Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, November 17, 2019 05:09:38 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Opinion

But who will build the roads?

By
15th-Nov-2014       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Kevin Carson :
China just announced a regional infrastructure plan to promote the integration of Asian markets under Chinese leadership - sparking predictably hypocritical outrage from the United States ("China's Pouring $40 Billion Into a New 'Silk Road,'" The Blaze, November 9). Chinese President Xi unveiled the Silk Road Fund to leaders of Bangladesh, Cambodia, Laos, Mongolia, Myanmar, Pakistan and Tajikistan as they prepared for a summit on Asian-Pacific affairs. The announcement follows the creation of a $50 billion bank last month by China and twenty other governments to finance regional infrastructure.
According to unnamed US officials, Silk Road is an unnecessary duplication of existing World Bank efforts. The subtext, of course, is that the World Bank and other Bretton Woods institutions, along with Western foreign aid programs, were created to integrate the world economy under the control of Western capital (primarily that of the US and its trilateral junior partners in Western Europe and Japan). China, as a rising regional power and the second largest economy in the world, challenges the hegemony of global economic governance institutions created to serve American interests - much as the rising power of imperial Germany a hundred years ago challenged Britain's unrivaled naval and colonial domination.
The hypocrisy comes in when you consider the sheer scale of US government global infrastructure financing since World War II, and its pretense that the goal of this financing is service to the neutral interests of some "international community."
Some people (especially liberals) frame state-funded infrastructure as a neutral good that benefits everyone. It is no such thing. Depending on its scale, structure, and degree of overlap between its funders and its beneficiaries, it benefits some economic actors at the expense of others like any other state-funded input. One stereotypical question we anarchists like to attribute to liberals - usually delivered in a whiny, quavering voice - is "but who will build the roooaaads?"
In fact, despite the lionization of "infrastructure" as "progressive," every major, centralized, nationally funded infrastructure project in American history has had politically organized business interests as its main constituency, serving primarily to subsidize their business models. In early US history it was mainly the Federalists and Whigs, parties of the national commercial interests, who promoted federally-funded "internal improvements." The massively subsidized national railroad system, with its high-capacity central trunk lines and reliable schedule, gave rise to a nationwide wholesale and retail ecosystem, which in turn enabled giant industrial corporations to produce on a continental scale. Like the railroad system, the federally subsidized civil aviation and Interstate Highway systems made large nationwide corporations artificially competitive against local producers by enabling them to externalize increased distribution costs onto the taxpayer.
Some right-leaning libertarians whose hearts bleed for corporate interests adopt a pose of ignorance, echoing liberal arguments that "the roads benefit anyone who wants to use them," or disingenuously twisting left-libertarian arguments that subsidized roads benefit some business interests at everyone else's expense as a condemnation of large corporations for "driving on public roads."
Some use similar chicanery on a global scale, asking how libertarians could object on principled grounds to obviously "neutral" activities like the US Navy keeping world sea lanes open for commerce. This is just a larger-scale libertarian equivalent of "but who will build the roooaaads?" For an answer we need only consult Adam Smith, who argued that public infrastructure should be financed by its beneficiaries: That public bridges be financed by tolls based on the weight of vehicles passing over them, and that navies be financed based on the value of merchant cargo shipped under their protection.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

Bolivia's political crisis and the role of US


Political crisis in Bolivia has taken a crucial turn. The landlocked country in western-central South America region has been witnessing political unrest after a presidential election held by former president Evo Morales allegedly to stay in power for the fourth time. Getting an asylum, Bolivia's first indigenous president Morales fled ...

Cricket »

Captain of Bangladesh National Cricket (ODI) team Mashrafe Bin Mortaza, MP, inaugurating the Pran-DRU Media Cricket Tournament by releasing the balloons as the chief guest at the Maulana Bhashani National Hockey Stadium on Saturday.


Sports »

Nadal bows out on top of the world


Rafael Nadal was unable to crown his season with a first ATP Finals title but he ends it as world number one and with a chance to lead Spain to Davis Cup glory.The Spaniard, who came to London under an injury cloud, had a terrible start to his week at ...

Entertainment »

Actress Tisha to make debut as film producer


Entertainment Desk :Two-time National Film Award winning actress Nusrat Imrose Tisha made her film debut with 'Third Person Singular Number' for which she was awarded Meril Prothom Alo Award in Best Film Actress (Critics') category.Tisha started her acting career through the drama 'Shat Prohorer Kabbo' in 1998. Now  near after ...

International »

US Air Force Chief of Staff calls for Gulf Arab unity to counter Iran


Reuters, Dubai :United States Air Force Chief of Staff David Goldfein on Saturday pressed Gulf Arab states to reconcile differences and unify military capabilities as tensions with Iran simmer.Washington sees an ongoing dispute that Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and non-Gulf state Egypt have with Qatar as a ...

Editorial »

Development unmet due to prevailing corruption


GLOBAL Bribery Risk Index put Bangladesh in the top position "Country with the highest risk" in terms of bribery threats in South Asia, in the updated index report titled Trace Bribery Risk Matrix, Bangladesh scored 72 out of 100 this year, which is two points higher than last year and ...

Entertainment »

Shahnaz Khushi wants to work in big screen


Entertainment Report :Creating hype among the viewers to mark in the field of acting by playing challenging roles on the small screen, Shanaz Khushi is now a household name to all. Shahnaz Khushi is a successful actress on the small screen. But she was never seen appearing in any movie ...

International »

North Korea rejects US offer of December talks


Reuters, Seoul :  North Korea said on Thursday it had turned down a U.S. offer for fresh talks, saying it was not interested in more talks merely aimed at "appeasing us" ahead of a year-end deadline Pyongyang has set for Washington to show more flexibility in negotiations.Kim Myong Gil, North ...

Editorial »

Industrial Policy


Jomo Kwame Sundaram and Anis Chowdhury :Industrial policy refers to the promotion of new investments and technology by governments to encourage the growth and development of specific economic sectors. However, scepticism persists about the feasibility and desirability of using industrial policy, especially of the ability to 'pick winners', often accused ...

Cricket »

Cameron Bancroft recalled to Australia Test squad


Australia's selectors have handed a surprise recall to batsman Cameron Bancroft for the upcoming two-Test series against Pakistan.Opener Sam Burns also returns to the squad but Usman Khawaja and Marcus Harris have been left out, after struggling against England.Harris averaged just 9.66 against in the last three tests of the ...

Entertainment »

Humayun Ahmed's first wife Gultekin married again


Entertainment Desk :Gultekin Khan, Humayun Ahmed's first wife, tied the knot for the second time with Aftab Ahmed, additional secretary of youth and sports ministry. The couple got married at Gultekin's house in Dhaka, completed the legal formalities in a private gathering with family and friends two weeks ago. It ...

Entertainment »

Momtaz is delighted for getting Nat’l award


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Last week was a memorable week for folk legend of the country Momtaz Begum. This Parliament Member received two national recognitions. For the first time, she became the top taxpayer of the country in category of singer. This information was disclosed on Wednesday. Finance Minister AHM Mustafa ...

Football »

Chelsea win battle to sign Australian women's football icon Kerr


Australian striker Sam Kerr will test herself at the top level of European football after impressing in her homeland and the United States as she joined Chelsea on Wednesday.The 26-year-old Matildas captain - who scored five times in this year's World Cup as the Australians reached the last 16 - ...

Editorial »

People need safe and reliable train service


IN Brahmanbaria's Kasba, Dhaka-bound inter-city train Turna Nishita Express by breaching traffic signal hit Chattogram-bound another inter-city train Udayan Express on Tuesday leaving 16 people dead and injured another 70 people. The nation was shocked witnessing the fatality of the accident. Different quarters have raised voice for not modernising the ...

International »

Senator Kamala Harris promises to lift cap for employment based green cards in US


PTI, Washington :Indian-origin US Senator Kamala Harris is in favour of lifting the existing per-country caps for employment based green cards, her presidential campaign has said, asserting that 95 per cent in line for legal permanent residency are primarily from India, China, the Philippines and Vietnam.Ms Harris' presidential campaign, which ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news