Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Sunday, January 24, 2021 10:51:25 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Saving the indigenous lands

By
21st-Dec-2014       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Valdenor Junior :
Imagine that the title on your house would be recognized only if Congress approved it. Would you feel safer or less secure? This reality is already faced by millions of Brazilians who live in the favelas and have their possessions subjected to this political game. A game that should be extended to the indigenous peoples of Brazil, according to several congresspeople.
The Proposal of Constitutional Amendment (PEC) 215 - which was supposed to be voted on December 16 until the vote was canceled due to protests by Indians - is intended to change the land demarcation regime of indigenous lands, which will depend upon politicians' approval. Currently, Article 231 of the Brazilian Constitution states that "Indians' social organization, customs, languages, beliefs, traditions, and originary rights over lands they occupy are recognized, and it competes to the federal government the demarcation, protection and respect to said possessions." The first paragraph of the article defines which are those lands:
 "Those inhabited by Indian peoples in a permanent capacity, those used by them for their productive activities, those which are indispensable to the preservation of environmental resources required by their welfare and those necessary to their physical and cultural reproduction, according to their uses, customs, and traditions."
Thus, the federal government is supposed to stipulate the boundaries of indigenous lands. When we speak of the federal government, of course, we mean the executive branch, via organs such as FUNAI (the National Indian Foundation). The several steps undertaken by the demarcation process can be found on their website.
None of them are essentially political. Technical and anthropological criteria are used to recognize a preexisting right to permanent possession, the same way that the regularization of the property of any citizen, in rural or urban areas, uses some criteria to register existing but undocumented properties. The process for indigenous peoples is different because of an ethnographic matter: their possession regime is different, regulated by specific uses and customs. But mostly the same rules apply in both cases.
The procedure is an administrative one and is supposed to verify whether there is actual possession over the land and whether it is legitimate. If it is not considered legitimate, the courts step in. The discussion, however, becomes legal, not political.
PEC 215 would change that scenario, giving the Brazilian Congress the exclusive right to approve demarcations and ratify the existing ones. With a sufficient majority, subjected to intrigue and ad hoc coalitions, land demarcations in Brazil can be slowed to a crawl, making the Indians' situations even more unbearable than they are.
In that case, what could happen to the Munduruku communities that live along the Tapajos river, where the government intend sto build several dams that will flood the entire region? They did not wait to find out: Seeing the government's negligence in recognizing their traditional rights and its impressive efficiency in the hydroelectric project, the Mundurukus from the Sawre Muybu community established the limits of their lands themselves and now got themselves into a legal battle against the Brazilian government (incidentally, you can donate for their cause on Indiegogo).
The common rights to the land are extremely fragile in the current regime and would become even worse if it is up to the politicians.
And it is both a violation of the indigenous communities' rights and a regression. Change should strengthen their rights, not make them even flimsier. Their lands should not be property of the Brazilian government anymore. The land, with "usufruct" by the Indians, should become common property, as is already the case in the Quilombola (fugitive slaves descendants) communities.
Change is expelling the state out of the Indian lands. PEC 215 intends to smash indigenous rights to the land. It intends to make the state ever more present in the lives of Indians. It should be rejected.
(Translated into English by Erick Vasconcelos.)

Tariff
Ibn Sina
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

Editorial »

More attention imperative for girls` education in new normal


Prolonged school closure continues to take its toll on the adolescents as many of them think they may not go back to school anymore for learning gap, economic crisis and early marriage. Nine-month closure of educational institutions made the adolescent girls more vulnerable to early marriage. A recent survey showed ...

City »

State Minister for Shipping Khalid Mahmud Chowdhury, among others, at a seminar on 'Transforming to a Shipbuilding and Exporting Country: Challenges for Bangladesh' organised by the Shipping Ministry in the auditorium of Engineers' Institute in the city on Saturday.


.

International »

U.S. television host Larry King dies


Reuters, Washington :Larry King, who quizzed thousands of world leaders, politicians and entertainers for CNN and other news outlets in a career spanning more than six decades, has died at age 87, CNN reported on Saturday, citing a source close to the family.King had been hospitalized in Los Angeles with ...

Football »

PSG thrash Montpellier to open three-point lead in Ligue 1


Agency :Paris Saint-Germain scored three goals in a four-minute blitz in the second half as they demolished 10-man Montpellier 4-0 on Friday to go three points clear at the top of Ligue 1.Kylian Mbappe bagged a double for his first goals of the year with Neymar and Mauro Icardi also ...

Entertainment »

Shakila Parvin in TVC, dramas, music videos


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Shakila Parvin is a model and actress. Before appearing on the screen as a model in different TV commercials, she came into limelight to perform as model in a music video of song titled Tor mon parai. According to her, Shakila’s parents call her Mukti, while friends ...

Editorial »

Excess liquidity a big threat to banking sector


REPORT in a national daily on Friday said Bangladesh Bank is in a quagmire sitting on huge excess liquidity from escalating remittance along with implementation of over Tk 2 trillion stimulus packages in one hand while private sector credit demand is quite for lack of investment and lower import bills ...

Football »

Liverpool`s 68-match unbeaten home record ended by Burnley


Agency :Champions Liverpool suffered a shock 1-0 defeat to lowly Burnley on Thursday, ending their 68 match unbeaten home record in the Premier League as their title defense continued to fade.An 83rd minute penalty from Ashley Barnes, after he was brought down by goalkeeper Alisson Becker, decided the contest after ...

Entertainment »

Sabila, Apurba`s Tipu Sultana coming Valentine`s Day


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Within very short time Ziaul Faruk Apurba and Sabila Nur-starrer drama Exchange, directed by Rubel Hasan, crossed 1 crore views. To cast them again, this time Mohidul Mohim has made a special drama titled Tipu Sultana on the occasion of coming Valentine’s Day. Mohim also wrote story ...

Editorial »

Bangladesh still risks losing EU GSP benefits


Bangladesh is still at risk of losing the European Union's (EU's) generalised system of preferences (GSP) plus as the latter has again warned about its readiness to launch the procedure for withdrawal of preferences in case of the country's failure to produce sufficient results. A news report in a national ...

City »

Director of ISPR Lt. Col. Abdullah Ibne Jayed greets Secretary of Defence Ministry Dr. Abu Hena Mostofa Kamal as the latter has been promoted to NDC Senior Secretary.


.

International »

Mongolian Prime Minister submits resignation after Covid-19 protests


Reuters :Mongolia's Prime Minister Khurelsukh Ukhnaa submitted his resignation to parliament on Thursday after protests in the capital Ulaanbaatar over the government's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, the state news agency Montsame reported.Khurelsukh said in his resignation statement that he should "assume the responsibility upon himself and accept the demand ...

Entertainment »

Shraddha becomes voice of voiceless yet again


Shraddha Kapoor being a wonderful actor and a wonderful person, she adds meaning to the word empathy every time she does something in support for the speechless and needy. Recently, the actress has raised her voice to show support for the voiceless animals by asking people to sign a petition ...

Editorial »

Ensure education more equal in the new normal after opening


A STUDY showed distance learning programmes through television, radio and internet, adopted after the school closure due to Covid-19, remain by and large ineffective. The interim Education Watch Report 2020-21 said the prolonged closure results in growing monotony and boredom in millions of children who are confined to their home, ...

Football »

Messi given two-game ban for Super Cup red card


Agency :Barcelona captain Lionel Messi has escaped a lengthy ban for lashing out at Athletic Bilbao's Asier Villalibre in Sunday's Spanish Super Cup final defeat and will only serve a two-game suspension.The Spanish soccer federation (RFEF) said on Tuesday Messi had been banned for two matches, meaning he will miss ...

International »

BJP more dangerous than Maoists: Mamata


Times of India :West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee on Tuesday called the BJP more dangerous than the Maoists and accused the saffron party of making false promises to the people of the state before elections.The TMC supremo, whose party is witnessing an exodus ahead of the assembly elections due ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news