Friday, August 14, 2020 11:14:40 PM
Glenn Geher :
Worried about the coronavirus? Me too. Here's an evolutionary take on how this virus may bear on the human social experience.
From an evolutionary perspective, organisms that come to exist in large numbers generally have a broad array of adaptations, or attributes that serve to increase their ability to replicate. This idea is essentially the foundation of modern evolutionary reasoning.
Someone asked me the other day to explain coronavirus from an evolutionary perspective. Easy as pie, unfortunately. The coronavirus, like any organism, evolved properties that facilitate its own reproduction. Any organism that is not effective at facilitating its own reproduction will fail to pass the Herculean test that is natural selection.
According to the World Health Organization, coughing is a foundational symptom of coronavirus (as it is for flu, the common cold, and so many other contagious illnesses).
Ever stop to wonder why coughing (and, often, sneezing) are such hallmark symptoms of these illnesses?
The evolutionary perspective suggests that we look at things from the perspective of the virus itself, in this case. If the virus facilitates coughing-especially in close proximity to others-then it has an increased chance of replicating itself. Done. That's how Darwinian adaptations work.
Viruses as Manipulators of Host Behavior
We know full well that parasites can affect behavior. As I wrote in this piece from 2018, titled Does the Flu Trick People into Being Sociable:
Do Parasites Affect Behavior? The answer to this question is straightforward: Yes. Many instances of parasites affecting behavior have been documented (see Moore, 2002). Perhaps the best-known instance of this pertains to Toxoplasma gondii, which travels from cats into other mammals, including mice. And humans, often with adverse consequences.
This parasite has a very interesting effect on the behavior of mice. When evidence of a cat is present, a typical mouse makes itself scarce. But a mouse infected with Toxoplasma gondii does anything but become scarce when a cat is nearby. In fact, an infected mouse shows a strong tendency to go right out into the open - easy prey for the furry killing machines. This parasite must make it into the body of a cat to advance its life course, so it makes good sense that these parasites evolved the capacity to manipulate the nervous systems of mice in such a way.
It turns out that mice are not the only mammals that are susceptible to such effects. You and I may be as well.
In a provocative study on the social-behavioral effects of the flu, renowned biomedical anthropologist, Chris Reiber, and her colleagues (2010) found evidence for an increased social drive in young adults who have the flu during the asymptomatic early stages of the illness. In short, it looks like people who have the flu but who don't yet know it are more likely to seek out social opportunities (such as attending parties) compared with others who are without the flu virus in their system. Think about that.
A Possible Social-Behavioral Component of the Coronavirus?
Importantly, this section is pure speculation. I have not systematically collected social-behavioral data on people infected with the coronavirus. But I will add this: Such speculation may actually be useful because this facet of things does not seem to be something that is being considered by the broader scientific community in a thoughtful and comprehensive manner right now.
We are being told to stop shaking hands with others and to keep a distance from others in general. Further, we know that such social-distancing tactics are helpful in reducing the spread of the virus (see this article at sky.com for a systematic take on this point) .
In light of all this, it may be worth considering if the coronavirus, like the common flu, may actually have some proximate mechanisms by which it increases human sociality in an evolved (and obviously unconscious) effort to facilitate its own replication. Remember, from a Darwinian perspective, this is how natural selection rolls.
For decades, scientists have been aware that parasites often have the capacity to hijack systems within a host's body so as to lead to responses and behaviors that ultimately serve to help the parasite itself replicate (often at a cost to the host; see Moore, 2002).
As the scientific community works collaboratively to address the current coronavirus crisis, all facets of scientific inquiry that are potentially relevant should be brought to the table. The scientific study of evolution and behavior is, to my mind, highly relevant and, as such, should be included in our efforts.
While the hypothesis proposed here is, to this point, speculation, it seems to me that it would be quite worth knowing if the coronavirus somehow manipulates the behavior of human hosts in ways that serve to increase the spread of the virus. Information on this point might lead to additional ways of thinking about how to fight this crisis that is affecting our worlds more and more each and every day.
This all said, please follow the guidance of the World Health Organization and of other legitimate institutions connected with health as we work together, as one people, to address this threat that has been foisted upon us. As I tell my students and my kids: We got this.
(Glenn Geher, Ph.D., is professor of psychology at the State University of New York at New Paltz. He is founding director of the campus' Evolutionary Studies (EvoS) program).
THE Parliamentary Standing Committee on Disaster Management and Relief Ministry expressed concern over the government's cash incentive programme for the rural extreme poor on Wednesday. Following the ninth meeting of the committee on Wednesday, the Chairman of the Standing Committee stated that the poor people were not benefited by the ...
Reuters :Lebanese security forces deployed heavily in Beirut on Thursday, stopping protesters from reaching a conference centre where MPs began meeting for the first time since the catastrophic chemicals explosion last week that killed 172 people.Senior US official David Hale is expected in Beirut later on Thursday to stress the ...
MEDIA report in a national daily on Wednesday said Bangladesh Bank's special fund for capital market investment is facing setback because of lukewarm response from banks which were to make the fund available from their money for funding the ailing bourse. The five year special fund of Tk 100 billion ...
Agency :Shakhtar Donetsk crushed hapless FC Basel 4-1 following a one-sided affair while Sevilla's Lucas Ocampos left it late to eliminate Wolverhampton Wanderers 1-0 in the UEFA Europa League quarterfinal on Tuesday.Donetsk needed no warmup time and broke the deadlock with just two minutes played as Marlos's corner kick allowed ...
AFP, Washington :US President Donald Trump's candidate to head the Inter-American Development Bank said Tuesday he has the backing of the majority of Latin American countries but accused Argentina of trying to "obstruct" his election, with the help of Mexico, Chile and Costa Rica.Mauricio Claver-Carone told a news conference that ...
MEDIA report said that the government has taken a move to rein in the soaring cost of development projects and the Planning Minister is going to hold a meeting with Secretaries of the Development Ministries and Planning Commission officials to find out ways how to plug corruption and misuse of ...
Al Jazeera News :Taiwan faces an increasingly difficult position as China pressures the democratic island to accept conditions that would turn it into the next Hong Kong, its top diplomat told visiting US Health Secretary Alex Azar on Tuesday.Azar arrived in Taiwan on Sunday as the highest-level US official to ...
Reuters, Nkara : Turkey will issue seismic exploration and drilling licenses in new areas of the eastern Mediterranean by the end of August and continue its operations in the region, Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu said on Tuesday, amid tensions with Greece.NATO allies Turkey and Greece are at odds over overlapping claims ...
Indian High Commissioner here Riva Ganguly Das on Tuesday said excellent India-Bangladesh bilateral relations and recent connectivity initiatives in railways and inland waterways created new business opportunities as these reduced trade cost between the two neighbouring countries."With resilient economies and robust business environment, both the countries will not only be ...
Business Desk :Emirates has rolled out a brand new, state-of-the-art online gateway to serve its travel trade partners around the world.Tailored for each market, and personalised for each partner to cater to their unique business environment and needs, the Emirates Partners Portal is a one-stop shop for travel industry partners ...
Borussia Dortmund are flexing their muscles in their efforts to keep England forward Jadon Sancho at the club.In the club's pre-season training-camp in Bad Ragaz, Switzerland, the 2012 German Champions sporting director Michael Zorc announced the surprising news."We plan on having Jadon Sancho in our team this season," Zorc commented. ...
AFP, Asuncion :Brazil great Ronaldinho could be freed on August 24 following five months detention in Paraguay over a forged passport, judicial sources told AFP on Monday.The former Barcelona, AC Milan and Paris Saint-Germain star was detained alongside his brother Roberto de Assis Moreira on March 6, accused of entering ...