Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Thursday, December 12, 2019 10:14:47 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Non-agriculture Tenancy

Right to pre-empt accrues only after transfer, not before

By
30th-Nov-2019       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Appellate Division :
       (Civil)
Md Abdul Wahhab Miah  
Md Imman Ali J
AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury J
Awlas Hossain Babor……..Petitioner
              vs
Ziaul Hasan Chowdhury and others….Respondents
Judgment
June 15th, 2015
Non Agricultural Tenancy Act (XXIII of 1949)
 Section 24
Whether because of the Pourashava road, the land stands partitioned by the act of a statutory body, and thus the pre-emptor is not a co-sharer……......(7)
Mahbubey Alam, Senior Advocate, instructed by Chowdhury Md Zahangir, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioner.
Kamal-ul-Alam, Senior Advocate, instructed by Zainul Abedin Advocate-on-Record-For the  Respondents No.1
None Represented-Respondent Nos. 2-57.
Judgment
Md Imman Ali J: This civil petition for leave to appeal is directed against the judgement and order dated 18-8-2011 passed by a Division Bench of the High Court Division in First Miscellaneous Appeal No. 234 of 2009.
2. Respondent No. 1 before us as pre-emptor filed the pre-emption case under Section 24 of the Non-Agricultural Tenancy Act on 1-1-2009 m the Court of Joint District Judge, 1st Court, Faridpur to pre-empt 0.0560 acre of land out of 0.1706 acre of plot No. 1311 of S.A Khatian No. 115 of Mouza No. 118 of Faridpur Pourashava.
3. The pre-emptor averred that he is the descendant of the person who owned 0.1031 acre of land in the subject and other plots, while the opposite parties No. 13-17, 18-20, 21-22 and 2-12, are the heirs of one Adil Uddin Ahmed, who was a recorded co-sharer of the case Khatian, but they do not possess the same, but live in Dhaka.
4. The aforesaid opposite parties No. 2-12, without informing the pre-emptor clandestinely transferred their share in the land on 25-11-2008 to opposite party No.1, the pre-emptee, who is a stranger. The pre-emptor, as a co-sharer in the land, having his place of abode thereon would definitely have purchased the land had he known of the opposite party's decision to sell the land.
5.  Case of the pre-emptee respondent is that when the seller declared his interest to sell the land neither the pre-emptor, nor his sister, the opposite party No. 29, who were present, showed any interest to buy the land. The opposite party Nos. 2-12 of the pre-emption case were not known to the pre-emptee. It was the husband of opposite party No. 29 who informed the pre-emptee of the owner's decision to sell the case land. When visited the opposite party No. 29's house, the seller declared his wish to sell the land presence of opposite party No.2, opposite party No. 3 and many concerned people, including the owners and the pre-emptee expressed his desire to buy the land. That though the land was purchased for Taka 36 lacs, the price was shown as Taka 11,01,000 at the instruction of opposite party No. 29.     
6. The Joint District Judge, 1st Court, Faridpur allowed the pre-emption case in Miscellaneous Case No, 1 of 2009. On appeal the High-court Division in First Miscellaneous Appeal No. 234 of 2009, on 18-8-2011, affirmed the judgment of the trial Court. The High Court Division observed that the evidence on record depict that the pre-emptor is a co-sharer by inheritance and is also holder of adjacent land and opposite party No,-2 admitted that the land was not partitioned and that it could not be proved that the case is barred by estoppels, waiver or acquiescence.                                             
7. As we picked up the leave petition for hearing Mr Mahbubey Alam, the learned Senior Advocate for the leave petitioner argued that as it is proved that the pre-emptor was present when the seller declared his intention to sell the land, but  expressed unwillingness to buy the same, the High Court Division erred in affirming the trial Court's judgment. He also submitted, that oral evidence on the difference between the actual and corded price should have been given effect, to as the Same was proved by oral and documentary evidence. He also added that the case land and the  pre-emptor's land  has been divided by a Pourashava road, and, as such, the pre-emptor's land cannot be deemed to be contiguous to the case land, and also the plea of necessity or family privacy is not applicable. He continued to say that because of the Pourashava road, the land stands partitioned by the act of a statutory body, and thus the pre-emptor is not a co-sharer.
8. Mr Kamal-ul-Alam, the learned Senior Advocate for respondent No.1 argued that the trial Court did not, by examining evidence, believe in the claim that the pre-emptor was present at the time the seller declared his intention to sell the land, but expressed his unwillingness to buy the land. He added that the right to pre-empt arises only after the transfer, not before that.
9 Having gone through the judgements of the court below and the transcripts of evidence, and having considered the submissions of the learned Advocates, we are left with no doubt as to the cogency and accuracy of the judgements of the Courts below.
10. On the petitioner's plea that the pre-emptor was present, but expressed unwillingness to buy the land, the trial Court made a factual finding that the same could not be proved. In any event the law is that right to pre-empt accrues only after transfer, not before.
11. We are unable to accept the contention that the Pourashava road caused the land to be partitioned, because that cannot be drawn to the concept of partition, which has to be voluntary or by judicial order.
The leave petition having no merit is thus dismissed.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Indian citizenship law to create instability in this region


PROTESTORS across India, particularly in northeast India, set fire to tyres and cut down trees to block roads on Tuesday after lawmakers approved the government's new citizenship bill. The legislation was placed before the upper house on Wednesday. It would fast-track citizenship for religious minorities, including Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, ...

Cricket »

New Zealand brace for Australian challenge, sweat on Boult fitness


The validity and durability of New Zealand's ranking and run of success in Test cricket will be tested in the sport's most hostile environment when it meet Australia on Thursday to open a three-match series.New Zealand have risen to No. 2 in the world test rankings after an unbeaten string ...

Entertainment »

Shalini Pandey is Ranveer’s heroine in Jayeshbhai Jordaar


Shalini Pandey had mesmerised everyone with her infectious charm and acting prowess in the Telugu blockbuster Arjun Reddy and we can confirm that her big Bollywood launch will be as Ranveer Singh’s heroine in the much-anticipated Jayeshbhai Jordaar releasing next year. Shalini debuts with this Yash Raj Films production whose ...

International »

Foreign interference in US elections 'unacceptable': Pompeo


AP, Washington :Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said on Tuesday that any foreign interference in American elections is "unacceptable" and warned Russia and others that the Trump administration will protect the integrity of the vote.In wide-ranging talks with his Russian counterpart Sergey Lavrov that also included disputes over arms control ...

International »

Johnson on track for 24-seat majority: Focaldata


Reuters, London :Prime Minister Boris Johnson's Conservative Party is on track for a 24-seat majority after Thursday's general election, polling company Focaldata forecast on Tuesday, down sharply from its forecast last month of an 82-seat majority.Focaldata predicted that the Conservatives would win 337 seats in the 650-seat parliament, followed by ...

Editorial »

Questions raised by President are valid but his govt doesn't care


PRESIDENT Abdul Hamid on Monday said commercial courses were turning public universities into business organisations and also disrupting the educational atmosphere on the campus.  "Thousands of graduates are being produced every year with these commercial courses where a section of teachers is making profits," he said at the 52nd Convocation ...

Sports »

Russia reacts with anger after doping ban from Olympics, WC


AFP, Lausanne :The World Anti-Doping Agency on Monday banned Russia for four years from major global sporting events including the 2020 Tokyo Olympics and the 2022 World Cup (WC) in Qatar over manipulated doping data, prompting an angry response from President Vladimir Putin.WADA's executive committee, meeting in Lausanne, handed Russia ...

International »

Activists hold placards as they attend a protest against climate change as the COP25 climate summit held in Madrid, Spain.


Business & Economy »

Japanese regulators recommend $22m fine on Nissan


AP, Tokyo :Japanese securities regulators are recommending that automaker Nissan be fined 2.4 billion yen ($22 million) over the under-reporting of compensation of its former chairman, Carlos Ghosn.The watchdog, the Securities and Exchange Surveillance Commission, said Tuesday it made the recommendation to the government's Financial Services Agency on the disclosure ...

Entertainment »

Deepika looks vulnerable and powerful in the latest posters of 'Chhapaak'


Recently, the makers of Deepika Padukone and Vikrant Massey starrer 'Chhapaak' dropped the much-awaited trailer which received thumbs up from the audience. The trailer gave us a glimpse of into the life of acid attack survivor Malti and showed us how she emerges out as a fighter against all the ...

Entertainment »

Sushmita announces return to films


Sushmita Sen has announced that she is returning to films, nearly a decade after her last Bollywood outing, Anees Bazmee's No Problem (2010). She shared the news in an Instagram post and said that it was the love of her fans that encouraged her to do films again."I have always ...

Editorial »

Save Buriganga to save Dhaka dwellers: Court can’t


THE High Court has directed the Department of Environment (DoE) and Dhaka WASA to take effective steps to stop polluting Buriganga River. On Sunday, the HC asked the DoE to shut down all illegal industries, factories, and organisations on the Buriganga which are polluting the river. At the same time, ...

Entertainment »

Disha Patani’s monochrome looks of her latest magazine shoot


Setting the temperatures soaring, the hottest girl of B-town Disha Patani is capturing hearts as she turned cover girl for the December issue of ‘Harper’s Bazaar’ magazine. Disha’s fashion game has always been on point and she is one of the few actresses who do justice to any look she ...

Football »

Joaquin becomes La Liga's oldest hat-trick hero, Sevilla held


Real Betis captain Joaquin became the oldest player to score a La Liga hat-trick after he inspired his team to beat Athletic Bilbao 3-2 on Sunday.At 38 years and 140 days old, Joaquin hit his first ever hat-trick and surpassed Real Madrid great Alfredo Di Stefano, whose record as the ...

International »

At London temple, Boris Johnson pledges support to PM Modi's new India


PTI, London :British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has made a pledge to partner with Prime Minister Narendra Modi on his mission to build a new India, as he and his girlfriend Carrie Symonds visited a famous Hindu temple in London to woo Indian diaspora votes ahead of Thursday's General Election.Dressed ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news