Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Tuesday, January 21, 2020 02:03:23 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Place of Worship

Management lies under the control of descendant of the founder

By
04th-Jan-2020       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

High Court Division :
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Mohammad Ullah J Gobinda Chandra Tagore J
Judgment
April 30th, 2019
Nirmal Chandra Nath.........Petitioner
vs
Government of People's Republic of Bangladesh represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Religious Affairs, Bangladesh Dhaka and 14 (fourteen) others. ........Respondents
Constitution of Bangladesh,1972
Article 102(2)
The control and management of the Mandir /Temple/Biggrah i.e. the place of worship shall be retained with the descendant of the founder. The properties dedicated to the purpose of management of the Mandir also belongs to the deity/deities.
If someone or somebody or a group of people intends to show that the Mandir is a public debottor/trust, he/she or they may take recourse to law under Section 92 read with Section 93 of the Code of Civil Procedure before an appropriate forum. Usually, a Mandir, whether it is private or public debottor, is opened for Hindu devotees irrespective of caste and creed so that they can offer puja therein. Fact remains that the Mandir was established long back and the devotees are attending therein on different religious occasions and the Sebaet is entertaining them and for that reason it has not transformed into a public debottor. . ..... (19)
Radhakanta Deb vs The Commissioner of Hindu Religious Endowments Orissa, AIR 1981 SC 798; Panchkari Roy V5 Amodr LaI Burman, 41 and  CWN 1349; Deoki Nandan vs Murlidhar, 1957 AIR SC 133 ref.
Moteen Uddin Anwar with Md Tashadduk Hasan, Advocates-For the Petitioner.
Probir Neogi with Anil Chandra Debnath, Advocates-For the Respondents Nos.5-15.
Judgment
Mohammad Ullah J : On an application under Article 102 of the Constitution of the People's Republic of Bangladesh, the Rule Nisi was issued calling upon the respondents to show cause as to why the impugned letter bearing Memo No. aweg/g/wcGm/wewea-2017/161 dated 25-4-2017 issued under the signature of the respondent No.2, Personal Secretary (Deputy Secretary), to the then Minister, Ministry of Religious Affairs requesting the Deputy Commissioner, Faridpur to constitute a committee purportedly protecting for the debottor property of Sree Sree Madan Gopal Biggrah and Sree Sree Shib Biggrah Mandir (hereinafter referred to as "the Mandir") located at Faridpur Sadar Upazila under District Faridpur (as contained in Annexure-F) should not be declared to have been issued without lawful authority and is of no legal effect and or why such other or further order or orders as to this Court may seem fit and proper shall not be passed.
2- At the time of issuance of the Rule on 22-5-2017, the operation of the impugned letter dated 25-4-2017 was stayed initially for a period of 3 (three) months and subsequently from time to time the period of stay was extended.
3. Shortly stated the relevant facts necessary for disposal of the Rule are as follows:
4. In order to establish the Mandir in Faridpur Sadar Upazila late Chandra Kanta Nath transferred 1.27 acre of land through a registered Orpannama dated 20-5-1941 in favour of the deity. From the recital of the said Orpannama, it would be seen that the Mandir is a private charity. The petitioner being the adopted son of the testator has been performing, maintaining and running the religious ritual and affairs of the Mandir as Sebaet. According to the said Orpannama, the petitioner shall continue to carry on the affairs of the Mandir as Sebaet until his death. It has further been stated in the petition that said Chandra Kanta Nath had no issue and during his life time, on 10-3-1976, he executed a will (Charampatra) authorizing his second wife, namely, Sneaholata Nath to adopt a son. Subsequently, after the death of the testator, Sneaholata filed Probate Suit No. 2 of 1975 in the Court of District Judge, Faridpur under Section 289 of the Succession Act, 1925. Subsequently, the said suit was transferred to the Additional District Judge, Faridpur for disposal. By the order dated 22-5-1976, the said will of the testator was granted to Sneaholata. According to the will of the testator, Sneaholata through a registered deed dated 28-3-1989 adopted the petitioner as their son upon observing the ritual. After the death of Sneaholata, the petitioner being the adopted son took over the responsibility and management of the affairs of the Mandir as Sebaet and still he has been discharging his J religious duties towards the deities. The petitioner came to know that some vested) quarters made a complaint to the Deputy Commissioner, Faridpur alleging that the affairs of the Mandir was not running as per the Orpannama made by the testator and some persons had been misappropriating the fund earned from the debottor property. Thereafter, on 24-4-2017, the Deputy Commissioner issued a letter to the Upazila Nirbahi Officer, Faridpur Sadar to enquire into the matter and to submit a report within 7 (seven) working days. Beside, the respondent No. 2 being the Personal Secretary to the then Minister, Ministry of Religious Affairs issued the impugned letter dated 25-4-2017 requesting the Deputy Commissioner, Faridpur to form a committee with the respondents No. 5-15 along with him to run the affairs of the Mandir. Thereafter, the petitioner having been aggrieved by such activities of the respondents served a notice demanding justice upon the respondents No. 1-4 requesting them to cancel, withdraw and rescind the said impugned letter dated 25-4-2017 but resulted in vain. In such facts and circumstances, the petitioner filed the instant Writ Petition and obtained the Rule and the order of stay as stated above.
5. After issuance of the Rule, the respondents Nos. 5-15 got themselves added in the Writ Petition vide order dated 2,4-7-2017 who have contested the Rule by filing an affidavit-in-opposition denying the material allegations made in the writ petition contending, inter alia, that the petitioner has been misappropriating the fund of debottor property and enjoying the same as his own property which is against 'the will of the testator and the Mandir is a public debottor and, as such, they had filed an application to the then Minister, Ministry of Religious Affairs for preventing the misappropriation and embezzlement of the fund earned from the debottor property. Accordingly, the respondent No.2 issued the impugned letter requesting the Deputy Commissioner, Faridpur to form a committee with the respondents No. 5-15 along with him for running and managing the affairs of the Mandir and, as such, the respondent No. 2 committed no illegality in issuing the impugned letter and thus the Rule is liable to be discharged.
6. Mr Moteen Uddin Anwar, learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner submits that the impugned letter is nothing but a DO letter issued by the respondent No.2 while he was performing the duty as the Personal Secretary to the then Minister, Ministry of Religious Affairs and thus the impugned letter has no binding effect on the recipient thereof and, as such" the same is liable to be declared to have been issued without lawful authority and beyond the jurisdiction of the respondent Number 2.
7. The learned Advocate submits further that the petitioner has been running, managing, and maintaining; the affairs of the Mandir from long time according to the will of the testator made in the Orpannama dated 20-5-1941 inasmuch as from the recital of the said Orpannama the Mandir is a privet debottor and therefore the respondents have no legal authority to interfere into the affairs of the Mandir in any way.
8. To substantiate  his submissions, the learned Advocate  has referred to the decisions in the cases of:
(1)     Sree Dallim Kumar Saha vs. Bangladesh represented by Deputy Commissioner, Feni Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Feni an unreported decision in Writ Petition No. 8149 of 2006 which was upheld vide judgment and order dated 24-3-2009 passed in Civil Petition For Leave To Appeal No. 1249 of 2008.
(2) Radhakanta Deb vs The Commissioner of Hindu Religious Endowments Orissa, reported in AIR 1981 SC 798 and,
(3) Panchkari Roy vs Amodr Lal Burman, reported in 41 CWN 1349.
9. On the other hand, Mr. Probir Neogi, learned Advocate appearing for the respondents No. 5-15 submits that the Mandir in question is a public debottor and the people should have free access to offer Puja to the deity as and when they desire.
10. The learned Advocate submits further that according to the Orpannama and will of the testator, the Mandlr is a public charity and, as such, the Government or the People at large should have the right to interfere into the affairs of the Mandir for ensuring its safety and security so that the devotees can offer Puja as and when they desire.
11. The learned Advocate for the respondents No. 5-15 seeks to' rely on the decision in the case of Deoki Nandan vs Murlidhar, reported in 1957 AIR SC 133.
12. We have considered the submissions of the learned Advocates for the contending parties and perused the materials on record.
13. Admittedly, the property involved in the instant Writ Petition is a debottor property. It is also undisputed that, Chandra Kanta Nath established the Mandir in question upon executing an Orpannama dated 20-5-1941. The petitioner claims that the Mandir is a private debottor property; on the other hand, the respondents No. 5-15 claim that it is a public debottor property.
14. The relevant' recital of the said Orpannama with regard to appointment of the Sebaet and management of the debottor property runs as follows:
“আমার পরলোকান্তে আমার ওয়ারিশানদের মধ্যে হিন্দু ধর্মাবলম্বী বয়োজ্যেষ্ঠ ব্যক্তি এবং তাহার লোকান্তরে কিংবা সে অসমর্থ হইলে তাহার পরবর্তী হিন্দু ধর্মাবলম্বী বয়োজ্যেষ্ঠ ব্যক্তি এবং ঐ পরবর্তী ব্যক্তির পরলোকান্তে কিংবা সে অসমর্থ হইলে তৎপরবর্তী হিন্দু ধর্মাবলম্বী বয়োজ্যেষ্ঠ ব্যক্তি এই রূপে এবং এই নিয়মে পরবর্তী ক্রমে উক্ত বিগ্রহের সেবাইত থাকিবে।”
১৫. ওঃ যধং ভঁৎঃযবৎ নববহ ংঃধঃবফ রহ ঃযব ংধরফ ঙৎঢ়ধহহধসধ ঃযধঃ:-
“আমি কিংবা আমার পরলোকান্তে আমার ওয়ারিশানদের মধ্যে যখন যে কোন সেবাইত থাকিবে ঐ উৎসর্গীয়কৃত সম্পত্তির আয়ের টাকা হইতে উক্ত সম্পত্তির খাজনা সেস ও ট্যাক্স ইত্যাদির ব্যয় মেরামত ব্যয় এবং উক্ত সম্পত্তি রক্ষণ করার জন্য যে কোন আবশ্যকীয় ব্যয় নির্বাহ করিয়া যে টাকা থাকিবে তাহা ও উক্ত শ্রী শ্রী মদন গোপাল বিগ্রহের দৈনিক সেবা পূজা এবং বার্ষিক জন্মাষ্টামী রাস, দোল ও ঝুলন ইত্যাদি উৎসবের ব্যয় এবং শ্রী শ্রী শিব বিগ্রহের দৈনিক সেবা পূজা এবং বার্ষিক শিবরাত্রি উৎসবের ব্যয় নির্বাহ করিব ও করিবে।”
16. From the above recitals of the Orpannama, it appears that the Sebaet of the Mandir shall be the heir and successive heir of the testator and not any stranger. Accordingly, the management of the debottor property is devolved on the said heir or successive heir of the testator.
17. The respondent No.6, Sankar Kumar Saha, on 25-4-2017 filed an application to the then Minister, Ministry of the Religious Affairs to form a committee along with the Deputy Commissioner, Faridpur purportedly, for securing the debottor property. It appears from the Annexure-H to the Supplementary Affidavit filed by the petitioner that the respondent No.2 being the Personal Secretary to the then Minister, Ministry of the Religious Affairs made a recommendation on the said application in the following manner:
“জেলা প্রশাসক, ফরিদপুর
জনাব যশোদা জীবন দেবনাথ (সিআইপি) সহ আপনার সভাপতিত্বে কমিটি গঠন করার জন্য নির্দেশক্রমে অনুরোধ করা হলো।
স্বা-অস্পষ্ট
২৫-৪-১৭ইং
18. At the same time, the respondent No.2 issued the impugned letter dated 25-4-2017 as contained in Annexure-F to the Writ Petition requesting, the Deputy Commissioner in the 'similar manner. We, therefore, deem it necessary to deal with the legal consequence of such letter popularly known as DO letter. A DO Letter is an abbreviation of the term "demi official" letter, which is generally used in the correspondence between two entities, the issuing. .person or authority and the government or non-government officials for an interchange or communication of opinion or information without any formality of the prescribed procedure. This sort of communication has no legal consequence i.e. the recipient of a DO Letter is not lawfully bound to act on the basis of such a letter. However, a  Member of Parliament or any other person may issue a DO Letter with a specific request or recommendation without hampering, curtailing or infringing any statutory right of the other party or against public policy. Being a, Personal Secretary to the then Minister it was imprudent for him to demand or claim favour for any person or a particular group causing detriment to the right of others in violation of the prescribed laws of the land and against the interest of the people in general. There is no doubt that the impugned letter is nothing but a D Letter and not a formal order of the Ministry concerned. Being a Private Secretary, the respondent No.2 has no legal authority to issue such letter. However, we refrain from making any further comment on the conduct of the respondent No.2 inasmuch as it does not involve any question of law but of ethics. The recipient of the DO Letter may or may not honour the recommendation of the issuing person keeping in mind that the action or inaction would be in accordance with the prescribed law.
19. From the recitals of the Orpannama made by the testator, we have already found that the nature of the endowment is a private debottor. So, the control and management of the Mandir/Temple/Biggrah i.e. the place of worship shall be retained with the descendant of the founder. The properties dedicated to the purpose of management of the Mandir also belongs to the deity/deities. In spite of the fact that if someone or somebody or a group of people intends to show that the Mandir is a public debottor/ trust, he/ she or they may take recourse to law under Section 92 read with Section 93 of the Code of Civil Procedure before an appropriate forum. Usually, a Mandir, whether it is private or public debottor, is opened for Hindu devotees irrespective of caste and creed so that they can offer puja therein. Fact remains that the Mandir was established, long back and the devotees are attending therein on different religious occasions and the Sebaet is entertaining them and for that reason it has not transformed into a public debottor.
20. In the facts and circumstances involved in the instant Writ Petition, we have found that the respondent No. 2 had no legal authority to issue the impugned letter either to remove the Sebaet or to form any managing committee in place of the Sebaet. In such view of the matter, the respondent No. 2 having administrative dominance as an executive officer of the Government has no manner of authority to interfere with the management of the debottor property whether it is private or public.
21. The decision as referred to by the teamed Advocate for the respondent Nos. 5-15 does not favour their case; rather it favours the case of the petitioner and goes against them and, as such, the same is not discussed elaborately.
22. The learned Advocate for the respondents No. 5-15 though invited to elaborate his submission on the point of authority of the respondent No.2 in issuing the impugned letter but he did not make any submission on this point.
23. In such view of the facts and circumstances of the case, we find merit in the Rule.
24. Accordingly, the Rule is made absolute. The impugned letter bearing Memo No . aweg/g/wcGm/wewea-2017/161 dated 25-4-2017 issued under the signature of the respondent No.2 is hereby declared illegal, without jurisdiction and is of no legal effect.
However, there would be no order as to cost.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Football »

Ronaldo double pulls Juventus clear as Inter stalled in Lecce


AFP, Milan :Cristiano Ronaldo struck twice as Juventus beat Parma 2-1 to pull four points clear of Inter Milan at the top of the Serie A table on Sunday.Inter's title push hit another stumbling block after a 1-1 draw at lowly Lecce while Ante Rebic fired city rivals AC Milan ...

International »

Abe strikes conciliatory note on S.Korea, row may be easing


Reuters, Tokyo :Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said on Monday that South Korea was its "most important neighbour" and that the two shared basic values, taking a conciliatory tone towards the country that has been locked in a bitter row with Tokyo for over a year.The comment comes after South ...

City »

Bangladesh Nari Progati Sangha formed a human chain in front of the National Museum in the city's Shahbagh on Monday urging all to be united to make South Asia fair.


Entertainment »

Chamok Tara acts in Padatik’s play today


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Country’s one of the popular theatre troupes, Padatik Nattya Sangsad will turn into 43 today. In its long time journey, Padatik produced 41 plays till now. Macbeth, Jonomanko, Kalratri, Mouse Trap, Beder Meye, Gohonjatra, Sojon Badiar Ghat, Maa, Kaler Jatra, Monsar Pala, Chandraboti, Chokkor, Khetmojur Khoimuddin, etc ...

Editorial »

Banks to face dire consequences for govt's contradictory borrowing policy


THE government is borrowing funds from banks at more than 9 per cent interest rates against treasury bills and bonds, which contradicts its move to force banks to implement 9 per cent lending rate. As per rules, lending to the government or even against any government guarantee does not create ...

Sports »

Members of Group Skyliners of the United States pose on the podium after winning the 16th Zagreb Snowflakes Trophy synchronized skating competition in Zagreb, Croatia on Saturday.


International »

Maduro ready to open direct talks with US


Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro said he was still comfortably in charge and open to direct negotiations with the US, in an interview published Saturday by The Washington Post.The interview was Maduro's first with a major US outlet since February of last year, when he abruptly ejected all Univision journalists from ...

Entertainment »

Tisha’s Pori O Panir Bottle on Customs Day


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :January 26 is the Customs Day. To mark the day, RTV will telecast a special play titled Pori O Panir Bottle on that day at 8:15pm. National Film Award winner actress Nusrat Imroz Tisha acted in an important role against Mosharraf Karim in the play directed by ...

Entertainment »

Raima has her fingers crossed for Dwitiyo Purush release


Raima Sen, who will soon make her Tamil debut with Agni Siragugal is all geared up for the release of Srijit Mukherji’s next Dwitiyo Purush alongside Parambrata Chatterjee. Like everyone else, she is also pretty much excited about this sequel and believes this one will also have a similar effect ...

Editorial »

Economic diplomacy needs rule of law and dependable banking system


OUR Foreign Minister on Friday said Bangladesh is now focusing on economic diplomacy with a view to boosting the local economy bringing foreign businesses to the country. Interestingly, the major shift in foreign policy is taking place at a time when foreign direct investment (FDI) reaches to nadir, remittance inflow ...

Football »

Bangladesh take on Sri Lanka in must win match today


Bangladesh will take on Sri Lanka in their must win group A last match of the Bangabandhu Gold Cup International Football tournament scheduled to be held today at the Bangabandhu National Stadium here.State-owned Bangladesh Television , private satellite channel RTV will telecast the match live while Bangladesh Betar will provide ...

Sports »

Humbert wins first ATP title in French showdown at Auckland


AFP, Auckland :Rising star Ugo Humbert won his maiden ATP title beating Benoit Paire in a three-set thriller in the final of the Auckland Classic on Saturday.In the all-French showdown, the unseeded Humbert held his nerve in the deciding tie-break of his first ATP final to beat the fifth seed ...

International »

UK plans Brexit celebrations but warns businesses may suffer


AP, London :The British government has announced plans for special events on the night of Jan. 31 when the country officially leaves the European Union but the country's treasury chief has admitted that some U.K. business sectors will suffer as a result.Sajid Javid told the Financial Times in an interview ...

City »

Prof MM Akash speaking at a press conference oranised by South Asia Alliance for Poverty Eradication at the Jatiya Press Club on Saturday with a call to make South Asia fair for all.


Editorial »

Charge-sheet filed in Sagira Morshed's murder case: Let there be speedy trial


THE latest success story of Police Bureau of Investigation or PBI has brought again one thing to the forefront that - it's possible to conduct police investigation fairly if the police remain sincere and neutral. The PBI on Thursday submitted the charge-sheet of 30-year-old Sagira Morshed murder case to the ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news