Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
Subscription Blog Signin Register
Logo
Wednesday, November 20, 2019 06:14:09 AM
Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

Opinion

Of anti-capitalism

By
01st-Apr-2014       
Share
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Save
  • E-mail
  • Print
Comments
Share your thought
Post a comment »
Read all () »

Joel Schlosberg :
From a free market anti-capitalist perspective, Jeremy Rifkin's account of "The Rise of Anti-Capitalism" [New York Times, March 15] gets it almost right. Rifkin's thesis that "The inherent dynamism of competitive markets is bringing costs so far down that many goods and services are becoming nearly free, abundant," in a process which "is about to affect the whole economy," and is fundamentally at odds with capitalism in the sense of diminishing profit returns to owners of capital to a vanishing minimum, is letter-perfect.
Also faultless is his rejoinder to the attempts by mainstream economists who grudgingly "acknowledge the creeping reality of a zero-marginal-cost economy" to downplay its extent and significance. Belittling it as "a parasite, dependent on government entitlements and private philanthropy" ignores solid evidence of its rapid growth into a "self-sufficient economic force." While it does serve as a platform for marketing "higher-end goods and specialized services," the demand for such premiums will be too small to provide a means of "ensuring large enough profit margins to allow the capitalist market to continue to grow."
Rifkin's means are also notably market-friendly. Private capital will be outcompeted, not outlawed. Welcoming ephemeralization of costs obviates the social democratic modus operandi of ensuring the availability of necessities by subsidizing, and in the process propping up, their costs.  
Observing that a decline in the workforce employed by for-profit businesses is an inevitable consequence of the dwindling of the amount of labor necessary to produce profit, he looks for a source of substitute livelihoods not in public works but the unimpeded growth of the nongovernmental nonprofit sector.
Rifkin's lapses stem from not sufficiently disentangling markets and capitalism.
While his motif of marginal utility is borrowed from market economics, he refers to zero-marginal-cost goods as "no longer subject to market forces" and "beyond markets." He sees markets' anti-capitalist tendencies as a "paradox" within capitalism. But the most capitalist sectors of the economy are the ones where high profit returns have been maintained by restricting price competition and state-stabilized cartelization: Healthcare, education and housing.
Michael Perelman has done extensive scholarship on how market price competition in goods with very low marginal costs relative to their fixed costs has always been problematic for capitalism, all the way back to the railroads of the nineteenth century.
Rifkin's assertion that economists "never anticipated the possibility of a technological revolution that might bring those costs to near zero" betrays a lack of perspective of free-market economists whose understanding of market forces included just such a possibility. In the twentieth century, Murray Rothbard explained that "We have to pay a certain amount for a loaf of bread, for shoes, for dresses because they are all scarce.
 If they were not scarce but superabundant like air, they would be free," and Israel Kirzner observed that markets under conditions of "vigorous entrepreneurial competition" will "tend toward the elimination of profit." In the nineteenth, Henry George argued that the more wealth is produced under private ownership without privilege, "the greater grows the common wealth in which all may share," and Frederic Bastiat that "any social order that is guided by the principles of liberty" would produce "a real, essential, and progressively increasing communal domain."
Some radicals not usually thought of as economists foresaw the essential principle. Howard Zinn envisaged a time when "[c]ertain basic things would be abundant enough to be taken out of the money system and be available - free - to everyone." Even Rifkin's view of a downsized capitalism persisting "in a more streamlined role … thriv[ing] as a powerful niche player" was anticipated by Bertrand Russell: "Provided the sphere of capitalism is restricted, and a large proportion of the population are rescued from its dominion, there is no reason to wish it wholly abolished. As a competitor and a rival, it might serve a useful purpose in preventing more democratic enterprises from sinking into sloth and technical conservatism."The rise of anti-capitalism is the rise of free markets.

Tariff
Add Rate

News Archive

Inside The New Nation

City »

Jatiyatabadi Krishak Dal formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Tuesday in protest against price spiral of essential commodities.


Cricket »

Archer admits short ball won't faze Kane Williamson


Jofra Archer, the England pacer, has said that bowling to Kane Williamson in the New Zealand Test series will be as challenging as it was against Steve Smith in the Ashes.Smith, the top-ranked batsman in MRF Tyres ICC Test Rankings, was in excellent form in the 2019 Ashes, accumulating 774 ...

Editorial »

Don't let rice and salt to follow the path of onion


PRICES of rice have been increasing. This is happening at a time when people are trying hard to absorb tremendous shock following the abnormal price hike of onion. Like the onions, the millers earlier had claimed surplus of rice and demanded cash incentives to export their product; whereas now prices ...

International »

US breaks off defense cost talks amid S Korea backlash over $5b demand


AFP, Seoul : The United States walked out of talks on hiking South Korea's contribution for American troops on its soil, Seoul said Tuesday, as Washington accused its ally of rebuffing a "fair and equitable" agreement.US President Donald Trump has repeatedly demanded the South pay more towards the costs of the ...

Business & Economy »

Mohammad Jakir Hossain, Deputy Commissioner of Joypurhat, handing over the educational materials among the students as the chief guest at "School Banking Conference 2019" organized by Prime Bank Limited at Joypurhat Sadar recently while Mohammad Salam Kabir, SP of Joypurhat and Rashida Begum, DGM of Bangladesh Bank (Bogura) graced the event as special guests. A K M Enamul Haque, Rajshahi Regional Head of the bank and local elites were also present.


Entertainment »

I didn't get a whole bunch of money: Jennifer Lopez


Singer-actor Jennifer Lopez revealed that she did not charge money for playing the role of a stripper in her last release 'Hustler'. "I didn't get paid a whole bunch of money for 'Hustlers,'" the 50-year-old star told for their 2019 'Men of the Year' issue released on Monday."I did it ...

Entertainment »

Srijit's talks on marriage with Mithila


Entertainment Report :The speculations since past few days that popular actress Mithila is set to tie the knot with eminent Tollywood filmmaker Srijit Mukherji.The rumour got wind in its sail as one of the prominent Indian daily newspapers The Times of India revealed the wedding date of the duo to ...

Business & Economy »

Asifuzzaman Chowdhury, Director of United Commercial Bank (UCB) Limited, inaugurating its 191st branch at Shantirhat in Chattogram recently. Mohammed Shawkat Jamil, Managing Director of the bank and local elites were also present.


Chittagong »

Tk 234cr realised in 4 days


Chattogram Bureau  :The enthusiastic taxpayers are rushing to the divisional Income Tax Fair-2019 now is being held at  GEC convention centre  in the city   under Chattogram Income Tax Zone  for the 4th day on Sunday since November 14 last.A total of 26807 eligible tax payers submitted their return forms and ...

Editorial »

Be a president of all Sri Lankan, not only for the Sinhalese


A significant change has been made in Sri Lankan politics while former wartime defence chief Gotabaya Rajapaksa won a presidential election on Saturday defeating his rival Sajith Premadasa with a huge margin of vote. We do congratulate Mr Rajapaksa for this victory. Media reports said that Mr Rajapaksa was the ...

Entertainment »

Kareena Kapoor’s latest alluring picture


Kareena Kapoor Khan needs no introduction when it comes to fashion and style. She can pull off any sartorial style with utmost grace and elegance. The actress is currently gearing up for her upcoming film Good Newwz starring opposite Akshay Kumar. The makers of the film have released the much-awaited ...

Entertainment »

Toma again in Cacoly’s movie


Sheikh Arif Bulbon :Now-a-days, Toma Mirza is a talented film actress who got the National Film Award for first time for acting in Shahneoyaj Cacoly-directed Nodijon. This time Toma is acting in yet another film of the same director. Toma will appear in Cacoly’s upcoming film titled From Bangladesh. Toma ...

Football »

Ronaldo scores 99th Portugal goal as holders seal Euro 2020 spot


AFP, Paris :Cristiano Ronaldo scored his 99th international goal as reigning champions Portugal secured their place at the Euro 2020 finals on Sunday with a 2-0 victory away to Luxembourg, while France ended their qualifying campaign with victory.Bruno Fernandes struck the opening goal on 39 minutes before Ronaldo tapped in ...

International »

China calls on US to 'stop flexing muscles' in South China Sea


Agencies, Bangkok :China on Monday called on the United States to stop flexing its muscles in the South China Sea and to avoid adding "new uncertainties" over Taiwan, during high-level talks that highlighted the tension between the world's two major powers.The remarks by Chinese Defence Minister Wei Fenghe to US ...

International »

China confirms aircraft carrier sailed through Taiwan Strait


AFP, Beijing :China confirmed on Monday that its first domestically built aircraft carrier had sailed through the Taiwan Strait for "routine" training and tests after Taipei accused Beijing of intimidation around upcoming elections.The ship, which has yet to be named, is Beijing's second carrier and will add massive firepower to ...

 
Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
 
Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
Create An Account Log in here
Email this news to a friend or like someone
Email:
Write a comment to this news