Headline
** Senegal move into WC last 16 ** BNP gets Suhrawardy Uddyan to hold Dhaka rally on 26 conditions ** HC orders ACC to complete probe in 3 months ** Bangladesh to get $30 million in climate adaptation fund ** Chinese protesters say police seeking them out ** Dhaka WASA MD takes Tk 57.99m as gross salary to13 yrs ** Chandpur teen stabbed to death after argument over WC match ** Saudi firm, BPDB to set up 1000MW solar power plant in BD ** In corruption-driven economy one can't punish big loan defaulters ** Late Casemiro strike sends Brazil into last 16 ** Rare protests spread across China ** Girls outshine boys total pass rate 87.44 per cent ** Farmers get arrested but big embezzlers remain untouched ** 7.1m Bangladeshis displaced by climate change in 2022: WHO ** Ghana beat South Korea by 3-2 goals ** Cabinet directs to verify news being shared about banking sector ** Govt now can raise fuel, power tariffs ** We are watching a drama : HC ** Thai AirAsia launches Dhaka-Bangkok inaugural flight ** New DAP may trouble housing sector ** 12 Pabna farmers get bail in loan default case ** Protests spread in China as anger mounts over 'zero-Covid' ** Strike paralyses waterways across Bangladesh ** Will the big loan defaulters remain untouched? ** A ball goes past the Belgium's goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois (right) as Morocco's Romain Saiss (centre) and Morocco's Achraf Hakimi block his view from an offside position during the World Cup group F soccer match between Belgium and Morocco at the Al Thumama Stadium in Doha of Qatar on Sunday. Agency photo **

Disaster memory and dismemory

17 October 2022


Ilan Kelman, PhD :
One character's words at the beginning of The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams (1944) are, "The play is memory. Being a memory play, it is sentimental, it is dimly lit, it is not realistic." Disaster memory can be similar within the rapidity of situations unfolding and traumatic experiences. Is this memory situation necessarily negative?
Coping with and surviving disaster means living in and with its aftermath, including memories. Not all experiences are desirable to remember, particularly in their full detail. They can impede the long path to recovery and living again while recalling and commemorating who and what one has lost. Memory guides this roller-coaster, and it guides memory.
Memory becomes a reality when we do not wish to retain, revisit or re-feature aspects of a disaster. Not remembering and misremembering can be valuable and needed.
Memory, notoriously unreliable and welcomingly unreliable, is an ever-present trope in fiction. The characters in the trilogy of Matrix movies (1999-2003) wonder if their lack of remembering reality means that it makes no difference: what they think they are experiencing and remembering is reality, so what they do not remember is irrelevant. For disaster experiences, revisiting the memory of death and destruction can be destructive and despairing. Survivors failing to escape the vividness when awake or dreaming might never maneuver beyond the horror.
In Philip K. Dick's short story We Can Remember It for You Wholesale (1966), a company sells implanted fake memories. One client's memory becomes muddled when his requests for false memories are based on his actual but now suppressed past. Dick's writings are steeped in disorientation, conflating reality, memory, and fantasy, typically due to the characters taking drugs, presumed to reflect his own experimentations. His wavering worlds are peopled by cut-outs grasping at flimsy memories of what was, what could be, and what will be.
Science fiction overlaps with science. In A Brief History of Time (1988), Stephen W. Hawking inquires, "Why do we remember the past but not the future? The laws of science do not distinguish between the past and the future." Our memories, though, currently do. For disasters, the power of capturing and controlling memory prevails. Disaster survivors deserve to live with their memories on their terms to mold their futures.
One post-disaster way of helping to heal for some, especially slow healing or "shealing," is not remembering everything, instead forgetting aspects of the devastation and tragedy. Hopefully, this "active forgetting" is neither denial nor collective forgetting. Otherwise, how could we learn from the mistakes that created the disaster in order to improve and avoid disaster recurrence? For some people, media publicity and retelling of disaster experiences aid them in their life, whereas others are harmed by it. Some seek prominent and continual memorialisation, while others evade it.
As Maroon 5 sings in Memories (2019), "'Cause the drinks bring back all the memories / And the memories bring back, memories bring back you." Depictions and memorials, what is and is not included, can create collective memories and collective forgettings of disaster. Some wish for more, and some wish for less. Some align with collective memories, and some diverge. Who should judge individuals' choices? Who has the right to criticise selectivity in recollection?
Disaster dismemory has been the topic of a research project (since 2012), a conference (2015), and an anthology (2020). They drew on the baseline that cultural memory and its representation can re-form or bypass disaster possibilities. We ought to tap into the positive parts of disaster (dis)memory to avoid future disasters without (re-)creating problems for people who need to or who prefer to forget.
Remembering Disaster and Disaster Avoided
In fact, memory can never be complete or entirely accurate. And we are successful at actively forgetting disasters that did not arise. Work is never-ending to avoid disasters, which saves lives, protects livelihoods and infrastructure, and stops disruption. These actions are rarely acknowledged, let alone remembered. Yet they have huge meanings given the disasters that did not occur, even if few remember them.
This dismemory, misrepresentation, and unexpression of what has not been experienced evoke critique about communicating and commemorating actions that stopped disasters from happening. It happens all the time in fiction, as with Arrival, so where are the celebrations in reality? Few heroes are identifiable since it requires collective action. The dispersed decisions and long-term interactions required to avoid disasters morph the possibility of memory for it, making it a memory process-sentimental, dimly lit, and not realistic.
It is a memory menagerie for disaster dodged. And then disaster memories dominate. Just as we create disaster and the disaster creates us, we create disaster memory, and disaster memory creates us.

(Ilan Kelman, Ph.D., is Professor of Disasters and Health at University College London, England and a Professor II at the University of Agder, Kristiansand, Norway).

Add Rate