Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Monday, October 26, 2020 01:49:24 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Opinion

Elections and the technocratic ideology

By
09th-Sep-2014       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Erick Vasconcelos :
People who vote for politicians such as Brazilian presidential candidate Aecio Neves, as well as many of his party's supporters (the Social Democracy Brazilian Party, PSDB), are often dumbfounded when they find out how unappealing ideas of "efficiency" in the public sector, "management shock," and "professionalization" in government are to a large sector of the population. It's a moderately widespread idea, also spearheaded in the Pernambuco state government (more as a campaign bullet point than real actions) by Eduardo Campos, who died on August 12. The belief is that there is - or at least should be - a vital separation between the public administration and politics; between ideology and efficiency. However, the idea of professionalizing politics, putting "technicians" in government positions, and "managing" public affairs like ordinary organizations in society is, in itself, deeply ideological.
And it isn't one of the youngest ideologies: Thorstein Veblen talked about his technocracy of engineers in the 1920s. Veblen, in his well-known The Engineers and the Price System described engineers ("technicians") as the class capable of promoting the principles of "scientific management" for production - as opposed to a system of market production with effective price signaling. Veblen didn't have any problems with the corporate organization and intended to universalize its model as the foundation of society, eliminating technical limitations to what he termed "industrial values," which were connected to productive efficiency (and had nothing to do with, and indeed were opposed to, market incentives).
Veblenian championed his ideas on industry and technique as the starting point of the mass production society he envisioned. That society and its values would give rise, through industrial workers, to a new democracy with a new management style that promoted efficiency, technical knowledge and administration. That is, a machine perfectly adjusted to the control and regulation of society.
This dystopian ideal was able to find adherents and modify itself slightly during the 20th century, especially in the works of managerial progressives such as Joseph Schumpeter and John Kenneth Galbraith. Nowadays, we hear it from politicians who may think they speak with the voice of innovation when they say that specialists should fill government positions. It's also a convenient ideology for a number of bureaucrats because it doesn't ask whether such government positions should exist at all, but only who should fill them. It's not about being governed or not, it's about who is going to do the governing. Who would we want to sit on the Iron Throne if not a "specialist?" Someone who wouldn't be driven by politico-ideological passions, but by the "industrial values" Veblen cherished. Someone to oil up the gears of this great machinery that is society.
That is all hogwash, of course, because when we talk about politics, we talk about ideology - about prioritizing, about choosing one collective goal as preferable to another. However, there are no macro social ends, at least not apart from a sum of individual goals or as a mere metaphor. Which is also the reason why it isn't possible to put public management under the control of experts, because the very definition of what constitutes "public management" is an ideological question subject to political negotiation and resistance.
It's impossible to remove ideology from government because government is an ideology: The ideology of power, control and suppression of dissidence. The ideology of conformity, of the macro-social, of the idea of society as an abstraction, never reducible to its individual components.
Governing, far from an activity without ideology and plans, is the stitching of majority plans within hierarchy. It's no wonder that anarchist movements have historically tended to horizontalism and consensus-building as strategies to avoid the formation of majorities and bureaucratic power structures. These ideas of horizontalism are intended to mitigate the effects of particular ideologies when applied to the collective. In contrast, technocracy looks like a form of enlightened despotism with its attempt to rationalize processes. Of course, it's a positive thing that socially desirable processes should be efficient and demand less resources - but we must first know which ones are the socially desirable processes. They're not a given.
It's somewhat ironic that lifelong politicians are the biggest (and maybe the most cynical) proponents of the technocratic creed. Aecio Neves himself, despite his claims of technical prowess in administration, is a specialist in one thing only: Getting positions in the government. He's been the director of a large state bank, secretary of the presidency, deputy, governor, senator.
It may be the case that Aecio Neves nowadays is a puppet of the narrative he's built for himself, replicating it as a hostage of his own rhetoric. Because Aecio has never been a technician; the technicians are the arms that execute his political plans.

(Erick Vasconcelos is a contributing author at the Center for a Stateless Society (c4ss.org).

Tariff
Sonali-Paper
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

People don't need directives on pandemic they need deeds of help to face economic hardship


HEALTH experts on Saturday suggested taking lessons from the mistakes in last seven months and implementing scientific decisions more than bureaucratic ones to fight the second wave of the Covid-19 which is apprehended to hit the country during winter. They also recommended intensifying community engagement and risk communication, but pointed ...

Business & Economy »

Dr Sultan Ahmed, Secretary of Power Division, inaugurating the 'Bangabondhu Avenue 33/11 sub-station' at Bangabondhu Avenue in city's Gulistan area on Sunday as chief guest. Engineer Bikash Dewan, Managing Director and other senior officials of Dhaka Power Distribution Company Limited (DPDC) were also present.


Business & Economy »

BPC gets new chairman


Business Desk :The government has appointed Md Abu Bakar Siddique as the chairman of the Bangladesh Petroleum Corporation (BPC).The Ministry of Public Administration issued a circular in this regard on Thursday, saying the order will come into immediate effect, reports UNB.He will replace Md Shamsul Rahman, an additional secretary of ...

City »

Chief of Naval Staff Admiral M Shaheen Iqbal speaks to officers and sailors of 'BNS Bijoy' on its arrival from Lebanon after completion of UN Peace Keeping Mission UNIFIL successfully on Sunday.


City »

Egyptian Ambassador to Bangladesh Walid Ahmed Shamseldin makes his farewell call on Foreign Minister Dr A K Abdul Momen at his office in the capital on Sunday


International »

`Demands not met`: Anti-govt protests resume in Iraq


Al Jazeera News :Protesters have gathered in Baghdad's Tahrir Square to mark one year since anti-government protests erupted and gripped Iraq.Sunday's demonstrations renewed calls from last October which saw the start of Iraq's biggest anti-government protest movement since the 2003 fall of Saddam Hussein, with demonstrations in the capital Baghdad ...

Entertainment »

Neha Kakkar, Rohanpreet Singh’s wedding takes place at Gurudwara


New videos from the wedding of singers Neha Kakkar and Rohanpreet Singh have been leaked on the internet. In the clips, the two are seen twinning in shades of peach and pink, as they get married at Gurudwara in Delhi. Videos from the ring ceremony were also shared online. Neha ...

International »

Nigeria says 51 civilians, 18 security forces killed in unrest


Al Jazeera News :Nigeria's president announced 51 civilians were killed in unrest following days of peaceful protests over police abuses and blamed "hooliganism" for the violence while asserting security forces used "extreme restraint".President Muhammadu Buhari's comments in a statement released late Friday are expected to further inflame tensions after Amnesty ...

Business & Economy »

MM Monirul Alam, CEO of Guardian Life Insurance Limited, handing over its first Maturity Claim (Individual Life Policy) cheque to its nominee at its head office in the city recently. Mahmudur Rahman Khan, SEVP, Mohammad Masuduzzaman Khan, EVP, Rubayat Saleheen, SVP and other officials of the company were also present.


Entertainment »

Ananya Panday`s friends had to say after watching Khaali Peeli


Ananya Panday has carved out a special place in the hearts of the audience with her quirky looks and her ability to nail every character. After the success of Khaali Peeli, Ananya is on cloud nine with all the love and appreciation that is coming her way. Not only were ...

Editorial »

Nothings to stop stealing funds for family planning


MEDIA reports said Directorate General of Family Planning (DGFP) has paid ghost bills against work orders that were not either fulfilled or not implemented at all by contractual parties. Such cases of fake billing and misappropriation funds galore with another DGFP project; in which a probe committee found payments were ...

Editorial »

Transfer may offer protection from anger of local people


NINETEEN police officials including the Commissioner of Sylhet Metropolitan Police (SMP) have been transferred on Thursday in the aftermath of Rayhan murder in city's Bandar Bazar police outpost on October 11.  The Commissioner has been transferred to Prime Minister's Special Protection Battalion (SPBn) as Deputy Inspector General (DIG) of Police ...

International »

Erdogan says Turkey tested Russian S-400s, shrugs off US reaction


Reuters, Ankara :Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan confirmed on Friday that Turkey had been testing the S-400 air defense system it bought from Russia, adding that the objection from NATO ally United States on the issue did not matter.Washington says Ankara's purchase of Russian S-400 systems compromise NATO defences, and has ...

Entertainment »

What film actors say about Pori Moni on the occasion of her birthday


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Children are very much fond of film actress Pori Moni. There is a reason for one thing. After releasing the song titled Dana kata pori performed by Pori Moni in Wajed Ali Sumon directed movie Rokto, it is still popular songs among all. In any stage show ...

Editorial »

Bangladesh should take immediate measures to cope with Kuwait's new foreign workers’ law


KUWAIT'S parliament has approved a law to reduce the number of foreign workers in the country by one year, as part of efforts to 'rebalance' its population. The new legislation, which would force hundreds of thousands of expats to leave the Gulf state, was passed with an aim to provide ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news