Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, April 5, 2020 06:19:39 PM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

ACC Act V of 2004

Steps in case failure of an investigating officer

By
14th-Mar-2020       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Appellate Division :
(Criminal)
Syed Mahmud Hossain CJ
Hasan Foez Siddique J
Zinat Ara J
Md Nuruzzaman J
Anti-Corruption Commission (Duduk), represented by its Chairman, Dhaka ..............Petitioner
vs
Md Shafiul Alam and another ............Respondents

Judgment
May 12th, 2019

Anti-Corruption Commission Act (V of 2004)
Section 20Ka(1)
If the investigating officer fails to complete investigation within the time stipulated or within extended time, the Commission shall appoint another investigating officer for holding investigation within 90 working days and departmental action would be taken against first investigating officer in accordance with law. The only provision is that if the investigation officer fails to complete the investigation within time, the Commission shall appoint another investigating officer and shall take step against the investigating officer.
...... ... the High Court Division committed an error of law in quashing the proceeding holding that since the mandatory provision had not been complied with, the proceeding was liable to be quashed. The conclusion arrived at by the High Court Division is erroneous.
...... (10 & II)
MA Aziz Khan, Advocate, instructed by Mahmuda Begum, Advocate-on-Record-For the Petitioner.
Probir Neogi, Senior Advocate, instructed by Md Zahirul Islam, Advocate-on-Record-For the Respondents.
Judgment
Hasan Foez Siddique J : This petition for leave to appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 15-2-2018 passed by the High Court Division in Criminal Miscellaneous Case No.35856 of 2017 quashing the proceeding of Special Case No.21 of 2017 arising out of GR No.168 of 2015 corresponding to Ukhiya Police Station Case No.16 dated 12-5-2015 under Sections 409/420/109 of the Penal Code read with Section 5(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 pending in the Court of Divisional Special Judge, Chittagong.
2. The relevant facts necessary for the disposal of this petition are that Mohammed Saftullah, Deputy Assistant Director, Durnity Daman Commission, lodged a First Information Report against the respondent and others on 12-5-2015 with Ukhiya Police Station bringing allegation of commission of offence under Sections 409/420/119/109 of the Penal Code read with Section 5(2) of the Act II of 1947.
3. After     holding     investigation,     the Investigating Officer submitted charge sheet on 30-12-2016 against the respondent and others for commission of offence under Sections 409/420/ 119/109 of the Penal Code read with Section 5(2) of the Act II of 1947. The case record was ultimately transmitted in the Court of Senior Special Judge, Cox's Bazar who took cognizance of the offence by his order No.4 dated 19-4-2017. Thereafter, the Senior Special Judge, Cox's Bazar transferred the case before the Divisional Special Judge, Chittagong for holding trial. The case was registered as Special Case No.21 of 2017 .
4. The respondent initially obtained bail from the Senior Special Judge, Cox's Bazar and, thereafter, from the Divisional Special Judge, Chittagong.
5. Thereafter, the respondent filed an application under Section 561 A of the Code of Criminal Procedure in the High Court Division for quashing the proceeding and obtained Rule. The High Court Division, by the impugned judgment and order, quashed the proceeding.
6. Thus, the Durnity Daman Commission preferred this criminal petition for leave to Appeal.
7. Mr MA Aziz Khan, learned Counsel appearing for the Durnity Damon Commission, submits that the High Court Division has committed a serious error of law in quashing the proceeding holding that the provision of time limitation to complete investigation as stipulated in Section 20Ka of the Durnity Daman Commission Ain is mandatory in nature. He submits that there is no such provision in Section 20Ka of the Ain that in case of failure to conclude investigation within the time stipulated the proceeding shall be stopped or dropped.
8. Mr Probir Neogi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent No.1, submits that the High Court Division upon proper interpretation of the provisions of Section 20Ka of the Ain rightly held that the time stipulated for holding investigation is mandatory in nature and, thus, it quashed the entire proceeding accordingly.
9. In this case, the First Information Report was lodged on 12-5-2015 and the Investigating Officer, holding investigation, submitted its report on 30-12-2016. The Senior Special Judge, Cox's Bazar took cognizance of the offence against the respondent and others on 19-4-2017 under sections 409/420/109 of the Penal Code read with section 5(2) of the Act II of 1947.
10. Section 20Ka(1) of the Durnity Daman Commission Ain (as amended by Act XVI of 2013) provides that the Investigating Officer shall complete investigation within 120 working days from the date of receipt of the order of holding investigation. Sub-section(2) of Section 20Ka of the Ain provides that the Commission may extend time of holding investigation for a period of 60 working days if the investigation is not completed within the time as stipulated in Section 20Ka(1) of the Ain. If the Investigating Officer fails to complete investigation within the time stipulated or within extended time, the Commission shall appoint another Investigating Officer for holding investigation within 90 working days and departmental action would be taken against first Investigating Officer in accordance with law. We do not find any such default clause in Section 20Ka that if the Investigating Officer fails to complete the investigation within stipulated time or extended time the proceeding shall stand stopped or to be dropped. The only provision is that if the Investigation Officer fails to complete the investigation within time, the Commission shall appoint another Investigating Officer and shall take step against the Investigating Officer.
11. In view of the aforesaid provision of law, the High Court Division committed an error of law in quashing the proceeding holding that since the mandatory provision had not been complied with, the proceeding was liable to be quashed. The conclusion arrived at by the High Court Division is erroneous. So, the same is liable to be interfered with.
12. Since both the parties are present through their learned Advocates, we are not inclined to grant leave which will delay the disposal of the matter.
13. Accordingly, we find substance in this petition. Thus, the petition is disposed of. The judgment and order of the High Court Division is set aside. The Divisional Special Judge, Chittagong is directed to proceed with the case in accordance with law. 

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Remittance flow gets interrupted


The coronavirus pandemic is set to deal a heavy blow to the country's overseas job market and the remittance flow as a large number of Bangladeshi migrants have already lost their jobs or were receiving low wages amid shutdowns enforced to contain the contagion. After different businesses were closed following ...

Business & Economy »

Bangladesh China Chamber of Commerce & Industry (BCCCI) distributing aid to some helpless people at Khilgaon Model Collage in the city on Thursday. Vice President Mohd Ishaqul Hossain Sweet, Joint Secretary General Al Mamun Mridha and Director MD Naim Hossain Bhuiyan, among others, were present.


Sports »

`We want to help as much as we can` - England players take pay cut


The centrally contracted male and female players in England have opted to take a pay cut during the current global crisis, which has brought cricket to a standstill.With the COVID-19 pandemic threatening to sabotage the entire cricket season in England, centrally contracted players have opted to take a pay cut ...

Football »

Neymar donates $1m to fight coronavirus


AFP, Rio De Janeiro :Neymar has donated $1 million to fight the impact of the new coronavirus in his native Brazil, according to TV network SBT.The Paris Saint-Germain star, the world's third-highest-paid footballer, donated part of the money to the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF), and the rest to a ...

City »

Chairman of the Governing Body of the city's Willes Little Flower School and College Arifur Rahman Titu distributing foods among the destitute on the premises of the institution on Saturday. Foods were bought from the joint aid of the teachers and governing body of the institution.


Editorial »

Front line soldiers must be well-armed to fight deadly coronavirus


AT least a dozen people with different illnesses died in Dhaka and other places after they were refused treatment by doctors since March 8 when the first case of coronavirus was reported in the country. Many said a sense of insecurity caused by the persisting shortage of personal protective equipment ...

City »

Devotees offering Jum'a prayers on the street without having place in the mosque. The snap was taken from in front of Naya Palton Jame Masjid in the city on Friday.


City »

Army personnel deployed in different areas trying to raise awareness among the commoners to stay home with a view to protecting themselves from coronavirus. The snap was taken from Chwakbazar in th city on Friday.


Business & Economy »

Local lawmaker Elias Uddin Mollah, on behalf of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman Maritime University, distributing essential food sttuff among the poor at Pallabi area in the city recently. Rear Admiral M Khaled Iqbal, Vice-Chancellor of the university was also present.


Sports »

Olympic chiefs bracing for extra costs in rescheduling Tokyo Games


AFP, Paris :Olympic chiefs said Thursday they were bracing themselves for the extra costs incurred by rescheduling the Tokyo Games by a year to 2021.The historic decision to postpone the summer Olympics by 12 months was taken this week amid the ongoing coronavirus pandemic. It was the first peacetime postponement ...

Football »

Suarez 'hurt' by criticism of Barca players' pay cut delay


AFP, Montevideo:Uruguay star Luis Suarez complained on Thursday that he has been "hurt" by criticism of him and fellow millionaire Barcelona players for the time it took to agree to pay cuts to help out other club employees.Argentine superstar Lionel Messi announced on Monday that Barca's players had agreed to ...

Editorial »

Let them seek publicity, but let them help generously


WHEN the poor people need cash and food support under the shutdown some wealthy people are misusing the occasion to demonstrate their charity otherwise. Some public leaders are using the plight of the poor to make their own fortune. They are giving less of the government given rice to the ...

City »

Mayor of Dhaka South City Corporation Sayeed Khokon handing over essentials for 500 families to its 26 No Ward Councilor Hashibur Rahman Manik at Nagar Bhaban on Thursday.


Sports »

Women`s European Championships to be moved back a year to 2020


The Women's European Championships - set to be held in England in 2021 - will be moved to the summer of 2022.The tournament was expected to be shifted after the men's European Championship and the Tokyo Olympics were both postponed until 2021 because of the global coronavirus pandemic.Three European teams ...

Sports »

Donations show 'togetherness' against virus, says Rashford


The public response in donating to charity to help feed deprived children after an appeal by Marcus Rashford has impressed the Manchester United forward.The 22-year-old England international teamed up with FareShare, a food distribution charity, after schools in the Manchester area were closed due to the coronavirus pandemic.Donations as of ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news