Game of Thrones actor Sophie Turner on her 24th birthday. She shared a picture from the 2017 MET Gala where she not just made her first appearance with now husband Nick Jonas but also met Sophie. Sharing the picture ...

Sports »

Venezuela's Rojas sets new indoor women's triple jump world record


Venezuela's Yulimar Rojas on Friday set a new indoor women's triple jump world record of 15.43m at a meeting in Madrid.The 24-year-old world champion bettered the previous world record of 15.36m set by Russia's Tatyana Lebedeva in Budapest in March 2004.Rojas's new mark also left her just seven centimetres short ...

International »

Sanders condemns Russian interference in 2020 elections


Agencies :Bernie Sanders on Friday condemned Russian interference in the 2020 election, telling Russia President Vladimir Putin that "if elected president, trust me, you are not going to be interfering in American elections."Sanders issued a statement in response to The Washington Post's report that the Vermont senator was briefed by ...

International »

China's President expresses thanks to Bill Gates help for tackling virus epidemic


AFP, Beijing :Chinese President Xi Jinping has written a letter expressing thanks to the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation for the organisation's "generosity" and support tackling a deadly virus epidemic, state media said Saturday.The outbreak of the new COVID-19 strain has claimed 2,345 lives in mainland China and infected more ...

Entertainment »

Angrezi Medium’s song Ek Zindagi is all about living dreams


Homi Adajania’s upcoming comedy-drama film Angrezi Medium is about the lovable relationship between a father and his daughter. The chemistry of the relation is portrayed beautifully by Irrfan Khan and Radhika Madaan in the trailer and now the makers have released the first song from the fil titled Ek Zindagi ...

Football »

Messi sees 'strange' things at Barcelona after social media row


Lionel Messi said Wednesday it was "strange" to see Barcelona locked in a row over a company accused of criticising current and former players, including himself, on social media.Barcelona president Josep Maria Bartomeu said on Tuesday the club had terminated its contract with PR company, I3 Ventures, who had been ...

Editorial »

21 February should be celebration of free speech


THE historic Amtala, where Language Movement activists gathered on February 21, 1952 to defy a curfew and protest the then Pakistan government's refusal to recognise Bangla as one of the State languages of Pakistan is covered by encroachers.Pakistan government was ultimately compelled to include an article in the country's Constitution ...

International »

How Trump visit could leverage CAA and Kashmir against PM Modi


Agencies, New Delhi :As India rolls out the red carpet to receive US President Donald Trump next week, rough spots that have arisen in the wake of the Modi government's decisions on Kashmir and the subsequent passing of the Citizenship Amendment Act will need diplomatic resolution. The Modi government's sudden ...

International »

India ‘bigger problem’ than China: Michael Bloomberg on carbon emissions


PTI, Washington :India poses a bigger problem than China when it comes to fighting climate change, particularly on reducing carbon emissions, Democratic presidential aspirant and former New York mayor Michael Bloomberg has said.During his maiden appearance on a Democratic presidential primary debate in Las Vegas on Wednesday, Bloomberg said it ...

Editorial »

We need a caring govt: Mere court's directions cannot go far


THE High Court Division on Tuesday directed the government to ensure setting up breastfeeding and baby care corners in the country's all the mills and factories. Most of the working women have to resign from jobs or take an attempt due to unavailability of baby care facilities at workplaces. When ...

Cricket »

Host Australia target fifth title at women's T20 World Cup


Mighty Australia go into their home Twenty20 World Cup this week as overwhelming favourites as they look to cement their superiority in women's cricket and draw a world-record crowd in the process.Meg Lanning's defending champions, and four-time winners, were rarely tested through the second half of 2019 when they whitewashed ...

Entertainment »

Baaghi 3’s new song Bhankas is surely the wedding song


After wowing the audience with the action packed trailer and the groovy number Dus Bahane 2.0, the makers of Baaghi 3 have released the latest song from the movie titled Bhankas. The new track, Bhankas is a remake of Bappi Lahiri’s original song and once again is set to break ...

International »

Sanders hopes early strength will prove he can beat Trump


AP, Las Vegas :Terry Reece has long been skeptical that voters would back Bernie Sanders, a 78-year-old self-described democratic socialist who is just months removed from a heart attack. Then the Vermont senator essentially tied for first place in the Democratic Party's Iowa caucuses and won its New Hampshire primary.That ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news