Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Monday, July 6, 2020 07:22:55 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Pluralism State Sovereignty A Problem For It?

  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Dr. Forqan Uddin Ahmed :
We tend to imagine that pluralism is a new phenomenon-that the past was a place of intolerance and cultural isolation, in which religious and ethnic minorities were violently persecuted. Then, the story goes, modern ideas of rationality kicked in and globalization made the world ever more interconnected so that now we have become more pluralistic and syncretic than ever. This story is quite wrong. In fact, there are many examples of times and places in the past where pluralism was the dominant philosophy!
We have already seen that ancient India was ruled at one time by a pluralistic emperor, Ashoka the Great. Ashoka was a Buddhist, but he allowed Hinduism, Jainism, and countless other religions to thrive in his empire. Over a period, India was ruled by the Mughal Emperor Akbar, who was also renowned for his pluralism. Akbar was a Muslim, but he took counsel by Hindus and other religious thinkers in his royal court. In fact, Akbar went beyond tolerance and tried to create a new syncretic religion for India, based on a combination of Hinduism, Islam, and elements of Jainism and Buddhism.
Pluralism was also dominant in many times and places in the Ottoman Empire, an Islamic state that ruled the Middle East and lasted from 1299 all the way to 1923! Of course, in all those centuries, there were some times less tolerant than others, but overall the Ottoman Empire was remarkably pluralistic and allowed all sorts of ethnicities and religions to coexist under a single flag and a loose imperial alliance.
To some, pluralism seems to suggest relativism. According to this line of reasoning, in order to be a pluralist, it's necessary to believe that all ethical laws are relative to culture and circumstance, so there can be no one moral law that applies to everyone. So by extension, some people believe that pluralism cannot exist alongside universal morality. This is often a criticism of pluralism.
However, not all pluralists think this way. Some pluralists, for example, argue for a limited kind of tolerance in which all views are tolerated as far as possible, with some restrictions added for truly hateful views. Other pluralists argue that universal morality comes from compassion and acceptance-the core of pluralism, and a primary message of almost every religion; thus, for example, they argue that issues like abortion or gay marriage are less important than being empathetic towards other human beings. This allows for pluralism alongside universal morality.
State sovereignty is limited by practical and ethical reasons. Although the state is an inevitable organization, it has no moral recognition. According to Lasky, the state is a means of enriching and establishing civic life. The claim of his power and loyalty depends on how the state can develop that possibility. He holds that the state can have no permanent claim to power. The government will gradually surrender to those on whom the outcome of his work is reflected. History teaches that in the end, the application of free will becomes fatal to the government.
Although the weakness of pluralism has diminished its influence, the pluralistic perspective has not been completely exiled from the courtyard of political science. Modern state scientists, such as Arthur Bentley, David Truman, have attempted to review state science from a group perspective. Robert Dall, Lipset, Richard Hofstadter, prominent US scientists have noted the need for different groups and associations in the framework of a liberal and moral democratic system. According to many, in the capitalist countries, antagonistic social classes and groups were formed for the position of the opposing social classes and for the interdependence of the capitalists.
The experts of Marx philosophy discussed the application of the character of sovereignty to a completely new and historical perspective. According to the Marxian theory, the state is a class governance machine, a state-owned class of economic power. With the help of machines and controlling the production, one tries to protect his own class interests. So the characteristic of political power and sovereignty of the state will depend on the economic power structure, ownership and production control. In order to explain sovereignty properly or the ultimate power of the state, one must understand the class character of the state. It is possible to realize and present sovereignty through the class character of the state. According to the Marxist view, in every exploited social system, the state system acts as the protector of the master of the means of production, i.e. the economically dominant class. In an exploited society, state power is never class neutral. If sovereignty can be termed a manifestation of state power, then sovereignty can never be neutral in any case. It is possible to prove its authenticity from the history of exploited society.
It is possible to establish public sovereignty for the first time in a socialist society. It was through the socialist revolution that the proletariat ended the economic, social and political domination of the oppressors, and established the rule of the oppressed masses. The socialist revolution is a new kind of revolution. Its main aim is to end the private ownership of the socialization of production materials, to end class exploitation, to end the role of the capitalist's state as a means of exploitation, and to vest the state power in the hands of the majority. Private ownership of property is the source of exploitation and in the exploited society, the state acts to exploit power. Therefore, in all formerly exploited societies, the state power also became the political power of the exploiters, as the state became the instrument of exploitation of the exploiting classes.
Each state has to depend on another state for economic, cultural and many factors. Instead of competition, instead of cooperation and conflict, friendship has become the essence of the modern world. Lasky believes that the world has become so interdependent that the free will of any state can be a serious threat to humankind. According to him, as Roman law has become irrelevant now, state sovereignty has become irrelevant. The proliferation of nuclear warheads has introduced the need to restrict state sovereignty. The stubborn initiative of a state possessed by nuclear warfare can turn entire human civilization into ruin. There are currently two alternative paths facing the entire human race - the survival of humankind as a whole or the accelerating of the way to destruction. The sovereignty of the state is essential for the survival of the human race.
(Dr. Forqan Uddin Ahmed, writer, columnist & researcher)

Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Opening barrage in India worsening flood situation in Bangladesh

FOR the third time in 15 days, the River Teesta overflowed its danger mark in Lalmonirhat, after India opened all 54 gates at Gazaldoba Barrage on Saturday morning, worsening the flood situation in the north. Parts of the northern region have been underwater for eight days as the Dharla and ...

City »

Nahida Sobhan, Bangladesh Ambassador to Jordan, hands over necessary utensils to Dalal Sawyalha, Director of Amman's Joyaideh Rehabilitation Center, where a total of 103 Bangladeshi female detainees are living now after their arrest on various offences. Photo Courtesy: Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Entertainment »

Neha Kakkar flaunts her Indian traditional look on the Internet

Neha Kakkar, world-famous Bollywood singer and the judge of singing reality show Indian Idol recently shared some of her throwback pictures from the sets of Indian Idol on social media. Kakkar, who once was a contestant of Indian Idol herself is now one of the popular judges on the show. ...

Entertainment »

Andrew Kishore’s condition critical

Entertainment Report :Renowned playback singer Andrew Kishore, who has been battling cancer for months, is now in a critical condition as his condition deteriorated further. The singer has recently returned home from Singapore after months of treatment there. He is now undergoing treatment at his birth place in Rajshahi. “I’m ...

Entertainment »

Sara Ali Khan is twinning with her mother Amrita Singh

Sara Ali Khan posted some adorable pictures with her mother and popular actress of 90s Amrita Singh on Instagram, giving major mother-daughter goals. Sara Ali Khan is very popular with her traditional looks and recently the actress shared some lovely photos with her mom where both the daughter and mother ...

Cricket »

It's an immense honour to be on Wisden's list: Shakib

Bangladesh ace all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan expressed his pleasure to be on the Wisden's prestigious list, which ranked him 2nd Most Valuable Player (MVP) in ODI and sixth best in Test cricket."It's an immense honour for me to be on this prestigious list of outstanding cricketers and represent my country," ...

Business & Economy »

BB bans former NRBC Bank chairman Farasath for 2yrs

Economic Reporter :Bangladesh Bank (BB) banned former NRBC Bank chairman Farasath Ali for two years for his involvement in irregularities during 2013-2016 and for providing fabricated information to the central bank.After three-years of investigation, BB issued a directive in this regard to Farasath Ali, the founding chairman of the NRBC ...

International »

More than 160 killed in Ethiopia protests over singer's murder

Al Jazeera News :At least 166 people have died during violent demonstrations that roiled Ethiopia in the days following the murder of popular singer Haacaaluu Hundeessa, police said."In the aftermath of Hachalu's death, 145 civilians and 11 security forces have lost their lives in the unrest in the region," said ...

International »

Ghana's president self-quarantine amid COVID-19 fear

Anadolu Agency, Abuja :The President of Ghana isolated himself after coming into contact with an associate who tested positive for the coronavirus, according to an official statement Saturday."President Nana Akufo-Addo will today begin a 14 day precautionary self-isolation measure in compliance with COVID-19 protocols," the Information Ministry said in a ...

Editorial »

Lagging behind in Covid testing proves a sheer failure in development

SINCE the first Covid-19 case was detected on 8 March, 118 days have elapsed, Bangladesh still lags behind in terms of increasing the testing facilities in comparison with the other South Asian countries. World Health Organization said Bangladesh is carrying out 4,409 tests per million people whereas the rate is ...

City »

Nagorik Oikya forms a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Saturday in protest against enhancement of house rent and price of water of WASA.

International »

China appoints hardliner to head new Hong Kong security agency

AFP, Hong Kong :China appointed a hardliner to head a new national security agency in Hong Kong on Friday as police brought the first charges under a sweeping new anti-subversion law that has shaken the semi-autonomous finance hub.Zheng Yanxiong - a party official best known for tackling protests on the ...

Entertainment »

Vaani Kapoor cast opposite Akshay in Bell Bottom

Actress Vaani Kapoor will be featuring in a lead role opposite Akshay Kumar in Bell Bottom a spy thriller directed by Ranjit M Tewari. This will be Vaani’s first film with superstar Akshay Kumar. Akshay released the first look of the poster of Bell Bottom in January 2020 and announced ...

Entertainment »

Aditi Rao Hydari talks about her film Sufiyum Sujatayum

Sufiyum Sujatayum was released on Amazon Prime Video on July 3 and was the first Malayalam movie to have a direct OTT release. The film garnered love and appreciation from the audience for it’s musical and magical romantic story it brought to the audience. Like a cherry on top, the ...

Entertainment »

Julie Sharmelee: A versatile singer

Entertainment Report :Julie Sharmelee is a versatile singer who is known to all for her contribution and works on play-back, modern, Ghazal, Narzul and Tagore songs. She got first inspiration in music from her mother noted journalist late Sameena Sidddique. She found a congenial atmosphere at home that nurtured her ...

Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Write a comment to this news